Oscars are over, 'out of touch with the audience' and saddled with DEI requirements: expert
The 97th Oscars will be awarded on Sunday, but the road to the golden statue has been a bumpy one, marked with controversies and a lack of breakout frontrunners to draw audiences' attention.
"I feel really underwhelmed by this year's nominations, wins at other award shows (such as the Golden Globes) and predicted wins at the Oscars," a Reddit user said on a forum dedicated to the Oscars.
Another agreed, writing, "I'm just not all that excited about most of the films this year. Bit of a meh year especially after last year. And the constant drama this season has been annoying, I don't care about that."
"So many Oscar voters have told me the Oscars jumped the shark. They feel this is the end of Oscars in some ways," Fox News' contributor and host of the "Arroyo Grande" podcast Raymond Arroyo told Fox News Digital.
"I think most people haven't seen any of these movies to be excited about them," he continued, citing films like "Emilia Perez," "Anora," and "The Brutalist" as some of the contenders bringing in awards at other shows this season that haven't drawn the kind of excitement from regular viewers.
"'Wicked's' really the only movie that's been a box office success that's nominated for best picture. All these other films, they're small arthouse movies at best," Arroyo said.
Per BoxOfficeMojo, only two of the best picture nominees, "Wicked" and "Dune: Part Two," cracked the top ten in ticket sales last year.
"Inside Out 2," and "Deadpool & Wolverine" took the top two spots, with a raft of franchise sequels rounding out the top ten, like "Moana 2," "Beetlejuice Beetlejuice," and "Twisters."
"They are not taking into account popular tastes when making these choices," Arroyo explained of the nominees. "And you have a group of people acting in isolation from their audience, which is a huge problem. When you claim to speak as the cultural mouthpiece and center of the country, it's a huge problem. And I think many people in Hollywood are acknowledging it and realize maybe they're out of touch, and maybe the Oscars aren't what they used to be."
"If they were in touch with the average moviegoer, you would have seen 'Deadpool [& Wolverine]' nominated. They didn't go for that."
"So many Oscar voters have told me the Oscars jumped the shark. They feel this is the end of Oscar in some ways.'
Arroyo has also spoken with several Oscar voters, some of whom are Oscar winners themselves, who appear to share audiences' lack of enthusiasm for some of the nominees.
"One said, 'I'm not even voting. The Oscars is over.' And the other said, 'It just doesn't mean what it used to.'"
He continued, "They're reflecting an industry that's being, it's been so shattered. You know, it's sort of what happened to us in television. You went from three channels to a cable universe. Now it's the wild west of the internet and every streaming show you're competing with. The world is changing, and it's changed a lot for people in the film industry. These streamers are taking over. But the collective audience doesn't necessarily gather around it. So, we're in a new day. And film is no longer the defining touchstone of the culture that it once was. And that's what I got from these voters, an acknowledgment that the ground has shifted, and maybe it's time for [the Oscars] to shift with it."
WATCH: OSCARS 'AREN'T WHAT THEY USED TO BE' BECAUSE THEY'RE OUT OF TOUCH WITH AUDIENCES: EXPERT
One of the suggestions from his conversations was to allow for an audience award to vote on their favorite movie "so that you'd get more popular films in the mix."
Arroyo also mentioned a possible hurdle for some productions to be considered is meeting The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences' "representation and inclusion standards."
Instituted in 2024 for the 96th annual ceremony, AMPAS now requires films in consideration for best picture to meet two out of four possible categories worth of criteria, focused on underrepresented groups, including women, racial or ethnic groups, LGBTQ+, or people with disabilities.
The representation can come onscreen through casting and storytelling, creative leadership behind the scenes like directors, cinematographers, makeup artists and more, internship and training opportunities for underrepresented groups, or representation in the marketing, publicity and distribution of the film.
"One of these Oscar winners pointed out to me, he said, 'You know, my film probably wouldn't qualify for an Oscar now because there's so many boxes you have to check,' many of them DEI-related,'" Arroyo said.
WATCH: OSCARS' DIVERSITY RULES MAY BE 'DISQUALIFYING' POPULAR OPTIONS BECAUSE OF DIVERSITY RULES
He continued, "You have to have so many nontraditional casting here and so many non-White people working on this part of the film. So it's an interesting thing that we're seeing that I think is disqualifying to a lot of films that we'll never hear of at the Oscars, because they just couldn't check those boxes. They didn't have the creative staff or the casting that could accommodate them."
