Court criticises Absa's bookkeeping after bank fails to recover R6. 7 million
Image: Absa/Facebook
Absa has lost a bid to attach property after it claimed that this was the best way to recover some R6.7 million it said was owed to it by two companies and Authar Arandana after they allegedly defaulted on a loan.
In dismissing the dispute over the multimillion-rand business loan, the South Gauteng High Court in Johannesburg was scathing in its judgement about the reliability of Absa's books. 'In any event, it seems clear to me that… it is evident the bookkeeping of the plaintiff was in disarray.'
The Judge, N.S. Kruger, said this conclusion was based on a review of communication between Absa as plaintiffs and defendants Gola Trading and Projects, Arandana, and Tswane Refineries. Kruger also considered 'various conflicting loan statements'.
Kruger said in the recent judgement that 'it seems that as far as [Absa] is concerned, the one hand is unaware of what the other is doing. In my view the defendants have succeeded in raising triable issues [matters that can be defended] in these respects'.
In 2021, Absa and Gola Trading and Projects signed a business loan, secured by a mortgage bond of R5.6 million and supported by personal guarantees from Arandana and Tswane Refineries.
The contract's date is in dispute, having been signed in either February or October 2021, but the court noted its structure and obligations are not. The loan included a capital facility of R5.535m, fees and VAT, and an additional amount for interest and potential legal costs.
According to the Absa, by mid-2023, Gola Trading and Projects had defaulted on payments, falling five instalments behind, which was more than R430 000. This, Absa claims, triggered a contractual clause allowing the loan to be cancelled and the full balance, of more than R5.27 million, to be called in immediately.
But the defendants contest this, saying no such arrears existed. They point to a series of loan statements showing lower arrears and argue that subsequent payments – including two of R90,000 and a larger one of over R194,000 – brought the account into a credit position. By 10 October 2023, they received a statement showing that no arrears were owed.
Despite this, Absa continued to chase the money, later adjusting the alleged arrears to R312,000 and seeking summary judgment. The amount claimed was later revised again to R4.27 million, which the judge said raised further questions.
The defendants argued that this pattern of inconsistencies undermines Absa's certificate of balance and suggested a material dispute that should be tested at trial.
Among the errors cited was an apparent reference to a '2019 agreement' in the bank's court papers – something Absa later admitted was a drafting mistake, the judgment noted. There were also discrepancies in the bank's internal calculations, leading to conflicting figures across statements and correspondence, the judge said.
The defendants argued that, even if the loan was technically in arrears at one point, Absa's subsequent conduct, accepting payments and requesting further instalments, effectively reinstated the contract.
They assert that no formal notice of breach was served before the alleged cancellation, and that the bank's changing demands demonstrate the agreement was still in place.
Adding to the complexity, the third defendant has since gone into voluntary liquidation.
Absa has postponed its claim against this party, focusing instead on recovering funds from Arandana and Gola Trading and Projects, and seeking a court order to declare the mortgaged property executable.
However, this matter will now have to be settled through mediation.
