Judge Tosses Out Defamation Lawsuit Against Media Ratings Site NewsGuard
U.S. District Judge Katherine Polk Failla also dismissed claims brought against the U.S. government, which was named in the lawsuit as NewsGuard once had a contract with the U.S. Air Force's USAF Research Lab.
More from Deadline
Voice Of America's Director Sues To Reverse Trump Administration's Shutdown Of U.S.-Backed Media Outlet
Rita Braver To Retire From 'CBS News Sunday Morning'
California Lawmakers Unveil Plans To "Modernize" Film & TV Tax Incentive Program Via Expanding Eligible Projects, Upping Credit To 35% In LA - Update
Read the NewsGuard decision.
Launched in 2018 by Steven Brill and Gordon Crovitz, NewsGuard employs a team of journalists to review news sites and give them a score of 0-100, information that is used by consumers and clients including AI companies, search engines, news aggregators, brands and researchers.
Consortium News received a rating of 47.5 out of 100, with a NewsGuard 'Nutrition Label' stating that it 'frequently published false and misleading claims about the war in Ukraine and other important subjects.' NewsGuard said that it had 'determined that the site repeatedly publishes false content and does not gather and present information responsibly.' Consortium News also objected to NewsGuard's characterization of its reporting as from an 'anti-U.S. perspective.'
Failla concluded that the allegedly defamatory statements were protected opinion, and not actionable. The judge also concluded that Consortium News did not 'plausibly allege' that the statements were false, and that the media outlet failed to show that NewsGuard acted with actual malice, the standard that public figure plaintiffs have to meet in defamation claims..
In a set of criteria used to determine its ratings, NewsGuard put a red 'X' in its Nutrition Label for Consortium News when it came to whether it 'regularly corrects or clarifies errors.' The judge, however, determined that the rating was 'protected opinion.'
The judge also wrote that the use of the term ''anti-U.S.' does not have a precise, readily understood meaning and is not capable of being objectively characterized as true or false.'
Consortium News 'does not allege that its position is true and NewsGuard's is false. Rather, Plaintiff concedes that its position is but one perspective,' Failla wrote.
Consortium News also claimed that the contract between the U.S. government and NewsGuard violated the First Amendment. But Failla wrote that Consortium failed to show that NewsGuard 'acted jointly' with the U.S. government in a way that amounted to state action.
The judge wrote, 'Plaintiff argues that there was a 'meeting of the minds' between the Government and NewsGuard to 'share and work mutually toward the identical interest in identifying and suppressing' foreign propaganda, sufficient to constitute joint action. However, it is not enough that the Government and NewsGuard shared and worked toward a mutual objective of identifying foreign propaganda. If such activity toward shared goals were sufficient, then every government contractor would be transformed into a state actor, contrary to well-settled law.'
The military contract with NewsGuard ended in 2022.
The judge also rejected Consortium's argument that President Donald Trump's executive order on 'Restoring Free Speech and Ending Federal Censorship' amounted to 'a concession by the government that its First Amendment claim has merit.' Failla called Consortium's citation of the EO 'the legal equivalent of a 'Hail Mary' pass.'
Consortium News' attorney did not immediately return a request for comment.
NewsGuard has been a target of FCC Chairman Brendan Carr, even though the federal agency does not have regulatory jurisdiction over the private rating service. In November, before he became chair, Carr accused NewsGuard of working in concert with advertising agencies to stifle conservative voices. At issue was a low rating that NewsGuard gave to Newsmax.
In response, Crovitz noted that 'many conservative sites get higher ratings from us than liberal sites get, such as Fox News getting a higher score than MSNBC and The Washington Examiner outscoring The New York Times.'
NewsGuard's lower ratings also have been given to left-leaning sites. In the lawsuit, the judge noted that 'It is fair to say that Consortium News offers a left-wing take on the news with an independent — and somewhat contrarian — streak.'
