CSEP study highlights the need for Karnataka to widen State-level initiatives in primary healthcare and elementary education
A study on the drivers of State-level initiatives in primary healthcare and elementary education in urban areas during the last decade has highlighted the need for Karnataka to widen the range of initiatives in primary healthcare and elementary education.
This is important to provide government-funded primary health and elementary education to all in Karnataka, and not just the poorest, the study stated.
The paper titled 'Drivers of primary healthcare and elementary education initiatives in Karnataka (2014–2024)' by Priyadarshini Singh, research fellow at the Centre for Social and Economic Progress (CSEP), was discussed by a panel of experts at a seminar on 'Policy options for urban health and education' on Wednesday.
The panel, which was comprised of public health and education experts Sudha Chandrashekar and Sanjay Kaul, discussed the implications of the study's findings for improving urban public health and education services in Karnataka and beyond.
Recommendations
The working paper, which recommends additional pathways from which new State-level initiatives can emerge, is part of a three-State (Karnataka, Rajasthan, and Odisha) study that examined the drivers of State-level initiatives in primary healthcare and elementary education, focusing specifically on urban areas from 2014-2024.
'The paper investigates three questions in the case of Karnataka — the key initiatives that focus on the overall primary health and elementary education system; ground-level issues in the working of Urban Primary Health Centres and schools, and the reason that drove the emergence of these initiatives,' said Ms. Singh, pointing out that the study is based on extensive fieldwork in two urban municipal corporations — one each in north and south Karnataka.
'Effective social welfare, whether in the areas of education, health, sanitation, water, or nutrition, is not only dependent on how well existing programmes are implemented and governance systems function but also on the extent to which social welfare is prioritised by the State and Central governments. Prioritisation is reflected in forms such as increased budget allocation, mission-mode implementation of existing programmes, or the development of new initiatives that solve specific challenges,' she said presenting the paper.
Sluggish performance
Pointing out that Karnataka is often praised in nationally prominent indices as a progressive State with strong fiscal, health, and education indicators, she said, 'However, our analysis questions this categorisation, suggesting that Karnataka's good performance is limited to certain indicators, where it is only marginally better than the national average. In many other health and education indicators, such as out-of-pocket expenditure and learning levels, Karnataka's performance is sluggish.'
The researcher said Karnataka exhibits stark intra-State disparities, and the uptake of public health and education facilities compared to private ones is poor. 'Despite historically undertaking prominent initiatives, Karnataka is not a national leader in health and education. We analyse the drivers of State-level initiatives to understand why Karnataka has not become a national leader with high uptake and quality of primary health and elementary education in urban areas,' she explained.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
5 hours ago
- The Hindu
CSEP study highlights the need for Karnataka to widen State-level initiatives in primary healthcare and elementary education
A study on the drivers of State-level initiatives in primary healthcare and elementary education in urban areas during the last decade has highlighted the need for Karnataka to widen the range of initiatives in primary healthcare and elementary education. This is important to provide government-funded primary health and elementary education to all in Karnataka, and not just the poorest, the study stated. The paper titled 'Drivers of primary healthcare and elementary education initiatives in Karnataka (2014–2024)' by Priyadarshini Singh, research fellow at the Centre for Social and Economic Progress (CSEP), was discussed by a panel of experts at a seminar on 'Policy options for urban health and education' on Wednesday. The panel, which was comprised of public health and education experts Sudha Chandrashekar and Sanjay Kaul, discussed the implications of the study's findings for improving urban public health and education services in Karnataka and beyond. Recommendations The working paper, which recommends additional pathways from which new State-level initiatives can emerge, is part of a three-State (Karnataka, Rajasthan, and Odisha) study that examined the drivers of State-level initiatives in primary healthcare and elementary education, focusing specifically on urban areas from 2014-2024. 'The paper investigates three questions in the case of Karnataka — the key initiatives that focus on the overall primary health and elementary education system; ground-level issues in the working of Urban Primary Health Centres and schools, and the reason that drove the emergence of these initiatives,' said Ms. Singh, pointing out that the study is based on extensive fieldwork in two urban municipal corporations — one each in north and south Karnataka. 'Effective social welfare, whether in the areas of education, health, sanitation, water, or nutrition, is not only dependent on how well existing programmes are implemented and governance systems function but also on the extent to which social welfare is prioritised by the State and Central governments. Prioritisation is reflected in forms such as increased budget allocation, mission-mode implementation of existing programmes, or the development of new initiatives that solve specific challenges,' she said presenting the paper. Sluggish performance Pointing out that Karnataka is often praised in nationally prominent indices as a progressive State with strong fiscal, health, and education indicators, she said, 'However, our analysis questions this categorisation, suggesting that Karnataka's good performance is limited to certain indicators, where it is only marginally better than the national average. In many other health and education indicators, such as out-of-pocket expenditure and learning levels, Karnataka's performance is sluggish.' The researcher said Karnataka exhibits stark intra-State disparities, and the uptake of public health and education facilities compared to private ones is poor. 'Despite historically undertaking prominent initiatives, Karnataka is not a national leader in health and education. We analyse the drivers of State-level initiatives to understand why Karnataka has not become a national leader with high uptake and quality of primary health and elementary education in urban areas,' she explained.