IOL
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
2 days ago
- The Citizen
Good news for GDP: Manufacturing PMI reaches above 50 points, but employment levels still weak
A score above 50 indicates the sector is growing, while a score below 50 means it is shrinking. Manufacturing PMI in July 2025 has reached above the 50 point mark and recorded an expansion for the first time in nine months. The Absa Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI) is an economic activity index based on a survey conducted by the Bureau for Economic Research (BER) and sponsored by Absa. It measures the health of South Africa's manufacturing sector. For July 2025, the seasonally adjusted PMI increased by 2.3 points to 50.8. The increase is attributed to a strong recovery in demand. ALSO READ: Absa PMI increases but in contractionary territory for eighth consecutive month First in nine months Absa said the last time the headline PMI was in the above-50 expansionary territory was in October 2024 at 52.6 points. PMI is based on feedback from purchasing managers about business like new orders, production levels, employment, supplier deliveries and inventories. A score above 50 indicates the sector is growing, while a score below 50 means it is shrinking. The index matters because it is used as an early warning system for the economy. Manufacturing drives growth, as the sector is linked directly to exports, employment and demand for raw materials. Drivers of the good news 'New sales orders rose by 9.7 points to 55.9 in July, recording a third consecutive month of improvement and signalling a much stronger recovery in demand at the start of the third quarter,' read the Index. BER said export sales also showed a significant increase, but at a low level, signalling that manufacturers remain cautious amid regulations and ongoing trade negotiations. The improvement in demand fostered an uptick in production, seeing the business activity index tick up 5.2 points to 47.1 points in July – still coming in below the neutral-50 mark for the ninth consecutive month. ALSO READ: Act now to absorb impact of Trump tariffs on SA vehicle manufacturing sector – BLSA Recovery in demand The index shows that the supplier deliveries increased by 1.4 points to 56.4 in July on the back of the strong uptick in new orders, which typically leads to longer delivery times and some delays. 'Despite the strong recovery in demand, which filtered through into an uptick in production, the employment index declined by 6 points in July, reaching 43.7, reversing the gains made in June and returning to levels seen earlier in the year. 'The weak employment level may be due to the slow recovery in activity, which, despite ticking up, remains in contractionary territory, signalling that manufacturers may wait to see a stronger recovery in demand before increasing employment.' Growing cost pressures BER added that the purchasing price index increased by 1.2 points in July, signalling growing cost pressures as the cost of some input materials increased. 'Crude oil prices increased fuel prices in the country, with petrol and diesel prices rising by 52 to 84 cents a litre, depending on the grade. The positive news is that, despite the uptick in the index, the current levels remain the second-lowest in over eight years.' The index tracking expected business conditions in six months' time declined from 62.5 points in June to 56.4 in July. 'Although still above the 50-neutral level, the direction of the index suggests that manufacturers are faced with an increasingly volatile and challenging trading environment on both the global and domestic front.' NOW READ: Sectors showing growth in job opportunities in SA
The Citizen
2 days ago
- The Citizen
Half of SMEs may not survive the next year without urgent help
The report shows that only one in four businesses is growing, meaning there is significant vulnerability in the sector. The small and medium enterprise (SME) sector in South Africa is often referred to as the 'backbone' of the economy, however, the sector is in danger, as a report reveals that half of the businesses cannot survive the next 12 months in their current situations. The first Small Business Growth Index (SBGI) by Absa and the South African Chamber of Commerce and Industry (SACCI) released on Friday, showed that urgent support is needed in the sector. The index is conducted by the Bureau of Market Research (BMR) and shows real-time barometer tracking the conditions shaping small business performance. SBGI was launched in February 2025, with the idea to monitor sales growth trends, identify emerging business opportunities and employment trends, and measure SME job creation contributions. ALSO READ: How mental health affects entrepreneurs SMEs growth in SA The report shows that only one in four businesses is growing, meaning there is significant vulnerability in the sector. The findings of the report are based on a survey of more than 1 600 small businesses across all nine provinces. Ronnie Mbatsane, managing executive for SME Business at Absa Business Banking, said these are businesses with 50 or fewer employees. It draws on a range of indicators — including current performance, operating conditions, cost pressures, cash flow, debt levels, investment intentions, growth expectations and perceived skills gaps. SMEs in a vulnerable zone Professor Paul Kibuuka, head of the Economic Research division at the BMR, said the country's SMEs are in a vulnerable zone, as they are caught between recovery efforts and rising operational costs. 