Best of Deadline
Everything We Know About 'Only Murders In The Building' Season 5 So Far
How Jon Gries' Return To 'The White Lotus' Could Shape Season 3
2025 TV Series Renewals: Photo Gallery
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Wire
8 minutes ago
- Business Wire
Lynkwell Celebrates Fourth Year on the Inc. 5000 List and New Executive Team Member
SCHENECTADY, N.Y.--(BUSINESS WIRE)-- Lynkwell, a leading energy infrastructure provider, announces its fourth consecutive year on the Inc. 5000 list of fastest-growing private companies in America. Demonstrating three-year revenue growth of 268 percent, Lynkwell's comprehensive suite of U.S.-based energy related hardware, software, and service solutions continues to find market validation in a dynamic industry. Lynkwell's 3-year growth rate of 268% outpaced the 169% median growth rate of the 2025 class. Share Fourth Consecutive Year on the Inc. 5000 List The Inc. 5000 list recognizes those independent companies who successfully navigate the rigors of entrepreneurship to achieve outstanding financial performance. Lynkwell's 3-year growth rate of 268% outpaced the 169% median growth rate of the 2025 class. Contributing to this year's success is the launch of several exclusive offerings designed to deliver the charging infrastructure performance demanded by the burgeoning electric vehicle (EV) industry. Portfolio highlights include Lynkwell's EVSE-360™ charging infrastructure protection plan, its QuickLynk™ automated charger onboarding solution, and the Lynkwell Upgrade™ charger replacement program. These offerings, combined with Lynkwell's existing comprehensive suite of hardware, software, and service solutions, is why Lynkwell remains one of the top ten public charging networks in the United States. 'We are always honored to be recognized by Inc., but this year means something much more,' commented Jason Zarillo, president of Lynkwell. 'In an industry as dynamic as electrification infrastructure, keeping pace is not enough. This past year, Lynkwell has proven that it can outpace and deliver on the demands of an industry both growing at tremendous speed and navigating unprecedented pressures. Our team and technology are recognized as the leaders they are, and I could not be prouder.' 'Making the Inc. 5000 is always a remarkable achievement, but earning a spot this year speaks volumes about a company's tenacity and clarity of vision,' says Mike Hofman, editor-in-chief of Inc. 'These businesses have thrived amid rising costs, shifting global dynamics, and constant change. They didn't just weather the storm—they grew through it, and their stories are a powerful reminder that the entrepreneurial spirit is the engine of the U.S. economy.' Lynkwell Appoints New Chief Financial Officer As Lynkwell continues to expand its offerings and invest in AI-driven automations to drive performance, it is bolstering its executive leadership team with the appointment of Frank Kosky as chief financial officer. With more than two decades of executive financial leadership experience, Kosky brings proven expertise in corporate finance and operational transformation, and strategic growth that will help accelerate Lynkwell's expansion in the rapidly evolving EV sector. In his role as CFO, Kosky will oversee financial strategy and planning to support Lynkwell's mission of advancing clean energy adoption through accessible and reliable EV charging solutions. He has a strong record of building high-performing finance organizations, strengthening operational efficiency, and driving long-term value creation for stakeholders. 'Frank's financial expertise and leadership skills make him an excellent addition to our executive team,' shared Schuyler Poukish, chief executive officer of Lynkwell. 'His ability to align financial strategy with operational execution will be critical as we continue to scale and expand our impact nationwide.' 'I am excited to join Lynkwell at such a pivotal time for both the company and the industry,' said Kosky. 'Lynkwell's mission to transform clean energy access and EV infrastructure aligns with my own passion for building sustainable, high-growth businesses. I look forward to working closely with the team to deliver on this vision.' By cultivating the most comprehensive and integrated suite of solutions, Lynkwell positions itself as the one partner any stakeholder needs to thrive in the EV charging ecosystem. Learn more about how Lynkwell helps fleets, businesses, government agencies, partners, utilities, and EV drivers thrive by visiting About Inc. Inc. is the leading media brand and playbook for the entrepreneurs and business leaders shaping our future. Through its journalism, Inc. aims to inform, educate, and elevate the profile of its community: the risk-takers, the innovators, and the ultra-driven go-getters who are creating the future of business. Inc. is published by Mansueto Ventures LLC, along with fellow leading business publication Fast Company. For more information, visit Methodology Companies on the 2025 Inc. 5000 are ranked according to percentage revenue growth from 2021 to 2024. To qualify, companies must have been founded and generating revenue by March 31, 2021. They must be U.S.-based, privately held, for-profit, and independent—not subsidiaries or divisions of other companies—as of December 31, 2024. (Since then, some on the list may have gone public or been acquired.) The minimum revenue required for 2021 is $100,000; the minimum for 2024 is $2 million. As always, Inc. reserves the right to decline applicants for subjective reasons. For the full list, company profiles, and a searchable database by industry and location, visit: About Lynkwell Lynkwell is a leading energy infrastructure development company focused on connecting renewable generation, battery storage, utilities, and microgrids with next-generation fueling technologies via its Lynkwell X-Change™ platform. Ranked as one of the fastest-growing private companies in the United States for the last four years, Lynkwell's leadership is bolstered by its top 10 nationwide cloud-based EV charging software platform which hosts dozens of EV charging networks and manages 10,000 assets. With a curated catalog of more than 500 products from leading global OEMs plus its own XLynk™ charger, Lynkwell's unique combination of full deployment solutions and energy integrations gives all clean energy stakeholders the power to thrive. Since 2016, the company has been instrumental in establishing private and public charging solutions and supporting infrastructure to empower America's growing clean energy revolution.
