Is Brigitte Macron wise to sue a right-wing podcaster over crackpot claims she was born a man?
a rare insight
into what Mr Justice Michael Twomey described as 'millionaire' court costs. It went public only because the defendant was arguing that the plaintiff would be unable to pay the likely eye-watering costs if the latter lost the case.
In short, the losing party could face an overall bill of between €1 million and €2 million, said the judge, who
remarked in passing
that the Taoiseach's salary of about €230,000 covers his work for an entire 12 months.
Anyone contemplating legal action might consider the American satirist Ambrose Bierce's definition of litigation: a machine that you go into as a pig and come out as a sausage.
In the US, defamation juries play with the kind of numbers that would make lawyers here blanch. In E Jean Carroll's defamation case against
Donald Trump
(following an earlier judgment that found him liable for sexually abusing her)
the jury awarded her $83.3 million
, which he is appealing.
READ MORE
But the really big ones are rarely just about numbers. Many fervently pray for the day that Trump and Rupert Murdoch
face off in court over the Wall Street Journal's report
about Trump's 'secret' birthday message for Epstein, but the number are almost irrelevant; it's about discovery.
It's only partly about the numbers in the Brigitte and
Emmanuel Macron
v Candace Owens US defamation lawsuit, in that a punitive jury could bankrupt Owens.
Owens, a right-wing podcaster and commentator, is married to the son of a wealthy Tory peer. With about 11 million followers between X and YouTube alone, it's no mystery why multiple platforms continue to carry her heinous, cracked conspiracy theories about the Macrons; it's a whale of a money-spinner.
American right-wing podcaster Candace Owens. The French president, Emmanuel Macron, and his wife, Brigitte Macron, filed a defamation suit last week against Owens, who claimed Brigitte Macron is actually a man. Photograph: Rebecca Noble/The New York Times
The 219-page lawsuit drills separately into each of the eight podcast episodes from her Becoming Brigitte series aired this year. Those episodes can (still) be found on multiple platforms, which means that tens of millions are still thrilling to her claims that Brigitte Macron was born a man and stole her (still living) brother's identity; that she fathered her children with an imaginary woman; that her husband is her incestuous son or nephew; that the couple are part 'of a very small group of elite oligarchs who routinely practice homosexuality and paedophilia, believe in Baphomet [a satanic figure] and worship a transgender deity'.
Though given verifiable evidence disproving the claims, she doubled down with the podcast series and accompanying X posts.
With news of the lawsuit, her followers have pivoted. Once overnight experts in epidemiology, crypto and elite paedophile gangs operating out of pizza parlours, they are now bringing such expertise to advising Owens on defamation law; counselling that the first amendment is her best protection, and that surely calling a person transgender is not considered an insult among the DEI libtards so where's the harm?
Some just want a chromosome test already.
Many who question the Macrons' decision to sue rightly fear Bierce's sausage machine. Some murmur darkly about
the Streisand effect
(where efforts to minimise or hide information only serve to escalate it). Or they shrug that them's the breaks of a public life, as if the couple were too dim to have considered the implications.
Brigitte Macron and relatives have already been through Bierce's machine. Their French defamation suit against the original conspiracy theorists ended badly this month when an appeals court overturned a ruling ordering the defendants to pay damages, on the basis that their false claims about Macron had been made in 'good faith'.
Perhaps the answer to the question 'why now?' lies in pages 91 and 92 of the US suit where Owens – 'egging on the Macrons' – said in a video last February: 'Where's your lawsuit? Where's your lawsuit, Brigitte?'
The taunt was picked up by
Joe Rogan
, often described as the most popular podcaster in the world, who agreed that Brigitte Macron was indeed a man and then said: '[Owens] would be getting sued right now instead of trying to bribe her. Instead of trying to give her money to shut the f**k up, they would sue her.' The Macrons deny offering her any type of bribe or money.
On the face of it, court days featuring the glamour, wealth and power of the Macrons v Owens promise rare entertainment for the masses. Yet there is something poignant about plaintiffs feeling compelled to include a birth announcement of a baby girl and family photographs of Brigitte as a child, of her first communion and of her first wedding in 1974 to prove the truth of her existence as a daughter, wife and mother.
