Convert or suffer: Pakistan's Christian and Hindu children trapped in forced conversions and child labour rings
A new report by Pakistan's National Commission on the Rights of the Child reveals widespread discrimination against Christian and Hindu children. The report highlights severe challenges, including forced conversions, child marriages, and bonded labor, particularly in Punjab.
ANI "Convert or suffer": Pakistan's Christian and Hindu children trapped in forced conversions and child labour rings A new report by Pakistan's own National Commission on the Rights of the Child (NCRC) has brought to light the deep-rooted and widespread discrimination faced by minority children, especially Christians and Hindus, within the Islamic Republic. Titled "Situation Analysis of Children from Minority Religions in Pakistan," the report offers a grim picture of systemic bias, institutional neglect, and targeted abuse. It calls for urgent government intervention, though scepticism remains over whether that call will be met with anything beyond lip service.According to Christian Daily International, the report points to "severe challenges" faced by religious minority children, which are not isolated incidents but part of a disturbing nationwide pattern of marginalisation and abuse. Forced conversions, child marriages, and child labour, particularly in bonded conditions, remain a daily reality for thousands of Christian and Hindu children.Among the most horrifying revelations in the NCRC's findings, highlighted by Christian Daily International, is the continued practice of abducting underage girls from minority communities and forcibly converting and marrying them to older Muslim men. The report explicitly states that "few legal options" exist for victims due to institutional bias, lack of law enforcement, and overwhelming public pressure. This is not a legal gray area; it is a human rights catastrophe.From April 2023 to December 2024, the NCRC received 27 official complaints involving cases of murder, abduction, forced religious conversion, and underage marriage, all targeting minority children. And these are merely the reported cases. Real numbers are feared to be significantly higher, as families often remain silent out of fear of retaliation or further victimisation by authorities.Christian Daily International notes that the situation is most dire in Punjab, the country's most populous province, where 40% of the total reported violence against minority children occurred between January 2022 and September 2024. Police data cited by the report reveals that 547 Christians, 32 Hindus, two Ahmadis, and two Sikhs were among the victims, along with 99 others.
The educational system, rather than offering a path to escape, only reinforces the exclusion of religious minorities. The NCRC report slams the Single National Curriculum for its "absence of religious inclusion," forcing Christian and Hindu students to study Islamic content that contradicts their faith. Christian Daily International further highlights how this negatively affects their GPA and academic progress, creating a culture of failure and alienation.Worse still, minority students face social discrimination within schools. According to the report, both teachers and classmates often ridicule or isolate children once their religious identity is known. As per testimonies collected in the report and shared by Christian Daily International, children from oppressed caste and minority backgrounds are hesitant to sit at the front of classrooms, ask questions, or even drink water from shared glasses. They are mocked for their beliefs and told to convert to Islam to receive "divine rewards."The findings expose the brutal truth: Pakistan's minority children are not just being left behind; they are being deliberately sidelined and systemically abused.The report also draws attention to bonded labour, with Christian and Hindu children often trapped in the vicious cycle of forced work at brick kilns or in agriculture. Their families, already burdened by intergenerational poverty and discrimination, are offered little to no protection by the state.Christian Daily International underscores the NCRC's strong call for immediate reforms: legal protections against forced conversion and child marriage, inclusive education policies, and enforcement of child labour laws. However, as NCRC Chairperson Ayesha Raza Farooq acknowledged, progress has been dismal due to "fragmented efforts, lack of coordination, and limited political will."Pirbhu Lal Satyani, the NCRC's representative for minority rights in Sindh, told Christian Daily International that the report was a comprehensive effort to map the many layers of vulnerability minority children face. He described these children as "the most marginalised," facing "stigma, stereotyping, and structural exclusion."The NCRC's findings are a national shame, but the international community, including watchdogs and religious rights groups, should see them as a call to action. Pakistan has long presented itself as a nation of religious tolerance. But as this government-backed report now confirms, that narrative crumbles when confronted with the reality faced by Christian and Hindu children.Pakistan can no longer claim ignorance or denial. Its institutions have documented the crisis. The question is: will it act, or continue to be complicit?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scroll.in
