
Is the India-Pakistan conflict spilling over to Australia and could it get worse?
Samina Yasmeen, a Pakistani-Australian and a professor at the University of Western Australia, said "some tension among some sections" of the community has already emerged. "There are some sections of the community that probably are active in this space where they're looking at the other side, whether it's India or Pakistan, as the enemy, and then talking about it," she told SBS News. "But if we look at it broadly, the South Asian community in Australia has traditionally been very friendly and cooperative towards each other."
People born in India and Pakistan make up a huge part of Australia's multicultural community. About 670,000 people in Australia were born in India, while there were almost 90,000 who were born in Pakistan, according to the 2021 Census. Some Indian community leaders have also said that, since the tensions have increased, they haven't observed a general sign of tension between these two communities. "They have been sensible. There has not been major commentary about this matter except for rare occasions or rare people," Yadu Singh, a spokesperson of the Federation of Indian Associations of NSW, told SBS News. He's concerned that, should tensions between India and Pakistan escalate into an "all-out" war, things could change in Australia.
"There is a real risk, real potential that those tensions in that part of the world may end up coming here," Singh said. "And communities involved from both countries may have protests ... And that may inflame the situation. And therefore, [a] confrontation situation can arise."
While there have not been any major protests by either community about the conflict, tension has been visible online. Some have made social media posts calling on their compatriots to boycott goods from the other side. Others urge store owners not to stock items produced in the other country. Nadeem, a founder of an Indian community group on Facebook, said he has witnessed these posts. "Australia is home to vibrant Indian, Pakistani and South Asian communities ... All my life, I've seen Indian, Pakistani, and all of them are working together," he told SBS News. "But whenever these things happen, it does create a bit of division. "South Asian people, we are very emotional, and whatever happens back home, it just affects the community here as well."
SBS News has seen a WhatsApp message sent to an Indian-Australian from their home country, which warns that Indians in Australia will have to "co-exist with Pakistanis who are increasingly going to get hostile". Yasmeen believes that, while those responsible for such posts and messages may be small in number, they "can definitely be louder" than other members of their communities. "Because we live in such a cyber-filled life these days, they can be very loud on social media, and that's where they can try and recruit others who follow their narrative," she explained. "In international politics and also in terms of social cohesion, it's really the role of narratives as they start emerging, as they start being shared by people, they change the views of the people who are exposed to those narratives."
Concerns are growing among the community leaders and experts like Yasmeen that the rising tension between countries may potentially affect social cohesion — a principle that Australian community leaders and politicians have increasingly stressed in recent times. "Generally, social cohesion is about how a society can trust each other and we can have common goals and common values and principles that we can we can call ourselves a community," Rojan Afrouz, a senior lecturer in social work at RMIT University, told SBS News. Given the multicultural makeup of Australia, war and conflicts overseas may impact the index. "Different groups here, obviously still have some kind of intergenerational understanding of their identity and also the conflict in their origin country and in their homeland," Afrouz explained. "What's going on in their homeland will definitely impact how they will react to that context, and also how they will react to their intergenerational understanding of conflict ... Obviously, all of those will impact the sense of community, trusting each other." In August 2024, Mike Burgess, director-general of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation, said that the war in Gaza had "undermined social cohesion" in Australia.
Both Indian and Pakistani community leaders are calling for members of the diaspora to preserve social cohesion in Australia while their home countries are under attack. "It does require all the communities to work together to make sure that instead of promoting the narrative of hatred, we actually get together and say it's time to stop the hostilities," Yasmeen said. Singh echoes her sentiment. "All of us are part of multicultural Australia. We all love Australia," he said. "We should not bring overseas foreign matters to the shores of Australia because this is a country which we all belong to." World Australia India Mike Burgess
Share this with family and friends
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
Labor commits $1.3bn to counter-drone capabilities
The Albanese government is earmarking $1.3bn over the next decade for counter-drone capabilities as part of a program to protect Australia from 'future threats'. Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) are central to 21st century warfare and only becoming cheaper, smaller, smarter and deadlier. It is part of Project Land 156 which involves the creation of systems that can find and stop enemy drones. Announcing the funding on Tuesday, Defence Industry Minister Pat Conroy said Labor had already issued contracts 'totalling $38.7m to 20 vendors', nearly doubling the number initially awarded in July. Australian companies make up 14 of the vendors. 'Under those contracts, and accelerated testing, at least 120 of the world's most capable threat detectors and drone-defeating technologies will be rapidly introduced into use,' Mr Conroy told the Queensland Media Club. 'The technology is evolving rapidly and we are moving with it. 'So, today, I can reveal that the Albanese Government has set aside $1.3bn for acquisition of counter-drone capabilities over the next 10 years.' He said the Albanese government would 'announce further counter-drone acquisitions in the very near future as part of Land 156' and that small and medium-sized enterprises 'are at the heart of this project'. 'I can also reveal that under Land 156, we have adopted a continuous modernisation model,' Mr Conroy said, calling it 'critical'. 'It means that the investments we make today … can help protect against potential future threats.' He went on to say that in Ukraine 'we've observed that it when it comes to drones, the cycle of adaptation and counter adaptation is around three to six months'. 'So, through Project Land 156, the (Australian Defence Force) will continually upgrade and refresh capabilities to address emerging drone threats,' Mr Conroy said. The $1.3bn will come from the $10bn already committed to the program over the next decade. Mr Conroy said it would ensure Australia stayed ahead 'in the uncrewed capability race'. Though, he also said it was 'not just about defence bases and defence assets', but that there were civil uses too. He pointed to the 2032 Brisbane Olympic Games as an example. The focus on drones comes as tensions simmer in the Indo-Pacific. The Trump administration has warned of an 'imminent' threat from China, saying Beijing was eyeing a move on Taiwan as early as 2027.

