Prison Service rejects call to review policy for prisoners on death of close relatives
The recommendation by the Office of the Inspector of Prisons comes from an investigation into the death of a 27-year-old male in Wheatfield Prison on January 8th, 2023, and a subsequent decision by the IPS to impose a condition on a visit by two of the deceased's brothers to see his body in a funeral home.
Advertisement
Both men declined the offer of compassionate temporary release because of the restriction that no other relatives could be present if they attended the funeral home for a private escorted visit to pay respect to their brother.
Relatives of the prisoner, identified only as Mr B, expressed deep dissatisfaction to OIP investigators about the restriction on the two brothers getting to see their sibling's body.
They claimed it was a very difficult time for everyone and particularly the two brothers in Wheatfield who they believed required emotional support from other family members.
Mr B was an enhanced prisoner on an incentivised regime serving a 17-month prison sentence in a shared cell in Wheatfield at the time of his death.
Advertisement
The OIP was informed by Mr B's wife and other relatives that he was in good mood and sounding 'nice and normal' in a number of phone calls from a contraband mobile phone to friends and family shortly before he was found unresponsive in his cell.
The report showed Mr B's cellmate alerted prison staff after waking up shortly before 1.15am and finding him unresponsive.
However, efforts to resuscitate Mr B were unsuccessful and were discontinued approximately 55 minutes later.
Prison medical records showed that Mr B had no history or current intentions of deliberate self-harm when assessed by healthcare staff after he was transferred to Wheatfield from the Midlands Prison in November 2022.
Advertisement
He had no medical referrals, prescribed medicine or hospital visits and was not subject to special monitoring in the six months before his death.
The OIP noted that the prisoner governor and chaplain relayed the news of Mr B's death to his two brothers at 7.45am.
They were both relocated together to a shared cell, while Mr B's cellmate was allowed to meet them to offer condolences and to discuss events.
The governor informed the OIP that arrangements were also put in place for Mr B's brothers to access healthcare and psychology services as well as being provided with additional phone calls.
Advertisement
The governor and chaplain also attended the home of the deceased's wife at 9am to offer their condolences and to answer any questions that they could.
The OIP noted that the family appreciated the in-person visit but expressed disappointment that they were not allowed to physically embrace Mr B's two brothers at their first family visit following his passing as they were only permitted a screened visit which prevented physical interaction.
However, Wheatfield's governor said the families of both prisoners visited at the same time and were permitted to engage with each other during the visit which would not normally be permitted.
The governor said the visit took place in the visiting area where there is a half partition between visiting booths and a low dividing panel between the visitor and prisoner.
Advertisement
In making its recommendation for a review of compassionate arrangements, the OIP said the unexpected death of a son and sibling is a painful experience in any circumstances 'all the more so if the deceased and some of his siblings are imprisoned at the time.'
The OIP said it was not aware of any individualised security concerns that required Mr B's relatives to be prohibited from physically comforting his incarcerated siblings whether in Wheatfield or at the funeral home.
Ireland
Irish Prison Service urged for halt of extra court...
Read More
The watchdog acknowledged the efforts by prison staff to be compassionate to the prisoner's family.
It noted that no recommendations were made by the IPS following a critical incident review of Mr B's death.
However, the IPS rejected the OIP's recommendation and claimed the prisoner's family were not prohibited from physically comforting his incarcerated siblings.