The Macrons have been subjected to 'a campaign of global humiliation', says the suit. 'It is invasive, dehumanising and deeply unjust'.
Owens, a mother of four, is unmoved. She continues to double down on her repulsive narrative while, in a classic Maga act of projection, portraying herself as a victim of media defamation and implying that her life is under threat.
Why a US podcaster would target a couple in a country her fans would be unable to find on a map is another question. Whether she is acting alone may be the stuff of another conspiracy theory – but as the woman herself proves hour after hour, anything is possible.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Thousands pay respects to NYPD officer killed in mass shooting in Manhattan
With officers stationed for security on rooftops around the Bronx mosque, fire trucks used their ladders to hold a huge American flag over a nearby street ahead of services for officer Didarul Islam. A flatbed truck carried a digital billboard showing photos of him and a commemorative message from his union. Mr Islam (36) was working a department-approved private security detail, in uniform, when he was fatally shot on Monday in a midtown Manhattan building that houses the National Football League's headquarters. A security guard, real estate company employee and investment firm executive were also killed. The gunman also wounded a fifth victim, an NFL employee, before taking his own life. 'This officer saved lives. He was out front. Others may be alive today because he was the barrier,' governor Kathy Hochul told family, friends and other dignitaries at the Parkchester Jame Masjid mosque. An immigrant from Bangladesh, Mr Islam was building a career in the police force. He served as a school safety agent before becoming a patrol officer less than four years ago. 'He could have gone into any other occupation he wanted, but he wanted to put on that uniform, and he wanted to protect fellow New Yorkers. And he wanted to let us know that he believed in what this city and what this country stood for,' mayor Eric Adams told the gathering. 'That's the greatest symbol of what we know we are as a country.' Mr Islam was assigned to a precinct in the Bronx, the borough where he lived with his wife and two young sons. His wife is expecting the birth of their third child soon. He was buried yesterday at a cemetery in Totowa, New Jersey. Another victim, Julia Hyman, was buried following a service on Wednesday at a Manhattan synagogue. ADVERTISEMENT The 27-year-old Cornell University graduate had worked for Rudin Management, which owns the building. Funeral arrangements for the two others killed, security guard Aland Etienne and investment firm executive Wesley LePatner, have not been made public. Police identified the gunman as Shane Tamura, a 27-year old former high school football player who most recently worked in a Las Vegas casino's surveillance department. Authorities say he drove to Manhattan because he believed he had a brain disease linked to contact sports and accused the NFL of hiding the dangers of playing football. Officials said he was heading for the NFL's office, but took the wrong elevator and went by mistake to another floor that housed Rudin Management's offices. The wounded NFL employee happened to be in the lobby when Tamura was firing. Mr Adams, a retired police captain, said the bloodshed 'cut me to my core.'
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
‘We don't want another 9/11 attack' – warning that Israel's war on Gaza could provoke attack on US soil
The worsening humanitarian situation in Gaza risks undermining America's standing in the Middle East and radicalising would-be terrorists to target the US, a senior congressional aide told The Telegraph. 'Ending Hamas is beneficial to American national security, but at what cost? If we continue to see this humanitarian crisis exacerbate, that does further damage to America's standing globally,' the source said, warning that US support for Israel comes with the risk of American citizens becoming targets in revenge plots by Hamas and its allies. 'Ultimately, we don't want to see another 9/11.' The source added that, while Israel is 'fighting a valiant and fair and worthy fight' against Hamas, the tools that Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister, and the IDF are using against the Palestinian territory risk provoking 'further escalation against the West'. The warning comes as international pressure is mounting on Israel to ensure humanitarian relief reaches the people of Gaza, amid reports from aid groups that thousands of children could die from starvation as the enclave teeters on the brink of famine. In a rare divergence from Mr Netanyahu, President Donald Trump acknowledged on Monday that there was 'real starvation' in Gaza, adding the US would set up aid centres. 