Road Safety Week: Will Auckland Transport Be Heroes Or Villains??
'In the same week they announce higher speeds around 150 schools across the city, it is disturbing to see AT highlight how the burden of safety falls on parents and kids,' says Jon Turner, Puketāpapa Local Board member and City Vision ward councillor candidate for Albert-Eden-Puketāpapa ward.
'It is outright hypocrisy for AT to say one thing on socials to launch Road Safety Week, when at the same time behind the scenes they're making Aucklanders less safe and refusing to listen to multiple voices calling for a re-assessment of the huge scale of the reversals about to go ahead. Right when we most need AT to stand by the evidence, stand up for Aucklanders, and push for a common-sense approach to a harmful and badly written speed rule, they've crumbled,' says Mr Turner.
'Other cities have found a way to do the right thing and retain their safe speed zones where there is public support. The new Minister of Transport is open to discussion. We know safe speeds work, and dozens of Albert-Eden residents have told me what safe speeds mean to them,' says Albert-Eden Local Board member Christina Robertson.
'AT has argued that the speed rule forces them to undertake a blanket reversal of over 1500 safe speeds, but we know this isn't the case. Hamilton and Dunedin took a very similar approach when setting safe speeds, so why isn't AT taking their lead in defending Auckland streets? I've examined AT's assessments of all the safer speeds implemented in my local board area since 2020, and found over 60 streets that clearly do not meet the criteria of the speed rule, but are still losing safe speeds. Aucklanders deserve answers–why is AT going further than the speed rule requires?' says Dr Robertson.
'AT reported last week that Auckland is 'seeing a return to higher levels of deaths and serious injuries (DSI)'. I have repeatedly asked AT, including at the Transport, Resilience and Infrastructure Committee last week, to make safety a priority and to reassess their approach to the Speed Rule to avoid unnecessary harm,' says Albert-Eden-Puketāpapa ward councillor Julie Fairey.
'We know bringing down speeds makes a big contribution to increasing road safety. Putting speeds up, especially when other councils have shown there are options available under the Speed Rule that AT could use to reduce this harm, is not heroic; it's villainous,' says Ms Fairey.
City Vision calls on Auckland Transport and the Minister of Transport to find a common-sense solution to avoid the huge cost to strip safe speeds from the communities that asked for them.
Notes:
Evaluation of AT's Safe Speeds programme shows significant reductions in deaths and serious injuries (DSIs) compared to the expected numbers if safe speeds had not been implemented.
Public support for safe speeds is wide- ranging for example:
January-March 2024, a Verian survey for NZTA Waka Kotahi showed that 7/10 New Zealanders support lowering speeds around schools to improve road safety.
June 2024, a Verian survey for AT showed more people support speed reductions than oppose them across Auckland, and support had increased since 2023.
After being informed about the decrease in deaths and serious injuries on roads where speed limits have been reduced, support for the speed limit reductions rose to 61% and opposition fell.
There is strong support across the Albert-Eden Local Board Area for the Phase 2 consultations on safe speeds ranged from 70% in Mt Eden/ Sandringham/ Balmoral to 93% in Mt Albert, with 76% support in Point Chevalier near Pasadena Intermediate and 83% support in Waterview.
78% of school leaders in Auckland support permanent safe speed zones around schools.
About City Vision:
City Vision is an alliance of Labour, Greens and community independents working together for progressive change in Tāmaki Makaurau Auckland. Since 1998, City Vision has championed policies that support a liveable, safe, connected, healthy, economically and environmentally sustainable city for all Aucklanders. City Vision stands local board candidates in the Waitematā, Puketāpapa and Albert-Eden Local Board areas.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsroom
3 days ago
- Newsroom
Crown and council to take voting edge over Māori on Waitakeres body
Joint oversight of the Waitakere Ranges by Māori, Auckland Council and the Crown will not now be through a committee with equal representation after feedback from west Aucklanders, some opposed to 'co-governance'. From initial proposals of an equal five seats for tangata whenua and five representing public bodies, the latest deed to establish the oversight committee has moved to six to five in favour of the council and Crown entities. The change leaves west Auckland-based iwi Te Kawerau ā Maki feeling 'a little bruised, and beaten up' after years of waiting, but accepting it 'could live with' the council's change of representation and wanting to get on and protect the ranges. Iwi chief executive Edward Ashby told Newsroom: 'It was pretty clear there was a fear – and I do think it is an irrational fear because it's an advisory body and we are not the boogie man. But we are really focused on the outcome. We are not too worried by the numbers.' The deed for the Waitakere