Former minister says WA government could easily enact shire takeover
The Shire of Coolgardie in WA's Goldfields is fighting for survival amid debts of more than $27.5 million and a government-led push to merge with its much larger neighbour, the City of Kalgoorlie-Boulder.
Representatives from both councils met this week in Perth with Local Government Minister Hannah Beazley, who also has her hands full with the troubled City of Nedlands.
The City of Kalgoorlie-Boulder is yet to publicly reveal if it is for or against the proposed tie-up, while the Shire of Coolgardie has threatened possible legal action.
"I would think, given their financial situation, they would have better things to spend their money on," Ms Beazley told reporters on Wednesday.
The government's language has carefully avoided the words merger or amalgamation, despite the end result being effectively the same, with the Shire of Coolgardie dissolved.
Ms Beazley said the process would include public consultation.
"They are two very different things; it's just because one entity is adjusting the boundaries, only affecting one other, so it is not affecting multiple local government areas."
Under WA's Local Government Act, a merger or amalgamation requires majority support from ratepayers in both local government areas.
But Mr Simpson said the boundary adjustment put forward for Coolgardie and Kalgoorlie-Boulder could be accomplished with the "stroke of a pen".
"In a merger, local government goes to the polls and if 50 per cent of a community turns up and says no, you've got yourself into a corner where you can't force it any further," he said.
Mr Simpson, who is a City of Karratha councillor, said he tried unsuccessfully during his time as minister to reduce the number of Perth councils from 30 to 15.
"I failed miserably, for a number of reasons," he said.
"Local governments put up a very good battle."
Mr Simpson said the combination of the Coolgardie and Kalgoorlie-Boulder councils would make the Goldfields region stronger.
"A larger local government has a stronger capacity to deliver more services and keep rates flowing. That is proven over and over, so I think it would be worthwhile," he said.
"If the debt is the only issue, we should put that aside in the business case and have a look at the strength of the two local governments coming together."
Former Kalgoorlie-Boulder mayor John Bowler, also a former local government minister in the Carpenter government, said there was little incentive for the larger city to take on Coolgardie.
Mr Bowler said the Shire of Coolgardie's plan to sell council-owned workers' accommodation should be allowed to play out to see if it could return debt to manageable levels.
"I don't think anything's going to happen while there's unrecovered debt," he said.
"Why should the ratepayers of Kalgoorlie-Boulder pay for the mistakes of Coolgardie?
"First of all, I think we have to let Coolgardie see how they go with the sale of that camp."
Mr Bowler said he was approached to play a role in the tie-up, but said he would not consider getting involved until the Shire of Coolgardie's debt was retired.
"The trouble is the size of Kalgoorlie-Boulder is about 10 times bigger and it really wouldn't be a joint, equal merger," he said.
A long-time resident of the tiny community of Widgiemooltha and former Coolgardie shire councillor, Jan McLeod, said any takeover by Kalgoorlie-Boulder would limit her community's voice.
"Any representation on council will be lost by sheer weight of numbers," she said.
"It's not good for local government, which is the government closest to the people."
Ms McLeod said there would be a loss of identity for residents.
"The City of Kalgoorlie-Boulder does not service any regional towns; there will be staffing issues," she said.
Ms Beazley denied there would be staffing issues.
"That's the solutions and options we're working through at the moment," she said.