'We have to get the kids fed,' he said. Responding to Israel's insistence that there is 'no starvation' and that such claims were being spread by Hamas, Mr Trump said: 'I see it, and you can't fake that,' although he stopped short of criticising Mr Netanyahu directly. Mr Trump was referring to images and television reports showing distressingly thin children inside Gaza. Marjorie Taylor Greene accused Israel of genocide Vice-president JD Vance also struck a more direct tone towards Israel during a visit to Ohio on Monday, in which he called the images of starving children 'heartbreaking' and said it was 'up to the Israelis' to allow aid into the enclave. MAGA Republicans broke with the administration this week, urging Mr Trump to get tough with Israel. Marjorie Taylor Greene, a MAGA firebrand and Trump loyalist, became the first GOP lawmaker to accuse the Jewish state of carrying out 'genocide'. Ms Taylor Greene, who has previously accused Israel critics within Congress of 'sympathising with terrorists', compared the 'genocide, humanitarian crisis and starvation' in Gaza to the horrors of October 7. She was joined by Steve Bannon, a former Trump adviser, who told his War Room podcast that Israel has 'almost no support' among MAGA supporters under the age of 30, and accused Mr Netanyahu of trying to 'save himself politically by dragging America in deeper to another Middle East war'. A former Trump White House senior adviser said: 'Right now the Bannons and the Marjorie Taylor Greenes are at the very beginning stages of potentially gaining traction on this issue.' Unwavering support for Israel has long been a core tenet of Republican politics, but as the humanitarian crisis unfolds in Gaza, patience with Mr Netanyahu's government among lawmakers in Washington is beginning to wear thin.
Irish Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
US actor jailed for rape of woman in Dublin
A man who placed his arms around the neck of a woman causing her to pass out before he raped her has been jailed for five years. American Kevin Yungman (32) first met the Brazilian woman in Paris three months previously when they both happened to be on a walking tour of the city. She was 19 at the time and had been working in Dublin. Yungman was 25 years old. They had never met before. They spent the day together, had wine and chocolate at the Eiffel Tower and returned to his accommodation where they had consensual sex. However during this meeting Yungman had told the woman at one point to start breathing fast, take a deep breath and hold it in before he placed a hand on her neck causing her to pass out. Yungman later explained to the woman that this was a technique he did when he was having sex. He said when a person passes out it feels like you have taken drugs. He said it was normal and suggested it could be addictive. The woman told him that she had been scared by it. They stayed in contact and agreed to meet again in Dublin the following June. They rented an AirBnB and again there was consensual sexual activity before Yungman raped the woman. He placed his arms around her neck and squeezed hard. She tried to keep his arms away from her but she could not move out. She later told gardaí she was not strong enough. The Criminal Courts of Justice, Dublin. (Image: Getty Images) She described to gardaí that at that point she passed out. Yungman tried to turn her over and told her 'that's my girl, that's my girl' before he raped her. The woman told gardaí she could not cope with it and asked him to 'please stop' telling him 'my body cannot take it'. Yungman said he would give her a break and they could go back to it later. Detective Garda Kerrie Sullivan told Anne Rowland SC, prosecuting, that Yungman with an address in Florida, was arrested in the United States in August 2024 and extradited back to Ireland. He had been initially questioned by gardaí in the immediate aftermath of the rape when they stopped him in Dublin Airport as he was about to board a flight to return home. He strenuously denied choking the woman and said any activity that had taken place was consensual. He was ultimately released without charge following questioning and permitted to return to the States pending direction from the Director of Public Prosecutions. Yungman was brought before the Central Criminal Court last Monday when he pleaded guilty to one charge of raping the woman in June 2018 in the Airbnb on Usher's Quay in Dublin city centre. The woman described in her victim impact statement experiencing panic attacks, mood swings, anxiety, suicidal thoughts, dysfunctional relationships and losing her faith in God, in the aftermath of the rape. 'I didn't celebrate birthdays as I felt there was no reason to celebrate my life,' the woman said. 'At 19, I didn't properly understand what was happening,' she said. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week 'I had been living a dream up until I met him,' the woman said describing living in Ireland as 'therapeutic' as she had just lost both her parents. She said the rape impacted her grieving process. 'In hindsight, I was vulnerable when I met him and he saw this in me,' she said. She said when she heard the court case was going ahead, she felt 'a little more hopeful' and she began to look after herself. 'I took actions to reconnect with my body, took up physical activities, began to have fun again I could look back on what happened with a mature mind, and I stopped blaming myself. I was only 19, enjoying life,' the woman said. 'This was manipulation and not my fault,' she continued. 