Harvard, Trump administration to face off in court over cancelled funding
BOSTON - Harvard University will urge a federal judge on July 21 to order US President Donald Trump's administration to restore about US$2.5 billion (S$3.2 billion) in cancelled federal grants and cease efforts to cut off research funding to the prestigious Ivy League school.
The court hearing before US District Judge Allison Burroughs in Boston marks a crucial moment in
the White House's escalating conflict with Harvard , which has been in the administration's crosshairs after it rejected
a list of demands to make changes to its governance, hiring and admissions practices in April .
The Cambridge, Massachusetts-based university says hundreds of research projects including ones concerning cancer treatments, infectious diseases and Parkinson's disease will be in jeopardy unless the judge declares the grant cancellations unlawful.
The country's oldest and richest university has become a central focus of the administration's broad campaign to leverage federal funding to force change at US universities, which Mr Trump says are gripped by anti-Semitic and "radical left" ideologies.
"The Trump administration's proposition is simple and commonsense: Don't allow anti-Semitism and DEI to run your campus, don't break the law, and protect the civil liberties of all students," said White House spokesperson Harrison Fields in a statement.
Among the earliest actions the administration took against Harvard was the cancellation of hundreds of grants awarded to researchers on the grounds that the school failed to do enough to address harassment of Jewish students on its campus.
The Trump administration has since
sought to bar international students from attending the school ;
threatened Harvard's accreditation status ; and opened the door to cutting off more funds by finding it violated federal civil rights law.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Asia At least 19 killed as Bangladesh air force plane crashes at college campus
Singapore Subsidies and grants for some 20,000 people miscalculated due to processing issue: MOH
Singapore ST Explains: What does it mean for etomidate to be listed under the Misuse of Drugs Act?
Business Why Singapore and its businesses stand to lose with US tariffs on the region
Singapore NTU introduces compulsory cadaver dissection classes for medical students from 2026
World US passenger jet has close call with B-52 bomber
Singapore Jail for man who conspired with another to bribe MOH agency employee with $18k Paris trip
Singapore New research institute will grow S'pore's talent in nuclear energy, safety
As part of Mr Trump's spending and tax bill, the Republican-led Congress increased the federal excise tax on Harvard's income from its $53 billion endowment to 8 per cent from 1.4 per cent. Income from the endowment covers 40 per cent of Harvard's operating budget.
Harvard President Alan Garber said last week that the various federal actions since Mr Trump returned to office in January could strip the school of nearly $1 billion annually, forcing it to lay off staff and freeze hiring.
Harvard has said it has taken steps to ensure its campus is welcoming to Jewish and Israeli students, who it acknowledges experienced "vicious and reprehensible" treatment following the onset of Israel's war against Hamas in Gaza in October 2023.
But Mr Garber has said the administration's demands have gone far beyond addressing anti-Semitism and unlawfully seek to regulate the "intellectual conditions" on its campus by controlling who it hires and who it teaches.
Those demands, which came in an April 11 letter from an administration task force, included calls for the private university to restructure its governance, alter its hiring and admissions practices to ensure an ideological balance of viewpoints and end certain academic programs.
After Harvard rejected those demands, it said the administration began retaliating against it in violation of the free speech protections of the US Constitution's First Amendment by abruptly cutting funding the school says is vital to supporting scientific and medical research.
Ms Burroughs, an appointee of Democratic President Barack Obama, in a separate case has already barred the administration from halting its ability to host international students.
Mr Trump has expressed optimism that Harvard will eventually settle with his administration. Fields on July 18 said a good deal was more than possible and that the administration is 'confident that Harvard will eventually come around and support the president's vision'.
