Scottish ministers urged to rethink ‘poor decision' on guga hunt licence
The group is urging the Scottish Government and its nature agency NatureScot to reverse the licence, which currently permits 500 of the infant birds to be culled.
The guga hunt has been an annual tradition in Ness, north Lewis, since the 15th century, with 10 men setting out for the rocky island of Sula Sgeir 40 miles away.
Uninhabited by humans, the island is home to thousands of pairs of breeding gannets, with the men spending two weeks there in August, taking the birds from open cliffs using a pole and noose, before the creatures are gutted, salted and preserved in brine.
Traditionally the preserved birds are said to have formed an essential part of the winter diet for the people of Ness, but guga is now regarded as a delicacy by some, although it is said to be an 'acquired taste'.
A NatureScot spokesperson said it recognises the 'cultural significance of the guga hunt', adding this was 'reflected in the provision to licence this traditional activity through the Wildlife and Countryside Act'.
They added that 2025 is the first year it had received a licence application from the Men of Ness – who carry out the guga hunt – since 2021.
The spokesperson continued: 'We have thoroughly assessed the application taking into account survey data and population analysis and we have granted a licence with a limit of 500 birds.
'This is significantly fewer than in previous years where up to 2,000 have been granted.
'This revised limit for 2025 safeguards the sustainability of the Sula Sgeir gannet population and allows for its continued recovery following avian flu.'
However OneKind chief executive Jason Rose said: 'Snatching wild baby birds from their nests and bashing their heads in, using the excuse of tradition, will appall and embarrass most people in the Western Isles and across Scotland.
'There is simply no need for this cruel activity to take place. We live in a modern society where we have many more choices about where our food comes from.
'The guga hunt is a grisly story from history that should be left in books or a museum.
'The Scottish Government and its nature agency have made a poor decision.
'Do they really think this kind of cruel and unnecessary activity is how anyone wants Scotland to be seen in the year 2025?
'OneKind will be writing to both NatureScot and Scottish ministers asking them to rethink. It's not too late to save these beautiful wild bird chicks.'
The Scottish Government has been contacted for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
2 hours ago
- Daily Record
Divers find wreckage of WW1 warship off Scottish coast 109 years after sinking
A team of ten divers from ProjectXplore identified the wreck 60 miles off the Scottish coast at a depth of 82 metres. The wreckage of HMS Nottingham, a Royal Navy warship lost during the First World War, has been discovered in the North Sea more than a century after it was torpedoed by a German U-boat. A team of ten divers from ProjectXplore, an international group dedicated to locating historically significant shipwrecks around the UK, identified the wreck 60 miles off the Scottish coast at a depth of 82 metres. The vessel had remained undiscovered for 109 years. ProjectXplore confirmed the warship's identity through a combination of distinctive features and artefacts found at the site. Divers recovered white dinner plates bearing a Royal Navy blue crown emblem, and spotted the word "Nottingham" embossed on the stern. The ship's dimensions, structure, and visible damage matched historical records of the sinking. The team said they had "no doubt" the wreck was HMS Nottingham, citing the ship's name stamp, size, equipment, and condition, which aligned with reports from the time of the attack. Built for the Royal Navy shortly before the outbreak of war, HMS Nottingham was a 457-foot Town-class light cruiser and part of the Birmingham sub-class. She was completed in early 1914 and served in the 1st Light Cruiser Squadron (LCS) of both the Home and Grand Fleets throughout her career. Nottingham took part in several major naval engagements in the early years of the war, including the battles of Heligoland Bight, Dogger Bank and Jutland. The cruiser helped to sink multiple German vessels during those confrontations. The ship met her fate on August 19, 1916 during the so-called Action of 19 August, when she was struck by three torpedoes fired by the German submarine U-52. The attack occurred while Nottingham was on a reconnaissance mission. Although the enemy vessel had been spotted earlier that morning, it was mistakenly identified by a crew member as a small fishing boat. Thirty-eight sailors were killed in the attack. Among the casualties, thirty-one are commemorated on the Plymouth Naval Memorial, two on the Chatham Naval Memorial, and two on the Portsmouth Naval Memorial. Three bodies were later recovered from the sea and are buried in cemeteries in the UK and Norway. Captain Charles B. Miller, 20 officers, and 357 crew members survived the sinking, having been rescued by two Royal Navy destroyers that responded to the distress. Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. Despite multiple efforts to locate HMS Nottingham over the past century, previous searches had all failed. ProjectXplore began its investigation in September 2024, starting with an intensive review of original sources, including ship logs, telegrams and naval charts. By April 2025, the team had surveyed a potential area of interest using sonar equipment, detecting a wreck that matched the dimensions, layout and orientation of HMS Nottingham. A diving expedition three months later allowed the team to confirm the ship's identity.
