logo
Mediawatch: How a Budget is covered

Mediawatch: How a Budget is covered

RNZ News24-05-2025

The Budget was front-page news for all the papers on Friday, but the big money had already been announced or signaled.
Photo:
The Southland Times
The sudden scrapping of pay equity claims was hailed as "saving the Budget" by Act leader David Seymour, while Finance Minister Nicola Willis insisted it was not a book-balancing move.
When reporters and analysts went into the Budget day lock-up, the estimated saving was the first number many looked for - and it led the coverage once the embargo lapsed.
The sum certainly startled presenter Ryan Bridge.
"12.8 billion dollars. Almost half the savings over the entire Budget period," he spluttered on the Herald website's live-streamed video coverage (which doubled as a practice for the Herald Now livestream launching this week).
But NZIER economist Christina Leung, who had been previewing the Budget for broadcasters since dawn, was not surprised - or energised.
"It was a boring Budget to be honest," she told Bridge.
The Three Gals, One Beehive podcast labelled it "a yeah, nah Budget." At the Spinoff, Bernard Hickey declared it merely "meh." Other pundits labelled it a 'true blue' Budget National would expect to deliver in times that are tight.
But the tepid reaction was mainly because they already knew where $3b of fresh state spending would go, thanks to the pre-Budget announcements staggered in advance to maximise media coverage.
Big ticket items like defence, rail, acute healthcare and more were old news by Thursday. Substantial sums committed to costly medicines via Pharmac last year were also already baked in.
The finance minister was managing expectations for reporters by teasing it as a "No BS" budget with no "unicorns and rainbows".
The same message was also driven home hard by the media, though The Herald's business editor-at-large Liam Dann did not need imaginary animals. Instead he used the word the government was trying to avoid.
"Austerity is an ugly word - but that's what experts call it when there's no new money to spend," said Dann in an
explainer for the Herald
.
"It is a Budget that promised little and therefore did not disappoint," The Post's editorial pointed out on Friday.
"There is now no question Willis' Budget was built on the backs of thousands of underpaid, hard-working New Zealand women" who had taken one for the team of 5 million, the paper said.
"The government is leaving the hard work of growth and recovery to businesses," The Post added - and pointed out it would be slow.
But some businesses were off the hook.
Just two days before the Budget, the government abandoned legislation to impose a 3 percent tax on the New Zealand revenues of online search and social media platforms.
BusinessDesk reported the Digital Services Tax Bill was forecast raise around $320 million over four years - and almost $100m a year in additional tax revenue after that.
Revenue Minister Simon Watts told Newstalk ZB Donald Trump's threat to punish countries taxing US corporations was a factor in scrapping the law change.
A bill to oblige Facebook and Google to pay for locally-produced news is also languishing on the back-burner. Many pundits believe the Fair Digital News Bargaining bill may be scrapped soon too, in part for the same reason.
And while incremental financial tweaks revealed on Budget day inevitably became the focus of the rolling coverage, it obscured some of the structural stuff.
Last week The Listener's political writer
Danyl McLauchlan noted
"mostly trivial payments and cuts announced each year (are) presented as 'winners' and 'losers' in Budget media coverage, without considering the vast, submerged commitments frozen-in from decades of previous Budgets."
The biggest of all was superannuation, he said, which was "untouchable so long as Winston Peters glowers at Willis from across the Cabinet table."
The Post noted
that while KiwiSaver contributions were cut for high earners, "it still remains politically impossible to make the same sorts of arguments about revising NZ Super."
In the Post, pundit
Ben Thomas said
the most urgent question in the next decade is how to make paying for an ageing population sustainable.
Newsroom's Fox Meyer
pointed out
several spending programmes - including the controversial school lunches - were "looming over fiscal cliffs."
With just $1.3b in nominal spending left, few in the media were expecting any unicorns or rainbows.
Noting that RNZ got a substantial boost of $26m a year in 2023 - in the wake of the failed merger with TVNZ - the government pegged back RNZ's budget by about seven percent for the next four years.
That's $4.6m a year in dollar terms, leaving RNZ about $62m a year as things stand.
RNZ was not required to find savings last year when many other public agencies and ministries were directed to make cuts, so it was no surprise the axe was swung this time.
"Government-funded media must deliver the same efficiency and value-for-money as the rest of the public sector. I expect RNZ to improve audience reach, trust and transparency ... in a period of tightened fiscal constraint," media and communications minister Paul Goldsmith said in a stern statement.
That was echoed by the finance minister.
RNZ's top brass were also
questioned
about RNZ's rising salary costs during last year's annual review in Parliament.
Chief executive Paul Thompson told the select committee RNZ was investing in its digital transition "and that all costs money."
"The media system in New Zealand is incredibly fragile - it doesn't make sense for RNZ to also be weak when the government has given us a mandate to be that strong cornerstone," he told the committee.
Māori media funding is under the auspices of the Māori Development Ministry Te Puni Kokiri and Māori broadcasting funding agency Te Māngai Pāho.
TMP's funding is
up marginally
to $66m, but the Budget reduces Whakaata Māori's annual funding by about $6m to just over $42m next year.
Māori media were heavily backed by the previous government and its minister of broadcasting and Māori development Willie Jackson, who was also a former broadcaster and media boss himself.
Just over $90m was made available in two separate Budgets to cover the cost of programmes and content. Some of that would last until 2029, and one stream of funding would end in 2027.
Whakaata Māori restructured last year to take account of money running out. As part of that restructure 27 jobs were cut, along with programmes and services.
Māori media and journalism
also benefited from the PIJF
until 2023. Waatea - the urban Māori radio station and online news service - added seven roles to its news team which also service the iwi radio network.
Interestingly the funding peril has barely been mentioned in the news - or in any politicians' statements, save for a passing mention in one by Willie Jackson and one from the Greens.
Goldsmith's statement was headed: 'Investing in Journalism'.
Two existing schemes covering the cost of reporters in the regions will see $6.4 million over four years :
Local Democracy Reporting
and [https://www.nzherald.co.nz/topic/public-interest-open-justice/ Open Justice - both of which have had significant sums of public funding to date.
The LDR scheme - modelled on a UK programme of the same name - is managed by RNZ.
It deploys 18 reporters in local newsrooms around the country, which would otherwise be unable to fully cover local affairs.
Previously-funded by both RNZ and NZ on Air, all the content created was free online at RNZ.co.nz and available to other interested publishers.
Open Justice
is administered by the New Zealand Herald's publisher NZME.
This pays reporters to cover courts about a dozen locations and was prompted by diminished coverage of non-high-profile cases in recent years.
Matters before the District and High Courts, Family and Youth Courts and a variety of tribunals too are now much more likely to be reported.
But not so much in the South Island. NZME's newsgathering and mastheads are concentrated in the north.
It is important to the judiciary and the government alike that justice is seen to be done - and the Open Justice reports appear on a wide range of news websites.
Open Justice was funded for two years initially in 2022 via NZ on Air at a cost of just less than $3m.
Both schemes were previously paid for out of the Public Interest Journalism Fund (PIJF) set up by the former government in 2020 to run for three years.
The fund was persistently criticised by the parties then in opposition, who
made claims
about the government buying media compliance and also stifling debate about the Treaty.
Some critics did not like state funding of private sector journalism, or paying the wages of newspaper reporters in private media companies.
But now in government, National's ministers seem to accept regional newsrooms ca not employ dedicated justice and local politics reporters within their own finances. And they are comfortable paying more for journalism that does not encroach on national issues.
The media minister pointedly said in his statement "reporting, rather than opinion" is being supported by the added funding.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Former New Plymouth mayor David Lean remembered as a 'visonary'
Former New Plymouth mayor David Lean remembered as a 'visonary'

