Who was the best 5-star quarterback of the 21st century: Tim Tebow or Vince Young?
Who was the best 5-star quarterback of the 21st century: Tim Tebow or Vince Young?
It is a well-known fact that the quarterback is the most important position in football, so it stands to reason that college football programs put a great deal of focus on the player they put under center. But there is only so much talent that can be distributed over the 100-plus schools in the Football Bowl Subdivision
Last month, the Athletic's Antonio Morales undertook the task of ranking every 5-star quarterback recruit of the past 25 years — a list that includes 61 total passers who earned the top rating. Among those mentioned was the Florida Gators' legendary two-time national champion Tim Tebow, who edged out Texas Longhorns stud Vince Young for the top spot in the rankings.
Two other players who passed through Gainesville were listed among the top 20 as well, while another pair landed in the middle of the pack.
No. 1 Tim Tebow (2006)
"Tebow was a key contributor during the Gators' national title run as a true freshman in 2006, won the Heisman in 2007, led Florida to a national championship in 2008 and finished in the top five of Heisman voting while leading the Gators to a 13-1 record and top-five finish in 2009. He accounted for 145 total touchdowns, passed for 9,285 yards and rushed for 2,947," Morales begins.
"That's the sort of career any fan base dreams of for a five-star quarterback."
No. 3 Cam Newton (2007)
"The 2010s were defined by super teams with elite rosters that won national championships, such as Alabama, Florida State, Ohio State and LSU. Auburn was an exception thanks to Newton, who blended skill, size, power and athleticism to post an all-time season in which he accounted for 51 touchdowns, won the Heisman and led the Tigers to a national title," Morales notes.
"One player can't carry a team to a national championship, but Newton came about as close as possible. He didn't have a single skill player drafted. Only tackles Brandon Mosley (fourth round) and Lee Ziemba (seventh round) were picked on the O-line. The entire starting defense had only two players drafted," he continues.
"Newton's 2010 campaign is the most impressive individual season from any player on this list."
No. 13 Chris Leak (2003)
"While those two reside among the top three in Morales' rankings, there is still another member of the Orange and Blue who was mentioned: Chris Leak," Morales declares.
"Leak was the No. 2 quarterback in his class and was a major recruiting win for Florida in 2003. Even though Tebow is remembered more, Leak was the primary quarterback on a team that won the national championship."
The Athletic's 5-star QB recruiting rankings top 20
Tim Tebow, Florida (2006) Vince Young, Texas (2002) Cam Newton, Florida (2007) Jameis Winston, Florida State (2012) Trevor Lawrence, Clemson (2018) Kyler Murray, Texas A&M (2015) Tua Tagovailoa, Alabama (2017) Bryce Young, Alabama (2020) Justin Fields, Georgia (2018) Caleb Williams, Oklahoma (2021) Bo Nix, Auburn (2019) J.J. McCarthy, Michigan (2021) Chris Leak, Florida (2003) Terrelle Pryor, Ohio State (2008) Tajh Boyd, Clemson (2009) Braxton Miller, Ohio State (2011) Chad Henne, Michigan (2004) Tyrod Taylor, Virginia Tech (2007) Aaron Murray, Georgia (2009) Matthew Stafford, Georgia (2006)
Other Florida 5-star recruits ranked
No. 38 Jeff Driskel (2011)
No. 40 John Brantley (2007)
Follow us @GatorsWire on X, formerly known as Twitter, as well as Bluesky, and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Florida Gators news, notes and opinions.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
21 minutes ago
- USA Today
ESPN ranks the top 25 college football plays since 2000: Which Alabama moments made list?
