'India Of 2008 Absorbed Attacks, This One Hits Back': John W Spencer Hails Operation Sindoor Against Pakistan
John W Spencer hailed India's 'Operation Sindoor' as a decisive military success. He said India's response to terrorism marked an era of deterrence without international mediation.
Retired United States Army officer John W Spencer on Wednesday termed India's 'Operation Sindoor' 'a decisive victory in modern warfare" and said that the country has not yet declared the operation complete. He also said the new India hits back, while the India back in 2008 absorbed attacks and waited.
In a lengthy X post, Spencer, who is also a researcher of urban warfare and an author, said India achieved a 'massive victory" in its operation against Pakistan.
'Operation Sindoor' met and exceeded its strategic aims through decisive powers and a symbolic force, he said.
'India has not declared Operation Sindoor completely over. What exists now is a sensitive halt in operations—some may call it a ceasefire, but military leaders have deliberately avoided that word. From a warfighting perspective, this is not merely a pause; it is a strategic hold following a rare and unambiguous military victory," Spencer wrote on his timeline on X.
'After just four days of calibrated military action, it is objectively conclusive: India achieved a massive victory."
'Operation Sindoor met and exceeded its strategic aims—destroying terrorist infrastructure, demonstrating military superiority, restoring deterrence, and unveiling a new national security doctrine. This was not symbolic force. It was decisive power, clearly applied," he wrote.
'India was attacked. On April 22, 2025, 26 Indian civilians, mostly Hindu tourists, were massacred in Pahalgam, Jammu & Kashmir. The Resistance Front (TRF), an offshoot of the Pakistan-based Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT), claimed responsibility. As has been the case for decades, the group is backed by Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI)," Spencer wrote on X.
'But unlike previous attacks, this time India didn't wait. It didn't appeal for international mediation or issue a diplomatic demarche. It launched warplanes. On May 7, India initiated Operation Sindoor, a swift and precisely calibrated military campaign. The Indian Air Force struck nine terrorist infrastructure targets inside Pakistan, including headquarters and operational hubs for Jaish-e-Mohammed and Lashkar-e-Taiba. The message was clear: terror attacks launched from Pakistani soil will now be treated as acts of war," he added.
Spencer also hailed Prime Minister Narendra Modi and mentioned how he made firm that India would not tolerate any nuclear blackmail.
'Prime Minister Narendra Modi made the new doctrine unmistakable: 'India will not tolerate any nuclear blackmail. India will strike precisely and decisively at the terrorist hideouts developing under the cover of nuclear blackmail." More than a retaliation, this was the unveiling of a strategic doctrine. As Modi said, 'Terror and talks can't go together. Water and blood can't flow together."," he wrote.
Spencer also wrote down how India's 'Operation Sindoor' was executed in phases.
'Operation Sindoor was executed in deliberate phases
· May 7: Nine precision strikes were launched deep into Pakistani territory. Targets included key terror training camps and logistics nodes in Bahawalpur, Muridke, Muzaffarabad, and elsewhere.
· May 8: Pakistan retaliated with a massive drone swarm across India's western states. India's multi-layered air defense network—domestically built and augmented by Israeli and Russian systems—neutralized nearly all of them.
· May 9: India escalated with additional strikes on six Pakistani military airbases and UAV coordination hubs.
· May 10: A temporary halt in firing was reached. India did not call it a ceasefire. The Indian military referred to it as a 'stoppage of firing"—a semantic but deliberate choice that reinforced its strategic control of the situation.
This wasn't just tactical success. It was doctrinal execution under live fire."
Also underlining the impacts of the 'Operation Sindoor', Spencer wrote,
'Strategic Effects Achieved
1. A New Red Line Was Drawn—and Enforced
Terror attacks from Pakistani soil will now be met with military force. That's not a threat. It's precedent.
2. Military Superiority Demonstrated
India showcased its ability to strike any target in Pakistan at will—terror sites, drone coordination hubs, even airbases. Meanwhile, Pakistan was unable to penetrate a single defended area inside India. That is not parity. That is overwhelming superiority. And that is how real deterrence is established.