'But honestly, when I truly felt alive again, was when I heard him say the word 'guilty',' the woman said before she described walking in the Phoenix Park afterwards 'and instantly life felt colourful again'. 'I want to close this time and never look back. Now, I will not live in pain anymore. The shadows of that memory is gone. I am glad now and I don't have to think about the dark memories,' she continued. She thanked everyone that was involved in this process. 'This is what helped me finally heal from the incident. I am extremely grateful for hearing me at the garda station, I cannot stress how important this was to me ,' she said. 'How important it was to be heard as I felt so ashamed and guilty,' she concluded her statement by saying she now has 'the power to speak up and not be silent anymore' Mr Justice Tony Hunt told the woman that he was very glad to hear the last few things she said. 'I listen to victims on a regular basis. Sometimes I feel I should tell them they should not let these things define them. I am really glad to hear that you have come around,' he said. He said as an older person you come to realise that you are not going to be young forever and advised the woman to make the best of her youth. 'It is very important you realise that. And I am glad to hear you are moving on,' Mr Justice Hunt said. Ms Rowland told Justice Hunt that the plea was acceptable to the DPP and was based on the rape when Yungman caused the woman to pass out. She later outlined an incident when Yungman had sex with the woman on the sofa in the rented Dublin apartment after she had told him she did not want to do anything. Yungman's mother took the stand and looked directly at the woman sitting in the body of the court. She used the woman's first name and told her that 'from the deepest place in my heart and as a Mam and as a woman, I want to say sorry. There is nothing that I can say that is going to erase the pain. I want you to know that I heard every word that you said and I feel your pain. I am sorry'. She said she taught her children the difference between right and wrong, describing themselves as a law abiding family. 'What happened to you should not happen to anyone'. 'I believe in accountability and that every wrongdoing must have a consequence. He needed to acknowledge his actions,' the woman continued. She said as a mother the thoughts of being away from her son in a prison in Ireland while she is in America is 'breaking my heart' but added 'even in our pain we understand that justice must be served'. She said she was not asking for forgiveness 'that would be too much' and said she was 'not asking for leniency'. 'Even in our pain we know we stand behind the truth and we know this is the truth. I pray every day that you heal from this,' the woman said. Mr Justice Hunt addressed the woman and said it was very unusual in a case such as this for a parent to take the stand and address the court in that manner. He told the woman 'your son is very fortunate'. Having adjourned the case earlier in the week after hearing the facts, on Thursday Mr Justice Hunt imposed a sentence of six years with the final 12 months suspended on strict conditions. The judge said this was a 'very sad and difficult case', noting there was a consensual background, which took a 'bad turn'. He said it was not the first and would not be the last of this type of case to come before the courts. 'It all comes back to this idea of respect for the consent of the other person to sexual activity,' Mr Justice Hunt said, noting that people have a 'duty' to confirm that consent to a sexual act has been freely and voluntarily given. The judge said the asphyxiation was among the aggravating factors in the case. Referring to the victim impact statement, the judge said the woman was an 'incredibly articulate and thoughtful person' and said the court was 'heartened' that she appears to be making progress in her recovery. Having set a headline sentence of eight years, the judge noted there was 'considerable mitigation' including Yungman's guilty plea and the difficulty he will face serving a sentence in a foreign jurisdiction. Mr Justice Hunt said there was a 'real prospect' of Yungman 'fully rehabilitating himself elsewhere with the disabilities that such convictions bring, but that is something he will face up to in the future'. He imposed a six-year sentence with the final 12 months suspended on strict conditions and backdated it to August 2024, when Yungman went into custody in the United States. The judge directed Yungman to have no contact direct or indirect with the victim in perpetuity. He also told the defendant he must leave the jurisdiction once he is released from custody and not return for 10 years. Mr Justice Hunt said Yungman was 'fortunate' to have the support of his mother and wider family, who would support him and help him after he has paid a penalty for his serious misconduct. He wished the victim well for the future and said in the circumstances, the court would also wish Yungman's family well. 'They are not responsible for what happened and they are patently decent people,' the judge said. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