Ranges Heritage Area Forum, a body to be set up under a 2008 law but only now being finalised, goes before Auckland Council's policy and planning committee on Thursday. The Waitākere Ranges Heritage Area Act recognised the 27,700 hectares of publicly owned land in the ranges as nationally significant, needing protection. It specified the Crown, council and nominated iwi to develop the deed and oversight body, a non-statutory body to identify areas of cooperation and develop a strategic plan for the area. It aims to identify areas tangata whenua can contribute to the management of public land and to acknowledge their traditional relationship with the ranges. The five seats for Māori are initially to be taken up by Te Kawerau ā Maki, as another iwi listed in the Act, Ngāti Whātua, has declined. Under the deed, there will be no change of ownership of land under the deed or forum structure, and the forum would not be able to direct spending of council or Crown funds, other than its own delegated budget. In April, the New Zealand First party complained the forum would be an example of 'co-governance' with Māori able to set strategy and veto council or government measures related to the ranges. MP Shane Jones said his party would never agree to an iwi having '50 percent sovereignty over the Waitakere forest'. Ashby dismissed the criticisms in April as scaremongering and said the forum as proposed was not co-governance. If it had been, there would have been a different structure and entity established. The deed simply acknowledged tangata whenua's special relationship with the ranges area. Around 2250 people and organisations made public submissions on the heritage forum deed, with 51 percent in favour, 39 percent against and 10 percent recorded as 'other'. Analysis of the submissions by research firm Ipsos said there was concern among those opposed to the deed at the prospect of 50-50 representation on the joint committee giving tangata whenua 'disproportionate influence' over management of the public land. Those in favour of the deed and shared oversight acknowledged the iwi role of kaitiaki or guardian and the importance of tangata whenua having a strong voice and seat at the table. It appears that public feedback, rather than the political claims by NZ First and the Act Party, has now seen the forum membership weighting changed to favour the public bodies. Council staff recommend three seats for the Waitakere Local Board, two for the council governing body and one for the Department of Conservation – and five seats to be occupied by Te Kawerau ā Maki, to be shared with Ngāti Whātua should that iwi choose at a later date to participate. The role of chair would come from the iwi side and deputy chair from the public bodies. Waitakere ward councillor Shane Henderson says the composition of the forum changed 'in response to feedback, not to scaremongering from central government politicians but the voices of West Aucklanders that fed back into the process'. He said the new balance allowed half of the six-member Waitakere local board to join the forum, with two ward councillors. DoC's strong interests in the heritage area also needed representation. 'So the new numbers work a little better on that basis too.' Te Kawerau ā Maki chief executive Edward Ashby. Photo: Supplied Ashby says the change in representation came after the consultation and was put to Te Kawerau ā Maki by the council. 'It's a place the council came to that we could live with at the end of the day. It's about giving these people some certainty that there would not be a super majority of Māori on the committee. There's been a lot of misunderstanding of the original proposal. 'It's good the deed is out there and people can read it; it clearly says it's advisory, about public land, it does not have power to make any decisions about budgets. That's all in there.' He said the political claims from Jones and Act's David Seymour, among others, led to fears among some members of the public. 'I do understand that if you are reading scaremongering headlines on Facebook you might react. It's unfortunate. 'It's just the political reality of the time. The original proposal was for 50-50, not out of any power grab but simply that the Crown and council was on one side of the equation and on the other side was Te Kawerau ā Maki and Ngāti Whātua. It was as simple as that.' He noted much of the feedback against the proposed deed had come from beyond Waitakere and Auckland. 'But, there's this beautiful area. It's our heartland and I'm biased. It really needs to be looked after. We really need to get together on how we make it work.' The six-five composition of the forum was 'at least an outcome that takes some of the edge out of some people's concerns, even though I think they were not well-founded concerns'. He hoped the compromise result did not turn the clock back in other areas of the country. 'I like to think most New Zealanders are fair minded … and I would hope that progress made is not lost. There's been some really good progressive stories.' The council's policy and planning committee considers the proposed deed on Thursday, with the full Governing Body having the final say before the forum is appointed. Ashby says: 'We just want to get on with it.'
