Rachel Fehily: Why are the experiences of people born, like me, in Temple Hill forgotten?
Blackrock
, Dublin, commonly known as St Patrick's Infant and Dietetic Hospital.
It is contested because there is a fundamental disagreement as to its historical purpose: there are two different retrospective interpretations of its function. To this day the Government insists that it was a hospital; but in reality,
it was an adoption home for infants and babies
.
It was stated in a
parliamentary question in the Dáil
by
Sinn Féin
TD Claire Kerrane last year that: 'Temple Hill does not qualify for supports, redress or recognition because it was a hospital, yet babies were adopted and paid for on foot of newspaper advertisements. Many children went to America. I have never heard of a hospital that does that.'
Despite the indisputable fact that many children were adopted from Temple Hill through the former adoption society St Patrick's Guild, and some were resident for lengthy periods of time, it is one of
at least four institutions
excluded from the Mother and Baby Institutions payment scheme as it was not on the initial list of homes investigated by the Commission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes. The fact that
it was not an institution within the meaning of the terms of the commission
and no mothers resided there with their babies (apparently they were taken from them at the door) kept it out of its terms of reference.
READ MORE
I am not seeking a payment under the scheme or looking for redress personally, because I left Temple Hill with my adoptive parents at the age of three months. I was fortunate to grow up with six siblings – five adopted, also from the same location – in a stimulating and supportive environment, but I am advocating for people who have been left out.
The
Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission
has stated that the official commission report was flawed because many institutions were excluded. Its remit was too narrow.
In an 'alternative report', a team including survivors, activists and eminent academics wrote that its 'text excluded significant cohorts of affected people' and that 'it is regrettable that the Commission did not request to modify its terms of reference to permit deep engagement with a wider range of organisations'.
Minister for Children, Disability and Equality
Norma Foley
will have a chance to review the operation of the scheme within six months of its second anniversary, by September 2026.
Many of the now-ageing adults who were resident and abused in institutions and identify themselves as 'survivors' in need of the supports offered by the scheme are currently left in limbo.
I had the pleasure of meeting the Irish artist Bernard Canavan, a recipient of the prestigious Presidential Award for his contribution to Irish culture in the UK at the Irish Cultural Centre in Hammersmith, London.
He recently held an exhibition at The United Arts Club in Dublin entitled Theocracy. His paintings represent the trauma that he and others endured in institutions. He was a long-term resident of the same Temple Hill in Blackrock, more than 25 years before me.
Despite evidence of his abuse, neglect, lengthy period of residency at Temple Hill, and his advanced age, he is excluded from the payment scheme because of 'contested' definitions.
The
National Council for Curriculum and Assessment
(NCCA) has set up a comprehensive curriculum resource on 'mother and baby homes' for the Junior Cycle. It developed it in collaboration with groups involved in advocating for survivors of 'historic' institutions. This is an important and worthwhile initiative.
The list of related literature for the English curriculum is comprehensive and impressive, including the novel Small Things Like These by
Claire Keegan
and the play An Trial by Máiréad Ní Ghráda. The curriculum has input from many survivors and is all the better for it. However, the framing of the curriculum comes directly from the NCCA, a statutory body of the Department of Education.
At the launch, Minister for Education
Helen McEntee
said: 'It is vital that our young people learn about the history of this State in every aspect, and in order to provide this teaching and learning, teachers must be supported with resources such as this one.'
One of the resources for Junior Cycle teachers - a series of slides, maps, a list of the homes included in the Commission's report - omits the contested homes.
Much of the lengthy reading list that goes with the teacher supports comprises 'official' reports. Searching through the voluminous reading list, I eventually found an alternative '
List of Institutions, Agencies and Personnel Involved in Separating Unmarried Mothers from their Children
.' It is collated by Claire McGettrick and the Justice for Magdalenes Research and Adoption Rights Alliance. The database includes St Patrick's Infant Dietetic Hospital (aka Temple Hill).
It is vital that students understand how our Government and legal system operates to include and exclude people from access to justice. These nuances matter. If school children are taught to think critically they might be driven to question as to whether their history curriculum is in fact 'history' or 'current affairs'?