New York Post
8 minutes ago
- New York Post
Despite Zohran Mamdani's past anti-cop stance, socialist still leading NYC mayoral race, poll shows
A majority of New York City voters are turned off by socialist Democratic nominee Zohran Mamdani's past anti-police stance — but he remains the candidate to beat for mayor, a new poll released Wednesday claims. The survey by American Pulse Research & Polling finds Mamdani with support from 36.9% of general election voters, to 24.6% for Andrew Cuomo, 16.8% for Republican nominee Curtis Sliwa, and 11.4% for incumbent Eric Adams. Mamdani's lead over Cuomo doubled from 6 to 12 percentage points since the group's prior poll in early July, mostly because the ex-governor's support dropped since losing the Democratic primary to the lefty Queens Assemblyman. Advertisement 5 A majority of New York City voters are turned off by socialist Democratic nominee Zohran Mamdani's past anti-police stands, but he remains the candidate to beat for mayor, a new poll finds. Matthew McDermott Still, the poll suggests Mamdani could be more vulnerable if one or more rivals drop out of the race. 'Zohran Mamdani remains the candidate to beat,' said lead pollster Dustin Olson. 'However, this new survey also indicates that he can still be beaten….When crime and public safety enter the conversation, his ceiling shows.' Advertisement For example, 58.4% said his prior support to defund the police and scrap an NYPD strategic response group made them less likely to vote for him. More voters said they would vote for 'anyone else' than Mamdani by 6 points after hearing about his anti-NYPD statements. Mamdani now claims he doesn't support slashing police funding. Advertisement 5 The survey by American Pulse Research & Polling finds Mamdani with support from 36.9% of general election voters. Matthew McDermott Nearly half — 45% of voters — said his policies are too extreme. But the problem for rivals Cuomo and Adams is that they carry heavy political baggage and are more unpopular than Mamdani, according to the poll. Fifty-five percent of voters have an unfavorable view of Cuomo, 65% of respondents had a negative view of Adams, and 45% were not fans of Sliwa. Advertisement 5 The poll also suggests Mamdani could be more vulnerable if one or more rivals drop out of the race. Michael Nigro Mamdani was the only candidate whom more voters viewed favorably by 4 points — 47.8% to 43.6% unfavorable — though he's likely to face millions of dollars in attack ads and more scrutiny from now until the Nov. 4 election. A staggering 68.7% of voters say they were less likely to vote for Adams because of Trump's Justice Department dropping the corruption charges against him, and 53% said they were less likely to vote for Cuomo for approving the cashless bail law as governor. The pollster also noted that Mamdani and Sliwa's support may be understated and Cuomo and Adams' overstated. As party nominees, Mamdani and Sliwa will have more prominent placements at the top of the ballot, giving them an advantage, while Cuomo and Adams will be farther down on independent ballot lines. Still, the poll found that Cuomo was within striking distance of Mamdani if either Adams or Sliwa hypothetically dropped out of the race. Sliwa and Adams said they're staying in the race. Without Sliwa in the race, Mamdani is in front with 38.3% to 32.3% for Cuomo and 20.4% for Adams. Advertisement 5 Screenshot of Zohran Mamdani's tweet in June 2020 advocating for taxing the rich, healing the sick, housing the poor, defunding the police, and building a socialist New York. ZohranKMamdani/X Without Adams in the race, Mamdani is ahead with 38.5% to 30.3% for Cuomo and 23% for Sliwa. Mamdani garnered 48% support from Democrats, or nearly half, in the poll. His support will grow if he can rally more Democrats to his side. Advertisement 5 Mamdani now claims he doesn't support slashing police funding. Ivan Kokoulin Similarly, Sliwa received the backing of 53% of Republicans, and his support will increase if he can consolidate the GOP faithful. American Pulse Research & Polling interviewed 638 likely voters from Aug. 14-19 via live phone calls and texts, and an online panel. It has a margin of error of plus or minus 3.9 percentage points. Advertisement A Gotham Polling & Analytics/AARP survey released Tuesday also showed Mamdani with a double-digit lead, but noted more voters souring on him.
