Independent MP slammed for linking NRL player Keith Titmuss' death to climate change
A Sydney Independent MP has been criticised for linking an NRL player's death to climate change.
Dr Sophie Scamps, the member for Mackellar on Sydney's northern beaches, has suggested 'lethal humidity' could have been a factor in the death of Keith Titmuss after a Manly Sea Eagles pre-season training session in November 2020.
FOX LEAGUE, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every game of every round in the 2025 NRL Telstra Premiership, LIVE in 4K with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer.
Code Sports reports Dr Scamps floated the theory that 'lethal humidity' would become more prominent when speaking at a Doctors for the Environment Australia event in February.
She made the comments referencing 'the death of the young man, the rugby league player', Titmuss, who died following a seizure at Manly's training base in Narrabeen.
Dr Scamps' remarks were prompted by a question about the link between climate change and health.
'One of the things that really struck me – we've got this thing called lethal humidity now,' said Dr Scamps, who is a GP.
'With every rise of one degree in temperature you have seven degrees increased per cent in humidity, so the death of that young man – and I'm not saying – the death of the young man the rugby league player when it was 33 degrees a very humid day, died from heat stress – you know, after a training session.
'That type of lethal humidity is something that the medical fraternity is getting more and more concerned about.
'Apparently, the human body can survive up to 54 degrees Celsius – it's pretty hot. But, with high-level humidity, that level comes down to kind of 33, even 31 degrees, so it's something to consider.'
Deputy State Coroner Derek Lee found that Manly's training session in the off-season heat was 'more likely than not inappropriate' and pointed to several factors that contributed to Titmuss's heat stroke, including his high body-mass index and a lack of aerobic capacity in comparison to teammates.
Lee did not reference 'lethal humidity' in his findings.
In his coroner's report, Lee noted the maximum temperature on the day of Titmuss' death as 25 degrees.
'The temperature (measured at Terrey Hills) was 21.3°C at 9:00am and 21.6°C at 3:00pm, with a maximum temperature of 24.9°C. The relative humidity was at 92% at 9:00am, decreasing to 74% at 3:00pm,' the coroner's report stated.
Titmuss' mother Lafo has been left upset by Dr Scamps' comments.
'I'm disappointed that (Dr Scamps) is using my son's name to try and gain political points when all she needed to do was read Derek Lee's findings, which mention nothing about climate change,' Lafo said, per Code Sports.
A coronial inquest, which wrapped up in May last year, found Titmuss died of 'exertional heat stroke'.
'Keith's death was a tragedy that will forever keep our thoughts focused on his family and friends – and not about politics,' Manly chief executive Tony Mestrov said on Tuesday.
'As a club, we have been made aware of political remarks, but the facts from the recent Deputy State Coroner's report never stipulated that Keith's death was anything to do with climate change or lethal humidity.
'To suggest otherwise is insensitive and incorrect.'
Titmuss collapsed during a training session at an indoor gym. He was rushed to hospital, where he suffered a fatal cardiac arrest.
A spokesperson for Dr Scamps again referenced 'lethal humidity' when asked about the MP's comments about Titmuss.
'Sophie and the entire Northern Beaches community are desperately sad for the Titmuss family after the terrible tragedy of Keith's death, which the Coroner's Court found was caused by exertional heat stroke,' the spokeswoman told Code Sports.
'As a doctor and former elite athlete, Sophie takes the threat of lethal humidity extremely seriously. As parents, we do not want our kids to have to train and compete in conditions that put their health at risk. Sophie will continue to push for action to ensure a safe working environment for all athletes, young and old.
'Separately, there is a rise of elite athletes around the world speaking up about the dangers that higher temperatures pose to athletes. The emergence of organisations like Sport4Climate, The Green Sports Alliance and the United Nation's Sports for Climate Action demonstrate the seriousness of the threat.'
Dr Scamps was one of six 'teal' Independents who defeated Liberal MPs at the 2022 federal election.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

News.com.au
5 days ago
- News.com.au
James Schiller subjected to horrific online abuse despite Newcastle's stunning comeback win over Manly
Newcastle Knights winger James Schiller has revealed the sickening threats hurled his way online after his side's golden point triumph against Manly on Thursday night. Schiller had a mixed bag, with five errors, four missed tackles and gave away three penalties. Starting at left centre to allow for the return of winger Greg Marzhew, Schiller looked lost out of position in the first half. It saw Knights coach Adam O'Brien move him back to the right wing in the second period and the 23-year-old looked like a different player, finishing the night with a try, a try assist and four line breaks as Newcastle came back from a 16-0 half-time deficit to win the match 26-22 in golden point. Over the moon after one of the great NRL comebacks, Schiller turned on his phone to see a barrage of hate, namely from one Instagram user who made vile threats towards the winger early in the second half. 'Count your days c*nt I will end your f***ing life,' they wrote in a message shared by Schiller to his Instagram. The win did little to calm the fan down either, as he doubled down after full-time. 'Doesn't make up for it even though you won,' the fan continued. '5 errors, 2 penalties, 1 six again and partridge in a pear tree I hope Dane (Gagai) jams his c**k down your throat and you choke and die.' The threats were then addressed on Friday by O'Brien who labelled it 'worrying'. 'That is worrying,' O'Brien said. 'I want to protect them … and for him to go through that over a couple of errors … it's a game of footy. 'He's got a family. That's partly the reason why you do want to protect them. 'I think it's a societal problem, isn't it? It's not just football players who are getting that sort of stuff. 'I understand there is some legislation, and I think at the moment it's in the hands of authorities to try and help in this situation with James. 'We need to be able to stop people doing it, change their thought process before doing it. 'I don't have social media but I know (the players) get it a fair bit.' Police have the authority to charge individuals for threats made through social media. In 2021, two men were charged after sending abusive or threatening messages to NRL star Latrell Mitchell on social media.