In Fintan O'Toole's
excellent recent article on the excavation of the Tuam site
, he writes that: 'This is making history in a double sense – doing something that has never been done before while simultaneously reshaping a country's understanding of its own recent past. And, hopefully, of its present.'
It seems ironic that the novel Nineteen Eighty-Four has been removed from the Senior Cycle curriculum for 2026 by the Department of Education, while Greta Gerwig's film Barbie has been deemed worthy of inclusion.
Leaving Certificate students won't have to read
George Orwell's
text or consider one of its most memorable lines: 'Who controls the past controls the future. Who controls the present controls the past.' But they will have a chance to consider this dialogue by Weird Barbie: 'That Ken of yours, he is one nice looking little protein pot … I'd like to see what kind of nude blob he's packing under those jeans.'
Rachel Fehily is a barrister, lecturer in literature and justice at UCD and is
engaged in interdisciplinary creative-based doctoral studies supported by Research Ireland
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Warning labels on alcohol an idea from ‘different time', Minister warned Cabinet colleague
Plans to require health warnings on alcohol products were thought up in a 'very different' time to the current period of global economic uncertainty, Minister for Enterprise Peter Burke privately warned a Cabinet colleague. The Government is expected to delay requirements for alcohol products to carry warnings about the links between alcohol consumption, liver disease and cancer. The mandatory health labelling had been due to be introduced next year, but it is expected will now not come into force until 2029. In a May 15th letter, Mr Burke asked Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill to consider pushing back the health labelling plans in light of the 'profound' risk Ireland was facing from the current global economic uncertainty. READ MORE The idea for health warning labels on alcohol was 'developed at a time when geopolitical economic pressures were very different to those being experienced at present', he told Ms Carroll MacNeill. The danger of US president Donald Trump 's sweeping tariff threats starting a transatlantic trade war with the European Union is causing significant concern inside Government including on its impact on Irish exports of whiskey and other alcohol products. Mr Burke appealed to his Fine Gael colleague to take these new circumstances into account and 'pause' plans for alcohol labelling. 'Recent months have seen significant global economic uncertainty and a rapidly shifting trading landscape – which you will be aware could have profound competitiveness implications for small open economies like Ireland,' he wrote. The fact Mr Burke had asked Ms Carroll MacNeill to delay the introduction of the labelling was previously reported but this is the first time the contents of his letter have been reported. [ Delay on health labelling on alcohol comes amid uncertain trading environment Opens in new window ] A copy of his letter to the Minister for Health – released to The Irish Times under the Freedom of Information Act – said the new labelling rules would lead to higher prices for consumers. 'The proposed measures will mean increased production and sale costs for Irish producers and importers, and add to the price payable by consumers, at a time when prices are also rising due to a multitude of other factors,' Mr Burke wrote. This would come at the same time companies and producers were already seeing 'very significant disruption' to their supply chains, he said. 'Notwithstanding the overarching health benefits of the proposal, I would ask you to consider pausing the introduction of the proposed new requirements,' the correspondence said. It is expected a decision will be taken at a Cabinet meeting on Tuesday to defer the new rules for several years. In his letter, Mr Burke said Ireland's plans had faced pushback from other EU governments, as it was believed the labelling rules would hamper the movement of trade and goods within the bloc's single market. There had also been intense lobbying from the drinks industry, over the 'likely negative impact on sales and costs,' he said.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
Two people moved from Cork disability centre ‘for their own safety' after incident with another resident
Two residents at a Cork city disability centre had to be moved to another house 'for their own safety' after an incident with another resident, the health and safety watchdog has said. The Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) published 28 inspection reports on disability services including one on an unannounced visit to Cork City North 13 centre , a facility run by Horizons. It was conducted on March 20th on foot of unsolicited information about the 'quality of care and support provided to residents'. At the time of the inspection, the provider was housing eight residents, a number of whom raised concerns about the behaviour of another resident. READ MORE One resident said this person, admitted in April of last year, was banging on doors throughout the home, which they said was 'frightening'. The resident stayed with a family member for a number of nights because they were 'upset' in response to the incidents. Another resident asked to speak to the inspector privately, telling them they were unhappy living there and did not feel safe there. 'One staff member told the inspector that in response to an incident two weeks before the inspection had taken place, they had to move two residents to another house 'for their safety',' the report notes. Hiqa's inspection also highlighted how the disability centre did not alert the chief inspector of an allegation or confirmed incident of abuse of resident in the centre within three working days. A complaint was made regarding the quality of care and support provided to a resident in the centre in January of last year, the report said. The complainant noted an alleged incident in November of last year where a resident had received marks to their arm which they stated had been caused by another person living in the centre. 'The alleged injury had been reviewed by staff nurses working in the centre where it had been deemed to be as a result of a medical issue,' the report said, adding that this was not reported to the Office of Chief Inspector. A number of incidents were noted pertaining to the impact of one resident's behaviour on others including banging and kicking doors in their home and going into residents' bedrooms and waking them. However, the report said there was no evidence to suggest this had been acknowledged or considered as 'psychological abuse' and had not been reported. The inspectors said residents were not protected from the risk of harm or from all forms of abuse. In the compliance plan submitted to Hiqa, the provider confirmed the resident who was admitted in April of last year was no longer living in the centre. It also outlined plans to improve rostering and address staff shortages.
