AI doesn't care about authors, but Meta should
As things stand, generative AI models are imitation engines – and they do not celebrate their sources, they conceal them. Writers carry forward ideas and techniques, yes, but an immeasurable part of human creativity comes from the certain knowledge that we will one day die. AI does not have that gift. For all it consumes, it does not choose what to remember or believe or feel. Authors are as much up in arms about the extreme-capitalist assumption that we're simply machines, regurgitating content, as we are about the systemic theft of our work. Human authors also tend to worry about the difference between inspiration and plagiarism. AI has not yet been programmed to care, and no one's holding their breath on that count.Timothy X AtackBristol
Andrew Vincent says creativity has always 'trained' on the work of others. He is right. Reading widely helps my writing, and art influences art. But I'm not objecting to Meta using my work for AI training; I'm objecting to Meta having done so without permission or payment, for commercial gain and outside the scope of fair use. I buy the books I need to read, or borrow them from a proper library, so that the authors get their fair library payment and their intellectual property is respected. Meta has stolen far more books than any single author could read – around 7 million. Please let's consider properly the long-term consequences of allowing big, wealthy tech to flout legal protections and steal intellectual property from artists.Abie LongstaffChair of the Children's Writers and Illustrators Group, Society of Authors
Do you have a photograph you'd like to share with Guardian readers? If so, please click here to upload it. A selection will be published in our Readers' best photographs galleries and in the print edition on Saturdays.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
AI data centers prompt tech giants to buy huge land plots in the US
Across rural America, a new kind of giant has arrived - windowless, brick-like monoliths housing the world's digital brains. The likes of Meta, Amazon and Tesla are snapping up vast tracts of land the size of Manhattan to build sprawling AI data centers that can cost upwards of $3 billion. But their arrival brings serious challenges for families living in their shadows, as the centers guzzle massive amounts of water and electricity. These unsightly buildings are also the poster children of a seismic shift in the economy that experts warn will lead to widespread job losses. If there was ever doubt about the impact of AI's stratospheric growth on office jobs, the latest government figures on private company construction spending tell a clear story. When ChatGPT launched in November 2022, investment in office space to house workers was five times greater than spending on data centers. AI-driven automation is already replacing jobs, as recent layoffs at Amazon, Microsoft, Proctor & Gamble, and others reveal — with fears the trend will only accelerate. For months, Wall Street executives have openly discussed plans to replace white-collar Americans with cost-cutting AI robots. Meanwhile, a report out last week showed layoffs in July had risen 140 percent from a year ago - with AI cited as a major factor. The turn to AI is also sucking up resources from local communities. 'It feels like we're fighting an unwinnable battle that we didn't sign up for,' Beverly Morris, 71, a resident in Newton County, Georgia, told The New York Times. In 2018, Facebook-owner Meta built a data center a thousand feet from her home. Since then, the Morris family has struggled to get enough water from their well to use the toilets, sinks, or dishwasher. When water does reach their home, it often leaves behind a brown residue. Morris received a $25,000 quote to fix the issue but can't afford the repairs. 'I'm scared to drink our own water,' she said. Meta officials claim their water use isn't affecting Morris's property, citing a local water analysis they conducted. But local authorities are raising alarms: Newton County, with a population just over 100,000, is expected to run completely dry by 2030. The Georgia community is not alone. Thirsty data centers - which are training on data from American consumers - are sucking up municipal water, leaving a wake of problems for residents in drought-prone areas. For example, millions of Texans have been advised to take shorter showers as parts of the state face a shortage. Meanwhile, multiple data centers, including a San-Antonio-based facility run by Microsoft and the US Army Corps churned through 463 million gallons of water in 2023 and 2024. Concerns are also growing that the energy grid is not prepared for AI's gargantuan power needs. Studies by the International Energy Agency showed that the centers alone are expected to burn through 945 terawatt-hours of energy each year by 2030. That's more energy than the country of Japan uses in a full year. 'AI is one of the biggest stories in the energy world today,' Fatih Birol, the agency's executive director said.
