Road user charge plan a 'good idea', but privacy a concern
Yesterday, the Government signed off on the first steps towards scrapping petrol tax and shifting all vehicles onto electronic road user charges (RUC).
Currently New Zealanders help pay for the roads via their vehicle licence (or 'rego') fee, road user charges (RUC) and the petrol excise duty (PED).
Minister of Transport Chris Bishop said the transition would ensure all vehicles pay based on actual road use (including weight) regardless of fuel type, and said eventually paying RUC would be similar to paying a monthly electricity bill.
Speaking to Breakfast, AA principal policy adviser Terry Collins said generally the move was "a good idea, but has some challenges", particularly around privacy and data collection.
ADVERTISEMENT
"If they're going to electronically monitor every vehicle, it's the privacy issues around it," he said.
AA principal policy advisor Terry Collins. (Source: Breakfast)
"Who wants to know where you are and when? And that unlocks that whole issue around everything to do with phones, and the data. Who has it, and what do they want to do with it?"
He said there were some "really good" aspects to the proposed legislative changes, including distance-based Warrant of Fitness.
However, Collins also raised concerns about the cost of putting a transponder in each car and the practicalities of monitoring each car.
"I think generally they don't want to have day-to-day monitoring (which) would be very expensive and it will be invasive. So it's how you download that information about your travel on a semi-regular basis, maybe monthly, where they can record it and send you the report."
The morning's headlines in 90 seconds, including privacy concerns over road user charges, possible changes to Wellington's waterfront, and one of the biggest sports memorabilia heists ever. (Source: 1News)
ADVERTISEMENT
He said there were some "real challenges ahead" to understand how to collect the data safely.
"Fuel excise duty was the cheapest to collect and hardest to evade, this one's going to be hardest to collect and the easiest to evade, so there's some real challenges ahead."
Transport Minister responds
Chris Bishop told Breakfast that the Government would engage with the Privacy Commissioner to ensure data was collected safely.
Chris Bishop said paying for RUC would be similar to paying an electricity bill at the end of each month. (Source: Breakfast)
'Ultimately, the standards will be set by the Government, and there will be potentially a range of competing providers. And I get the concerns around privacy,' he said.
He said other places, such as Sydney, already used transponder technology in their cars to monitor where they were going and what they were doing.
ADVERTISEMENT
'When you go through a toll gantry it gives a little beep, and it charges you to your credit card and you pay at the end of the month, or week, or whatever.'
'In other countries jurisdictions they've had those for over a decade, so we're actually miles behind the rest of the world.
'And some of these concerns around privacy, and tracking, things like that, we are really conscious about that and we are going to work our way through that to protect against all of that kind of stuff.'
Labour's Peeni Henare said there were still questions Kiwis would want answered before the rollout of the new system, expected in 2027.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
2 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Gisborne advocate criticises Kāinga Ora land sales amid ‘housing crisis'
'We currently plan to sell about 36 hectares of land that is no longer needed for either new social housing projects or for urban development work,' an information sheet on land sales said. Land included a range of larger sites in Auckland and Wellington, as well as 'smaller vacant sites across the country which are not needed for social housing projects'. Kāinga Ora properties on the market and properties sold were also listed online. These included properties in Gisborne, on the Coast and at Te Karaka. A social housing property for sale as at July 31 is 4 Tui St in Gisborne. Vacant land Kāinga Ora has for sale in Kaiti as at July 31 is at 43 Ranfurly St, 5 Lawrence St, 23 Cavendish Cres and 28 Dalton St. Land at Tolaga Bay is also on the market – at 2,4,6,8 and 10 Discovery St and 1 and 9 Adventure Ave. Elgin properties sold as at July 31 were 47, 49, 51 and 53 Centennial Cres, as well as 8 Puriri St. In Te Karaka, the property at 22 Currie St had sold. 