3. Restored Deterrence
India retaliated forcefully but stopped short of full war. The controlled escalation sent a clear deterrent signal: India will respond, and it controls the pace.
4. Asserted Strategic Independence"
Spencer, in his X post, also highlighted that the situation was dealt with by India single-handedly, without seeking international mediation.
'India handled this crisis without seeking international mediation. It enforced doctrine on sovereign terms, using sovereign means. Operation Sindoor was not about occupation or regime change. It was limited war executed for specific objectives. Critics who argue India should have gone further miss the point. Strategic success isn't about the scale of destruction—it's about achieving the desired political effect," he wrote.
'India was not fighting for vengeance. It was fighting for deterrence. And it worked. India's restraint is not weakness—it is maturity. It imposed costs, redefined thresholds, and retained escalation dominance. India didn't just respond to an attack. It changed the strategic equation," Spencer mentioned.
'In an age where many modern wars spiral into open-ended occupations or political confusion, Operation Sindoor stands apart. This was a demonstration of disciplined military strategy: clear goals, aligned ways and means, and adaptive execution in the face of unpredictable escalation. India absorbed a blow, defined its objective, and achieved it—all within a contained timeframe."
'The use of force in Operation Sindoor was overwhelming yet controlled—precise, decisive, and without hesitation. That kind of clarity is rare in modern war. In an era defined by 'forever wars" and cycles of violence without strategic direction, Sindoor stands apart. It offers a model of limited war with clearly defined ends, matched ways and means, and a state that never relinquished the initiative."
Comparing the India back in 2008 – during the UPA's regime, and the present India, Spencer wrote, 'The India of 2008 absorbed attacks and waited. This India hits back—immediately, precisely, and with clarity."
'Modi's doctrine, India's advancing domestic defense industry, and the professionalism of its armed forces all signal a country no longer preparing for the last war. It is preparing for the next one. The halt in operations is not the end of Operation Sindoor. It is a pause. India holds the initiative. If provoked again, it will strike again," he wrote.
'This is deterrence restored. This is a new doctrine revealed. And it should be studied by all nations confronting the scourge of state-sponsored terrorism. Operation Sindoor was a modern war—fought under the shadow of nuclear escalation, with global attention, and within a limited objective framework. And by every measure that matters, it was a strategic success—and a decisive Indian victory," his X post read.
'After just four days of calibrated military action, it is objectively conclusive: India achieved a massive victory. Operation Sindoor met and exceeded its strategic aims—destroying terrorist infrastructure, demonstrating military superiority, restoring deterrence, and unveiling… https://t.co/YvxCjaJJRs — John Spencer (@SpencerGuard) May 14, 2025
India launched Operation Sindoor on May 7 to destroy nine terror infrastructures in Pakistan and Pakistan-Occupied-Kashmir in retaliation to the Pahalgam terror attack.
All subsequent retaliations to Pakistani offensives were carried out under 'Operation Sindoor'.
top videos
View all
On May 10, India and Pakistan announced reaching an understanding to stop all firings and military actions on land, air and sea, with effect from 5 pm that day.
ALSO READ | Trump At It Again: After Ceasefire Post, US President Asks India To 'Go Out To Dinner' With Pakistan
Watch India Pakistan Breaking News on CNN-News18. Get breaking news, in-depth analysis, and expert perspectives on everything from politics to crime and society. Stay informed with the latest India news only on News18. Download the News18 App to stay updated!