7NEWS
7 days ago
- 7NEWS
Viral energy drink that rose to fame on TikTok is now available to buy at Woolies for just $3.60
It's fizzy, fruity and packed with a caffeine punch. Australia, meet your new energy drink obsession. The viral-favourite energy drink that's got everyone in the US buzzing, literally, is finally available at Woolworths online nationwide. CELSIUS Energy Drink, the brand that's been quietly powering through workouts, dancefloors and 3 pm slumps across America, has officially touched down, down under. And yes, that drink Dakota Johnson accidentally 'overdosed' on while filming 'Loser Baby' is front and centre in the range. In a now-viral interview with Dakota, hilariously admitted to Variety, she had no idea CELSIUS is an energy drink, saying, 'I was like, I'm so inspired. I'm awake all night long. I thought it was vitamins.' Stars, they're just like us, only with slightly more accidental caffeine jitters. Whether you're smashing fitness goals or just trying to stay awake during meetings, CELSIUS is designed to fuel you through it. It's sugar-free, low in calories, made with natural flavours and green tea extract, and completely aspartame-free. Translation? A fizzy little can of pep that won't leave you with the crash (or guilt) of a traditional energy drink. The newest flavour to hit Woolies' shelves is Sunset Vibe, and it tastes exactly how it sounds: a tropical escape. It's mango meets passionfruit in a sparkling burst of sunshine that somehow makes you want to do burpees. It joins a seriously stacked lineup of flavours including Kiwi Strawberry, Watermelon Lemonade, Green Apple Cherry and Cosmic Vibe. Even better, the entire range is now online at Woolworths and rolling out in-store across the country from 11 June. At just $3.60 a can (usually $4), now's your chance to stock up before everyone else realises what's going on. And if you're still energy-curious, there's a wave of buzzy options making moves on the Aussie market. Gatorade's Fast Twitch is an athlete-approved hit, Alani Nu is backed by celebs like Kim Kardashian and Paris Hilton, and V Riise is the go-to for a steadier, longer-lasting lift. Energy drinks aren't niche anymore, they're a full-on lifestyle. So whether you're hitting the gym, your deadline, or just trying to stay vertical during an afternoon meeting, CELSIUS might just be your new sidekick.


The Advertiser
7 days ago
- The Advertiser
Contract talks for Manly lock after fractured rib pain
Manly have opened talks to re-sign off-contract duo Siosiua Taukeiaho and Jazz Tevaga, with the latter revealing he has played the past month with a fractured rib. Taukeiaho and Tevaga both landed at the Sea Eagles on one-year deals over the summer, and are both likely to earn one-year extensions. The Sea Eagles are on something of a re-signing spree at the moment, with fellow forward Ethan Bullemor closing in on a four-year extension at the club. Manly have also moved to begin talks with Tom and Jake Trbojevic, who are off contract at the end of 2026 and free agents from November 1 this year. Talks are also ongoing with young winger Clayton Faulalo, while Manly are keen to keep fellow off-contract outside back Tommy Talau. "We've started discussions with Jazz and Siua," Manly CEO Tony Mestrov told AAP. "Siua came for a year, had a few injuries, but his leg speed has been great, and Jazz is a tough bugger. "Siua and Jazz have probably been two of our best forwards this year. They've added to the culture of what we're trying to do, being tough and relentless. "We've started discussions, just started with both, with a view to keeping them next year and extending them." Taukeiaho's talks come after Manly offered him a lifeline over the summer, after he failed a medical at Canterbury in 2023 and was released by Catalans last year. The former Sydney Roosters premiership winner won't face Newcastle on Thursday because of a calf strain, but has been one of Manly's most reliable players this year. Tevaga, meanwhile, took something of a gamble when he knocked back an offer from the Warriors to move to Australia on his one-year deal. After filling in at dummy-half to start the year, he has been particularly good in his preferred spot of lock in recent weeks with Jake Trbojevic out. "I put all my eggs in this basket," Tevaga said. "I'd prefer to stay. We came over here for an opportunity. I feel like I've lived up to the transaction. Hopefully we can get something across the line. "I'm no Isaah Yeo or anything, but I feel like it's working well (at lock) and giving me a good balance." Tevaga will go back to the bench this week with Trbojevic returning at No.13, having also required needles on a fractured rib suffered in round eight against Penrith. "I've been battling and it doesn't help when you lose a few players, but It's getting better," Tevaga said. "At first it was a rib cartilage, and then I copped a whack on it, and with the rib cartilage out, it just threw me in a vulnerable position. "I was going to sit out the Sharks game ... If you watch it I just couldn't wrestle. In the play-the-ball, I couldn't fight, because it was just in pain, but the jab helps it." Manly have opened talks to re-sign off-contract duo Siosiua Taukeiaho and Jazz Tevaga, with the latter revealing