The National
3 hours ago
- The National
Hostile takeover of craft groups by Tedooo app is soul-destroying
The project in question is a hollowed-out piece of log housing a woodland scene complete with hand-sculpted hedgehog and owl. It's fake, obviously. The photo is fake, the sob story is fake, and there's another tell-tale sign that it's fake – the part of the story that mentions 'the Tedooo app'. READ MORE: Scottish ice rink to close due to 'spiralling energy costs' Anyone who is a member of a craft or DIY Facebook group will be familiar with those three infuriating little words. Over the past five years, countless thriving communities have been taken over by this Israeli start-up, which calls itself 'the first social-commerce platform dedicated and customised for the handmade, crafts and DIY communities'. Members are then spammed with content that is either AI-generated fakery, or stolen from other online sources. In some cases, long-established groups with hundreds of thousands of members appear to have been bought from their previous owners and renamed accordingly. In others, the takeover is more stealthy, with the original moderators switching to posting Tedooo-promoting spam. The post with the sad boy was shared on 'DIY Crafty Fun & Crafters on the Tedooo app!', a group with one million members, by a moderator named Artur Zamber, who appears to be an elderly Russian with 18 Facebook friends. The post has 31,000 reactions and nearly 6000 comments, most complimenting the fake boy on his implausible skills. While some may be from bots, many others are from real people. READ MORE: Banned tall ship seen floating near Buckie harbour You might be thinking, who cares? If gullible folk want to waste their time on such nonsense, let them. But the extent to which Tedooo has disrupted and destroyed groups for creative people is driving members to distraction, and the site's unethical practices are having real-world negative impacts. 'The paid pattern sharing in their groups is rife,' says Bea King, an Aberdeen-based crafter who sells crochet patterns under the brand name cottontail&whiskers Ltd. King made direct contact with Tedooo's founder, Michelle Apelker, to have her products taken down, as the app had no copyright infringement system in place. Pictures of King's wonderfully detailed creations have also been pinched and used as false advertising on groups taken over by Tedooo, and she's in contact with many others who have had the same experiences. 'No-one knows exactly how they got all the groups,' she says. 'That bit is a mystery.' Another maker, Shropshire-based Laura Sutcliffe, has also been in direct contact with Apelker, to complain that her patterns and those of many others were being shared in the chat section of the Tedooo app itself. Apelker's response amounted to little more than a shrug. 'There's groups with hundreds of thousands of members. The groups made by private people. And they are managing their own groups.' READ MORE: Perth artist to sell Harris Tweed designs at major event this weekend She suggested that the same culprits were undoubtedly sharing copyrighted material on other social media platforms too, so Sutcliffe should take it up with them directly. When Sutcliffe pushed back, saying Apelker should take responsibility for the activities on her own app, her Tedooo account was suspended. Venture capital firm Stardom Ventures, which has funded Tedooo to the tune of at least $2 million, proclaims that it looks for 'rebels who want to revolutionise the way we create and consume media'. Tedooo is certainly doing that, by ruining users' experiences, permitting content theft and either driving people out of long-established groups or sucking them in with time-wasting trickery. The process of 'enshittification' of an online platform, as first articulated by journalist Cory Doctorow in 2022, comprises three stages: 'first, they are good to their users; then they abuse their users to make things better for their business customers; finally, they abuse those [[business]] customers to claw back all the value for themselves.' It's difficult to see quite how this applies to Tedooo's business model, given the limited evidence that the app itself has many satisfied customers (except perhaps those looking for stolen crochet patterns). Its aggressive marketing might prompt intrigued new users to sign up, but surely it proceeds to alienate them by ruining their favourite communities. Unless, of course, the initial sign-up – and the data surrendered – is where the value lies. Among the infiltrated groups are those offering low-budget DIY and decorating tips, which were once an invaluable resource for people trying to maximise bedroom space for their children or make their homes more accessible to disabled family members. Now that the vast majority of posts are spam, featuring stolen content, any questions posed in the comments go unanswered. Close inspection of many pictures showing space-saving 'hacks' reveals them to be physically impossible. It's sad to see these wholesome, positive spaces captured, and trust among users broken. Hopefully those that have resisted the Tedooo takeover will survive and thrive.