an hour ago
- Scroll.in
Rahul Gandhi, Kharge among Opposition leaders detained during Bihar voter roll revision protest
Congress chief Mallikarjun Kharge and party leader Rahul Gandhi were among the Opposition members detained by the Delhi Police on Monday while they were marching to the Election Commission's office to protest against the contentious revision of voter rolls in Bihar. Congress MP Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, Shiv Sena (Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray)'s Sanjay Raut and Trinamool Congress' Sagarika Ghose were also among the leaders who were detained, ANI reported. After the police action, Rahul Gandhi told reporters that the 'truth is in front of the country'. 'This fight is not political,' he said. 'This fight is to save the Constitution. This fight is for One Man, One Vote. We want a clean, pure voters list.' The special intensive revision of the electoral rolls in Bihar was announced by the Election Commission in June. As part of the exercise, persons whose names were not on the 2003 voter list needed to submit proof of eligibility to vote. The draft roll was published on August 1, ahead of the Bihar polls expected to take place in October or November. It showed that more than 65 lakh names had been deleted from the list. The list will be revised by September after the Election Commission assesses objections and claims about the exclusion and inclusion of voters in the draft roll. The Opposition parties have been arguing that the exercise risked disenfranchising voters as they may not be able to produce the necessary documents. On Saturday, the Election Commission told the Supreme Court that it is not required under the rules to publish a list of persons excluded from Bihar's draft electoral roll. In an affidavit, the poll panel said that the rules do not require it to explain why a person's name is missing from the draft roll. The submission was made in response to a petition by the non-profit organisation Association for Democratic Reforms, which had sought a court directive for the poll panel to explain the reasons for deleting 65 lakh names from the draft electoral roll. A Scroll analysis of the data published by the Election Commission on August 1 showed that women made up 55% of voters who were excluded from Bihar's draft voter list after the revision. It also showed that five of the state's 10 districts with the largest share of Muslim population had the highest number of excluded voters. At 15.1%, Gopalganj district in western Bihar saw the highest rate of exclusion in the state. The voter list in the district's Gopalganj Assembly constituency shrunk by 18.2% – also the highest in the state.
India Today
an hour ago
- India Today
Israel has succeeded: Haunting final message of Gaza journalist killed in strike
Anas al-Sharif, who was among five Al Jazeera journalists killed in an Israeli strike on a Gaza City on Sunday, left behind an emotional will urging the world not to abandon besieged Gaza and the Palestinian people."This is my will and my final message. If these words reach you, know that Israel has succeeded in killing me and silencing my voice..." Anas al-Sharif's message, shared on X after his death, his final appeal, he urged solidarity with Palestine's 'wronged and innocent children' and called on people worldwide to 'be bridges toward the liberation of the land and its people.' He ended with: 'Do not forget Gaza And do not forget me in your sincere prayers.'This is my will and my final message. If these words reach you, know that Israel has succeeded in killing me and silencing my voice. First, peace be upon you and Allah's mercy and knows I gave every effort and all my strength to be a support and a voice for my— Anas Al-Sharif (@AnasAlSharif0) August 10, 2025 'I gave every effort and all my strength to be a support and a voice for my people, ever since I opened my eyes to life in the alleys and streets of the Jabalia refugee camp.""I entrust you with Palestine—the jewel in the crown of the Muslim world, the heartbeat of every free person in this world. I entrust you with its people, with its wronged and innocent children who never had the time to dream or live in safety and peace. Their pure bodies were crushed under thousands of