NZ Herald
3 days ago
- NZ Herald
Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown urges Government to reconsider bed night levy to reboot city's struggling economy
Bridges urged the National Party-led Government to consider serious policy or fiscal stimulus across New Zealand, especially in major cities, to help 'get things going'. The bleak state of Auckland's economy was underscored by a Herald story this month showing a 6.6% drop in card spending in the central city between April and May 2024 and the same period in 2025. The picture was even starker on Karangahape Rd, where spending plunged by 22.5%. It had been the worst winter ever, said Helen McIntryre, who has owned a gift and furniture shop on K Rd for 34 years. Brown backed Bridges' call for the Government to take stronger action to support the economy during these challenging times, noting Auckland's 6.1% unemployment rate had implications for the rest of the country. He said introducing a bed night levy would deliver immediate stimulus by boosting tourism and attracting major events to Auckland. 'There's no reason the Government couldn't make a bed night levy an urgent priority and have it in place by next year,' Brown said. 'The sector supports it and so do most Aucklanders.' Brown has been calling on the Government to approve a bed night levy for some time, but Tourism Minister Louise Upston has ruled it out, saying there would be no new taxes. Today, Upston acknowledged Bridges' comments and noted the ongoing interest in a bed tax. However, she reiterated that 'a tax is not something I'm pursuing this term'. Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Tourism Minister Louise Upston are not keen on a bed night levy at this stage. Photo / Dean Purcell 'The most pressing challenge for New Zealand tourism is that we simply don't have enough visitors, and I'm focused on growing those numbers. 'This Government is firmly committed to growing the economy, including Auckland's, and tourism remains a key part of that strategy,' the minister said. So far this term, the Government has hiked the international tourism levy for visitors to New Zealand by nearly 200% from $35 to $100, and announced international tourists would be charged $20 to $40 at four popular destinations – the Tongariro Crossing, Cathedral Cove, Milford Sound and Aoraki Mt Cook. Asked about Bridges' call for a stimulus package on RNZ on Monday, Prime Minister Christopher Luxon said progress would 'come through to the big cities eventually'. 'I know it's difficult – particularly in our big cities... we've got to keep doing everything we can, but open to more things and discussing more things, but I think at this stage it's keep doing what we are doing,' he said. Herald business editor-at-large Liam Dann backed Bridges' call for a stimulus package in a weekend column, arguing that Auckland's economy is 'broken' and urgently needed Government attention. Karangahape Rd shop owner Helen McIntyre says this winter has been the worst in 32 years. Photo / Jason Dorday Dann suggested the Government could allocate funding to revive three 'dead' buildings in the midtown area – St James Theatre, the vacant Smith & Caughey's building, and the Sky World indoor entertainment complex. He argued restoring these sites would breathe life back into the city and keep skilled workers employed while the broader economy recovers. Hospitality New Zealand chief executive Steve Armitage said Auckland had faced significant challenges in recent years, particularly across the hospitality, accommodation, tourism and events sectors. He supported the introduction of sustainable funding through a levy as soon as possible to create a dedicated and reliable revenue stream to promote tourism, attract major events and conferences, and stimulate spending across hotels, restaurants, retail and entertainment venues. However, rather than adopting an Auckland-only approach, Armitage said Hospitality NZ favoured a nationwide system applied fairly and consistently. A national framework would better support tourism-related activity, including the attraction and delivery of major and business events. Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown and Hospitality NZ want a bed night levy to attract more events, such as Kinky Boots at the Civic Theatre. Photo / Jason Oxenham Localised models risk creating unnecessary complexity and inconsistency, Armitage said. The mayor said that when Auckland did well, the country did well, saying NZ's underlying problem was a low-productivity economy that wasn't exporting enough to the world. His goal was for Auckland to lead the country on a path to prosperity, saying his 2025 manifesto identified key opportunities for growth in technology, housing and tourism. Recently, Brown launched the Auckland Innovation & Technology Alliance to attract investment and strengthen the city's position as a competitive hub for tech and innovation. He's also working with Housing Minister Chris Bishop to make use of land for faster and smarter growth. Employers and Manufacturers Association head of advocacy Alan McDonald told RNZ there were some signs of recovery led by the primary sector and in the regions, but in Auckland, which was more about manufacturing and services, hospitality, tourism and education were all down. Sign up to The Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
The Spinoff
4 days ago
- The Spinoff
The motley crew of contenders trying to take down Auckland mayor Wayne Brown