It added: 'The Irish Prison Service assesses its capacity to make compassionate arrangements for prisoners and their families on a case-by-case basis, based on operational and security constraints.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
3 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
'A year too long': Sinn Féin senator hits out at delay to miscarriage leave law
A Sinn Féin senator has called for more awareness to be raised on the effects of miscarriages after her bill was pushed back by the Government. Nicole Ryan introduced a bill that would entitle women to at least five days of paid leave and their partners to two and a half days. Advertisement The proposed legislation would also lead to the establishment of a confidential opt-in register of pregnancy loss. However, the Government has pushed back the Bill by 12 months Speaking to Ms Ryan spoke of her disappointment at the delay and voiced her concern about what women will go through in the meantime. "12 months is a very long time, and there will be women who are going through miscarriages, various pregnancy losses under 23 weeks, so it was disappointing to see that push back from the Government on this really important issue." Advertisement Ms Ryan said more must be done, by the Government and society in general to make people aware of how a miscarriage can affect someone's life. The Sinn Féin senator shared what women have been telling her of their experience in the workplace following a miscarriage. "A lot of the time, for women, it is a lottery of who your employer is, for instance. "Some have been ment with kindness, others have been met with coldness and questions of when are you going back to work, like you didn't just experience something incredibly traumatic in your life. Advertisement "Some people may not understand how complicated the issue is and how women have lost something. It is a grieving process, whether it is a week or 22 weeks, it is still a loss regardless." "Women are sometimes afraid to say to their employer that they have had a miscarriage, because then it seems they were trying for a child, and they are afraid of being dismissed, or if they are on probation, their probation getting extended or ended. "There is a lot of education that needs to happen for employers, and what a woman would go through. Sometimes a miscarriage could last a whole month or longer, because you have to do check-up appointments, and sometimes take a medical intervention a second time." Ms Ryan was among a number of senators who spoke in the Seanad about their experience of miscarriage. Advertisement Through this experience, Ms Ryan spoke on the lack of support available and the way people talk regarding miscarriages. "Through my experience, I just didn't feel massively supported at all in what I was going through. "Sometimes people say things off the cuff, like at least you can get pregnant, or at least it was only a couple of weeks, you can get on with it. "The minute you find out you are pregnant, you have knocked out a life, you think about their hair colour, their eye colour, what school they might go to, you are planning things in your own head. Advertisement "Then, when that is suddenly ripped away from you, you lose a sense of your own self for a while. It is not as easy as picking myself up and getting on with it." The time that followed Ms Ryan's miscarriage made her more aware of what happens during pregnancy loss, many symptoms and effects she admitted she was unaware of. Ireland Abortion laws 'still failing women who struggle to... Read More The Cork senator says education is key going forward to best help women during a miscarriage. "Even when I was going through it in the hospital setting, I wasn't told a lot of things that were going to happen to me. "I was just told, take this medication, it is going to be a bad period. It was nothing like a bad period; it was way worse. Everything through that miscarriage was incredibly traumatic. "We are doing a disservice to women by not even explaining some of the most basic things around the choices we have to make when it comes to pregnancy loss."
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
Death at Guys Marsh prison prompts call to curb illicit alcohol and drugs
Ministers should draw up a specific policy to reduce inmate access to illicitly brewed alcohol and medication after the death of a vulnerable prisoner, a coroner has said. An inquest jury found last month that Sheldon Jeans, who was discovered dead in his cell at HMP Guys Marsh on or about 13 November 2022, had died as a result of consuming illegal alcohol and four different medications that had not been prescribed to him, recording death by misadventure. Rachael Griffin, the senior Dorset coroner, issued a prevention of future deaths (PFD) report in response to findings at the inquest, highlighting national policy and guidance relating to the handling of hooch and medication in prisons as areas for concern. 