Facing 153 sexual abuse cases, the Fresno Diocese seeks bankruptcy. Critics call it delay tactic
The financial reorganization process comes more than a year after the diocese declared its initial intent to seek relief in U.S. bankruptcy court.
Fresno church officials said the action will help them avoid insolvency, while victims of abuse and their attorneys excoriated the church for what they describe as delay tactics to help the diocese evade justice.
Church officials are scheduled at Eastern District Court in Fresno on Monday for their next hearing in front of Judge René Lastreto II.
'I am clear-sighted that this path is the only path that will allow us to handle claims of sexual abuse with fair, equitable compassion while simultaneously ensuring the continuation of ministry within our Diocese,' Bishop Joseph V. Brennan wrote in a letter to parishioners. 'Our Church must address the suffering that victims of clergy sexual abuse endure.'
Although the church has not conceded responsibility on all 153 claims, Brennan said a fund will be established by the court for distribution to survivors.
Jeff Anderson, whose law firm has represented clergy abuse victims in 11 of California's 12 dioceses, including the Archdiocese of Los Angeles, said the proceedings help the diocese and bishop avoid accountability.
'By forcing survivors into bankruptcy court, they are once again denying responsibility,' Anderson wrote in a statement. 'But we will stand with survivors and fight for the full measure of truth, justice, and healing they deserve.'
In May 2024, the church acknowledged more than 150 sexual abuse claims made against it since Assembly Bill 218 was enacted in January 2020.
AB 218 opened a three-year window for some civil sexual assault claims that previously timed out due to the statute of limitations.
The deadline to file a claim closed Dec. 31, 2022, under the legislation.
Attorney Jennifer Stein said all 50 of the firm's clients filed lawsuits directly because of AB 218, with one filing in 2019 in anticipation of the Assembly bill's passage.
She said most victims were children forever 'scarred' by the trauma that stemmed from clergy abuse.
'That's trauma that stays with you throughout your professional and academic career, in interpersonal relationships and marriages,' she said. 'Each and every single survivor has a story to tell as a result of their abuse and that isn't highlighted enough.'
Stein said that bankruptcy robs victims of the spotlight and converts court proceedings into a focus on property and corporate structure that could span several years.
'As compared to state court litigation, bankruptcy is about the church's ability to pay,' she said.
Fresno's diocese includes more than 1 million Catholics among 87 parishes and 21 schools from Fresno, Kern, Kings, Inyo, Madera, Mariposa, Merced and Tulare counties.
The diocese released a list of 63 clergy and lay people accused in 2021, including ordained priests as early as 1906. Though most were local, some clergy hailed from Guatemala, France, Ireland, Mexico and the Philippines.
On Monday, attorney Rick Simons filed a motion in court calling for an investigation into Fresno's bankruptcy announcement. He said he believes the more than year-long lag since May 2024 was fraudulently used to delay several dozen cases. Simons manages a legal proceeding called Northern California Clergy Cases, in which nearly 1,800 individual lawsuits have been filed against seven Catholic dioceses, including Fresno.
Simons told The Times the advantages for the church include survivors dying out, getting tired and quitting or greatly reducing their expectations.
He also noted that the church could have used this time to rearrange money and property to make sure certain funds or accounts are not part of the debtor's estate. The declared intent for bankruptcy also 'stops jury trials and discovery from going forward while cases are waiting for bankruptcy,' according to Simons.
The church declined to comment on the accusation.
Church officials have said that they do not expect an impact to diocese-run elementary and high schools along with catholic charities and other area affiliates.
Though diocese officials have said they also do not expect an impact at Catholic cemeteries, those properties have been listed in the Chapter 11 filing.
The diocese acknowledged that the value of Diocesan assets available to resolve claims, including any available insurance coverage, may not be sufficient to cover the claims and could leave the diocese insolvent.