tags :
india pakistan conflict Operation Sindoor
Location :
New Delhi, India, India
First Published:
May 14, 2025, 11:39 IST
News india 'India Of 2008 Absorbed Attacks, This One Hits Back': John W Spencer Hails Operation Sindoor Against Pakistan
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
16 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Assam decides to stop issuing new Aadhaar cards to adults after one-month window
SILCHAR: Assam chief minister Himanta Biswa Sarma on Thursday said that people in Assam will have a one-month window from September 1 to apply for the 12-digit Aadhaar identity number before the issuance of fresh cards to adults is stopped as a precautionary measure to ensure that illegal immigrants from Bangladesh do not obtain the identification number in the future. Assam chief minister Himanta Biswa Sarma (ANI) Only a one-month window from September 1 will be given to them to apply for an Aadhaar card if anyone has not got the document yet, he told reporters after a Cabinet meeting here. Already, the chief minister said, Assam has reached the saturation point. The new order will take effect from October 1, with exceptions for Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST) and Tea Tribes, the chief minister told reporters. 'This is a precautionary measure to ensure no illegal foreigner can become an Indian citizen in the future. It is irrespective of religion or any other criteria. We are committed to safeguarding Assam from infiltration,' Sarma said. The chief minister pointed out that Aadhaar enrolment in Assam has already exceeded the population count. 'The saturation among the general population is 102 per cent, which means the number of cards is higher than the number of people. But in the case of Tea Tribes, SC and ST, saturation is only 96 per cent, which is why they need more time,' he explained. Sarma said a genuine Indian adult who has been left out could approach the district commissioner, who would have to verify their credentials and approve issuance of Aadhaar in the 'rarest of rare' circumstances. The chief minister recalled the state's continuous crackdown on illegal immigration from Bangladesh. 'In the last one year, we have been detaining and deporting illegal Bangladeshi immigrants almost every day. Just yesterday, seven people were deported. But we cannot rule out the possibility that some may have slipped through. This restriction will act as a deterrent measure,' he said. Sarma said Assam's demography had undergone stark changes in the past. 'In many areas, indigenous Assamese people have lost jobs, land and other facilities to illegal migrants. During eviction drives, they have even attacked government officials. In Uriamghat, 12,000 to 15,000 people gathered to resist officials. Many were not locals... This shows a larger conspiracy, and we are fighting against it,' he alleged. He also argued that there is hardly any need for new Aadhaar enrolment among adults, as most of them already have the identity card. 'Only children and newborns now require Aadhaar enrolment,' he said. Following the National Register of Citizens (NRC) exercise in 2018, more than 2.66 million people in Assam were initially denied Aadhaar cards. However, the Supreme Court later allowed them to obtain the card.
Hindustan Times
16 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
UP ATS busts racket involved in making fake Aadhaar cards for illegal immigrants, 8 held
The Uttar Pradesh Anti-Terrorism Squad (ATS) on Thursday busted an interstate racket involved in making fake Aadhaar cards and other Indian identity documents for Rohingyas, Bangladeshi nationals, Nepalis, and other foreigners living illegally in India. The arrests were made following a series of coordinated raids across multiple states. (For Representation) The alleged kingpin and seven other members of the gang have been arrested following a series of coordinated raids across multiple states, said the ATS. Those arrested are the gang's kingpin Mohammad Naseem and Mohammad Shakib of Azamgarh, Himanshu Rai and Mrityunjay Gupta of Mau, Salman Ansari of Ghaziabad, Gaurav Kumar Gautam of Auraiya, Rajeev Tiwari of Gorakhpur and Vishal Kumar of Azamgarh. 'The ATS recovered high-tech electronic devices used for forging documents, fingerprint scanners and laptops, multiple mobile phones used for VPN operations, large number of forged Aadhaar cards, birth certificates and supporting Indian documents,' read an ATS press note. According to the ATS, the gang was using both electronic and manual methods to manipulate Aadhaar data. Several Jan Seva Kendras registered for Aadhaar enrolment were allegedly misused to illegally generate or modify Aadhaar cards. Investigators revealed that operators used VPN networks and remote access systems to bypass security checks and make fraudulent changes in official records. The ATS said the forged Aadhaar cards were later used by illegal immigrants to obtain passports, residential proofs and access to government welfare schemes. In many cases, birth certificates, residence proofs and affidavits were fabricated as supporting documents. 'The beneficiaries of these fake Aadhaar cards include infiltrators, Rohingya refugees, Bangladeshi citizens and others without valid Indian documents. They paid hefty sums to middlemen and racketeers for these services,' an ATS officer said. Based on months of intelligence inputs , the UP ATS registered an FIR in this connection on August 20. Subsequently, search and raid operations were carried out in Azamgarh, Gorakhpur, Mau, Saharanpur, Auraiya (Uttar Pradesh), Murshidabad and Kolkata (West Bengal), Lakhisarai and Katihar (Bihar), and Delhi-NCR. During the operation, ATS teams seized forged Indian documents and Aadhaar cards, along with the devices used for forgery in large numbers. The ATS has sought police custody remand of the accused to interrogate them further and trace more operatives linked to the racket. Officials believe that several more people, including document forgers, data operators, and middlemen, are part of the wider network. 'The operation is still going on. Teams are conducting searches in multiple districts and states to trace the remaining accused. This is a major step in preventing illegal immigrants from misusing forged Indian identities,' said an ATS official.
