NSW Premier Chris Minns and Opposition Leader Mark Speakman slam anti-abortion activist Joanna Howe over misinformation, bullying claims
Mr Minns accused campaigner Dr Joanna Howe on Wednesday of spreading an 'enormous amount of misinformation' on social media, but noted he did not blame her for a rumour that consciences objectors would be compelled to perform abortions.
'It's whipped up a lot of good people in the community, believing that the reform changes, the legislative changes, are far more extensive than they are,' Mr Minns said.
'I think that there are genuine differences, particularly when you have a matter as sensitive as abortion.
'It's not helped by putting an enormous amount of misinformation.
'As for threatening politicians about what you will and won't do, well that's a matter for activists. But, generally speaking, Australian politicians, regardless of their background or ideology, react incredibly poorly to that kind of threat.'
Mr Speakman on Tuesday night accused Ms Howe, who is self-described as 'the lead advocate' against the bill, of 'brazen bullying' following an email in which she told the Liberal leader she would halt a campaign targeting Labor seats.
'Should Premier Minns vote for the bill and enable its passage, I will be leading a 20-month campaign across five marginal seats that are currently Labor-held but are also in socially conservative electorates,' Mr Speakman said Ms Howe said.
'However, if you choose to vote for the bill, I will be left with no other choice but to suspend my planned campaign against Labor in order to lead a public campaign aimed at
encouraging a grassroots opposition to you as Liberal leader.'
In response, Mr Speakman said he would 'not cave to brazen bullying like this nor to the Americanisation of NSW politics. I will vote according to my conscience and balance difficult and sensitive ethical, social, moral and medical concerns.
'I thank all constituents who have contacted me. I have carefully considered their sincere and varying views. I will therefore vote for the bill. I think that, on balance, the bill will make no material difference to the rate of abortion in NSW.
'It will not interfere with freedom of conscience and will probably lead to better, not worse, health outcomes for many pregnant women seeking abortions.'
Mr Speakman said some opposition to the bill was 'based on misinformation' and that 'the attacks on freedom of conscience and freedom of religion in the original bill have now been removed by successful amendments.'
The Liberal leader described the bill as a 'shadow of its former self' and could 'no longer be characterised as a 'radical Greens bill'', noting that there was 'no way I could have voted for the bill in its original form'.
Those views were somewhat reflected by Mr Minns on Wednesday.
The Premier told the media he would support the bill 'in its current incarnation'.
'I couldn't have supported the removal of conscientious objection, but it's not in the bill anymore,' he said.
The bill, introduced by upper house Greens MP Dr Amanda Cohn in February, would expand access to abortions by allowing nurse practitioners to supply medication to terminate pregnancies of up to nine weeks in gestation.
It will be voted on tonight in the NSW Legislative Assembly where, if passed, it will become law.
The vote comes after a raft of amendments, including the removal of provisions to empower the Health Minister to compel public health services to comply with directions to offer abortion services and would require practitioners who object to abortion to refer a patient to someone who will perform the abortion.
The bill has stirred fiery debate since it was tabled.
In a parliamentary debate last week, upper house Liberal MP Chris Rath compared abortion to the Nazi genocide of Jews, stating 'it is bizarre that abortion is increasingly being categorised as a human right to health care'.
Mr Rath later apologised for the statement.
In Facebook video on Wednesday, Ms Howe claimed Mr Speakman's speech had been leaked to the media 'because they think it will stop me from speaking', and vowed to publish the email to 'let you guys decide' if she was a 'bully'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
22 minutes ago
- Perth Now
'Get on with the job' after failed bid to turf premier
Tasmania's returned minority Liberal premier has declared he wants to get on the with job after a snap election and weeks of political uncertainty. Jeremy Rockliff received parliament's green light to continue governing on Tuesday afternoon when a Labor bid to seize power via a no-confidence motion fell spectacularly flat. Neither the Liberals (14 seats) or Labor (10) reached the required 18 seats needed for majority at the July 19 election. Labor, which has been in opposition for 11 years, tried to unseat Mr Rockliff as premier and install its leader Dean Winter in the role on parliament's first day back. But none of the cross bench, which includes five Greens, five independents and one Shooters, Fishers and Farmers MP, backed Mr Winter's motion. Several crossbenchers lashed Mr Winter for a lack of compromise during negotiations and for still moving a motion that was doomed to fail after the Greens ruled out support on Monday. The Greens and several independents noted they lacked faith in the Liberals, but has less faith that Labor could form a workable government. First-term independent and former journalist Peter George said Labor had undermined the very notion of collaboration by not shifting on any of its policies. "In my years of reporting politics, which stretch back to the Whitlam years, never have I come across an opposition party less ready for government," he said. Labor received its worst primary vote in more than a century at the election and suffered a 3.1 per cent swing against it. Mr Rockliff, who has presided over a minority government since 2023, said MPs had learnt a lot in recent weeks. "The time to get on with the job, to work together in the best interests of Tasmania, starts right now," he said. The Liberals made several policy concessions to a largely progressive cross bench, including a ban on greyhound racing and a review examining the state's salmon industry. Mr Winter accused Mr Rockliff of selling out jobs and doing anything to stay in power. Mr Rockliff defended the concessions as an acknowledgement of the minority situation. The snap election, Tasmania's fourth in seven years, was triggered after Mr Rockliff lost a no-confidence motion in June criticising the state's ballooning budget debt. The Greens offered at that point to work with Labor to form government, but Mr Winter refused.