RNZ News

time40 minutes ago

  • RNZ News

Former New Plymouth mayor David Lean remembered as a 'visonary'

Former New Plymouth mayor David Lean - seen here at the opening of the New Plymouth Wastewater Treatment Plant in 1984 - has died aged 76. Photo: Taranaki Daily News Former New Plymouth mayor David "Daisy" Lean is being remembered as a "visionary" who injected a youthful energy into the role. The 76-year-old, who died earlier this week, was one of the country's youngest ever mayors when elected in 1980 - at just 32 years of age. He wore the mayoral chains until 1992. Lean has been credited with halting the pumping of New Plymouth's untreated wastewater into the Tasman Sea and securing railway land critical to the city's celebrated Coastal Walkway among other achievements, including the construction of the Todd Aquatic Centre and TSB Stadium. Former New Plymouth mayor David Lean in his mayoral robe. Photo: Supplied Peter Tennent - who was mayor between 2001 and 2010 - had an abiding memory of Lean's ascent to the mayoralty in 1980. "I remember the Oakura Beach Carnival the previous year when Denny Sutherland was mayor, he wore a three-piece suit to present the sash to winner of the Miss Taranaki beach resorts competition. "The following year, we had a new young mayor by the name of David Lean and he was wearing a pair of speedos when he jumped up on stage and made the presentation to the winner." Tennent said Lean brought a new energy and focus to the role. "He was an awfully nice guy, supportive of me and others who've been privileged enough to represent this community and my heart goes out to his wife Janet and all of the family. They've lost a a wonderful family man." Lean had been a huge contributor to New Plymouth, he said. "He was man of vision, a man who believed that it was not appropriate that we pushed our wastewater straight into the ocean. That it was treated, it was a big issue when he was elected an awful lot of money, but I've got to say none of us would even think of dumping raw sewage into the ocean now." Kinsley Sampson was chief executive during David Lean's mayoralty and his right hand man. David Lean at the opening of the New Plymouth Wastewater Treatment Plant in 1984 with his wife Janet. Photo: Taranaki Daily News He remembered the young mayor famously drinking a glass of water from the wastewater treatment plant once it was commissioned. The stunt had a point. "There is still some argument about it, but what he drank was water that had been through the carousel plant and then before it went to the sea it was chlorinated so it was perfectly safe. "But what he had demonstrated was that we were now releasing germ-free water to the Tasman Sea via our outfall." Sampson said the Coastal Walkway was just a dream when Lean came to office. "But the New Zealand Railways decided to shift their marshalling yards and railway station from the where the wind wand is now and David was determined that we would buy that land because he wanted to turn the city to the sea again and create Puke Ariki Landing, the area where the wind wand is and the port to Waiwhakaiho River walkway." There were tough times too. In 1995, Lean was assaulted outside a restaurant he and wife Janet established after he lost the mayoralty. Sampson said it was a dark day. "In closing one evening, there was some unpleasant young men and it ended up in David being assaulted and he was hurt very, very badly and suffered brain damage which amongst other things affected his sense of taste and smell, but yeah ,that was pretty awful." But it did not end Lean's public service. David Lean in recent years. Photo: SUPPLIED / ANDY JACKSON He was the region's Civil Defence controller for 35 years, inaugural chair of Sport Taranaki, a long-time district health board member and still a current regional councillor after almost three decades on council. Taranaki Regional Council chairman Craig Williamson - who was to speak at Lean's funeral - said service was in his blood. "He just wanted to make a difference and he wanted to give back. He was also involved outside of politics with other organisations that are for the betterment of the community too. It was just his thing from way back in the day until now. He was a champion and a good friend and a good bloke. He'll be missed." A celebration of David Lean's life was to be held at Butlers Reef in Ōākura on Thursday. He was survived by this wife Janet, children Kirsten, Brooke, Greer and Kent, and seven grandchildren. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