52.8% of the survey's respondents said they are trading with difficulty or at risk of closure. The report reveals that in the past six months, SMEs have experienced significant cost inflation across all major categories. Transport and fuel costs saw the steepest increases. Utilities (electricity, water) and raw materials/stock costs also rose sharply. Borrowing costs, rental, wages and taxes have all increased for most firms, compounding the strain on margins. ALSO READ: Challenges and opportunities for SMEs in 2025 Current business challenges 'SMEs play a pivotal role in South Africa's economy, contributing to employment, innovation and inclusive growth. However, these businesses continue to face a host of challenges exacerbated by recent economic disruptions, infrastructural deficiencies, and regulatory burdens,' reads the report. One of the greatest challenges is inadequate capital. Lack of capital emerges as the most significant obstacle, limiting SMEs' ability to scale, invest in equipment or respond to market demands. The second is increased competition. 'Businesses report growing pressure from both formal and informal competitors, including larger firms with greater resources and political connections.' The greatest challenge remains limited access to finance. 'Despite the existence of loan schemes and support initiatives, many SMEs remain excluded due to eligibility barriers, bureaucratic processes or limited institutional support.' NOW READ: Mid-year financial check for SMEs: Tips to prepare for the next six months
The Citizen
4 days ago
- The Citizen
June salaries stabilised after months of decline, but adverse external factors remain
If you earn a salary you will be glad to hear that there is some relief coming, but the dark cloud of US tariffs still hovers. Salaries stabilised in June after three months of decline, supported by a favourable inflation environment and an anticipated interest rate cut on Thursday. Salary earners may see some relief from financial pressures, but external factors are still expected to weigh on future earnings and unemployment levels. Take-home pay, tracked in the BankservAfrica Take-home Pay Index (BTPI), held steady in June after three months of moderation. 'The nominal average take-home pay was R17 310 in June, showing a marginal 0.1% decline on May's R17 325. 'However, this was still notably above the R15 514 level of a year ago,' Shergeran Naidoo, BankservAfrica's head of stakeholder engagements, says. However, Elize Kruger, an independent economist, says while the first six months of BTPI data signals 2025 will, on average, be a good salary year, the economic outlook has deteriorated in recent months. ALSO READ: Take-home pay slides for third month with grim job opportunities and earnings Significant moderation in inflation helped salaries Real take-home pay, adjusted for inflation, moderated marginally by 0.2% to R14 804 in June, compared to R14 827 in May, but was still notably up on year-ago levels. 'The significant moderation in consumer inflation during 2024 had a positive impact on the purchasing power of salary earners and the scenario is continuing into 2025, with the latest headline inflation at only 3% for June,' Kruger says. After a challenging few years for salary earners, due to the sluggish local economy and the elevated inflation rate, 2024 turned out to be the best year since 2015, with an average real salary increase of 1.5%. 'With inflation forecast to average 3.5% in 2025 unlike the 4.4% in 2024 and the broader industry suggesting an average salary increase above 5%, 2025 will be the second consecutive year of a real increase in earnings.' Kruger says in addition to supporting salary earners' consumption expenditure and softening the impact of global headwinds on the local economy, the favourable inflation environment created ample scope for the South African Reserve Bank (Sarb) to cut interest rates further. 'Carpe Diem Research Services forecasts a 25 basis points cut at the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) meeting tomorrow. This is likely to be the final cut in the current downward cycle.' ALSO READ: Salaries decreased by 2% in April, but higher than a year ago 2025 volatile but real consumption held up well Despite 2025 turning out to be a volatile year so far, real consumption expenditure held up well, which is an encouraging sign for an economy heavily reliant on consumer spending. Even with confidence levels slipping in the first quarter, the level of real final consumption expenditure by households was 2.8% higher compared to a year earlier. Early indications from Statistics SA indicate that the performance continued in the second quarter, with real retail sales in the first five months of the year up by 4.3%. Uncertainty and low confidence could affect employment and salaries However, Kruger points out that the general economic environment deteriorated in recent months, with downward revisions to growth prospects locally and globally and high levels of uncertainty, fuelling low confidence and a pause on investment decisions. ALSO READ: Decrease in take-home pay reflection of mounting economic pressure 'This could affect employment levels and earnings in the coming months, in an economy with an already high unemployment rate of 32.9%. In addition, tensions between the US and South Africa, coupled with uncertainty over the tariff landscape beyond 1 August, present a growing concern for the economy and its trade outlook. 'As such, it remains of utmost importance that the South African government prioritise its diplomatic engagement with US authorities to negotiate a favourable trade regime to avert job losses in sectors such as automotive and agriculture, which would otherwise face severe impacts,' Kruger says.
