'Murderers must reveal where bodies are hidden to get parole' says ex-top cop
The ex-police chief who brought serial killer Peter Tobin to justice says murderers who do not reveal locations of victims' bodies should never be released.
David Swindle tells our Criminal Record podcast that he backs a Suzanne's Law where the killer must disclose their victim's whereabouts if they are to be considered for parole.
The Scottish Government has included a proposal for a Suzanne's Law in the Witnesses, and Justice Reform (Scotland) Bill which is going through parliament.
Suzanne's Law is named after office worker Suzanne Pilley, who was murdered by colleague and ex David Gilroy in 2010.
He was sentenced to life in 2012 but has never revealed what he did with her body, which is believed to be buried in Argyll.
Other high-profile cases include Arlene Fraser, Margaret Fleming and Lynda Spence. Swindle, who probed more than 100 murders in a 34-year police career, said: 'We need to have something like a Suzanne's Law to stop people getting out if they don't reveal what they did with the body.
'With Suzanne Pilley her body has never been found and there is a person convicted of that, the same as Arlene Fraser, Margaret Fleming and Lynda Spence.
'These people have never revealed what they did with the bodies. If they don't reveal what they did they should not then be eligible for parole. If your loved one is murdered by someone who is in prison and has never revealed what they did with the body, you would not want them to get out.'
Swindle, who retired in 2011, says a murder without a body leaves victims' families in limbo.
He added: 'People think by destroying the body that there is no evidence but you will still be caught.'
England and Wales already have a similar measure – Helen's Law.
Suzanne's dad Rob died in 2019 without knowing where she was buried. Detectives believe Gilroy killed her in the building where they worked in Edinburgh after he confronted her over ending their affair.
Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community!
Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today.
You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland.
No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team.
All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in!
If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'.
We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like.
To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
Arlene, from Elgin, Moray, vanished from her home in 1998 after her c hildren went to school.
Her husband Nat Fraser, who is serving life for her murder, has refused to say what became of his wife.
Avril Jones and Edward Cairney were jailed for life in 2019 for killing Margaret, 19, at their home in Inverkip. They refused to say where they put her.
Financial adviser Lynda was abducted, tortured and killed in 2011. Colin Coats and Philip Wade were convicted of killing the 27-year-old Glaswegian in 2013. Her body has never been found
Swindle led the probe into Tobin's murder of Polish student Angelika Kluk in Glasgow in 2006 for which he got life.
He set up Operation Anagram which led to Tobin being convicted of the murders of Vicky Hamilton, 15, and Dinah McNicol, 18.
A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'The Justice Secretary supported an amendment at Stage 2 in May which requires the Parole Board to take account of whether the prisoner has information about the disposal of the victim's remains but has not disclosed it.
'If the Bill is passed then this will become law.'
To watch the podcast, head over to our YouTube channel by clicking here.
You can also subscribe to listen to this podcast on Spotify or Apple Podcasts by searching for 'Criminal Record' .
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
21 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Vladimir Putin's dad 'gouged out his mum's eye in anger-fuelled attack'
The horror incident was detailed in a new book about the Russian president's life. Vladimir Putin's father gouged out one of his mother's eye with a pitchfork when she was only 17, a bombshell new book has revealed. The alleged incident led to the Russian president's mother Maria losing the eye, and his father Volodka being forced into marriage. The strange story has been recounted in a new book, The Tsar in Person: How Vladimir Putin Fooled Us All, which goes back to his early years and life before he took charge in Moscow. It also claims the attack was a result of a "fit of rage" from his father, who is said to have come to Maria's - known as Marusya - home with male friends while she was on her own in her village in 1928, the Mirror reports. Villager Anfisa Kormilitsyna recalled: "Marusya didn't want to let them in." Anfisa added that Maria's reaction appeared to anger Volodka. She continued: "They took the pitchfork that was standing by the fence and started breaking down the gate. She got scared, ran out of the house, and raced up to the fence. "And Volodka [Vladimir senior, Putin's father] at that moment broke through the gate with the pitchfork and hit Marusya right in the face. "In short, he accidentally gouged out her eye. He took her to the hospital right away. There, Marusya's eye was removed." She continued: "So Marusya's mother threatened Volodka: if you don't marry, I'll put you on trial. So they got married. Marusya was very embarrassed about her glass eye later, never looked you in the face when talking, and tilted her head to the side." Anfisa added Putin's father had a reputation for terrorising teenage girls: "He liked to lift up girls' skirts and tie them in a knot over their heads. Co-author Roman Badanin said this was so the village boys could get a better look at the girl's knickers." Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. Independent Russian news outlet Proekt reported: "Putin's mother had been one-eyed since her youth because the other eye had been put out with a pitchfork in a fit of rage by the father of the future Russian leader." Despite the grim story, Putin has only ever referred to his parents as perfect. His mother was in her 40s when he was born, resulting in rumours he had been adopted or was the child of a lover. He said last year: "Never - I want to emphasise this - never did I see my father drunk. That never happened at all. I'm not even talking about my mother. I never heard a single swear word from him. Not one. Well, I'm not even talking about my mother here either." The book's authors accused the despot of covering up his personal life.