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
Lehrmann in new bid to clear name after defamation loss
Bruce Lehrmann will have three days to convince an appeals court to toss out findings he likely raped his colleague Brittany Higgins in parliament house. The former federal political staffer is seeking to overturn a Federal Court judgment he was not defamed by Network Ten and journalist Lisa Wilkinson during an interview with Ms Higgins on The Project in 2021. Justice Michael Lee found Ms Higgins' claims she had been raped in parliament house in 2019 were substantially true in a ruling against Lehrmann in April 2024. But Lehrmann, 29, claims the judgment was rife with errors and launched an appeal which will be ventilated over three days, beginning on Wednesday in Sydney. The ex-Liberal staffer alleges he was denied procedural fairness because the events found by the judge were "starkly different" from the case run by Ten. He points to the allegation Ms Higgins had repeatedly said "no on a loop" during the alleged incident, which Justice Lee was not satisfied had occurred. The case as found by Justice Lee wasn't put to him during cross-examination for his response, Lehrmann argues. He says because of deficiencies in Ms Higgins' evidence, the judge should not have found he engaged in rape. The judge found Lehrmann had been "hell-bent" on having sex with Ms Higgins and had a mindset of "non-advertent recklessness" which showed he knew she was not consenting. But that definition of rape has been criticised by Lehrmann, who claims it's inconsistent with the meaning conveyed to an ordinary person. Justice Lee is also accused of erring by finding Lehrmann would only be entitled to damages of $20,000 if he had succeeded in his defamation suit against Ten. Lehrmann's lawyer Zali Burrows has previously said he should be awarded a seven-figure sum for the "false charge of rape". Lehrmann continues to deny he sexually assaulted Ms Higgins and a criminal case against him in 2022 was abandoned without any findings against him. "Having escaped the lions' den, Mr Lehrmann made the mistake of going back for his hat," Justice Lee said in his decision in 2024. 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028
Sydney Morning Herald
2 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Push to recognise overseas qualifications before unions and business clash on tax
Nurses, engineers and other immigrants with qualifications from overseas would be able to work in Australia under a proposal that won support at Tuesday's economic roundtable as unions and bosses jousted over a bid to slap a new tax on businesses. Treasurer Jim Chalmers hailed the first day of the three-day Canberra talkfest as a moment of consensus on skills reform, prompting Labor to do an about-face and start drafting a joint statement of intent after last week downplaying expectations of any international summit-style statement. As Chalmers prepared to oversee disputes over artificial intelligence at Wednesday's session, he lauded the collaboration of economists, captains of industry and workers' representatives, who he said had 'really risen to the occasion'. But other sources in the closed-off cabinet room said the meeting was highly stage-managed. 'No one is challenging anyone,' one participant said on the condition of anonymity. Former Reserve Bank governor Philip Lowe launched a significant attack on Labor's economic record, saying in a clip released as the roundtable began that Chalmers had spent more at a time when restraint was needed to bring down inflation. 'After COVID, we haven't really got back to a clearly articulated framework for decision-making with fiscal policy,' Lowe said in a video recorded a month ago and released on Tuesday by the University of NSW and think tank e61. Noting that higher interest rates were the chief tool used to tackle inflation, Lowe said 'exercising discipline is not popular, and exercising restraint is not popular. It's much easier for the political class to say, if things need to slow, we'll get the central bank to do that with interest rates, and they can, they can take the blame.' At the roundtable, there was broad backing for slashing another tranche of so-called 'nuisance tariffs' – tiny charges on imports which add to compliance costs and consumer prices. But trade union bosses at the high-profile talkfest, including the ACTU's Sally McManus, raised concerns about acknowledging some foreign degrees and warned that industries would need to be protected if tariffs were removed.