'In my opinion there is a risk that future deaths could occur unless action is taken … There is a lack of national policy, and local guidance at HMP Guys Marsh, to inform staff working in prisons of the dangers of illicitly brewed alcohol, also known as hooch,' she wrote. The report has been sent to the Department of Health and Social Care, HM Prison and Probation Service, HMP Guys Marsh, and Oxleas NHS foundation trust, requesting a response by 19 September 2025 detailing actions to be taken and a timetable for that action. Jeans, 32, from Portsmouth, had a history of mental health issues and was anxious about the impending outcome of a parole hearing when he took them, a jury at Dorset coroner's court in Bournemouth heard. In the report, the coroner drew attention to evidence given about the continual problem in prison of hooch, which is illicitly brewed from substances legitimately available to prisoners. In September 2022, shortly before Sheldon's death, 215.5 litres were seized at HMP Guys Marsh. Hooch was described as a dangerous substance during the inquest, and has sedative effects which can be increased when consumed alongside certain medications. The coroner said that while policies are in place concerning the possession and use of illicit substances in prisons, these focus on drugs or medication and 'remain silent in relation to alcohol'. The coroner also raised concerns over prisoners having access to prescription medication that was not prescribed to them. Sheldon had taken four different types of medication, none of which had been prescribed to him, alongside consuming hooch. At the inquest, the jury concluded that the substances in isolation would not have been fatal, but taken together caused a sedative effect which, combined with Sheldon's body posture, led to respiratory depression. At the inquest, it was heard that prescription medication at HMP Guys Marsh can either be taken under supervision, or a prisoner is provided with the medication for them to keep and take in their cells. While it is not known how Sheldon accessed the medication he consumed, evidence was provided at the inquest about how prisoners are able to access each other's cells during states of unlock – such as during meal collection times. Medication was shown to be left around cells and in unsecured plastic containers, despite lockable cupboards available. Following the inquest, the jury concluded that Sheldon's death had been by misadventure, and that while he had deliberately taken the substances, he had not intended to end his life. A Ministry of Justice spokesperson said: 'We will carefully consider the coroner's findings and will respond to the report in due course.' The jury found the levels of drugs and alcohol separately would not have killed Jeans. But his posture resulted in fatal respiratory depression, which he had not intended. He was found to have taken pregabalin, used to treat epilepsy and anxiety, and the antidepressant mirtazapine. Jeans also took the opioid painkiller dihydrocodeine and quetiapine, which is used to treat mental health conditions. He had not been prescribed any of them. Leigh Day partner Benjamin Burrows, who represents Sheldon's family, said: 'Our hope is that steps are taken in prisons across the country, not just HMP Guys Marsh, to address these issues and to safeguard against this kind of tragic death occurring again.'
BreakingNews.ie
5 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Registrar left stunned by racial slurs from kids
An Irish-born medical registrar said he was left stunned after a group of children hurled racial slurs at him as he left a shopping complex last week. Dr Taimoor Salman estimates children as young as 10 years old shouted 'Mr Curry Man' in a broken Indian accent at him. Advertisement The incident occurred after 9pm on Thursday evening as Dr Salman dropped into Blackcastle Shopping Centre in Navan, Co. Meath to pick up a few groceries on his way home from work at Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital in Drogheda, Co. Louth. He had stepped into his car and was about to reverse when a young boy cycled in front of him and repeatedly shouted 'Mr Curry Man'. "I said he was being very rude and as I reversed an older boy, a young teen, came up and asked me if I had said something so I told him that his friend had been rude," he said. "The older boy told me to shut up and then started doing impersonationations of Apu, the Indian shopkeeper in the Simpsons. I just left. I didn't say anything more as they were children. Advertisement "I was stunned and upset. I have seen racial abuse and throw away remarks first hand to me and my colleagues at the hospital but I would never expect this from children who are generally very accepting of other nationalities. "There seems to be a horrible pack mentality and this incident was insidious." Dr Taimoor was born in Ireland where his father trained and practised as a surgeon and worked in Our Lady's Hospital in Navan before moving the family to work in the UK and Saudi Arabia. "I lived in Navan and went to primart school here and have nothing but good memories of the town as a child. I never experienced any racism here. Advertisement "That's part of the reason I came back to live here with my wife and young daughter in 2017 and after I began working in the hospital in Drogheda." Dr Salman, whose parents were born in Pakistan, believes that the streets of Navan have become too dangerous for him to walk at night. "This wave of hatred to people of colour is quite recent and increasingly more open and brash. I've been back in Ireland for 15 years. In 2017, it was a peaceful and safe place and I could walk anywhere at any time without fear. Now it is too unsafe and I would only go to crowded places." "There is no invasion in this country. This is everyone's home and everyone has to be respectful to everyone else. Racism is ugly and it shouldn't be accepted or tolerated. Advertisement "I've seen senior consultants and colleagues at the hospital targeted and even in guidelines, we are told to use the word 'coloured' people. Why? All people are just people. We all have a heart and we will all live and die. There should be no distinction. "I saw a child on Thursday night. I didn't see a colour. No-one should see a colour"