tons of Israeli bombs and missiles, torn apart and scattered across the walls," his message read further."I urge you not to let chains silence you, nor borders restrain you. Be bridges toward the liberation of the land and its people, until the sun of dignity and freedom rises over our stolen homeland. I entrust you to take care of my family. I entrust you with my beloved daughter Sham, the light of my eyes, whom I never got the chance to watch grow up as I had dreamed," he a longing to return with his family to his ancestral town of occupied Asqalan (Al-Majdal), he said, 'Allah's will came first, and His decree is final.' He called for the care of his wife, two children, and mother, adding, 'If I die, I die steadfast upon my principles.'The X posts end note said that Anas had requested this letter, written on April 6, to be published upon his was among five journalists — alongside Mohamed Qraiqea, Ibrahim Dahir, Moumin Alaywa and Mohammed Noufal — killed in Sunday's strike. According to the Gaza Media Office, at least 237 journalists have been killed since the start of Israel's military campaign on October 7, 2023.- EndsMust Watch
The Print
2 hours ago
- The Print
Seven reasons why Rahul Gandhi's voter fraud claim must be taken with a pinch of salt
While it is fair for Gandhi to point out what may be problematic with one Lok Sabha result, where the BJP won with a margin of 32,707 votes, it is quite unreasonable to allege that the BJP and the ECI were in cahoots. The BJP candidate, PC Mohan, won the seat with a 2.5 per cent margin in a constituency where over 13 lakh votes were cast in the Lok Sabha elections. While the Election Commission of India (ECI) has demanded a signed oath saying all the details provided by him were true, it would do well to actually check out the claims, regardless of the Gandhi scion's arrogant claim that his statement in public constitutes an oath. At the very least, this would show that ECI is not afraid of scrutiny and correcting mistakes—which are sure to exist. Or else, why initiate a SIR in Bihar? An SIR is the only realistic way of validating genuine voters and chucking out the rest. If there can be over one lakh alleged 'fake' voters in just one assembly constituency, potentially deleting 65 lakh voters from the Bihar list hardly sounds unreasonable. Rahul Gandhi's 'atom bomb' provides us with the best justification for a nationwide Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls—a process that the Congress and most opposition parties have opposed in Bihar. Speaking in Bengaluru on Thursday, 7 August, he provided what he claimed was evidence proving the existence of over one lakh fake voters in Mahadevapura in Bengaluru Central Lok Sabha constituency. Re-examining fake voters claim Gandhi's broader claim, that the Bengaluru Central result was tantamount to vote-stealing, must be taken with a pinch of salt. He picked the one constituency with a significant number of Muslim voters, and polarisation and counter-polarisation are normal here. He must re-examine his premises for several reasons. First, it is facile to assume that all the 1,00,250 'fake voters' had gone to the BJP. No one can prove that. The caveat is that not all may be fakes, and not all votes may have been cast either. Second, according to Gandhi's analysis, 11,965 'fake voters' were duplicates with names in other states, 40,009 had invalid addresses, 10,452 were bulk voters registered at a single address, 33,692 first-time voters had misused form 6 (used to register first-time voters or make corrections), and 4,132 voter cards did not have valid photos. In Bihar, out of the proposed deletions, 22 lakh were reported deceased, 35 lakh were migrants who may have shifted permanently out of Bihar, and another 7 lakh had their names in multiple state voter lists (ie, the equivalent of Rahul Gandhi's 'duplicate' voters). The Bihar list of likely exclusions hardly sounds unreasonable, but Gandhi won't acknowledge that. Third, the claim that the BJP won the Bengaluru Central seat only because of huge gains in the Mahadevapura (one of eight assembly segments in the Lok Sabha seat, where the BJP won four and the Congress the other four) is questionable. Mahadevapura, despite having many minority voters, has large numbers of migrants and middle-class voters from other states working in the IT services sector. The voter list must indeed be investigated, but it is worth pointing out two realities: these voters usually tend to vote BJP, and Mahadevapura is a BJP stronghold. And if a sharp swing toward one party in one constituency is evidence of possible fraud, then what does one make of the Dhule Lok Sabha result in Maharashtra? In 2024, the BJP led significantly in five assembly constituencies there, but lost badly in the Muslim-dominated Malegaon Central, where the Congress' lead of a massive 1.9 