In charts: Trump moves erode US status as a safe haven
When US President Donald Trump imposed his so-called 'retaliatory' tariffs on 2 April, they had been widely anticipated. However, few were prepared for the scale of the tariffs and the way they were calculated. Even as financial markets reacted in panic, some of the immediate response was different from that during similar shocks this century.
Stock returns for each country over 20 days since the eve of the Trump tariff announcements on 1 April show that equities globally were down. The quantum varied. The US and Chinese markets were down sharply. As was the case with the stock market in Vietnam, which has become an alternative to China for companies looking to site factories and supply to the US market. Overall, emerging markets, even excluding China, were down. On the other hand, some other markets, notably India and Mexico, which are seen as benefiting from the possible exit of companies from China, rose sharply.
Also Read |
Mint Primer: What Trump's tariff tantrums mean for investors
The
IMF, in its latest Global Financial Stability Report
, looked at how stocks reacted over the course of one week to major global geopolitical 'shocks' like the 9/11 attack and the Russian invasion of Ukraine. This shows that while markets fell, they bounced back. Stocks in commodity-exporting countries (such as the major oil exporters) saw the strongest bounce back within a week. Interestingly, both developed and emerging market stocks were up one week after the collapse of Lehman Brothers in 2008, driven in part by sharp interest rate cuts and massive liquidity infusions by central banks across the world.
The Trump tariff crisis, at least in its immediate impact on markets, has been different in remarkable ways. A major difference in the reaction to the Trump tariff shock, as opposed to other shocks, was that investors no longer saw US financial instruments as safe havens. US treasuries, normally a go-to in times of uncertainty, saw a wave of selling, forcing yields up (bond prices and yields move in opposite directions).
When Russia invaded Ukraine, the US dollar rose against the rupee, as well as against currencies of most emerging and developed markets. Similarly, in 2008, in the aftermath of the greatest economic crisis since the Great Depression, the dollar strengthened against both developed-market and emerging-market currencies in the fortnight after the collapse of Lehman Brothers. In sharp contrast, the Trump tariffs saw the dollar remain flat against the rupee and lose value against developed-market currencies.
Geopolitical and economic shocks are usually a double whammy for Indian markets. Firstly, there's the impact on stocks. Secondly, if foreign investors sell stocks in India and pull money out, the rupee slides against the dollar. In each of four shock events over the past decade, over a 20-day period, dollar returns of the BSE Sensex have trailed its rupee returns by a substantial margin. That's the currency effect, and the rupee is losing value against the dollar.
However, during the first Trump tariff shock in March 2018, when the US imposed tariffs on Indian steel and aluminium (and India responded with retaliatory tariffs in June), the dollar returns on the Sensex were about par with its rupee returns. In this round of Trump tariffs, imposed on 2 April, the Indian markets have risen in the three weeks since, with dollar returns of the BSE Sensex beating its rupee returns.
Also Read | Mint Primer:
How will Trump's next obsession, a weaker dollar, play out?
The biggest difference is how bond markets have reacted. Typically, the US treasury bond is a safe haven, especially during economic uncertainty. But the US treasury market took a beating. This was partly due to technical reasons (large holders of bonds unwinding leveraged trades), but it also reflected a new thinking among investors that US assets were no longer as secure as before.
In times of uncertainty, the cumulative change in the spread between Indian government bonds (10-year maturity) and the equivalent
US treasury bond
should widen, as investors dump emerging market assets and buy US treasuries. That's what happened in the immediate aftermath of the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Amid Trump tariffs, the spread widened for two days, but then dramatically tightened. Ten days after the crisis, this spread has actually shrunk by a cumulative 25 basis points. By the standards of the gigantic US treasury market, that's a massive move.
www.howindialives.com is a database and search engine for public data
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
25 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
UK finance minister Reeves to meet China's vice premier on London trip
LONDON, - British finance minister Rachel Reeves will hold a meeting with Chinese vice premier He Lifeng during his visit to Britain this week for trade talks with the United States, a British government source said on Sunday. China's foreign ministry said He would be in Britain between June 8 and June 13 when there will be talks in London with three of U.S. President Donald Trump's top aides to try to resolve a trade dispute between the world's two largest economies that has kept global markets on edge. The British government source said Reeves would host He for a bilateral meeting during the trip, although there were no details on when the talks would be held. The British finance minister met He during a visit to China in January, part of British attempts to improve ties with Beijing, one of the main policy goals of Prime Minister Keir Starmer's government. However, many British lawmakers remain sceptical of China amid regular accusations of espionage by spies working for Beijing, and plans for a new large Chinese embassy in London remains a divisive subject, with the opposition Conservative Party saying it must be blocked. The Chinese government wants to build the embassy at Royal Mint Court, a historic site near the Tower of London, which would be its largest in Europe but its requests for planning permission have been rejected by the local council, and the government will make a final decision. The Sunday Times reported that a senior U.S. official had said Washington was "deeply concerned" about the plans, due to its proximity to London's financial hubs and three significant data centres, and approval could impact UK-U.S. trade talks. "These issues will be taken care of assiduously in the planning process," British technology minister Peter Kyle told Sky News on Sunday.