US-China trade deal 'welcome relief' for Kiwi exporters
US-China trade deal 'welcome relief' for Kiwi exporters

RNZ News

timean hour ago

  • RNZ News

US-China trade deal 'welcome relief' for Kiwi exporters

Todd McClay at the Mystery Creek Fieldays yesterday. Photo: Monique Steele Agriculture Minister Todd McClay who also has Trade portfolio has welcomed news of [ a possible US-China trade deal]. US President Donald Trump says a deal with China is "done" after two days of high-level talks in London. The overnight announcement comes as the government welcomes the state of the country's agriculture sector. The Ministry of Primary Industries' Situation and Outlook report is projecting a double digit increase in New Zealand export revenues this year - though it warns about global uncertainty. It estimates New Zealand's agricultural export revenue could reach just under $60 billion by the end of June, up from a dip in 2023-4. Agriculture and Trade Minister Todd McClay told Morning Report if a US-China deal has been done it would be "good news". At an OECD trade ministers meeting in Paris last week he had met with the trade ministers of both China and the US. Both had then gone off for joint talks so some momentum had been building to try and find a solution to their tariffs impasse. If things calmed down for international trade it would bring "welcome relief" for exporters and result in some "sensible decision-making". McClay said the remarkable growth in primary exports was very positive. Dairy had enjoyed a solid season with a good supply of grass which had increased milk production. The meat sector was performing well and for the first time $5 billion worth of kiwifruit had been exported. Even the US market faced with tariff uncertainty was providing some opportunities for Kiwi exporters, citing the example of NZ King Salmon which has talked of increased sales at a higher price. Kiwi exporters were working hard to add value to their products, McClay said. One example was selling ready to eat burger patties to China which resulted in greater returns for farmers. "So we're seeing Kiwi exporters go for value, not competing on price anywhere as much as they used to." Photo: RNZ / Richard Tindiller A government-backed grass certification standard for dairy and meat exports had been launched at Mystery Creek Fieldays yesterday, McClay said. This would be highly desirable for markets in China, other parts of Asia and the Middle East, McClay said. "Grass fed now is increasingly wanted by consumers and they're willing to pay more." On sustainable products, Groundswell has been calling for New Zealand to exit the Paris Agreement on Climate Change. McClay said that was not going to happen mainly because it would make exports to many markets untenable. He believed Groundswell and others were worried about higher costs and lower production if they adopted sustainable measures. "We've been really clear - we think through technology and other things we can meet these obligations without putting farmers out of business." Alternatives to farmers going into the Emissions Trading Scheme were being worked on and would be announced soon. McClay said the requirement of reducing methane by 10 percent by 2030 was on track to be met. "So it shows farmers are willing to do it but we have to lean heavily into technology rather than just planting trees." A number of products, known as methane inhibitors , have been developed already although they might have to overcome consumer resistance. McClay said anything developed would have to go through rigorous scientific testing. There would be a range of solutions developed and farmers would decide which ones they wanted to pick up. "The overseas customers through the dairy company should be paying for this, not the New Zealand farmer."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store