In court, the administration has argued that Ms Burroughs lacks jurisdiction to hear the challenge and that the grant contracts made clear they could be cancelled if the funded projects do not carry out federal government policy objectives. REUTERS
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

AsiaOne
20 minutes ago
- AsiaOne
White House touts Columbia deal, critics see dangerous precedent, World News
Columbia University's agreement to pay more than US$220 million (S$280 million) to the US government to resolve federal probes was not capitulation but a means to restore vital public funding, the university's acting president said on Thursday (July 24). But critics expressed concern about a harmful precedent in what they see as President Donald Trump's push for greater control over elite US colleges. Trump has targeted Columbia and other universities over the pro-Palestinian student protest movement that roiled college campuses last year. Harvard University is fighting the Trump administration in court and critics have likened the Columbia deal to extortion. Columbia faced the loss of billions of dollars in future federal funds and the potential revocation of the visa status of thousands of international students, said Acting President Claire Shipman. "This was not capitulation," Shipman told CNN, adding that the deal protected the university's "academic integrity". [[nid:719812]] Under the settlement, Columbia will pay US$200 million to the US Treasury and a further US$21 million to a fund to resolve alleged civil rights violations against Jewish employees following the Oct 7, 2023, Hamas attack on Israel, senior administration officials said. In return, the university regained access to some US$1.7 billion in federal funding and grants, Shipman said. The deal comes after the Trump administration in March penalised Columbia over how it handled last year's protests by canceling US$400 million in federal funding. It contended that Columbia's response to alleged antisemitism and harassment of Jewish and Israeli members of the university community was insufficient. The school later acquiesced to a series of demands that included scrutiny of departments offering courses on the Middle East and other concessions that were widely condemned by US academics. Wednesday's deal formalised many of those concessions in what Education Secretary Linda McMahon called an "incredible win" for the government. [[nid:720061]] "It is our hope this is going to be a template for other universities around the country," McMahon told cable network NewsNation. "We're already seeing other universities taking these measures before investigation." McMahon said Columbia agreed to discipline student offenders for severe disruptions of campus operations, bring viewpoint diversity to their Middle Eastern studies programs, eliminate race preferences from their hiring and admissions practices, and end DEI (diversity, equity and inclusion) programs. Columbia law professor David Pozen called the agreement a "shakedown" and said it set a precedent for "pay-to-play" deals the Trump administration is seeking with other schools. "The agreement gives legal form to an extortion scheme," Pozen said in a blog post, calling it the first time antisemitism and DEI have been invoked as the basis for a government-enforced restructuring of a private university. Shipman said the agreement contained no provisions that "shall be construed as giving the United States authority to dictate faculty hiring, university hiring, admissions decisions, or the content of academic speech." [[nid:720454]]
Business Times
an hour ago
- Business Times
US prepares to allow limited oil operations in Venezuela, starting with Chevron, sources say
[HOUSTON] The United States is preparing to grant new authorisations to key partners of Venezuela's state-run PDVSA, starting with Chevron, to allow them to operate with limitations in the sanctioned Opec nation and swap oil, five sources close to the matter said on Thursday. If granted, the authorisations to the US oil major, and possibly also to PDVSA's European partners, would mark a policy shift from a pressure strategy Washington adopted this year on Venezuela's energy industry, under US sanctions since 2019. President Donald Trump's administration might now allow the energy companies to pay oilfield contractors and make necessary imports to secure operational continuity. Some imports could be swapped for Venezuelan oil, as authorised in previous licenses, three of the sources said. A senior State Department official said in a statement they could not speak about any specific licenses to PDVSA's partners, but added the United States would not allow President Nicolas Maduro's government to profit from the sale of oil. A source in touch with US and Venezuelan officials said it was difficult to understand how Maduro's government would not benefit from cargoes Chevron can sell to the US, and later on Thursday Maduro hailed work done to keep Chevron in the country. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up 'There are already working groups so that Chevron can re-incorporate its functions,' Maduro told an interview with Telesur, adding that Chevron's top leadership had already been informed of licenses so it can keep operating in Venezuela. Chevron shares touched US$155.93 on Thursday, their highest level since April 3, according to LSEG data. 