School wrongly suspended student ‘trying to do the right thing,' judge rules
The decision was issued Monday by District Court Judge Vivian Henderson after she heard testimony from the student's mother, as well as the former principal of St. John the Apostle Catholic School, and the superintendent of schools for the Diocese of Richmond, according to a transcript of the hearing.
'The unfortunate victim in this matter was (the boy who reported the incident),' Henderson said in announcing her decision. 'Because to see him punished as the person who was trying to do the right thing is appalling … Especially in an environment where students are forced, younger and younger kids are being forced, to make adult-like decisions, without clear boundaries or parameters.'
Rachel Wigand sued St. John's in September after her 11-year-old son was suspended for 1½ days. The lawsuit claimed the school breached its contract with the Wigand family by punishing the boy for something not in the student-parent handbook.
The handbook doesn't say anything about needing to immediately report incidents in which a student has ammunition, according to the complaint. The only thing it says must be immediately reported is allegations involving sexual harassment.
In an interview with The Virginian-Pilot last year, Wigand said her son waited a couple of hours to come forward because he wanted do it when the other boy wasn't around. She also said her son couldn't understand why he was punished, especially when it was the same disciplinary action received by the student who brought the bullet to school.
In her lawsuit, Wigand asked that she be reimbursed for the $4,780 in tuition she paid for her son for the first half of the school year. But on Monday, her attorney Tim Anderson told the judge she was only requesting $81, as well as attorney's fees and other costs. The $81 represents about how much a day and a half of tuition amounted to, Anderson said.
'This wasn't about the money,' the lawyer said. 'It was about much more than that. What we wanted was a clear ruling from the court that this was a suspension and that it was not allowed under the contract.'
St. John's officials repeatedly claimed the punishment was not a suspension, Anderson said, and that it was allowed under the rules.
The Catholic Diocese of Richmond issued a statement Tuesday in which it said it stood by the school's decision.
'At St. John the Apostle School, we are dedicated to maintaining a safe and focused learning environment for our students,' the statement said. 'While we disagree with the court's decision, we respect the legal process. Our focus continues to be providing enriching and Christ-centered learning experiences for our students, and we are hopeful this conclusion will bring all parties involved an opportunity to move forward.'
Wigand applauded the judge's decision Tuesday. While her children still attend St. John's, she's considering sending them elsewhere next year.
'I truly appreciated having an independent third party recognize that the school's decision was wrong,' she said. 'After seven months, it was a weight lifted off my back for just trying to do what was best and right for my child.'
Jane Harper, jane.harper@pilotonline.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Los Angeles Times
10 hours ago
- Los Angeles Times
Suspected Islamist rebels kill at least 30 in eastern Congo
KINSHASA, Congo — Suspected Islamist rebels have killed at least 30 people in a series of attacks in eastern Congo's North Kivu province in recent days, a Congolese military official said Saturday. The killings took place in Bapere village between Wednesday and Friday, according to Col. Alain Kiwawa, the military administrator of Lubero territory, where the village is located. 'We have more than 30 people dead, and at least a hundred who are being held hostage,' Kiwawa told the Associated Press. A civil society leader, Samuel Kaheni, the president of the Bapere civil society organization, said that several houses were burned and victims were mostly killed with knives. The attacks are the latest in a string of recent attacks by Islamic-State-aligned Allied Democratic Force after its members killed nearly 40 people last month in an attack on a Catholic church in Ituri. Most of the victims were killed with machetes. The ADF, with roots in neighboring Uganda, operates in the border villages between Uganda and Congo. The two countries have launched a joint armed operation against the group, but it has only increased its attacks in recent months. The incidence of ADF attacks adds to the complicated security challenges in the eastern region of the Democratic Republic of Congo, where dozens of other armed groups are fighting and the central government is battling the Rwanda-backed M23 rebels, which have taken control of Goma and other key cities. Lubero's military administrator called on the residents to be on guard against further violence. 'I ask the population to speak out and remain vigilant,' he said. Kamale writes for the Associated Press.
10 hours ago
Suspected Islamist rebels kill 30 in Congo's North Kivu province
KINSHASA, Congo -- Suspected Islamist rebels have killed at least 30 people in a series of attacks in Congo's North Kivu province in recent days, a Congolese military official said Saturday. The killings took place in Bapere village between Wednesday and Friday, according to Col. Alain Kiwawa, the military administrator of Lubero territory where the village is located. 'We have more than 30 people dead, and at least a hundred who are being held hostage,' Kiwawa told The Associated Press. A civil society leader, Samuel Kaheni, the president of the Bapere civil society organization, added that several houses were burned and victims were mostly killed with knives. The attacks are the latest in a string of recent attacks by Islamic State-aligned Allied Democratic Force (ADF) after its members killed nearly 40 people last month in an attack on a Catholic church in Ituri. Most of the victims were killed with machetes. The ADF, with roots in neighboring Uganda, operates in the border villages between Uganda and Congo. Both countries have launched a joint armed operation against the group, but the group has only increased its attacks in recent months. The incidence of ADF attacks adds to the complicated security challenges in the eastern region of Congo, where dozens of other armed groups are fighting, and the central government is battling the M23 rebels, which have taken control of Goma and other key cities. Lubero's military administrator called on the residents to be on guard against further violence.
The Hill
12 hours ago
- The Hill
Suspected Islamist rebels kill 30 in Congo's North Kivu province
KINSHASA, Congo (AP) — Suspected Islamist rebels have killed at least 30 people in a series of attacks in Congo's North Kivu province in recent days, a Congolese military official said Saturday. The killings took place in Bapere village between Wednesday and Friday, according to Col. Alain Kiwawa, the military administrator of Lubero territory where the village is located. 'We have more than 30 people dead, and at least a hundred who are being held hostage,' Kiwawa told The Associated Press. A civil society leader, Samuel Kaheni, the president of the Bapere civil society organization, added that several houses were burned and victims were mostly killed with knives. The attacks are the latest in a string of recent attacks by Islamic State-aligned Allied Democratic Force (ADF) after its members killed nearly 40 people last month in an attack on a Catholic church in Ituri. Most of the victims were killed with machetes. The ADF, with roots in neighboring Uganda, operates in the border villages between Uganda and Congo. Both countries have launched a joint armed operation against the group, but the group has only increased its attacks in recent months. The incidence of ADF attacks adds to the complicated security challenges in the eastern region of Congo, where dozens of other armed groups are fighting, and the central government is battling the M23 rebels, which have taken control of Goma and other key cities. Lubero's military administrator called on the residents to be on guard against further violence. 'I ask the population to speak out and remain vigilant,' he said.