'Like any developer, we are continually reviewing the land we own to see if it is still fit for purpose, and as such, it is expected that the divestment of sites will be an ongoing process,' the Kāinga Ora information said. 'It is likely that further sites will be added to our divestment programme in the future.' In a separate statement to the Gisborne Herald, the agency said: 'Market conditions are continually evolving, demand for new housing can change, and more detailed due diligence may mean sites intended for redevelopment no longer work for us.' Lizz Crawford, the manager of Oasis Community Shelter in Kaiti, was concerned with the sales of Kāinga Ora property amid a "housing crisis". Photo / Gisborne Herald Crawford said the selling of properties was part of an ongoing crisis. 'It appears we have not only a housing crisis, but a societal crisis, which has more than likely exacerbated the lack of housing for the most vulnerable of society. 'There are countries that have actively reduced homelessness, and it is sad to see that New Zealand is not one of them. We have done the opposite and not only turned a blind eye, but perhaps our backs, too,' she said. East Coast MP Dana Kirkpatrick outlined the Government's policy on housing as well as helping the homeless. In response to questions about homelessness and housing, East Coast MP Dana Kirkpatrick said the Government had recently released the latest Homelessness Insights Report and announced 'a series of actions to reduce the number of people living without shelter, including sleeping rough in New Zealand'. The report 'confirms what frontline organisations have been saying ... there are too many people in housing need. Accurate numbers are difficult to pin down. People without shelter often move around and may avoid engaging with government services, but it's clear we have a real problem', she said. The Government was making 'a serious response' to housing issues, Kirkpatrick said. 'At present, over $550 million is spent annually across a range of programmes run by multiple agencies, including Transitional Housing, Housing First, Rapid Rehousing and many other support services. 'We've made it clear that officials should engage with frontline providers to do this because they are the organisations working at the frontline of this problem. We will not be returning to the previous Government's large-scale emergency housing model, which cost over $1 million a day at its peak and was a social disaster.' The Government was reviewing housing support services, she said. 'Our aim is to make the system simpler, more effective and reduce duplication. We want to fund what works.' 'We're also looking at ways to improve the social housing system to ensure it delivers the right homes in the right places for the right people. The Government has recently changed Kāinga Ora's funding settings to enable the agency to build more one-bedroom units. About 50% of people on the Housing Register require a one-bedroom unit, but they only make up about 12% of Kāinga Ora's housing stock.' Some new homes were blessed recently on Kowhai St in Te Hapara and were ready for tenants to move in.
Scoop
3 hours ago
- Scoop
Boaties Soon Off The Hook: ACT Ends Unfair Petrol Tax
ACT MP and keen boatie Cameron Luxton is celebrating a long-overdue win for fairness with the end of petrol excise taxes for boat users and other off-road fuel users. 'Fuel tax is supposed to fund roads. So why have boat owners been forced to pay it when their vehicles never touch a road,' says Luxton. 'It's always been unfair, which is why ACT has been fighting since 2021 to scrap this boatie tax. Now, it's finally happening. 'Following the 2023 election, ACT secured a coalition commitment to replace petrol excise with road user charges (RUCs) across the board with progress confirmed this week. 'This means you'll no longer be taxed at the pump when filling up your boat, lawnmower, quad bike, or chainsaw. 'For boaties, that's around 70 cents a litre in excise saved, plus another 10 cents in GST that gets put on top. That's $120 off a 150-litre tank. It's a massive win for fairness and common sense. 'The shift to RUCs won't happen overnight – it's part of a broader transition and will involve public consultation – but the Government's direction is clear, and ACT will make sure this promise is kept. 'The day I get to go fishing without paying road tax will be a good one – and it's thanks to Kiwis who've supported ACT.'