ESPN ranks the top 25 college football plays since 2000: Which Alabama moments made list? Over the past 25 college football seasons, the Alabama Crimson Tide have had no shortage of big moments on the national stage. That's what happens when you win six national championships in a span of 12 seasons, as Alabama did under coach Nick Saban from 2009-2020. The second closest to the Crimson Tide in hardware since the dawn of the 21st century: the LSU Tigers -- a program Saban helped build from a perennial underachiever -- and the Ohio State Buckeyes with three apiece. It's no surprise then that some of the biggest moments involving Alabama teams from Saban's 17 seasons in Tuscaloosa made their way onto ESPN's ranking of the top 25 college football plays since 2000. That includes both the joys from Alabama's victories as well as the anguish in their defeats. A total of five plays featuring Alabama football made ESPN's list. Here's a breakdown of Alabama's appearances in ESPN's top 25 college football plays from the first quarter of the 21st century. '2nd and 26': Tua Tagovailoa to DeVonta Smith touchdown ranked Alabama's best play Alabama has no shortage of thrilling moments that fans can describe in graphic detail from the snap of the ball until the final whistle, but ESPN ranked '2nd and 26' against Georgia in the College Football Playoff National Championship on Jan. 8, 2018 at No. 4 overall on its list. Tua Tagovailoa's dagger to DeVonta Smith in overtime gave Alabama a 26-23 win and its fifth championship in eight years. ESPN's Bill Connelly said of the play: "The national title game at the end of the 2017 season came at you in waves. Georgia dominated and led 13-0 at halftime. Alabama subbed in freshman Tua Tagovailoa and charged back to tie the score, but the Tide missed an easy field goal attempt at the buzzer. Georgia moved backward in OT but nailed a 51-yard field goal. Tagovailoa took an atrocious sack and lost 16 yards. Bama had control but lost it, and now Georgia was about to finally topple the Tide. "And then, without a timeout and with the building still buzzing, Tagovailoa calmly looked off the safeties, then fired back to a fellow freshman for the most thrilling, breathless ending to a national title game in the College Football Playoff era." 'Gravedigger': late Alabama touchdown to bury Auburn ranked top 20 college football play Speaking of clutch throws, few if any in the history of the Iron Bowl were as incredible as Jalen Milroe's game-winning pass to Isaiah Bond in the corner of the end-zone on Nov. 25, 2023 at Jordan-Hare Stadium. Alabama converted on 4th-and-goal from the 31-yard line with 32 seconds left for a 27-24 win, its fourth straight Iron Bowl victory. 'Gravedigger' was ranked No. 20 on ESPN's list, with Chris Low saying: "The legendary plays in the Iron Bowl are too many to count, but Jalen Milroe-to-Isaiah Bond on fourth-and-goal from the 31 ranks with any of them. Auburn, suffering through a losing season in Hugh Freeze's first year on the Plains, seemingly had the game won in what would have been a massive upset. With the Jordan-Hare Stadium crowd roaring, Alabama was pushed back to the 31 after initially having a first-and-goal from the 7. Only 43 seconds remained, and Auburn rushed just two defenders. Milroe stood in the pocket for five seconds before delivering a strike in the left corner of the end zone to a leaping Bond for the game-winning touchdown and a 27-24 win in what was Nick Saban's final Iron Bowl." Alabama anguish: three plays on ESPN list that cost Crimson Tide Not every big play in an Alabama game over the past 25 years has gone in the Crimson Tide's favor. Far from it, in fact. A total of three plays on ESPN's list came against Saban teams, including one that cost Alabama a national championship and another that denied them a chance to play for one. Topping ESPN's list was Auburn's 'Kick Six' from 2013. Chris Davis' 109-yard return for a touchdown was named the single best college football play of the past 25 years. Behind 'Kick Six' was Texas A&M star Johnny Manziel's first-quarter escape for a 10-yard touchdown pass to Ryan Swope against Alabama in November 2012. The play, in which Manziel ran into a defender, bobbled the ball, and then rolled out of the pocket for the touchdown was ranked No. 12 on ESPN's list. The Aggies held off a furious Alabama rally to escape with a 29-24 win. Directly behind Manziel's banner day in Tuscaloosa was the play that denied Alabama a chance at a second straight title. Hunter Renfrow's game-winning touchdown with one second left on the clock at Tampa's Raymond James Stadium in the 2017 College Football Playoff National Championship gave the Clemson Tigers a 35-31 win over Alabama. Renfrow's catch made ESPN's list of best plays at No. 13. Contact/Follow us @RollTideWire on X, and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Alabama news, notes and opinions.