he has played the past month with a fractured rib. Taukeiaho and Tevaga both landed at the Sea Eagles on one-year deals over the summer, and are both likely to earn one-year extensions. The Sea Eagles are on something of a re-signing spree at the moment, with fellow forward Ethan Bullemor closing in on a four-year extension at the club. Manly have also moved to begin talks with Tom and Jake Trbojevic, who are off contract at the end of 2026 and free agents from November 1 this year. Talks are also ongoing with young winger Clayton Faulalo, while Manly are keen to keep fellow off-contract outside back Tommy Talau. "We've started discussions with Jazz and Siua," Manly CEO Tony Mestrov told AAP. "Siua came for a year, had a few injuries, but his leg speed has been great, and Jazz is a tough bugger. "Siua and Jazz have probably been two of our best forwards this year. They've added to the culture of what we're trying to do, being tough and relentless. "We've started discussions, just started with both, with a view to keeping them next year and extending them." Taukeiaho's talks come after Manly offered him a lifeline over the summer, after he failed a medical at Canterbury in 2023 and was released by Catalans last year. The former Sydney Roosters premiership winner won't face Newcastle on Thursday because of a calf strain, but has been one of Manly's most reliable players this year. Tevaga, meanwhile, took something of a gamble when he knocked back an offer from the Warriors to move to Australia on his one-year deal. After filling in at dummy-half to start the year, he has been particularly good in his preferred spot of lock in recent weeks with Jake Trbojevic out. "I put all my eggs in this basket," Tevaga said. "I'd prefer to stay. We came over here for an opportunity. I feel like I've lived up to the transaction. Hopefully we can get something across the line. "I'm no Isaah Yeo or anything, but I feel like it's working well (at lock) and giving me a good balance." Tevaga will go back to the bench this week with Trbojevic returning at No.13, having also required needles on a fractured rib suffered in round eight against Penrith. "I've been battling and it doesn't help when you lose a few players, but It's getting better," Tevaga said. "At first it was a rib cartilage, and then I copped a whack on it, and with the rib cartilage out, it just threw me in a vulnerable position. "I was going to sit out the Sharks game ... If you watch it I just couldn't wrestle. In the play-the-ball, I couldn't fight, because it was just in pain, but the jab helps it." Manly have opened talks to re-sign off-contract duo Siosiua Taukeiaho and Jazz Tevaga, with the latter revealing he has played the past month with a fractured rib. Taukeiaho and Tevaga both landed at the Sea Eagles on one-year deals over the summer, and are both likely to earn one-year extensions. The Sea Eagles are on something of a re-signing spree at the moment, with fellow forward Ethan Bullemor closing in on a four-year extension at the club. Manly have also moved to begin talks with Tom and Jake Trbojevic, who are off contract at the end of 2026 and free agents from November 1 this year. Talks are also ongoing with young winger Clayton Faulalo, while Manly are keen to keep fellow off-contract outside back Tommy Talau. "We've started discussions with Jazz and Siua," Manly CEO Tony Mestrov told AAP. "Siua came for a year, had a few injuries, but his leg speed has been great, and Jazz is a tough bugger. "Siua and Jazz have probably been two of our best forwards this year. They've added to the culture of what we're trying to do, being tough and relentless. "We've started discussions, just started with both, with a view to keeping them next year and extending them." Taukeiaho's talks come after Manly offered him a lifeline over the summer, after he failed a medical at Canterbury in 2023 and was released by Catalans last year. The former Sydney Roosters premiership winner won't face Newcastle on Thursday because of a calf strain, but has been one of Manly's most reliable players this year. Tevaga, meanwhile, took something of a gamble when he knocked back an offer from the Warriors to move to Australia on his one-year deal. After filling in at dummy-half to start the year, he has been particularly good in his preferred spot of lock in recent weeks with Jake Trbojevic out. "I put all my eggs in this basket," Tevaga said. "I'd prefer to stay. We came over here for an opportunity. I feel like I've lived up to the transaction. Hopefully we can get something across the line. "I'm no Isaah Yeo or anything, but I feel like it's working well (at lock) and giving me a good balance." Tevaga will go back to the bench this week with Trbojevic returning at No.13, having also required needles on a fractured rib suffered in round eight against Penrith. "I've been battling and it doesn't help when you lose a few players, but It's getting better," Tevaga said. "At first it was a rib cartilage, and then I copped a whack on it, and with the rib cartilage out, it just threw me in a vulnerable position. "I was going to sit out the Sharks game ... If you watch it I just couldn't wrestle. In the play-the-ball, I couldn't fight, because it was just in pain, but the jab helps it."