Edinburgh Live
21 minutes ago
- Edinburgh Live
Gangster Ross McGill's promising athletic past long before Edinburgh gang wars
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info Gangster Ross McGill is now known to many as the Dubai-based crime lord Mr Big, but things could've turned out very differently. He first came to public attention as a promising young athlete, and began collecting sprinting medals at 15-years-old. In 2010, he claimed a bronze in the under 17's 60 metre race at Kelvin Hall in Glasgow. The following year, he came first in the New Years Day meeting in Musselburgh - winning the 60m handicap race. The following month in the under 20s men's event he smashed the club's 60 metre record beating the best in Scotland in the process, reports the Daily Record. By this time he had been called into a training group for the Scottish Athletics team coached by Olympian Brian Whittle, now Tory MSP. He was picked to represent his country in the Celtic games in Antrim in Northern Ireland in August 2011 and came second in the 100 metres. McGill also set a highly impressive personal best time of just over 11 seconds. But it was his one and only appearance. Despite the prospect of a promising and lucrative athletics career he seemed to disappear off the radar. But McGill was embarking on another race - to the top of the criminal ladder. While he enjoyed some success as a runner he obviously believed that greater success, power and riches were to be found elsewhere. At the age of 14 in 2008 the keen Rangers fan had joined the Union Bears, an emerging Rangers fans ultra group. By 2021 he was its leader or Capo with access all areas at Ibrox and had been photographed with Rangers captain James Tavernier and then manager Steven Gerard. Nobody at Ibrox suspected there was anything wrong with this outwardly pleasant and articulate individual. In September that year he unexpectedly resigned his position as leader and appeared to have disappeared off the radar for a second time. However he was about to go down a third route that would bring him even great notoriety. In early March this year a series of attacks on members and associates of the Daniel crime family both in Edinburgh and Glasgow began, which to this day has resulted in more than 50 police arrests. The attacks would continue into June and involved daytime assaults with machetes and firebombings of people's homes and commercial property. Sign up for Edinburgh Live newsletters for more headlines straight to your inbox At that time the Daniel's had been in a long running feud with another Glasgow crime family the Lyons. It appeared that associates of Edinburgh cocaine baron Mark Richardson - a Daniel ally - had in turn duped a Lyons associate by paying for a £500,000 drugs deal with fake notes. It had echoes of a previous incident almost 25 years ago. In this instance the Lyons were alleged to have stolen £20,000 worth of coke from a Daniel safe house in Milton, Glasgow. The man said to be orchestrating the violence was none other than Ross McGill, now holed up in Dubai and the alleged victim of the fake cash scam. A group of highly motivated young men going under the name Tamo Junto were carrying out the attacks in Scotland, allegedly under under McGill's orders, posting videos of the violence including burning properties. The footage also carried warnings of further attacks against the Daniel's and their associates. The Richardson crew had made the mistake of thinking he was a nobody and easy prey - but nothing could have been further from the truth. In reality the 31 year old he had been on a police watch list for several years over claims he was involved in drug dealing and serious and organised crime. As a result he he fled the UK fearing he would be arrested after French cops cracked an encrypted criminals phone network EncroChat. That had been the means by which gangs across the world could previously contact each other, do business, and leave messages without being caught. Now Police Scotland had a haul of incriminating information that was already bringing down a large number of organised crime groups. McGill, who was known by the nickname Miami, had initially fled to Malaga in Spain before moving to Dubai where he resurfaced as an aspiring crimelord. To this day it is not clear how McGill made the transformation from promising athlete, to fans leader to international crime figure. It was however clear he had made contacts with some of Scotland's most powerful underworld figures but how? One suggestion is that he developed links with key figures following Rangers - both at home and abroad - providing an excellent cover for any clandestine meetings. It's also been claimed McGill was introduced to the highest levels of criminal networks by by another Glasgow organised crime figure 47 year old James White - known as the Don. He had previously been the right hand man of two drug dealing brothers James and Barry Gillespie from Rutherglen near Glasgow. The Gillespie's had been exposed for the first time in 2019 by our sister paper the Sunday Mail as Scotland's two most powerful crime figures. By then they had relocated to the town of Fortaleza