Time of India
9 hours ago
- Time of India
No Family Doctors, No Continuity of Care: Dr. Paul Flags Dangerous Gap in India's Healthcare System
New Delhi: In a bold call for transformation, Dr. V. K. Paul , Member (Health), NITI Aayog , outlined a sweeping blueprint to revamp India's medical education system, stating that the country must train not just for adequacy but for ambition, as part of its journey toward becoming a developed nation. Speaking at a policy dialogue hosted by the Centre for Social and Economic Progress (CSEP), Dr. Paul addressed critical issues of medical manpower, quality of postgraduate training, and structural reforms needed to match the healthcare needs of 2040 and beyond. 'We must shed the illusion that we're anywhere close to sufficient,' Dr. Paul said. 'A ratio of one doctor per 1,000, the WHO norm, may suffice for low-income nations. For India, aiming to be a global leader, we need three per 1,000—this must be our goalpost by 2040.' India's Specialist Shortage is 'Alarming' Citing data on specialist shortfalls, Dr. Paul painted a sobering picture stating that the current rate of producing 5,500 general surgeons per year, India will take 34 years to match the average for lower-middle-income countries and 69 years to meet high-income benchmarks. For psychiatrists, the country has 0.7 per 100,000 people, compared to the LMIC average of 2, and would require 23 years to close the gap. For cardiologists, India lags drastically—with projections of an 82-year wait to meet international standards. 'This is not just a workforce issue; it's an issue of national health resilience,' he said. Dr. Paul called for an overhaul of the MBBS curriculum to better prepare graduates for real-world care. He stressed the need for deeper exposure to internal medicine, geriatrics, psychiatry, and chronic disease management—areas that often receive less than four weeks of training under the current system. 'Our internship structure is broken. How can a student become proficient in schizophrenia or diabetes management with three weeks of exposure?' he asked. 'In high-income countries, becoming a family physician takes 10 years. We try to compress all that into five and a half.' Urgent Need to Mainstream Family and Emergency Medicine Perhaps the most impassioned part of Dr. Paul's address was his plea to mainstream Family Medicine—a specialty largely ignored in Indian medical training. 'If we continue on our current path, by 2035 we will be a country with only specialists and barely any generalists,' he warned. 'That's a broken healthcare model. Family physicians are critical for managing chronic diseases, elderly care, mental health, and ensuring continuity of care.' Despite national policy backing and global best practices, India has less than 100 Family Medicine postgraduate seats. Dr. Paul urged the National Medical Commission (NMC) to urgently expand these, including adopting the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) model, where Family Medicine training is delivered without needing a standalone department. He also highlighted the neglect of Emergency Medicine, which he called 'the face of healthcare' and critical for equitable access. 'Emergency departments in most medical colleges are grossly underdeveloped. A single resident, 30 patients, and no consultant oversight—that's the reality today,' he said, advocating mandatory emergency medicine departments in new colleges. Dr. Paul urged policymakers to view health not as a cost but as a driver of economic development. 'Healthy people drive innovation, productivity, and growth. The healthcare workforce must be seen as a core part of India's human capital strategy,' he said. He concluded with a call for collaboration across ministries, private sector participation, and a shift in mindset: ' Medical education reform is no longer optional. It is foundational to India's ambition to become a developed, equitable nation.'
The Hindu
16 hours ago
- The Hindu
New Health Sub Centres to come up in T.N. with no new staff posts, basic infrastructure
Tamil Nadu is set to see the creation of 642 new Health Sub Centres (HSC) in rural and urban areas. However, there is a catch. The new facilities have been approved, but without new staff posts and basic infrastructure support. Instead, Auxiliary Nurse Midwives (ANM), who are working in Primary Health Centres (PHC), will be redeployed to the new HSCs. This decision has raised some serious questions on how the Health department has been handling acute shortages of manpower, including some 3,000-odd vacancies of Village Health Nurses (VHN)/ANMs for the past four years, while adding on new health infrastructure. The State currently has 8,713 HSCs, with the norms prescribing one HSC for every 5,000-6,000 population. Establishing 642 urban and rural HSCs on the basis of population was one of the announcements made by the Health Minister in the Assembly earlier this year. In line with this, a Government Order issued on June 13 stated that the Directorate of Public Health and Preventive Medicine submitted a proposal and the list of 642 HSCs were identified for new creation on rationalisation as per population norms in rural and urban areas 'with no additional fund'. Each HSC has one post of VHN. Based on the proposal, the State government, while giving administrative nod for establishing the HSCs (617 in rural and 25 in urban), stated that creation of new posts will not be sanctioned and ANMs have to be redeployed to the HSCs as the posts of VHNs and ANMs carries identical scale of pay and are interchangeable. The available rent-free building or any government building should be utilised for the HSCs, and for the most basic infrastructure, such as fan and furniture, the existing infrastructure available in the PHC under which the HSC is located should be utilised. But this was not all. Electricity charges for the newly-created HSCs should be managed from the funds allocated towards electricity charges for the respective PHCs. As per official data, 2,013 posts of VHNs (of the 8,713 sanctioned) and 1,251 posts of ANMs (of the 2,057 sanctioned) are lying vacant, a source in the Health department pointed out. 'This shortage remains unresolved for the last four years citing court cases. For a government that has strong legal teams, it is unacceptable that legal issues relating to health manpower are not being resolved,' he said. Redeploying ANMs from PHCs to the new HSCs will give rise to additional vacancies in PHCs. 'As of now, 806 ANMs are in place. If nearly 600 of them are shifted, then additional vacancies will rise in PHCs. Not to forget that there is a huge vacancy of staff nurses in PHCs,' he added. 'Every time we ask, the court cases are cited for delay in filling up the VHN vacancies. As a result, maternal and child health services are getting affected. When the government has been successful in many cases, they should sort out this at the earliest. Instead of redeploying ANMs, the department should create new posts and fill up the vacant posts of VHNs at the earliest,' K.S. Manimegalai, State president, Tamil Nadu Government Health Women Union, said. A health official said they would fill up the vacancies immediately after the case was vacated in the Supreme Court. 'We have already filed the counter to vacate the stay and are waiting for the judgement,' he said, adding that ANM redeployment would be done as per procedure and need.