Hindustan Times
27 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Vietnamese bride gets bizarre dowry from parents: 100 rare civet cats worth $70,000
A bride in Vietnam received a bizarre yet luxurious dowry from her parents: 100 civet cats, used in the production of Kopi Luwak—one of the most expensive coffees in the world. According to a report by the South China Morning Post, the 22-year-old bride, who has not been publicly identified, received the animals along with gold bars, cash, company shares, and multiple high-value properties. The 100 civet cats, all female, are worth an estimated $70,000. In addition to the animals, her dowry included 25 gold bars, $20,000 in cash, company shares valued at $11,500, seven properties, and other assets. In return, the groom's family offered a bride price of 10 gold bars, $7,600 in cash, and diamond jewellery. Civet cats are considered valuable assets in Vietnam, where one female can fetch around $700, and a pregnant one may sell for over $1,000. They play a central role in producing Kopi Luwak coffee: civets consume ripe coffee cherries, and after digestion, the beans are collected from their excrement, processed, and roasted into a premium brew. Beyond coffee production, civet meat is regarded as a luxury food in China and Vietnam and is also used in traditional Chinese medicine. The bride's father explained that he wanted his daughter to own income-generating assets so she could be financially independent. 'My daughter is a business school graduate. She is fully capable of managing these assets. No matter the method, it ensures her financial independence,' he was quoted as saying. He also noted that it was entirely up to her whether to raise or sell the animals. Reactions online were mixed. Some users praised the gesture, contrasting it with more traditional dowry practices in other countries. They lauded Vietnamese elites for offering forward-thinking assets, saying that teaching a daughter to manage a business is far more empowering than simply handing over money. However, others voiced concern over the ethical implications. Critics pointed out that beneath the luxury was potential animal exploitation and called for deeper reflection on the morality of using wildlife in both business and marital transactions.
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
37 minutes ago
- First Post
China clears rare earths export applications, not clear if Indian companies included
China's decision in April to halt exports of a wide range of rare earths and related magnets disrupted global supply chains, affecting industries from automotive and aerospace to semiconductors and defence read more Miners are seen at the Bayan Obo mine containing rare earth minerals, in Inner Mongolia, China. File image/ Reuters China said Saturday (June 7) it is prepared to accelerate the approval process for rare earth exports to European Union companies and will issue a final ruling on its trade probe into EU brandy imports by July 5. The developments come amid broader efforts to resolve ongoing trade tensions between Beijing and Brussels. Talks were held earlier this week in Paris between Chinese Commerce Minister Wang Wentao and EU Trade Commissioner Maros Sefcovic, China's Commerce Ministry said in a statement. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Price commitment discussions on Chinese-made electric vehicles exported to the EU have also reached the final phase. 'Efforts from both sides are still needed,' the ministry said. The ministry added that China 'was willing to establish a green channel for qualified applications to speed up the approval process' for rare earth exports. It also noted that Beijing recognised rising demand for rare earth materials across sectors including electric vehicles and robotics and that it 'was willing to further strengthen communication and dialogue with relevant countries' on the matter. Rare earths and trade friction China's decision in April to halt exports of a wide range of rare earths and related magnets disrupted global supply chains, affecting industries from automotive and aerospace to semiconductors and defence. The move has become a flashpoint in EU-China trade relations. The ministry said it 'attached great importance to the EU's concerns' and indicated it would work to resolve the bottleneck in a timely manner. Brandy duties under review China's anti-dumping duties of up to 39 per cent on European brandy, particularly French cognac, were implemented shortly after the EU imposed tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles. The Chinese measures have impacted major French producers including LVMH's Hennessy, Pernod Ricard's Martell, and Remy Cointreau. French President Emmanuel Macron previously accused Beijing of 'pure retaliation' over the duties. Beijing had initially planned to announce a final decision on the brandy investigation in January, later postponing it to April and now July 5. On Saturday, the Commerce Ministry confirmed that French firms and industry associations had submitted price commitment proposals and that investigators had reached agreement on key terms. 'Chinese authorities are now reviewing the complete text on those commitments and will issue a final announcement before July 5,' the statement said. Electric vehicle negotiations ongoing The European Commission said in April it was working with Beijing to consider a minimum price framework for Chinese electric vehicles in lieu of the tariffs imposed in 2023. China's Commerce Ministry said the EU also proposed examining 'new technical paths' related to electric vehicles, and that China was now evaluating those ideas. Wang also told Sefcovic that China hoped the EU would 'meet us halfway and take effective measures to facilitate, safeguard and promote compliant trade in high-tech products to China.' STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD With inputs from agencies