Another factor that may shake up the Oscars and its future is the ratings from Sunday's ceremony, hosted by Conan O'Brien.
Last year's ceremony, which started an hour earlier than usual, drew 19.5 million viewers in the 18-49 adult demographic, up 4% from 2023, per Variety. The outlet also reported that it was the third consecutive year of viewer growth since 2021, and the most watched since 2020.
Of the ratings, Arroyo said, "They'll bump up and down, depending if there's a big movie that year. But this year you get the feeling, aside from 'Wicked,' there was really nothing that captured the zeitgeist or that people were really inspired by or moved by or even went in droves to."
"I'm not sure if it has that same power any longer, given the rules, given the times, and given the isolation that the Academy works in," added.
"Assuming everything that we are accessing in our daily lives. I mean, there's some great television that rivals, you know, the best films that they're nominating this year, and there's great television shows out there. So the creatives have moved on, and maybe the Oscars need to broaden what they're doing and make it a little more democratic and allow the audience a voice."
Fox News Digital has reached out to a rep for the Academy for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
16 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Bride Feels 'Disrespected' After Family Members Brought Fast Food to Her 'Elegant' Catered Wedding
A bride shared on Reddit that she and the groom planned an "elegant brunch reception" at a venue owned by a "renowned" chef to celebrate their wedding reception She said her uncle's family, seemingly not enticed by the catered spread, snuck in fried chicken from a fast food restaurant and ate it "openly" at one of the reception tables "I'm struggling with feeling like I was disrespected on a day that we put so much time, money, energy and thought into planning," the bride wroteA bride says she and the groom booked a venue owned by a "renowned" chef to host an "elegant brunch reception" to celebrate their wedding — only to have some of her family members sneak in their own fast food to eat. She shared her story in a post on Reddit's "Wedding Planning" forum, beginning by detailing how the couple "meticulously" planned "every single aspect" of their big day, including curating a brunch spread. "We hand-selected our menu items months in advance, including shrimp and grits, quiche, a biscuit bar with assorted jellies, sausage, and bacon, chicken and waffles, and much, much more," the bride wrote, noting that it cost "about $98 per person." While the couple was excited to treat their guests to an unforgettable meal, the bride's uncle and his family had other ideas. The family stopped at a fast-food restaurant on the way to the reception to get fried chicken to eat in the car. While she had no issue with this, it was what happened next that left her fuming. When the family arrived at the reception, her uncle's wife "took a look at all the food we had meticulously chosen to serve, and exited to the parking lot to retrieve the leftover fast food." According to the bride, the family then proceeded to eat the fried chicken "openly at one of our decorated round tables." "What makes it worse is they not only took pictures of themselves eating the fast food at the table (with the brand packaging all out in the open), but they have now posted those pictures on Facebook on two separate occasions," she noted. "The latest post was a Father's Day post, and one of our other family members made a comment, something to the effect of 'nothing classier than bringing (fast food) to a catered wedding!' And they LAUGHED at it!!!! Like it's a big joke," she continued. The bride said she and her mom were "hurt" by their family members' behavior — and she can't seem to get past it. "I'm struggling with feeling like I was disrespected on a day that we put so much time, money, energy and thought into planning, and every time they post about it just digs the knife in deeper," she explained. She concluded her post by asking fellow Reddit users whether she is overreacting or justified in being upset. In the comments section, many readers agreed with the bride that her family members were "rude" to bring fast food into the reception. But they also encouraged her to let it go and not allow the incident spoil the memories of her special day. "I wouldn't waste energy on it anymore. They were embarrassing themselves, and that menu sounds very agreeable so everyone else probably loved it," one person wrote. Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. Another said: "You have every right to be upset, your feelings are completely valid. But unfortunately, what's done is done. So, let yourself vent, process it, and then try to move forward. Don't let their lack of decency linger in your mind longer than it deserves to." Some commenters even suggested that this will be something the couple will be able to laugh about one day and treat as a funny wedding anecdote. "Someday you and hubby will laugh about this together... and that day might come sooner than you think," one person wrote, adding, "Your wedding sounded absolutely gorgeous. Try to focus on the other 99% that was perfect, to help you move past this small blip." Read the original article on People