Business Wire
39 minutes ago
- Business Wire
NUBURU Hits First Milestone in Tekne Acquisition with Initial Stake and Tekne US JV Launch
CENTENNIAL, Colo.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--NUBURU, Inc. (NYSE American: BURU) ('NUBURU' or the 'Company'), a global leader in high-performance blue laser technology, is pleased to announce the successful execution of the first milestone under the phased acquisition plan for Tekne S.p.A. ('Tekne') established following formal notice received from the Italian government under the 'Golden Power' framework. Through its new subsidiary, Nuburu Defense, the Company secured an initial equity stake equal to the maximum interest permitted under current Golden Power regulatory thresholds (3%) and agreed to an action plan that, by utilizing the Luxembourg investment vehicle TCEI, will pave the way to a controlling interest in Tekne. This step serves as the foundation for the launch of a U.S.-Based Defense 80/20 Joint Venture between Nuburu Defense and Tekne, aimed at being immediately operational with three primary mandates: Deliver an initial USD $7.5 million backlog of Tekne special vehicle contracts outside Italy, while managing sales to non-Italian clients across Tekne's pipeline. Manufacture, assemble, and market Tekne's proven product lines for the Americas. Develop new defense-tech solutions, integrating Tekne's licenses with NUBURU's blue-laser platform to create proprietary IP for allied markets. 'This joint venture transforms the phased acquisition plan into a revenue-generating reality, ' said Alessandro Zamboni, Executive Chairman of NUBURU. 'We can now execute contracts, expanding Tekne's reach into the Americas, and laying the groundwork for co-developed technologies that can shape the future of allied defense.' As part of the broader phased plan, the binding agreement signed between the Company and Tekne's shareholders — which provides for Nuburu Defense's path from minority stake to an eventual 70% controlling interest in Tekne — includes commitments to finance up to €40 million in Tekne's working capital needs over the next 12 months, also supported by Supply@ME Capital Plc's inventory monetization platform and potential further additional investors through the platform. A renewed Golden Power notification will be filed to progress to majority ownership in compliance with Italian requirements. To bolster execution, NUBURU has engaged Anthony Sinnott, a retired U.S. Marine Corps officer and former DoD senior advisor, as a strategic consultant. Mr. Sinnott brings extensive operational, NATO, and Fortune 500 leadership experience, including service on Tekne's board. Together, these steps advance NUBURU's Defense & Security Hub strategy — uniting Tekne's deployed Tactical Bubble systems and defense vehicle expertise with NUBURU's blue-laser technology and its confirmed upcoming acquisition of the Software as a Service startup focused on operational resilience, which allows for an expanded offering from Nuburu Defense. Further updates will follow as NUBURU continues to execute the phased plan and expand its defense and security footprint. About NUBURU Founded in 2015, NUBURU, Inc. has developed and previously manufactured industrial blue laser technology. Under a renewed strategic vision led by Executive Chairman Alessandro Zamboni, the Company is expanding into complementary sectors including defense-tech, security, and critical infrastructure resilience. NUBURU is leveraging a combination of internal innovation and strategic acquisitions to build out its Defense & Security Hub, targeting long-term, sustainable growth across high-value government and enterprise markets. For more information, visit Forward-Looking Statements This press release contains certain 'forward-looking statements' within the meaning of the United States Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933, as amended, and Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended. All statements other than statements of historical fact contained in this press release may be forward-looking statements, identified by words such as 'may,' 'should,' 'expect,' 'intend,' 'will,' 'estimate,' 'anticipate,' 'believe,' 'predict,' 'plan,' 'seek,' 'targets,' 'projects,' 'could,' 'would,' 'continue,' 'forecast,' or their negatives or variations. These statements are subject to risks, uncertainties, and other factors that could cause actual results to differ materially, including but not limited to: (1) the ability to meet security exchange listing standards; (2) the impact of the loss of the Company's patent portfolio through foreclosure; (3) failure to achieve expectations regarding business development and acquisition strategy; (4) inability to access sufficient capital; (5) inability to realize anticipated benefits of acquisitions; (6) changes in applicable laws or regulations; (7) adverse economic, business, or competitive factors; (8) financial market volatility due to geopolitical and economic factors; and (9) other risks detailed in the Company's SEC filings, including its most recent Form 10-K or Form 10-Q. These filings address additional risks that could cause actual results to differ from those in the forward-looking statements. Readers should not place undue reliance on these statements, which speak only as of the date they are made. NUBURU undertakes no obligation to update or revise these statements, except as required by law. Source: NUBURU, Inc.