'Chevron conducts its business globally in compliance with laws and regulations applicable to its business, as well as the sanctions frameworks provided for by the US government, including in Venezuela,' a company spokesperson said. The move to ease some restrictions on Venezuela's oil sector follows a prisoner swap this month in which Maduro released 10 American detainees while accepting the return of more than 200 Venezuelans who had been deported from the US and held in an El Salvador prison. Relations between the two countries have been tense for years, and the Trump administration has publicly supported opposition leaders who say their candidate won last year's election, not Maduro. Trump in February announced the cancellation of a handful of energy licenses in Venezuela, including Chevron's, and gave until late May to wind down all transactions. The move left all operations in oil and gas joint ventures with Chevron and other partners in PDVSA's hands, but the companies were authorized to preserve their stakes and output remained almost unchanged. The US State Department, which in May blocked a move by special presidential envoy Richard Grenell to extend the licenses, is this time imposing conditions on any authorization modifications, so that no cash reaches Maduro's coffers, the three sources said. In the past, US officials have promised no money would reach Maduro from oil proceeds despite licenses. But it did because PDVSA demands tax and royalties to be paid before granting exports permits. Even if parties agree to oil swaps, those arrangements save PDVSA, and ultimately Maduro's government, millions of dollars per year in imports. Secretary of State Marco Rubio is not expected this time to ban the authorisations, but is negotiating their scope, they added. It was not immediately clear if the terms of the license that could be granted to Chevron would be reproduced for other foreign companies in Venezuela, including Italy's Eni and Spain's Repsol, which have been asking the US to allow them to swap fuel supplies for Venezuelan oil. The authorisations might remain private, one of the sources said. The US Treasury Department's Office of Foreign Assets Control and PDVSA did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Where will the oil go? Following the cancellation of Chevron's license earlier this year, Trump announced the imposition of secondary tariffs on buyers of Venezuelan oil. But the measure, expected to severely hit Venezuela's main crude buyer China, has not been enforced, allowing the South American country to divert to Asia crude grades that were previously sold to US and European refiners through PDVSA's joint-venture partners. The reshuffle, which has maintained Venezuela's oil output and exports close to the levels they were at before the license cancellations, has been criticised by politicians in Washington and was discussed as part of talks for the new authorisations, the sources said. During former US President Joe Biden's administration, targeted licenses to PDVSA's partners allowed Western refiners to regain access to Venezuelan supplies, but they also granted a stable source of cash to Maduro's administration as the companies were required by Venezuela to pay royalties and taxes. REUTERS

AsiaOne
an hour ago
- AsiaOne
US House Speaker Johnson says Epstein case 'not a hoax', World News
WASHINGTON — Republican House of Representatives Speaker Mike Johnson said the Jeffrey Epstein scandal was "not a hoax" in an interview released on Thursday (July 24), as the case continued to stoke turmoil within President Donald Trump's party. Trump has denounced the furor over his late friend, a disgraced financier and convicted sex offender as "the Jeffrey Epstein Hoax" and urged his fellow Republicans without success to drop the issue. "It's not a hoax. Of course not," Johnson said in an interview with CBS News. Johnson said on Tuesday he would send lawmakers home a day early for a five-week summer recess to avoid a political fight over whether to make public additional files on Epstein, who hung himself in a New York City jail in 2019, according to New York City's chief medical examiner. Even so, a Republican-controlled subcommittee of the House Oversight Committee on Wednesday approved a subpoena seeking all Justice Department files on Epstein. Three Republicans joined five Democrats to back the effort, in a sign that Trump's party was not ready to move on from the issue. "We want full transparency. We want everybody who is involved in any way with the Epstein evils — let's call it what it was — to be brought to justice as quickly as possible. We want the full weight of the law on their heads," Johnson told CBS in the interview, conducted on Wednesday. A disclosure on Wednesday about Trump's appearance in the Justice Department's case records threatened to deepen a political crisis that has engulfed his administration for weeks. The Wall Street Journal reported that US Attorney General Pam Bondi told Trump in May that his name appeared in investigative files related to Epstein. [[nid:720547]]