in Brazil with White but went missing around 2019 and are now thought to have been murdered. White was extradited back to Scotland in 2022 from Brazil to stand trial at the High Court in Glasgow where he was sentenced in 2023 to nine years and ten months for his involvement in serious and organised crime. McGill is also a close pal of ex-Union Bears Lloyd Cross, 33, now serving a six year prison stretch for his role in a £100million racket smuggling cocaine in banana boxes. The man said to have masterminded that particular operation was gangland Mr Big Jamie 'Iceman' Stevenson who is serving a sentence of 16 years and three months for his role. It's also been claimed that McGill's rise rapid rise has been boosted by support from gang chiefs Steven Lyons, 44, and the late Ross Monaghan, 43, who was shot dead at his bar in Fuengirola in Spain along with close friend and associate Eddie Lyons jnr in May. Join Edinburgh Live's Whatsapp Community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages With White and others in prison and the Gillespies missing presumed dead, it's been claimed that Ross McGill now oversees drug routes from South America previously established by others. In turn fast-tracking his rise to the top of the criminal tree. However people we have spoken to suggest that McGill like other criminals before him is merely filling the vacuum that normally opens when major crime figures are behind bars. In a recent interview for Criminal Record Graeme Pearson, former Director General of the Scottish Crime and Drug Enforcement said: "You have the new first division coming through who are saying these old guys are in the jail, we don't need to bother with them, we'll do our own thing and that creates the violence we now witness." One source said: "People think he must be backed by someone bigger, but McGill is very much his own man and used to running his own organisation. "The Union Bears is a good example of that." As things stand at present McGill appears to be stuck in Dubai as he faces arrest if he returns to the UK. At present there is no extradition treaty between the UK and the United Arab Emirates (UAE) but that could change in the future. There have been suggestions that McGill - and other Scottish underworld figures based there - could try to get UAE citizenship to avoid being sent back to Britain. One police source told the Daily Record: "At the end of the day McGill can run but he can't hide. "But you have to remember that McGill used to be good at running."
Daily Record
3 hours ago
- Daily Record
Intervention has reopened wounds in Scottish politics
Record View says there will be some in the SNP who will be quietly hoping the hype around Sturgeon's book dies down quickly. It's been almost a year since Alex Salmond 's death but the former first minister 's legacy continues to be a contentious topic. Nicola Sturgeon never reconciled with her political mentor after he was arrested and charged with multiple counts of sexual assault in 2020. Salmond was ultimately cleared in court but he never forgave those in his former party that he viewed as betraying him. His allies believe there was a conspiracy against him and have vowed to continue fighting to clear his name. So it's in that context that Sturgeon has published her long-awaited political memoir this week. Extracts published over the weekend have seen the former first minister try to claim that it was Salmond who leaked details to the press of a Scottish Government investigation into his behaviour. That's prompted a furious backlash from Salmond's allies, who firmly believe the leak came from Sturgeon's camp. Regardless of who is right, the squabble is unedifying and does not reflect well on Scottish politics. There will be some in the SNP who will be quietly hoping the hype around Sturgeon's book dies down quickly. With the party desperate to hold on to power at next year's Holyrood election, the last thing it needs is to get bogged down in another row over its two most famous former leaders. John Swinney has a big enough job on his hands without the public being reminded of how divided some of his former colleagues are. It's in everyone's interest that this row is put to bed once and for all. Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. Each penny counts It's outrageous that a firm at the centre of a £6million NHS corruption scandal was still carrying out work for one health board three years after they were first charged. NHS Lothian carried on using the services of Oricom until March last year. It comes after four men were jailed for a total of 29 years in June following a major investigation into the award of lucrative NHS contracts to the Ayrshire-based telecommunications firm. At a time when the health service is under pressure like never before, bosses should be double-checking where each and every penny is being spent. Taxpayers' cash certainly should not be handed over to a firm where employees were fleecing the health service. Contracts with Oricom should have been ripped up as soon as there was any suspicion over its activities. Bosses at NHS Lothian must answer as to why this situation was allowed to continue.