Yahoo
27 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Teachers Are Sharing The "Horrifying" Things They've Noticed With Gen Alpha Students, And My Jaw Is On The Floor
Being a teacher can be a tough job as is, but when you add in the nonchalant attitudes of some parents, some students using AI, and issues caused by some students who can't detach themselves from social media, it becomes, well, tougher. Recently, Redditor u/MineTech5000 asked the teachers of the Reddit community to share their Gen Alpha student horror stories, and ohhhh boy: 1."A high school student asked me what it means to 'put it in his own words' instead of copying and pasting." —Outrageous_Owl_9315 2."I left teaching in 2023. I taught an earth science class with mostly sophomores. One of the questions on a test about plate tectonics said, 'What do Chile, California, Alaska, and Japan have in common?' I was looking for anything related to the Ring of Fire — or anything mentioning that those places are on a fault line or get earthquakes. Well, one student answered, 'They're all in America.'" —Kairos385 3."We had a kid who didn't know that deserts are dry. Also, hardly any of my students know the difference between vowels and consonants." —flowerodell 4."I asked an undergraduate student for their opinion on a text, and they pulled out their phone, typed my question into ChatGPT, and then read aloud the answer it gave." —Asleep_Breadfruit_18 5."I'm currently studying to be a teacher. In one of my in-school placements, I had students come up to me and ask what time it was. I would always look at the clock on the wall (that they had a clear view of ) and tell them the none of the kids knew how to read a clock. I even explained how to read it, but they looked at me like I had two heads." —spookkish 6."This didn't happen in my class, but I was at a coffee shop, and two young girls didn't recognize a quarter. One asked the other, 'Is this a nickel? Wait, is a nickel only five cents?'" —missesrobinson 7."I've taught high school for the last nine years. The scariest thing for me is that they can't THINK. Problem-solving, troubleshooting, reasoning, etc. — there are so many kids who have little processing power, and it seems to be getting rapidly worse in the last couple of years. I think it's TikTok. Kids these days don't even have time to think about the bite-sized piece of media they just consumed before the next one is up." —UniqueUsername82D 8."Elementary PE teacher here. The number of children who bite when angry is terrifying. I have several who will chase a kid down after they've been wronged, grab their arm, and bite them like a dog. So far, they're all under seven, but I'm up to four in different classes. It's a specific problem, but I'll add that, in general, we are doomed." —krazycatlady21 9."I work for a school transportation department, and when I'm not in the office, I'm a 'permanent substitute' who fills in for absent bus drivers. Each bus is parked in the same 'lane' at the school every single day, regardless of who's driving. Most students walk up to the bus, and if they see it isn't their regular driver, they'll look around in horror and start aimlessly wandering around. I tell them every time that their bus will always be in the same lane, yet some kids will wander around every time. It also doesn't help that many of them don't know their address, either. High school is the worst. I've done this for 11 years, and it gets worse every single year. Mind you, I drive for some of the top academic schools in the state." —oldatheart515 10."I've spent almost a decade in education now. These kids have zero attention span — absolutely none. They need constant stimulation, nonstop engagement, and distraction after distraction shaped by far too much access to social media. It's both sad and frightening." —CranberryBauce 11."I had a pre-K student whose speech was unintelligible. He could not communicate. I told his mom he needed to be tested for speech therapy, and she replied, 'Aw, so he won't baby-talk anymore? I'm gonna miss hearing that!'" —Scottishdog1120 12."I teach high school math. I've encountered many students who were operating at maybe a second-grade level of math. I've encountered high school seniors who couldn't do two times three in their heads, juniors who didn't know what a square root was, juniors who didn't know how to multiply by zero or one, etc. I had one sophomore this year who couldn't wrap her mind around '20 more than' in a certain problem. I tried to explain it for a few minutes, saying, 'Let's say you and I go into a store. I'm going to buy some apples, and you plan on buying 20 more apples than I do. If I buy five apples, how many would you buy?' She answered, '20?'" —get_your_mood_right 13."One of my fourth graders was provisionally promoted from third grade in the middle of the school year. He was reading at a first-grade level when he arrived in my class. He hit his 14-day suspension cap quickly because he was constantly fighting with other kids instead of actually trying to learn. The guidance counselor pulled him out to do a therapeutic art project one afternoon. That's how we discovered that he doesn't know his