Sky News AU
an hour ago
- Sky News AU
Opposition attacks Albanese government for 'badly mismanaging' Israel ties as feud exposes deep divisions over Palestine
The federal opposition has accused the Albanese government of mismanaging the Australia-Israel relationship after a spiralling diplomatic row sunk ties to new lows. Both countries have issued visa cancellations against each other in a tit-for-tat retaliation, after the Albanese government decided to recognise Palestinian statehood. Israel revoked the visas of Australian diplomats to the Palestinian Authority, after the Albanese government cancelled an Israeli lawmaker's visa. Shadow Foreign Affairs Minister Michaelia Cash said the decision to cancel the visa of Israeli MP Simcha Rothman had triggered 'escalating diplomatic consequences'. The federal opposition has accused the Albanese government of mismanaging the Australia-Israel relationship after a spiralling diplomatic row sunk ties to new lows. 'The Albanese government has badly mismanaged this relationship at a time when careful diplomacy is more important than ever,' Ms Cash said. 'Instead of maintaining trust with Israel - one of our closest democratic allies - Labor has recklessly inflamed tensions and undermined Australia's credibility. The government cancelled Mr Rothman's visa, claiming he made inflammatory remarks that would jeopardise the safety of the Australian Islamic community. 'The Coalition has serious concerns about the Albanese government's reasons for cancelling the visa of Israeli parliamentarian Simcha Rothman,' Ms Cash said. 'It is extraordinary that Home Affairs documents, as reported in the media, reveal the stated reasons for blocking Mr Rothman's entry into Australia was in part his advocacy for the elimination of Hamas.' The Australian newspaper revealed on Tuesday that Mr Rothman was denied his visa over concerns his presence could spark counter-protests. Internal Home Affairs documents said his calls to eliminate Hamas would be considered 'inflammatory and concerning', according to the report. This comes despite the fact that Hamas has been listed as a terrorist organisation responsible for murdering thousands of innocent civilians. 'To suggest that calls for the destruction of Hamas are 'inflammatory' or grounds for visa cancellation is absurd,' Ms Cash said. She lamented that the government had 'badly mismanaged this relationship at a time when careful diplomacy is more important than ever'. Opposition Leader Sussan Ley also condemned the handling of the issue, saying the rejection of Mr Rothman's visa was 'a very unusual thing'. 'I really regret the way that the relationship between the Albanese government and the government of Israel is deteriorating,' Ms Ley told reporters on Tuesday. 'Israel is a liberal democracy in the Middle East, and we should be supporting them as that liberal democracy. 'It's a very unusual thing to refuse a visa, and I haven't seen explanations from Tony Burke that actually explain what is going on here.' Ms Ley did not confirm whether she believed Mr Rothman should be allowed into Australia, but said the reasons for his denial need to be made public. 'We need the Minister for Home Affairs to explain… disagreeing with the Albanese government is not a reason to refuse a visa,' she said. The opposition's attack followed Foreign Minister Penny Wong calling Israel's move to revoke Australian visas as an 'unjustified reaction' to recognising Palestine as a state. 'At a time when dialogue and diplomacy are needed more than ever, the Netanyahu government is isolating Israel,' Ms Wong said on Tuesday. 'This is an unjustified reaction, following Australia's decision to recognise Palestine.' Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Saar confirmed that the visas of Australian representatives to the Palestinian Authority had been revoked. Like many countries, Australia maintains an embassy to Israel in Tel Aviv and a representative office to the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank city of Ramallah. The row has left Australia more deeply entangled in the Middle Eastern conflict, with both sides trading blame and domestic opinion divided. Polling for The Sydney Morning Herald showed only 24 per cent of voters supported recognition of Palestine regardless of who held power in Gaza. Thirty-two per cent favoured waiting until Hamas was removed or Palestine recognised Israel's right to exist. Forty-four per cent opposed any change to Australia's current position.

News.com.au
2 hours ago
- News.com.au
Liberal backbencher Garth Hamilton says Australia should pay jobless migrants to leave Australia
Queensland MP Garth Hamilton says Australia should consider paying jobless migrants up to $9000 to leave the country as a way of curtailing rising immigration levels. The Liberal backbencher said the policy was not politically divisive, and said similar approached had worked in 'left-wing governments in the EU' like France, Germany, Switzerland and Belgium. Quoting figures between $6000 to $9000, he said the payment would 'give people a pathway home' and labelled the move as a 'reasonably compassionate and fair approach'. 'The reality is, a lot of migrants who are coming over here aren't finding work, they aren't finding their housing,' he told 2GB on Tuesday. 'They aren't finding that things were as rosy as they'd hoped because of the high immigration policies that we've employed, things haven't quite been working out.' He said high immigration was impacting housing availability, rent, lines at hospitals and schools and warned Australia needed to 'address it now'. Speaking directly on the housing crisis, he said: 'We're not going to build our way out of this problem'. Mr Hamilton said an urgent response was warranted, given that any cuts to immigration would not 'solve the immediate problem now and today'. 'If all we do … is just cut the rate of immigration, that'll help a bit down the track, but it won't solve the immediate problem now and today,' he said. 'And I want to point out, this isn't some right wing solution. All of the governments that deploy this are pretty much left wing, France, Germany, Switzerland, Belgium. 'So this is about left or right. This is about putting the citizens of the country first'. Net overseas migration decreased by 16.7 per cent in 2023-24 to 446,000, however figures remain significantly above pre-Covid rates of 247,620 recorded in December 2019. While a Dutton-Coalition government went to the May polls pledging to slash net overseas migration by 100,000, Labor has forecast a decline to 225,000 in 2026-27. As it stands the Coalition are yet to cement their policy position on immigration amid a review into the area.