The diocese also verified that it was not receiving any financial help from the Vatican.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Los Angeles Times
05-08-2025
- Los Angeles Times
'Essentially Epstein Island:' law firm calls for federal probe into L.A. County sex abuse
A prominent law firm suing L.A. County over childhood sexual abuse is pushing for a federal investigation into how so many children were harmed on the government's watch. The county agreed in April to a $4 billion settlement to resolve roughly 7,000 cases of sexual abuse inside the county's juvenile detention facilities and foster homes dating back decades. But attorney John Manly, who has about 200 cases against the county, said despite the eye-popping sum, there's still no clear picture of who is responsible for the rampant abuse. No one has been criminally charged since the deluge of cases began. 'This is essentially Epstein Island being supervised by Los Angeles County probation officers,' said Manly, referring to Jeffrey Epstein, the notorious financier who died by suicide while awaiting trial on sex-trafficking charges. 'It's shocking, and there's no outrage, none, zero. It's like, 'Oh yeah, okay, we'll just take $4 billion of public money and we'll settle, and then it'll be gone.' No, we want answers.' Manly served as lead counsel for victims abused by USA Gymnastics doctor Larry Nassar and former USC gynecologist George Tyndall. His firm, Manly, Stewart & Finaldi, is one of several firms that are not part of the L.A. County settlement. The first trial for his cases is set to begin this month. In a letter addressed to U.S. Atty. Bill Essayli, Manly wrote that he wanted to see the U.S. Attorney's Office conduct an 'immediate investigation' into any federal crimes committed by staff within the L.A. County Probation Department, which is responsible for overseeing the juvenile facilities where much of the alleged abuse took place. 'The sad and unbelievable truth is these camps were dens of sexual predation where LA County probation officers in charge of helping these children get on track turned them into human sex toys,' the Aug. 4 letter stated. 'The lack of interest in prosecution of those literally engaged in a massive human trafficking operation where thousands of vulnerable children were savaged sexually reeks of politics, corruption and a malignant indifference to the children.' The U.S. Attorney's Office declined to comment. The deluge of litigation against the county is rooted in a change in state law, known as AB 218, which gave victims of childhood sexual abuse a new window to sue their abuser. Since then, the county, along with many school districts, have been flooded with lawsuits, some dating back to the 1950s. A county spokesperson did not immediately respond to a request for comment. The county has said in the past they've taken many steps to try to prevent abuse in recent years, including strengthening the vetting of foster parents and probation staffers and winding down the use of group homes, where some of the alleged abuse took place. County officials have said it has been nearly impossible to defend themselves against these cases because many of the records were discarded long ago. Prosecuting those cases has been similarly difficult, as many victims, who were children at the time of the abuse, never knew the first names of their abusers. The perpetrators are usually identified in the lawsuits as some variation on John Doe, with few identifying details. Since the flood of lawsuits began, county officials referred only two of the cases to the District Attorney's Office for investigation: Altovise Abner, a probation supervisor who was investigated for having sex with a minor at a camp in 2006, and Thomas Jackson, a former probation official who was accused by more than two dozen women of sexually abusing them when they were minors. Jackson resigned in 2023 after three decades with the county. The cases against both were outside the statute of limitations, according to a memo by the DA's office explaining the decision not to prosecute.
Business Wire
04-08-2025
- Business Wire
Law Firm of Cerri, Boskovich & Allard Announces Two Students Sexually Abused 50 Years Ago Settle Lawsuit With Mountain View Whisman School District for $1.6 Million
MOUNTAIN VIEW, Calif.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--The law firm of Cerri, Boskovich & Allard is reporting that two students sexually abused in the early 1970s have settled their lawsuit against the Mountain View Whisman School District (MVWSD) for $1.6 million. The lawsuit alleged sexual abuse by Steven Myers, a former teacher and vice principal at Crittenden Middle School during the early 1970s. The settlement resolves claims that Myers groomed and assaulted two students in the early 1970s, highlighting serious oversight failures in the district at the time. It took the passage of Assembly Bill 218 in 2020 to extend the statute of limitations for such lawsuits, allowing survivors to seek justice decades after the abuse occurred. 'For decades, school districts like Mountain View Whisman have avoided taking responsibility for the harm they caused to sexual abuse victims,' attorney Lauren Cerri said. 'It took the passage of Assembly Bill 218 in 2020 to extend the statute of limitations for such lawsuits, allowing survivors to seek justice decades after the abuse occurred.' The Mountain View Whisman lawsuit is part of broader legal actions against Myers, who also faced sexual abuse allegations arising from his employment with Santa Cruz City Schools (SCCS), where he served as principal of Branciforte Junior High School from 1981 to 1984 and ran the Traveling School. In 2024, the law firm of Cerri, Boskovich & Allard achieved justice for two more victims of Myers against SCCS. The lawsuit brought by the firm settled for $4.5 million. 'These cases reveal a pattern of misconduct by Myers, who exploited his authority across multiple districts over decades,' Cerri said. Myers, who has gone by many aliases including Stephen Jackson, operated the Traveling School Summer Program, a six-week initiative for students with behavioral and academic challenges, at both Crittenden and later in Santa Cruz. The program, described as a "school on wheels," included controversial elements like "Body Theme Days," where students were required to wear minimal clothing, and massage sessions led by Myers. Depositions revealed a lack of oversight, with no policies governing teacher-student interactions or background checks conducted on Myers. Across five decades, from 1968 to 2018, at least 11 men have reported sexual abuse by Myers, with over 20 alleging inappropriate conduct during their minor years in locations including Mountain View, Santa Cruz, and Denver. Despite these allegations, Myers has not faced criminal prosecution due to statutes of limitations. His teaching credentials were revoked in California and Colorado following reports of misconduct. The settlements by MVWSD and SCCS mark steps toward accountability for past failures, providing some justice for survivors. These cases underscore the critical need for rigorous background checks, oversight, and policies to protect students in educational settings. This press release may constitute Attorney Advertising in some jurisdictions under the applicable law and ethical rules.