shapes, either. It was one of the worst cases of educational neglect that I've seen. Of course, the parent was upset that he kid was not on the Honor Roll and demanded to know why he was failing every subject. Oh, yeah, the regional superintendent overruled us and promoted the student to fifth grade." —fastfood12 14."Only 27% of the incoming sixth graders at the local middle school are proficient in math skills. They also have next-to-zero problem-solving or critical thinking skills. They have a 'do it for me or I'm not doing it' mindset for schoolwork. You could turn in zero work for a class and get passed, though. We don't require motivation anymore." —wanderingsoul420666 15."I teach high school seniors and am trying to bring back 'pen and paper schooling.' Kids don't know how to use staplers, and this is not an isolated incident. One broke my stapler trying to refill it because he didn't realize you could break/shorten the replacement staples. Many don't know which side to staple or how to line up pages. I had a student today claim that a stapler was broken because they didn't push it down hard enough until it, you know, stapled. With so many things done online, they can't do anything with paper. It's depressingly defeating at times." —tawey 16."I've had a student use AI on fully opinion-based questions several times. Kids aren't even reading the question or the internet answer. One quiz question asked students to share their comfort level with performing CPR. A student's response was, 'As an AI, I cannot perform CPR.' Someone even used AI to rank my classroom values (things like respect, integrity, and resilience). AI is so new, and no one knows how to use it as a learning tool. It's evolving faster than we can harness." —cumulobiscuit "I teach high school, and I have kids about to be adults who don't know the difference between left and right without making the 'L' shape with their hands. I also have kids who Google basic math calculations, like four times two." —SwattyP *Sigh.* If you're a teacher, what's something completely shocking or unhinged that you've witnessed or experienced with your Gen Alpha students? Let us know in the comments, or you can anonymously submit your story using the form below! Note: Some submissions have been edited for length and/or clarity.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Will Smith says Oscars slap fallout was brutal
Three years after he slapped comedian Chris Rock on stage at the Oscars, Will Smith says making a mistake so publicly was "brutal". "The last few years for me have been really deep reflection," the actor tells 1Xtra's Remi Burgz. "After the Oscars I shut it down for a minute and really went into the internal work and just taking a big, strong, honest look at myself." Will was banned from the awards ceremony for 10 years after he hit the comedian for joking about his wife's shaved head - a result of alopecia, a hair loss condition. "For the first time in my career, [I was] having to deal with a level of disapproval that I never had to experience," Will says. "The addiction to the approval of others that I had to dissolve, it was brutal." At the 2022 ceremony in Los Angeles, Chris Rock mocked Will's wife Jada's appearance. Clips showing Will immediately marching on stage and slapping him across the face and telling him to keep his wife's name out his mouth have been viewed millions of times online. Will resigned from the Oscars Academy shortly after, saying his actions were "shocking, painful, and inexcusable". The 56-year-old tells 1Xtra the fallout has also given him to time to reflect. "It was just like there was a manhole cover over some unexplored areas and the manhole cover came off," he says. "It was scary for a minute what was in there. "But then all of a sudden, all these new thoughts, new energies, new creativity came through like a geyser and it started showing up as music." Earlier this year Will released his first album in 20 years, Based On A True Story, and tells 1Xtra he asked for advice before heading back to the studio. "When I started writing, I called Jay Z and I called Kendrick," he says. "Kendrick said you have to say those things you've always been scared to say and Jay Z said don't even go near it if you're not trying to tell the truth." The new music hasn't been a hit with critics. Pitchfork said it was "excruciatingly corny" while Rolling Stone described it as "cringey... clunky and dated" in a two-and-a-half star review. But Will says it was a "fun way to express the madness of what goes on in my head". "It is the exploration of what I call the 'despicable prisoners'. "It's the parts of myself that have been banished, the parts of myself I'm not allowed to talk about on the radio, the part of myself I'm not even allowed to acknowledge is real. "Working in that space of authenticity, honesty and imperfection, allowing that to grow into a higher perfection than the imagery of Will Smith is where I am as an artist and as a human right now." Remi's full interview with Will Smith is available to stream on BBC Sounds. Why did Will Smith hit Chris Rock? Will Smith resigns from Oscars Academy over slap Will Smith banned from Oscars for 10 years Listen to Newsbeat live at 12:45 and 17:45 weekdays - or listen back here.
