Mining of authors' work is nothing new – AI is just doing what creative humans do
Authors say they are angry that Meta has used their material to train its artificial intelligence (Authors call for UK government to hold Meta accountable for copyright infringement, 31 March). But hasn't that been going on for thousands of years? Isn't all human thought an iteration of what has gone before? Artists and scientists have been mining the work of others for generations; that's how human thought evolves.
Ian McEwan was influenced by LP Hartley's The Go-Between. George Orwell's Nighteen Eighty-Four was inspired by Yevgeny Zamyatin's We. Did Richard Osman invent the genre of cosy crime? The publishing industry as a whole is guilty of putting out bandwagon books, which ape the style, themes and tropes of a hit.
The chief executive of the Society of Authors, Anna Ganley, says writers are 'up in arms'. Did she coin that phrase? Creativity has always 'trained' on the work of others.Andrew VincentWestmancote, Worcestershire
Do you have a photograph you'd like to share with Guardian readers? If so, please click here to upload it. A selection will be published in our Readers' best photographs galleries and in the print edition on Saturdays.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
8 hours ago
- The Guardian
Tell us your favourite new podcasts of 2025 so far
We would like to hear about the new podcasts you have particularly enjoyed listening to so far this year. Is there a podcast from this year that has you rapt? Are there any new releases that you would recommend? Tell us your nomination and why you like it below. You can tell us your favourite new podcast of the year so far using this form. Please include as much detail as possible. Please note, the maximum file size is 5.7 MB. Your contact details are helpful so we can contact you for more information. They will only be seen by the Guardian. Your contact details are helpful so we can contact you for more information. They will only be seen by the Guardian. If you include other people's names please ask them first.
Wales Online
8 hours ago
- Wales Online
Julianne Moore turned down parts over sunburn fears
Julianne Moore turned down parts over sunburn fears The 64-year-old Hollywood actress has admitted her pale skin often becomes a factor in her decision-making Julianne Moore (Image: GETTY ) Julianne Moore turns down jobs which involve a lot of filming outdoors because she's scared of getting sunburnt. The 64-year-old Hollywood actress has admitted her pale skin often becomes a factor in her decision-making when looking at prospective movie roles because she doesn't want to be forced to film outside with no shade because she would "incinerate". She told the Guardian newspaper: "I have, on occasion, turned things down if it's something that was taking place outside, like, all the time with no shade. "'Guess what? We're shooting at the beach every single day!' That would be tough. I would incinerate." Julianne has Scottish heritage through her mother, who moved from the UK to the US as a young girl, and she admits her mom's roots played a big part in her own childhood. She added: "Many of us have parents who were from somewhere else, so that meant your parents had different customs or languages. Article continues below "My mother felt very different from the American mothers I knew. She had an accent. She cooked different things: nothing weird, just roast beef, for instance. We had little kilts. I had my hair braided and American mothers didn't do that." Julianne - who is mother to Caleb, 27, and Liv, 23, with husband Bart Freundlich - also revealed she bonded with her The Room Next Door co-star Tilda Swinton over their shared heritage. She added: "I love her. She's Scottish and I'm Scottish-American. We both have red hair. Our children – her twins and my oldest – are the same age. And both of our sons have red beards. Isn't that funny?" One of Julianne's latest roles is in new movie Echo Valley opposite Sydney Sweeney, 27, as her onscreen daughter and she's praised her co-star as "so talented" and revealed they had a lot of "fun"on the shoot. She told Extra: "Sydney's so terrific, she's so available, she's so professional, she's so talented, and we just had a really good time, you know, building the relationship and being with each other. "I think we're aware of how important this relationship is, the mother-daughter bond, and how much it can hold, how elastic it is, and how far you can push it with each other. Article continues below "It can be volatile, especially when kids are younger, when girls are teenagers and you realise they've had this tremendous history. But it was fun. I think we were able to match each other's energy, and we really enjoyed each other's company, and it worked."
The Independent
9 hours ago
- The Independent
Meta sues deepfake ‘nudify' app which uses AI to remove clothing from photos
Meta is suing a Chinese app maker that uses artificial intelligence to take images of clothed people and turn them into nudes. "CrushAI" — the company behind the app used to make the deepfake nudes — is operated by Joy Timeline HK Limited. Meta filed a lawsuit against the company in Hong Kong to ban it from advertising its services on Meta platforms, CBS News reports. "This legal action underscores both the seriousness with which we take this abuse and our commitment to doing all we can to protect our community from it," Meta said in a statement. "We'll continue to take necessary steps — which could include legal action — against those who abuse our platforms like this." According to the lawsuit, Joy Timeline made "multiple attempts" to try to get around Meta's ad review process. Joy Timeline's app isn't the first app of its kind and previous apps that promise to make clothed photos into nudes have actually managed to bypass ad filters on major social media platforms — including Meta — in order to hawk their software. The company said that the "nudify" apps have devised various ways of skirting past the ad filter, including by using inoffensive imagery to try to fly under the radar. "We've worked with external experts and our own specialist teams to expand the list of safety-related terms, phrases and emojis that our systems are trained to detect with these ads," Meta said in a statement. Alexios Mantzarlis, the author of the Faked Up blog, told the BBC there had been "at least 10,000 ads" promoting nudify apps on Meta's Facebook and Instagram platforms. "Even as [Meta] was making this announcement, I was able to find a dozen ads by CrushAI live on the platform and a hundred more from other 'nudifiers'," he told the broadcaster. "This abuse vector requires continued monitoring from researchers and the media to keep platforms accountable and curtail the reach of these noxious tools." The threat of the software is that anyone could feasibly take a photo and, without the photo subject's consent, turn it into a fake nude. Meta said that it bans "non-consensual intimate imagery" on its platforms, and previously told CBS News that it removes any ads on its platforms for "nudify" apps. On Thursday, Meta said it would work with the Tech Coalition's Lantern Program — aimed at tracking sites that break child safety rules — to share information with other tech companies about apps, sites, or companies that violate its policies.