Time of India
16 minutes ago
- Time of India
America's merit-based system : Impact of hourly rate – based compensation on knowledge workers in India
The global labor market has undergone significant changes over the years, with workers from different countries and cultures coming together to fight for better pay and living conditions. The relationship between India and the United States has evolved significantly, with both countries recognizing the importance of strengthening their bilateral ties. A crucial aspect of this relationship is the connection between trade and immigration, which is deeply intertwined. The US government proposed comprehensive immigration reforms in 2013, aimed at addressing the challenges faced by guest workers and employers. In 2025, implementing a merit-based system could be a potential solution, one that would eventually disrupt the traditional practice of 'brokerage of intellectual capital' of citizens from abroad, where talent is often underutilized due to outdated practices. A merit-based system would provide Indian workers with better job opportunities and fair compensation based on their skills and experience. This would lead to increased job satisfaction, reduced turnover rates, and improved overall well-being and attract top talent from around the world, driving innovation and growth. The shift towards a merit-based system and hourly rate-based compensation for knowledge workers in India could have significant implications. Hourly rate-based compensation could lead to more fairness in pay, as workers are rewarded based on their actual work hours and output. High-skilled knowledge workers may have the opportunity to earn more by working on high-value projects or taking on additional hours. With hourly rate-based compensation, knowledge workers may have more flexibility to choose their projects, clients, or working hours, allowing them to optimize their work-life balance and productivity. The emphasis on meritocracy could drive competition among knowledge workers, encouraging them to develop new skills, enhance their expertise, and deliver high-quality work to stay competitive. To stay competitive, knowledge workers will need to prioritize ongoing learning, upskilling, and reskilling to maintain their market value. With the rise of remote work, Indian knowledge workers may have more opportunities to work with global clients, potentially leading to increased earning potential and exposure to diverse projects. Indian students who demonstrate high levels of academic achievement, language proficiency, and specialized skills may have increased chances of visa approval under a merit-based system. The US administration has expressed interest in retaining high-caliber talent, including graduates of American colleges, which could lead to more opportunities for Indian students to pursue their careers in the US. The forthcoming disruptive immigration policies could benefit the Indian economy by encouraging the return of skilled Indian workers who have gained valuable experience and expertise in the US. These returnees would bring back new ideas, skills, and knowledge, which would help to drive innovation and growth in India. The disruption could create more opportunities for high-skilled Indian knowledge workers to work on projects that match their expertise, potentially leading to higher earnings. The emphasis on meritocracy and hourly rate-based compensation may lead to growing demand for specialized skills, such as data science, artificial intelligence, and cybersecurity. By streamlining work visa processes, increasing cooperation on trade agreements, encouraging people-to-people ties through cultural exchange programs and educational initiatives, and implementing a more merit-based system, both countries can benefit. India would gain increased access to the US market, while the US would tap into India's growing economy and skilled workforce, ultimately strengthening Indo-American bilateral ties. This new landscape presents opportunities for Indian knowledge workers and students to succeed in the global economy, but it also requires them to be adaptable, innovative, and entrepreneurial. Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email Disclaimer Views expressed above are the author's own.