Daily Record
4 hours ago
- Daily Record
Perth fire service cuts could put lives at risk, union warns
If approved, the FBU said, it would mean the permanent removal of the third pumping appliance at Perth and 15 firefighter posts. Lives could be at risk if the number of Perth frontline firefighting appliances are cut according to the Fire Brigades Union (FBU). Their warning comes as Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (SFRS) chiefs announced a public consultation into changes at Perth Community Fire Station in the city. In 2023 the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service cut Perth appliances from three to two, with a reduction of 15 firefighters – a move which they want to make permanent. But the Fire Brigade Union (FBU) point out that firefighters who attended recent Perth blazes - the tragic fire in Scott Street in which a man lost his life and at Balhousie School now facing demolition – reported being under pressure while waiting for help from other fire stations. If the 2023 changes are approved, the FBU said, it would mean the permanent removal of the third pumping appliance at Perth and 15 firefighter posts. SFRS chiefs said Perth operational demand for the city's three wholetime appliances is lower than most fire stations with two wholetime appliances. But Perth-based FBU official Colin Brown said: 'As we have seen in recent weeks the speed and weight of response to fires and other emergencies is crucial to save life and property. 'Crews who attended the fires at Scott Street and Balhousie School have reported being stretched too thin in the early stages of these incidents whilst they awaited additional crews coming from county stations – Dundee's and Fife. 'Perth crews were also deployed to support and provided fire cover into Aviemore during the recent spate of wildfires. 'Cutting firefighter numbers and fire appliances removes resilience from the service when incidents do occur, this has the potential to put lives at risk and the FBU would encourage members of the public to fully engage in the ongoing SFRS consultation and let both SFRS and the Scottish Government know they don't want to see their fire and rescue service cut even deeper. 'The changes in Perth, if approved, would mean the permanent removal of the third pumping appliance and 15 firefighter posts.' Perth MSP Murdo Fraser criticised the move, particularly given the two devastating blazes in the city last month. He said: 'These proposed cuts to Perth Fire Station have been feared for a while and I understand the concerns that these will leave the brave firefighters who work there extremely short of much needed resources. 'The spate of recent fires we have seen in Perth underlines the need for a properly resourced fire and rescue service in our community.' SFRS head of service delivery for the east and the north of Scotland deputy assistant chief officer Andrew Girrity, said: 'Our modelling has shown that two appliances would align better with risk and demand. 'Currently, the third vehicle at Perth is a combined aerial rescue pump, and we want to change this to a dedicated high reach appliance. 'Since 2023, the dedicated high reach appliance has been temporarily crewed, and we need to find a permanent solution.' Speaking about the service delivery review Mr Girrity added: 'We have an opportunity for the first time since the national SFRS was formed in 2013 to review how we provide our emergency service across Scotland. 'I would encourage as many people as possible to take part in the public consultation process and attend the public meetings.' A drop-in public meeting will take place tomorrow, Wednesday July 23, from 3pm to 7pm at AK Bell Library in Perth.