"There would still need to be local services and a footprint in Coolgardie to ensure that community is well served."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Australian
16 hours ago
- The Australian
Save Our Songlines' Raelene Cooper warns UNESCO of government ‘manipulation' Burrup Peninsula Murujuga Aboriginal Corp
The Indigenous campaigner leading the fight against the North West Shelf LNG extension has cited Environment Minister Murray Watt's decision not to publicly release the proposed conditions for the contentious project in her submission to UNESCO. Save Our Songlines founder Raelene Cooper also used her submission to the international body – which will decide in the coming days whether to admit the rock art-rich Burrup Peninsula, or Murujuga, on Western Australia's northwest coast to the World Heritage List – to accuse the WA and federal governments of manipulating and misrepresenting scientific findings from a crucial research project. Federal and WA officials as well as representatives from Murujuga Aboriginal Corp are travelling to Paris this week in an attempt to overturn a draft recommendation against the World Heritage listing of Murujuga, which is home to more than one million ancient rock carvings. The draft finding recommending deferring the listing until the heavy industry on the surrounding Burrup Peninsula, including some of Australia's largest industrial projects, was curtailed. Ms Cooper and a number of her supporters have also travelled to Paris for the meeting, with Save Our Songlines having prepared a submission for the UNESCO panel to consider. A statement prepared in recent days by Ms Cooper for UNESCO reinforces her support for the World Heritage nomination and the proposed conditions in the draft decision handed to the body by the International Council on Monuments and Sites earlier this year. That draft decision recommended referring the World Heritage application back to Australia to allow it to 'prevent any further industrial development adjacent to, and within, the Murujuga Cultural Landscape' and 'develop an appropriate decommissioning and rehabilitation plan for existing industrial activities'. At the time of the draft decision, Senator Watt criticised what he said were the 'factual inaccuracies' that had influenced the findings. Just days later, he gave conditional approval to Woodside's plans to extend the operating life of the North West Shelf out to 2070. Ms Cooper told UNESCO that the senator's decision was an example of the Australian government taking action that was contrary to the recommendations presented to UNESCO, with the decision to keep the proposed conditions from the public exacerbating the issue. 'Save our Songlines is currently unable to provide detailed comment on the adequacy of any conditions that may be attached to this approval, because the minister has refused to release the proposed conditions, and they are subject to ongoing negotiation with the proponent (Woodside Energy),' Ms Cooper wrote. 'However, Save our Songlines believes any ongoing operations of the NWS facility are likely to result in unacceptable ongoing impacts to the heritage values of Murujuga, and are contrary to the ICOMOS recommendations for decommissioning and rehabilitation of industrial development at Murujuga.' While the attempts by the state and federal governments and MAC to salvage the listing will likely centre on presenting the recent findings of a rock art monitoring program, Ms Cooper told UNESCO she questioned the validity of that research. 'Save our Songlines is further concerned that the Australian commonwealth government and West Australian state governments have engaged in manipulation and misrepresentation of scientific research in making the claim that pollution from LNG processing does not put the heritage values at risk,' she wrote. 'Save our Songlines believes this is the latest episode in an ongoing effort by the state party to enable industrial developments which are causing, and will continue to cause, profound and ongoing threats to Murujuga.' Ms Cooper is a former chair of MAC but quit the organisation's board after she established Save Our Songlines. Current MAC chair Peter Hicks has been highly critical of attempts to disrupt the listing process, warning that environmental groups had hijacked the process for their own agendas. Mr Hicks will be joined at UNESCO by WA Environment Minister Matthew Swinbourn and the lead scientist from the rock art monitoring program, Ben Mullins. Mr Swinbourn said he was travelling to Paris to stand alongside Murujuga's traditional owners as they seek to have the area's outstanding cultural and historical values recognised. 'The scientific evidence shows that industry and cultural heritage can coexist when properly managed, and that current industrial activity is not damaging the rock art. 'Ongoing monitoring, undertaken in partnership between the WA government and MAC, will continue safeguarding this irreplaceable cultural heritage,' he said. 'World Heritage listing will further help protect the ancient rock art and cultural landscapes of Murujuga for generations to come. 'This is about ensuring the unique stories and significance of Murujuga are recognised and celebrated by the international community.' Paul Garvey Senior Reporter Paul Garvey is an award-winning journalist with more than two decades' experience in newsrooms around Australia and the world. He is currently the senior reporter in The Australian's WA bureau, covering politics, courts, billionaires and everything in between. He has previously written for The Wall Street Journal in New York, The Australian Financial Review in Melbourne, and for The Australian from Hong Kong before returning to his native Perth. He was the WA Journalist of the Year in 2024 and is a two-time winner of The Beck Prize for political journalism. Nation Zempilas noted Peter Dutton's emphatic defeat in explaining why the WA parliamentary party would not be adopting the positions Indigenous An academic who said 'Blak activists' were turning Melbourne University into 'an ideological re-education camp' has been mocked for using anti-discrimination laws in a bid to save his job.
ABC News
a day ago
- ABC News
Glenorchy dubbed the 'slot machine capital' of Tasmania as mayor calls for gambling reform
Sue Hickey We have what is colloquially known as the 'Golden Mile' and certainly two former mayors were strong advocates for dealing at the state government level with this issue. And we do have a statement of commitment on gambling, which only gives us the authority to advocate or partner and engage with our community organisations and service providers, because as a local government, we literally do not have any power to police any of this. Kylie Baxter Do you think that a pre-commitment card would be an effective way to address the harm in your town, mayor? Sue Hickey Well, I really like the suggestions put forward by Tim Costello. He's obviously all across this and I don't care what form of harm removal or harm measures that they use, whether it's cashless gaming, $1 bets, slower spin speeds, pre-commitment technology, something has to be done about it because, I think, we as a nation and as a state have to ask ourselves, what is the social and economic cost of not dealing with this issue? I personally know of the destruction of gambling to a friend of mine's life and livelihood and then the breakdown of the family and just horrendous outcomes from that. But over my life in politics, I've come across so many people who have been broken by their gaming addiction. So we need the government, whoever this is going to be, to invest in harm minimisation, urgently. And we've got to stop doing the talking, and we've got to do some action. Kylie Baxter The data tells us there are 240 pokey machines in Glenorchy. Would you like to see a reduction also in the number of machines available for use? Sue Hickey Absolutely. That's from a personal perspective. Obviously, other people would have different perspectives. If I had my way, there'd probably be none. But, you know, there are lots of people who can gamble safely. You know, Nana who goes there and spends $5 or $10 on a Sunday with her friends, obviously can handle it. But there are other people who might be in a pit in their lives of some sort, and it suddenly becomes an escape. And then next thing you know, it's an addiction, and then it's a tragedy. So this is where I think there needs to be some controls around the electronic gaming machines.