Daily Mail
7 hours ago
- Daily Mail
America's ghost cities where trillion-dollar beasts the size of Manhattan devour all your secrets
Across rural America, a new kind of giant has arrived - windowless, brick-like monoliths housing the world's digital brains. The likes of Meta, Amazon and Tesla are snapping up vast tracts of land the size of Manhattan to build sprawling AI data centers that can cost upwards of $3 billion. But their arrival brings serious challenges for families living in their shadows, as the centers guzzle massive amounts of water and electricity. These unsightly buildings are also the poster children of a seismic shift in the economy that experts warn will lead to widespread job losses. If there was ever doubt about the impact of AI's stratospheric growth on office jobs, the latest government figures on private company construction spending tell a clear story. When ChatGPT launched in November 2022, investment in office space to house workers was five times greater than spending on data centers. Today, as the graph below shows, the two are nearly neck and neck. This isn't a coincidence. AI-driven automation is already replacing jobs, as recent layoffs at Amazon, Microsoft, Proctor & Gamble, and others reveal — with fears the trend will only accelerate. For months, Wall Street executives have openly discussed plans to replace white-collar Americans with cost-cutting AI robots. Meanwhile, a report out last week showed layoffs in July had risen 140 percent from a year ago - with AI cited as a major factor. The turn to AI is also sucking up resources from local communities. 'It feels like we're fighting an unwinnable battle that we didn't sign up for,' Beverly Morris, 71, a resident in Newton County, Georgia, told The New York Times. In 2018, Facebook-owner Meta built a data center a thousand feet from her home. Since then, the Morris family has struggled to get enough water from their well to use the toilets, sinks, or dishwasher. When water does reach their home, it often leaves behind a brown residue. Morris received a $25,000 quote to fix the issue but can't afford the repairs. 'I'm scared to drink our own water,' she said. Meta officials claim their water use isn't affecting Morris's property, citing a local water analysis they conducted. But local authorities are raising alarms: Newton County, with a population just over 100,000, is expected to run completely dry by 2030. The Georgia community is not alone. Thirsty data centers - which are training on data from American consumers - are sucking up municipal water, leaving a wake of problems for residents in drought-prone areas. For example, millions of Texans have been advised to take shorter showers as parts of the state face a shortage. Meanwhile, multiple data centers, including a San-Antonio-based facility run by Microsoft and the US Army Corps churned through 463 million gallons of water in 2023 and 2024. Concerns are also growing that the energy grid is not prepared for AI's gargantuan power needs. Studies by the International Energy Agency showed that the centers alone are expected to burn through 945 terawatt-hours of energy each year by 2030. That's more energy than the country of Japan uses in a full year. 'AI is one of the biggest stories in the energy world today,' Fatih Birol, the agency's executive director said. In cities that have already been experiencing water issues, like this water break in Texas, centers are exacerbating local droughts Despite questions around resource dependence, major companies are pouring money into even bigger facilities with even more job-displacing capabilities. Meta, which plans to spend $72 billion on AI in 2025, is building two massive data centers in the US, named Prometheus and Hyperion. Mark Zuckerberg, Meta's CEO, compared the scale of Hyperion to New York City's 14,600-acre Manhattan borough in a post on Threads. Its nearly the same size. 'We're building multiple more titan clusters as well,' the social media boss said on his platform. 'Just one of these covers a significant part of the footprint of Manhattan.'
The Guardian
a day ago
- The Guardian
My Grandmother Trelotótó review – following a lost family history from Mozambique to Portugal
At nearly three hours, Catarina Ruivo's sprawling documentary seeks to halt the march of death. When her grandmother Júlia died, she left behind a treasure trove of letters, written between 1946 and 1957 when she was living in Mozambique, then under Portuguese colonial rule. Read out by actor Rita Durão, this correspondence captures the hopes and dreams of a young woman, newly married and adapting to a foreign land. The voiceover is paired with Ruivo's footage of present-day, independent Mozambique, images that breathe a second life into these messages from the past. The juxtaposition between Júlia's writings and the Mozambican cityscapes recalls Chantal Akerman's seminal News from Home (1978), in which Akerman combined her narration of her mother's letters with languid shots of New York City to reveal the intricacies of the mother-daughter relationship and the rhythm of urban living. My Grandmother Trelotótó doesn't quite achieve such cinematic alchemy. Júlia's letters, while seemingly benevolent, betray a colonial gaze that erases the hardships endured by the local population (a fact acknowledged by Ruivo in an artist's statement). The way Mozambique is framed – quotidian scenes full of anonymous faces – appears merely illustrative; it does little to complicate or push against Júlia's problematised point of view. The lethargy of the Mozambique section is countered by video glimpses of Júlia's final years back in Portugal, also shot by Ruivo. Here is where the film feels most reviving; these moments take in the older woman as she is, curious, active, and full of vitality. Ruivo also pays close attention to the rituals of rural life: painstaking scenes of dough being kneaded, and meal preparation. The documentary portrait could have turned into a protracted elegy if not for these sequences, which are filled with a dynamism more powerful than words. My Grandmother Trelotótó is at the ICA, London, from 15 August.