NZ Herald
15 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Chlöe Swarbrick reckons Green Party leading Opposition, only party offering tax ideas
Asked by the Herald whether she felt the Green Party was therefore currently leading the Opposition with its offerings rather than Labour, Swarbrick replied that she felt that was a 'pretty evidence-based position, yeah'. 'I'm stoked with the mahi that we have done to show people the issues that this Government is creating for us, but also how we would solve those issues,' she said. 'I'm proud of the work that we've done. That can only be a positive thing. We are setting the agenda, we are contributing positively to the debate, and that is exciting people. That's a good thing.' Throughout the Herald's interview with Swarbrick, she noted it is the Green Party that is holding a consistent policy position, pointing to the wealth tax offering at the 2020 and 2023 election campaign. 'We've put it in our budget document for 2025. People know exactly where we sit,' she said. That budget document proposed to generate about $89 billion through the likes of a wealth tax, an inheritance tax and reinstating the 10-year bright-line test. While it also would have cut income tax for many workers, it was criticised by governing parties as being Marxist in nature, while Labour's Chris Hipkins said it was 'unrealistic'. Swarbrick is convinced there is a need to make change, noting a recent report from Inland Revenue in June which flagged that New Zealanders would likely need to pay more tax to cover the cost of an ageing population. It said an alternative could be to cut spending, but with so much uncertainty in the future, the tax system should be designed so revenue is generated fairly and efficiently if required. The Green co-leader said that showed it shouldn't be a 'matter of if, but how we fix the tax system'. 'I think that any responsible political party needs to be able to put forward a solution to deal with that issue. From where we're sitting very clearly, the only party who has so far done that is the Greens.' Greens co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick suggests her party is leading the Opposition in driving the agenda. Photo / Mark Mitchell Labour is expected to unveil its closely guarded tax policy later this year. Nothing has been confirmed, but there are indications it will settle on a Capital Gains Tax (CGT). The Greens favour a wealth tax, which Swarbrick said was in part down to how much revenue the respective taxes would generate and 'fairness'. A CGT would take several years to ramp up. Swarbrick believes a wealth tax would allow an important 'redistribution' of wealth. 'That redistribution of the burden of our tax system also unlocks all of that resource necessary for that investment, but it also deals with that rapidly growing inequality if we're applying the wealth tax instead of the capital gains tax,' she said. She said the Greens were offering 'solutions' to respond to a 'very clear need from communities'. '[Like] so many people across this country, we are angry. We are not happy with the status quo. We are not happy with what this Government is doing. But we need to have an alternative.' The co-leader believed it 'would be great if every political party could come to the table with some evidence-based positions on anything'. One of her clear frustrations with the current Government is it going forward with proposals despite risks being identified by officials. That isn't new to governments, but there have been numerous reports showing concern from agencies about various policies. Ministers say they've been elected to push the agenda New Zealanders voted for and to cut through bureaucracy. Swarbrick said: 'They've taken that legislation through select committee and had overwhelming opposition, and they've still decided to go ahead with doing that stuff anyway'. She believes any future government her party is a part of would be the most progressive or left-leaning New Zealand has seen under MMP. 'I think that that's obviously desperately what we need. You look at the socioeconomic political history of this country and every 40 or so years, we have a form of economic transformation.' Economic transformation looks like moving away from 'man-made metrics' such as 'the likes of GDP' and instead focusing on policies that 'support the wellbeing of people and planet'. She said we are about four decades on from the 'era of neoliberalism' beginning in the 1980s and 'we can see the wheels are falling off'. 'A new system is desperately being cried out for.' The Herald asked whether she would push Labour left, away from a political centre ground. 'This takes me back to the core proposition that I have been harping on about since I first got involved in politics, which is, I don't just think it's a matter of what the political parties are saying and doing. It's what New Zealanders want and need.' Labour's yet to unveil its tax policy. Photo / Mark Mitchell As for the AGM this week, Swarbrick appears confident the party has moved on from the troubles of 2024, which included MPs resigning and a walkout from their conference. She said her current party was 'forged in fire' through that experience. 'Here we are stronger than ever, putting out tangible solutions to the issues that New Zealanders face.' She spoke about the 'new alliances' the Greens are trying to develop. They include coal miners on the West Coast of the South Island, which also happens to be the birthplace of the Labour Party. 'I think it's really important for people to understand that the Green Party and the actual coal miners on the ground have a lot more in common than you might otherwise think. 'What these coal miners really want at the end of the day is a decent income to be able to stay in their community and to feel a sense of pride. Those are things that we can work together on.' Wouldn't that just take votes away from Labour, who the Greens would need to enter government? 'It's something that I've said for time immemorial that I've been doing this gig, is no politician and no political party is entitled to anything. It is New Zealanders who get to decide the direction of travel for this country. 'I just actually want all of us to take a step back, take a deep breath, and challenge the assumptions that we make around who by default gets access to certain voters. That's just not the way that I think that things should work.' Jamie Ensor is a political reporter in the NZ Herald press gallery team based at Parliament. He was previously a TV reporter and digital producer in the Newshub press gallery office. In 2025, he was a finalist for Political Journalist of the Year at the Voyager Media Awards.