ABC News
a day ago
- ABC News
Liberal Party's climate policy a huge headache for state and federal leaders
Political parties are funny beasts, as the Liberals were reminded on the weekend. To win elections they need to appeal to broad sections of the community, many of whom only have a passing interest in politics once every few years. Former Liberal Prime Minister John Howard famously referred to the party as a "broad church" for voters. And yet the heart of the parties — the kind of people who, for example, show up to Saturday morning meetings years out from an election — are not always representative of broader society. Both Labor and the Liberals can struggle at times because it is those very people who help shape policies — and more importantly, party brands in the eyes of ordinary voters. It can create headaches when, for example, that core group votes to abandon a commitment to net-zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050, continuing a debate which has dogged the party for years, as the WA Liberals' State Council did on Saturday. The group also voted to remove the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Island flags behind the prime minister at press conferences and cut back on Welcome to Country ceremonies. The net zero issue has dogged the Liberals for years, with federal leader Sussan Ley setting up a working group to review the party's policy after its federal election drubbing. But the WA Liberals' State Council was not waiting for that review, nor was one of its most prominent voices who supported the motion. "We're part of a process," frontbencher Andrew Hastie, acknowledged on Saturday. "But I think it's pretty clear the South Australian division, the WA division, the Northern Territory division have adopted this position. "We'll see how the LNP goes in future weeks." The debate is shaping up as a thorny issue for Ley, who faces not only division between the party's membership and its elected members, but among its own MPs. In a sign of just how thorny the issue is, WA Leader Basil Zempilas had to spend part of his Monday morning defending his different position after attending the council meeting, but leaving before votes were taken. "The WA Parliamentary Liberal Party supports the status quo," he told reporters. "We are very comfortable with standing in front of the Aboriginal flag, we are very comfortable with the Welcome to Country and we support the status quo on the net zero targets." Party members who spoke to the ABC on the condition of anonymity to speak freely pointed out there was not necessarily anything unusual with that position. The views of the lay party — ordinary members who voted on Saturday — are not binding on elected MPs, who have the final say on the party's policies. Lay party motions are just one viewpoint to consider, they said. Also, they added, the motions were focused on the federal party, not the state. Which is all well and good, and gives Zempilas the ability to freely offer his own position without creating an even bigger storm. But it does little to solve the Liberals' key problem: the effect this splintering can have on public perception at both state and federal levels. Because the potential cost of this position is making it harder to win back the very voters who have deserted the party in recent years. At a state level, the party had bled voters to a more centrist Labor Party for a range of reasons, including it would seem the Liberals' drift further to the right on some issues. Federally, the cost has been even more clearly seen in seats taken by teal independents. The seat of Curtin, taking in Perth's leafy Western suburbs, had been as Liberal as they come until independent Kate Chaney swung the electorate in 2019 with a campaign heavily focused on climate. "I got the biggest swing in WA, five-and-a-half per cent. Pretty sure I got a strong endorsement," was Hastie's alternative view. For some though, there is also a view this issue is about more than just net zero, but ultimately the leadership of the party. While far from a universal view, there is little doubt having such a public show of disunity so early into Ley's leadership will only work against her prospects of staying in the job long-term. Hastie had been touted as a possible leadership contender after the May federal election, but bowed out early before Ley was installed. "I'd be foolish to say I don't have a desire to lead, I do have a desire to lead," he told the Curtin's Cast podcast at the time. "But the timing was all out for personal reasons." Politics is a game where little is done without an eye to the future prospects of each decision. Hastie, and others, clearly see some benefit in creating a clear point of difference with Labor over future climate policy. The question voters will decide in a few years' time is whether that is of benefit only among the party's core base, or helps win over electors more widely.