A list containing Wayne Brown and the people who will almost certainly lose to Wayne Brown. There are 12 people running for the Auckland mayoralty, though running might be a strong term. The incumbent, Wayne Brown, has barely broken into a light canter as he sets course for re-election. It's not just a coronation though. At least some of his rivals are putting up a fight, with at least one of them promising to emulate Elon Musk and turn what he calls his 'great mind' to fixing Auckland's problems. John Alcock When John Alcock ran in the Pakuranga electorate in the 2023 general election, it was on a platform of reclaiming 'New Zealand from ideological extremism'. Though that phrase is usually the hallmark of a candidate who possesses moderate and politically mainstream views, Alcock appears to have some out-there ideas, including decentralising our financial and governmental systems and crafting a future 'where empowered individuals build resilient communities'. Alcock was once a board member for the Act Party and is now highly interested in cryptocurrencies. Wayne Brown Remember when mayor Wayne Brown failed to publicly declare a state of emergency until nearly 10.30pm on the night of the Auckland Anniversary weekend floods? Remember how, in the criticism that followed, he grumped that it wasn't his job to ' rush out with buckets '. Remember how, worst of all, he referred to the universally delightful people of the media as ' drongos '? If you'd told Aucklanders then that in just a few short years' time, Brown would be paddleboarding to almost certain re-election atop an unstoppable wave of mildly favourable voter sentiment, they would have spat a mouthful of brown floodwater straight into your face. Sorry to those stuck in a 2023 time prison, but that's what's happening. Brown has engineered one of the most remarkable redemption arcs in local politics history, going from being perceived as a godawful angry old boomer to a lovable angry old boomer. He's done it through playing against type and learning the art of political compromise. For all his self-aggrandising Mr Fix It branding, Brown's shown a surprising ability to take new ideas on board. He's elevated people from outside his natural circle of allies, demoted naysaying local government lifers, talked up intensification around train stations and busways, and spruiked for cheap mass transit options. Brown still texts the chief executive of AT when he sees a rogue road cone. He remains offensive, in ways that are sometimes funny, and sometimes not. But ask most Aucklanders what they think of him, and they'll say he's grown on them. The man with one of politics' most polarising personalities is somehow one of its most unifying figures. Brown's re-election odds are so good, he seems to have eschewed campaigning to focus all his efforts on getting rid of the councillors he doesn't like. He'll likely win, provided no floods hit between now and October. Eric Chuah Dr Eric Chuah once worked as a strategist for United Future's Peter Dunne, which should stand him in good stead for securing a sliver of the vote in an election race dominated by more popular and well-known rivals. Chuah's promises are nonspecific on minor issues such as minimising rates, reducing unnecessary council spending, and ensuring safer policing. However he gets into granular detail on how to fix dog walking, proposing a timeshare scheme where dog owners would be allowed to walk their dogs between 3 and 5pm, and the rest of the public are permitted to go outside without being mauled by an aggressive labradoodle outside those hours. Michael Coote Michael Coote appears to be a finance professional. He stood for mayor and Waitakere ward councillor in the 2022 local elections, where he distinguished himself by failing to give any detail to and appearing in several lists of people who are also standing for mayor at the bottom of coverage on other candidates. Coote didn't respond to an email from The Spinoff. Ted Johnston Johnston is perhaps best known for his handpainted 2019 local election hoardings, which gave people the distinct impression that if they didn't vote for him, he would murder them with an axe. Obviously the implied threats paid off, because soon after, Johnston became a leader in the New Conservative Party. He was stood down from that gig by the party board in 2023, and is back to his first political love: running strident, ultimately doomed independent campaigns to become Auckland's mayor. Johnston has more than 30 years of experience as a criminal barrister. Kerrin Leoni Kerrin Leoni appears to be the only high-profile candidate actively campaigning for the mayoralty right now. The Whau ward councillor was the sole respondent when Auckland university's debating society invited three candidates to a debate last month. She's put up hoardings touting her experience as an 'economist and business owner'. She's taking what chances she can to talk down Brown in the media. Though her chances remain relatively slim, Leoni remains the mayor's most credible rival in the race. Her policy priorities include building more affordable housing and prioritising investment in public transport, walking and cycling. Rob McNeil Rob McNeil is the executive president of the Animal Justice Party. He could fill a similar nature-focused political niche to Michael Morris, who campaigned to replace concrete in the city centre with greenery and confine development to places with 'little or no biodiversity' while running for the Auckland mayoralty under the Animal Justice Auckland banner in 2022. Ryan Pausina According to his 2022 candidate blurb, Ryan Pausina's local political awakening came after a friend encouraged him to run for mayor of Coromandel. He quickly realised he would fix everything there within five months and decided to turn his talents to a more substantial challenge. Anything other than running the nation's biggest city would be, as per the blurb, a waste of his talents. 'It has been said that Elon Musk realised at one point in his life that other people don't think like he does,' the text concludes. 'People with a great mind should use it.' The blurb doesn't contain any advice for what people should do if they're blessed with the gift of great humility. Jason Pieterse Jason Pieterse did not respond to an email from The Spinoff asking who he is and why he's standing for mayor of Auckland. A person with that name does appear to have offered support to the New Zealand rugby team 'The All Blacks' in a Facebook comment from a year ago. Simon Stam A man named Simon Stam ran in Round The Bays in 2014, achieving a time of 48 minutes and 18 seconds, at a pace of nine minutes and 39 seconds per kilometre. Peter Wakeman Wikipedia describes Peter Wakeman as a 'perennial candidate', and he does appear to have stood in a remarkable number of political races around the country over the last few decades. In 2013, Wakeman rushed the stage during the launch of Lianne Dalziel's campaign to become Christchurch's mayor. Though he had to be restrained, his actions were credited with breathing new life into the race. Denise Widdison Facebook lists two Denise Widdisons in Auckland. One regularly offers free stuff to Te Atatu residents, including toys and, most notably, a full box of lemons. Another is a self-employed former student of Auckland Girls Grammar. Which one is standing for mayor? You decide.