Irish Times
8 hours ago
- Irish Times
Psychiatrists call for ban of psychoactive substance that ‘has done major damage' to teens' mental health
In recent years, there are increasing concerns about the impact of Hexahydrocannabinol (HHC) on people's mental health, particularly among children and adolescents. What is HHC? HHC is a legally available, semi-synthetic cannabinoid. Chemically, it is like THIC, which is the main psychoactive substance found in cannabis that produces a 'high'. And where can you get it? As it is legal, it is actually quite widely available. It has been on the Irish market since 2022 and is available to purchase in shops and online. It comes in a number of forms, including vapes and edibles. Why are health professionals concerned? The HSE and the Irish College of Psychiatrists have raised concerns in recent years about the impact this has on people's mental health. This was confirmed in recent days after a new study by researchers in University Hospital Galway found HHC was the second most common drug used by patients presenting with psychosis over a 21-month period. Cannabis was used the most, the study found. [ Cannabis-like drug causing severe psychosis in young men, College of Psychiatrists warn Opens in new window ] What were the findings of the study? Research published in the BJPsych Bulletin examined medical records of patients admitted for psychotic illness into University Hospital Galway to assess the use HHC or other illicit drugs before admission. Of the 214 total admissions for psychotic illness between May 2023 and December 2024, 28 admissions (13.1 per cent) were preceded by use of HHC, nine of whom used only HHC. Sixteen (34 per cent) admissions of first-episode psychosis were preceded by HHC use, with seven of these people using only HHC. And were there cohorts of society more likely to use HHC? According to the study, HHC users were more likely to be male and range in age from 18 to 49 with a median age of 24. The researchers said psychosis associated with HHC appears 'to be more prominent in young people with early-phase psychosis', adding that it highlighted a need for policymakers to 'change legislation to avoid further harm'. So what do psychiatrists want to see happen? The Irish College of Psychiatrists said this research confirms their calls over the past year that the substance should be banned. 'HHC is a particularly harmful substance that, in just a few short years since its creation, has done major damage to the mental health of many people, and adolescents in particular,' the statement said. 'It beggars belief that HHC is still freely available around Ireland without any restrictions, given the overwhelming evidence of its harms. The legislative framework exists for the Government to ban HHC – it now needs to act urgently to do so before more people and their loved ones are negatively impacted.' [ Her 17-year-old daughter is under psychiatric care after becoming addicted to HHC vapes Opens in new window ] And is the HSE seeing this too? The HSE has previously said there has been a 'concerning' increase in the number of children and young people presenting to addiction services with mental health problems due to HHC. [ HHC vapes: 'It only took a few puffs to turn him completely zombie-like' Opens in new window ] What do vendors say? Luke Gavin, chief executive of Owls Oil, which sells HHC products, said the sector is 'pro-regulation' but does not agree with an outright ban on the substance. He said there is an 'opportunity' to enact appropriate regulations that assure of safety and ensure standards are followed. Mr Gavin said this comes down to being 'educated' about what's being consumed and why. 'I believe there's a reason we're here. Cannabis is not available and people are looking for a safer alternative to black market cannabis. That's why I believe HHC has exploded. People want to consume these products safely.'