lakh votes was enough to give it a marginal victory despite losing five other assembly segments. Polarisation can lead to such skews. Fourth, while the Congress is at liberty to make its point using the best means at its disposal, any neutral observer cannot ignore this: it chose the one constituency with a large Muslim voter base (around 3.5 lakh), and fielded a Muslim candidate (Rizwan Arshad) to harvest a bulk of minority vote. In the last three elections, the Congress candidate here has always been Muslim, and each time a counter-consolidation helped PC Mohan win, though with declining margins between 2014, 2019, and 2024. Counter-consolidation in Mahadevapura can easily explain Mohan's victory, even assuming there were many fake votes. Given a significant number of illegal Bangladeshi immigrants, the possibility that some of them were also 'fake' voters in the constituency is difficult to dismiss. Fifth, as I have noted in an earlier article, voter lists—both additions and deletions—are supervised by temporary staff on loan from state governments. Therefore, there's a good chance that lists can be partially manipulated. Party workers (not just BJP, but also Congress) also tend to work closely with the ECI to get their bloc of voters registered. This may skew the lists in one direction or the other. In 2018, a Congress MLA was linked to the discovery of 9,896 voter ID cards in an apartment in Bengaluru's Jalahalli. Both BJP and Congress traded accusations against each other for being responsible for this. Sixth, voter lists can never be totally accurate, given the large number of people moving to the richer southern states for jobs and livelihoods (not to speak of the porous border states of Bihar and West Bengal). Many migrant voters may have trouble showing address proof, which may explain why some addresses may have multiple (even 80) voters registered there. These days, Aadhaar is required in many situations, and for migrants, it makes sense to use a fixed, available address to have their Aadhaar cards delivered. Additionally, when people move from city to city, they may change their voter IDs, but the old IDs may not be deleted. Hence, the possibility of multiple voter IDs remaining on the ECI's books. Seventh, the state and national voter rolls are often left unreconciled, which makes regular deletions or additions difficult to ensure. Also read: Opposition MPs to march from Parliament to ECI office despite no police nod Not malice but incompetence We can conclude the following from Rahul Gandhi's 'atom bomb'. One, there is a problem with voter lists, and fake voters can get onto those lists, but there is no reason to assume that it happened only in favour of one party in one constituency and one state. We should not attribute to malice or malign intent what can easily be explained by the Election Commission's lack of resources and local-level failures or even incompetence. Two, the Election Commission cannot endlessly field accusations about aiding election fraud, whether it is about EVMs or fake voters, without damaging its own credibility. Maybe, just maybe, there can be some kind of parliamentary scrutiny of its actions, scrutiny that does not impinge on its independence. A bipartisan law that ensures the Commission's independence and helps it carry out its duties impartially is the need of the hour. Three, the Election Commission probably needs a larger permanent staff to ensure that it is not solely dependent on state-level part-time officials who may have political leanings. Recently, when the Election Commission ordered the West Bengal Chief Secretary to suspend four electoral registration officers and file FIRs against them for enabling bogus voters to get onto the list, Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee fulminated against the order and said she won't allow it. She also reminded block-level officers doing the Commission's work that they are state employees, and not the Election Commission's, which amounts to intimidation of staff working temporarily for the Commission. The Election Commission cannot be expected to produce a foolproof list if state governments have the power to threaten officials working for the Commission. What is good about Rahul Gandhi's 'atom bomb' is that it has alerted us to the possibility of fake voters and how they may tilt close contests. However, nothing can be achieved by pretending that this is solely the work of the BJP or the Election Commission. All parties are complicit in this fraud, and should fix things while they can still be fixed. The Election Commission and the Modi government would do well to take heed and act instead of merely scoring political points against the Gandhi scion. R Jagannathan is the former editorial director, Swarajya magazine. He tweets @TheJaggi. Views are personal. (Edited by Ratan Priya)