USA Today
01-08-2025
- USA Today
Antonio Brown, at court-mandated appearance for bankruptcy case, downplays rich lifestyle
In social media posts, Antonio Brown has appeared to be living a life of luxury in the United Arab Emirates. In a court-mandated appearance as part of his bankruptcy case, however, he said the reality is different. Brown fielded questions about his finances and social media activity during an Aug. 1 meeting of creditors in his Chapter 7 bankruptcy case, downplaying the lavish lifestyle that he has appeared to be living in Dubai over the past seven weeks. The former NFL wide receiver said he does not have any cryptocurrency accounts, does not own any jewelry, does not own any of the expensive sports cars that he has been seen driving in social media posts and is not paying rent in the United Arab Emirates. "I'm actually staying out here with some people, brother," Brown said when asked about his living arrangements. The 37-year-old declined to specify who owns the property at which he has been staying or who is paying the rent, but he said the person is not an American citizen. Attempted murder charge. Bankruptcy. Music. The bizarre post-NFL life of Antonio Brown Brown also indicated that he could soon return to the United States, where he has a warrant out for his arrest after being charged with attempted second-degree murder on June 11. The charge stems from an alleged altercation outside an amateur boxing event on May 16 in Miami. "Hopefully, yes," Brown said, when asked if he planned to return to the U.S. at some point in the near future. The question came in the context of scheduling, as Brown will be asked to sit for a deposition in the bankruptcy case. Because he has an active warrant out for his arrest, he likely would be detained by Customs and Border Protection upon returning to the U.S. A State Department spokesperson declined comment earlier this week when asked by USA TODAY Sports if Brown could be extradited from the United Arab Emirates. The spokesperson cited the department's longstanding policy to not comment on the possible existence of extradition requests. Brown filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in May 2024, according to court records, and his case has since been converted to Chapter 7 − a form of bankruptcy in which the court can seize assets and garnish wages to repay creditors. The longtime Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver, who publicly estimated that he made more than $100 million during his NFL career, now owes more than $3.5 million to a handful of creditors. Brown was ordered to appear at Friday's meeting of creditors, which is also known as a 341 meeting, after previously failing to provide the necessary financial documents to the U.S. trustee overseeing his case, Leslie Osborne. Brown joined the meeting several minutes late from what appeared to be a Dubai hotel room. Meetings of creditors are not court hearings and they are not overseen by a judge. But they nevertheless play an important role in the early stages of the bankruptcy process, requiring debtors to answer questions about their finances under penalty of perjury. Friday's meeting was open to members of the public. Osborne's attorney, D. Brett Marks, asked Brown several questions about his life in Dubai and some of his activity on social media, including a June 26 post on X in which the former NFL wideout posted a screenshot of an account balance exceeding $24 million with the caption "bankrupt over." Brown replied that it was an old post and he does not have an account with $24 million. Brown also offered unclear answers when asked about how he is making money and paying for his current lifestyle. When asked about video clips of himself driving luxurious sports cars that he has posted on social media, he denied owning any cars in the United Arab Emirates, then suggested that such clips might have been manufactured by artificial intelligence. Upon further questioning, Brown said he sometimes has access to sports cars as part of a promotional arrangement with a rental car company. Report: Former NFL WR Antonio Brown facing attempted murder charge in Florida Osborne, the trustee tasked with helping Brown pay off his debts, said at the start of the meeting that he had received only two of the requested bank statements from the seven-time Pro Bowler. Brown told Osborne that he would work with his attorney to provide the requested documents − including the original deed of one of the houses he owns in Florida, which could be put up for sale to pay off some of Brown's debts. At the most recent court hearing in Brown's bankruptcy case, on July 24, judge Peter Russin said Brown's case would be "hanging in the balance" if he did not provide financial documents and follow the court's rules. "I really want to explain to him that he's got his future in his own hands," Russin said during the hearing. "He can resolve all these things very simply just by doing what he's obligated to do anyway, and leave here with his financial situation generally intact." Contact Tom Schad at tschad@ or on social media @
