Clarence Thomas's Wish for Same-Sex Marriage Is About to Come True
Kim Davis, the Kentucky county clerk who was jailed in 2015 for refusing to issue same-sex marriage licenses, is appealing her case. Davis is appealing a $100,000 jury verdict for emotional damages plus $260,000 for attorneys' fees, reported ABC News Monday.
In a petition filed last month, Davis claimed that her First Amendment rights protecting her religious freedom effectively immunized her from repercussions for denying the licenses.
'The mistake must be corrected,' Davis's attorney Mathew Staver argued in the petition, further condemning Justice Anthony Kennedy's majority opinion in Obergefell v. Hodges as 'legal fiction.'
'This court should revisit and reverse Obergefell for the same reasons articulated in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Center,' reads one titled portion, under which Staver claims that 'Obergefell was wrong when it was decided and it is wrong today because it was grounded entirely on the legal fiction of substantive due process.'
Staver's argument alluded to Justice Clarence Thomas's concurring opinion in Dobbs, which overturned the nationwide right to abortion established in Roe v. Wade. In his 2022 opinion, Thomas argued that the court 'should reconsider' its substantive due process precedents, including contraception, same-sex marriage, and even same-sex relationships.
Davis served six days in jail for refusing to issue the licenses. Her appeal marks the first time that the nation's highest judiciary has been formally asked to reconsider the landmark decision.
'If there ever was a case of exceptional importance,' Staver wrote, 'the first individual in the Republic's history who was jailed for following her religious convictions regarding the historic definition of marriage, this should be it.'
Gay marriage was effectively legalized in 2015, when the Supreme Court ruled in Obergefell that keeping marriage licenses from same-sex couples was discriminatory. The decision mandated that all states issue licenses to gay and lesbian couples, and required states to recognize marriages performed in other jurisdictions, as well.
Marriage equality was further protected at the federal level in 2022, when the Respect for Marriage Act became law, requiring all 50 states to recognize same-sex marriages performed in other states. It did not, however, formally legalize gay marriage, so if the Supreme Court were to take up Davis's case and overturn Obergefell, gay marriage rights would fall with it.
Roughly 69 percent of Americans support same-sex marriages, according to a 2024 Gallup poll. Republican support for gay couples' equal rights has dipped in recent years, however, from a record high of 55 percent in favor of it in 2021 to 46 percent in 2024.
Solve the daily Crossword
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
20 minutes ago
- New York Post
NY Rep. Elise Stefanik demands to know if Gov. Hochul knew massive prison strike was brewing: ‘Why did she refuse to act?'
ALBANY – Upstate Rep. Elise Stefanik is calling on Gov. Kathy Hochul to come clean about this year's massive corrections workers strike and whether she knew about the brewing 'powder keg' in state prisons. The Republican North Country rep, in a statement first obtained by The Post, said Hochul 'must immediately address' a new report by the prison workers' union largely blaming the state for allegedly ignoring warning signs of the simmering crisis and strike threats. 'What did she know, when did she know it, and why did she refuse to act?,' Stefanik writes in the statement. 3 North Country Rep. Elise Stefanik is attacking Gov. Kathy Hochul over her handling of the illegal corrections officers strike earlier this year. Hans Pennink Thousands of corrections officers illegally walked off the job in February, requiring Hochul to deploy over 6,000 National Guard troops to supplement staffing shortages in the problem-plagued facilities. The memo from the state Correctional Officers & Police Benevolent Association issued last week alleged its leadership had showed a top Hochul aide a video of members threatening to strike at an annual meeting weeks earlier, and were told the issue would be raised to the governor. 'The deterioration of prison conditions statewide and the indifference of the State's elected leaders to cries for help from the rank-and-file pushed staff to the breaking point, and then they broke,' the union memo reads. Stefanik — who is widely believed to be mounting a Republican challenge to Hochul in next year's gubernatorial election — slammed the Democrat for allegedly failing to act to prevent the strike. 'The union representing Correction Officers stated they warned Kathy Hochul before their strike that prisons were a dangerous powder keg, a strike was imminent, and that lives of officers were at risk. Hochul did nothing,' Stefanik wrote. 3 Rep. Elise Stefanik says Hochul 'did nothing' to respond to a 'powder keg' in the state prisons pre-strike. AP While the Hochul administration declared an end to the strike in early March, upwards of 2,000 National Guard troops remain to backfill staffing holes at the facilities, which are 4,000 to 5,000 personnel short of the Department of Corrections and Community Supervisions' ideal staffing level, Commissioner Daniel Martuscello wrote in a recent court filing. The department was already suffering from staffing shortages even before the strike, a report from the state comptroller's office said last month. A spokesperson for Hochul, in response to Stefanik's statement, accused the congresswoman of condoning the illegal strike and called the corrections officers' demands 'unrealistic.' 'Unlike Congresswoman Stefanik, Governor Hochul does not condone breaking the law. Corrections officers who joined the illegal work stoppage earlier this year knowingly put both the incarcerated population and their fellow officers at risk. Walking off the job because an unrealistic list of demands isn't met is unacceptable and illegal,' a rep for Hochul's office wrote in a statement. 3 A spokesperson for Gov. Kathy Hochul called illegally striking corrections officers demands 'unrealistic'. Hans Pennink 'Instead of issuing empty statements, Governor Hochul will keep focusing on real reforms that improve conditions for everyone in DOCCS facilities, including incarcerated individuals and the employees who serve there,' the statement said. The Hochul rep emphasized that corrections workers have received a pay bump since the strike. The spokesperson also noted that the state tried to pause the requirements of a solitary confinement law that the agency claimed it was unable to implement considering its dire staffing levels, but a court ordered them to resume. A spokesperson for NYSCOPBA declined to comment saying the report speaks for itself. The union also declined to share the video it says showed the Hochul administration official in February. The union, which found itself at odds with its members during the illegal strike is up for contract negotiations with the state in May 2026, per its memo.
Boston Globe
20 minutes ago
- Boston Globe
Appeals court lets the White House suspend or end billions in foreign aid
After groups of grant recipients sued to challenge that order, U.S. District Judge Amir Ali ordered the administration to release the full amount of foreign assistance that Congress had appropriated for the 2024 budget year. Advertisement The appeal court's majority partially vacated Ali's order. Judges Karen LeCraft Henderson and Gregory Katsas concluded that the plaintiffs did not have a valid legal basis for the court to hear their claims. The ruling was not on the merits of whether the government unconstitutionally infringed on Congress' spending powers. Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up 'The parties also dispute the scope of the district court's remedy but we need not resolve it ... because the grantees have failed to satisfy the requirements for a preliminary injunction in any event,' Henderson wrote. Judge Florence Pan, who dissented, said the Supreme Court has held 'in no uncertain terms' that the president does not have the authority to disobey laws for policy reasons. 'Yet that is what the majority enables today,' Pan wrote. 'The majority opinion thus misconstrues the separation-of-powers claim brought by the grantees, misapplies precedent, and allows Executive Branch officials to evade judicial review of constitutionally impermissible actions.' Advertisement The money at issue includes nearly $4 billion for USAID to spend on global health programs and more than $6 billion for HIV and AIDS programs. Trump has portrayed the foreign aid as wasteful spending that does not align with his foreign policy goals. Henderson was nominated to the court by Republican President George H.W. Bush. Katsas was nominated by Trump. Pan was nominated by Democratic President Joe Biden.
Fox News
21 minutes ago
- Fox News
Texas Democrats who fled could face bribery charges, governor says
Texas Democrats who fled the state to break quorum could possibly face bribery charges, Republican Governor Greg Abbott said in an interview with Fox News Digital.