Washington Post
38 minutes ago
- Washington Post
'A UFC fight': Tensions rise in Stanley Cup Final as the Panthers get the upper hand on the Oilers
FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. — Things got chippy in the Stanley Cup Final late in Game 3 when the Florida Panthers were well on their way to blowing out the Edmonton Oilers. Brawls ensued, Darnell Nurse and Jonah Gadjovich dropped the gloves, and eight guys got sent to the showers early with misconduct penalties.
Hamilton Spectator
43 minutes ago
- Hamilton Spectator
‘A UFC fight': Tensions rise in Stanley Cup Final as the Panthers get the upper hand on the Oilers
FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. (AP) — Things got chippy in the Stanley Cup Final late in Game 3 when the Florida Panthers were well on their way to blowing out the Edmonton Oilers. Brawls ensued, Darnell Nurse and Jonah Gadjovich dropped the gloves, and eight guys got sent to the showers early with misconduct penalties. 'When we get into garbage time, those things happen, and I don't mind when those things happen,' Oilers captain Connor McDavid said. 'It's what good teams do: fight your way out of the rink. I don't mind that in garbage time.' Long before garbage time, Florida took it to Edmonton, with the defending champions dictating their style of play and knocking their opponents off kilter to take a 2-1 series lead with a 6-1 laugher. If more of that continues in Game 4 on Thursday night, it's advantage Panthers because they thrive on making other teams feel uncomfortable. 'We played our game, our style, stuck up for each other when we needed to,' Panthers winger Matthew Tkachuk said. 'If you have to take a punch, take a punch. If you have to take a cross-check, take a cross-check — a spear, a slash, whatever the case is, you've got to take it.' It should not be surprising that tensions boiled over given the lopsided score in the 10th game in the Cup final between these two teams over the past year. The Oilers and Panthers have grown a healthy distaste for each other with all that familiarity. With that comes plenty of hits, shoves and jabs that lead to slashes, punches and gear strewn all over the ice. The 140 combined penalty minutes in Game 3 were the most in a final since Game 4 between Montreal and Calgary in 1986. 'The game's over with 11 minutes left,' Oilers star Leon Draisaitl said Tuesday after practice. 'Then all hell breaks loose. It's a UFC fight.' The penalties that mattered to the result came early. The Oilers were not shy about criticizing the officiating and the Panthers for allegedly influencing it. Goaltender Stuart Skinner said, 'Some guys are flaking and going down trying to cause penalties,' and Evander Kane questioned some of the calls. 'There seems to be a little bit more attention on our group,' said Kane, who took two minor penalties in the first period alone. 'They seem to get away with it more than we do. It's tough to find the line.' Toeing that line is what the Panthers do best, and it is a recipe that has them in the final for a third consecutive year under coach Paul Maurice , who credited Tkachuk for having 'a little bit more impact on the tenacity of the team than the guy who wears a suit behind the bench and never takes a shift.' Florida's roster is full of truculence with talent to match. Sam Bennett delivered a big, open-ice hit that led to his breakaway and playoff-leading 14th goal, and finishing checks on John Klingberg has hampered the veteran defenseman's play in the series compared to the first three rounds. 'That's part of their DNA, that's what they do,' Draisaitl said. 'It's an emotional time. It's two teams that want to win, two teams of doing it their own way, but I don't think anybody is going crazy here. They're good at what they do.' Maurice did not buy into the idea that Game 3 was the Panthers showing what they can do at their best. The opener went to overtime and Florida needed double OT to win Game 2 . 'I think the first two games are indicative of what Game 4 is going to look like,' Maurice said. 'We're not going to look at (Game 3) and say, 'That's the way it should look if we play our game.'' The Oilers certainly look at it as the opposite, discombobulated and nothing resembling the group that had gone 12-2 since a couple of losses to open the first round. They've dropped two in a row for the first time since. 'We just got to play our game,' Nurse said. 'We got guys that can do all that kind of stuff. But is that our game? So I think we just got to stick to play the way that we play. We're such a good hockey team when we just play hockey, and we just got to do that.' ___ AP NHL playoffs: and
