Palestine pulled
And now to the chorus of international condemnation of Israel last week to which our freshly re-elected prime minister lent his voice:
ANTHONY ALBANESE: Well, Israel's actions are completely unacceptable. It is outrageous that there be a blockade of food and supplies to people who are in need in Gaza.
- ABC, 26 May 2025
Anthony Albanese accused the Netanyahu government of choking off food and vital supplies to a war-ravaged people whose desperation and hunger were on full display last week:
FERGAL KEANE: An agony that cannot be denied.
DOCTOR: This is [inaudible], he is 5 years old.
FERGAL KEANE: Today a British doctor captured these images in the pediatric ward at Nasser hospital …
DOCTOR: Skin and bone.
REPORTER: There was abundant aid that could have helped them. But nearly three months of Israeli blockade kept it out of Gaza …
- BBC News, 26 May 2025
Pictures like these which have hardened opinion even further against the government of Israel and prompted diplomatic protests from across Europe, the UK and Canada. Last Monday the Prime Minister ratcheted up the rhetoric too:
ANTHONY ALBANESE: People are starving and the idea that a democratic state withholds supply is an outrage.
- ABC, 26 May 2025
The ABC carried those remarks in its news bulletins across the day before inviting Nasser Mashni, President of the Australian Palestine Advocacy Network, to come on air to respond.
In the four minute interview which followed he pushed for a stronger response to the carnage on the ground:
NASSER MASHNI: It's a rogue state. It's time to treat it that way. And that includes sanctions, includes recalling our ambassador, expelling the Israeli ambassador ...
- ABC News Channel, 26 May 2025
Combining serious critiques with inflammatory invective which it should be said was met with inadequate challenge:
NASSER MASHNI: … the space that Israel inhabited on October 6th has disappeared. The milk's been spilt. Israel never gets to go back to being that normal country again.
- ABC News Channel, 26 May 2025
Within half an hour of the interview in which the ABC claims Mashni was factually wrong on one point, it was posted on iview and on the ABC website.
But try and watch it now and this is what you find because within two hours of the video going up it was taken back down prompting accusations by the advocate that:
'… This appears to be another instance of Palestinian voices being silenced.'
- Crikey, 27 May 2025
So why was the video removed?
Was it as a frenzied internet believed the result of pro-Israel lobbying? Or the intervention by a cowed ABC executive?
None of the above. The video was pulled because it was originally designated to not run online in the first place.
The original content was done as a live-to-air interview as part of broader coverage and was not intended to be published as a stand-alone clip. It was mistakenly uploaded and when that was noticed it was taken down.
- Email, ABC Spokesperson, 28 May 2025
This clumsy error has inflamed already intense scrutiny on the public broadcaster's handling of the conflict.
And it comes amid a new flashpoint with Benjamin Netanyahu desperate to cling to power having launched a new phase of the war and being accused of using a US-backed aid program as a bargaining chip while Hamas, which continues to hold dozens of hostages, and is accused by Israel of threatening those who assist.
The result? Yet more bloodshed.
And for those who resile from Nasser Mashni's criticisms of Netanyahu, they might consider them in light of these words from one of Israel's most steadfast defenders and a former prime minister:
What we are doing in Gaza now is a war of devastation: indiscriminate, limitless, cruel and criminal killing of civilians …
It is time to halt, before we are all banished from the family of nations and are summoned to the International Criminal Court for war crimes, with no good defense.
Enough is enough.
- Haaretz, 27 May 2025
And this is why deleting a pro-Palestinian voice from your website, even if it was posted by error, will inevitably be seen as censorship.
Indeed, it's so very telling that the ABC received no complaints about the interview itself but more than a hundred about the decision to remove it.
We see no reason why the interview cannot be reposted online perhaps with an editor's note to address any errors or shortcomings and allow audiences to make up their own minds.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
18 minutes ago
- News.com.au
The next Robert Toia? Players set to step up to NRL
These are some of the names that could soon step up from rugby league's lower grades into the big time.
News.com.au
18 minutes ago
- News.com.au
‘He's bleeding': Police footage reveals moment after street punch
Shocking body-worn footage shown to a jury captures the moment police found a father of two unconscious and bleeding, minutes after he was allegedly punched by a former rugby league player during a street altercation. Oshae Jackson Tuiasau, 29, has pleaded not guilty in the Brisbane Supreme Court to unlawfully striking 39-year-old Toro George, who died in hospital eight days after the alleged attack on December 19, 2021, in Surfers Paradise. Mr Tuiasau, a former Gold Coast Titans player and Queensland under 20 representative, claims he acted in self-defence during an escalating early morning altercation. Police body-worn camera footage played to the jury showed Mr George unconscious and slumped on a seat as officers questioned the group he had been with. 'What happened to him, he's bleeding,' one officer asked, before another checked Mr George's pulse and confirming he was still alive. Police then laid him down on the bench, with one officer, who continually monitored Mr George's condition, describing his pulse as going 'a hundred miles an hour'. 'A big thump, thump, thump, thump,' the officer said in the footage. 'Got an ambulance coming for you, mate,' he added. The officer can also be heard saying, 'It looks like he's gasping for air. 'He's got blood pouring out of his nose too.' About four minutes later, the officer reported he could no longer detect a pulse. 'I think his pulse is gone … yep,' he said. The officers quickly moved Mr George onto the ground, ripped open his shirt and began CPR. Witness Odain Marsters told police at the time that Mr George had simply collapsed, while another family member, Lekisha Marsters, repeated the same story. Under questioning, Mr Marsters admitted that he had not been truthful. 'I thought that he was going to be all right, I didn't want things to get more serious,' he said. Mr Marsters said he urged the group not to speak to police until they had 'clear heads'. The jury was told that Mr George's fatal injury came after a night of escalating tension sparked by a sexual assault allegation at Havana RnB Nightclub. Earlier in the evening, a young woman told the court that she had been celebrating her 19th birthday when a man, later identified as Mr George, allegedly touched her inappropriately on the dance floor. 'A male touched me inappropriately … in my crotch area,' she said. 'His hand started above my belly button and was pushed against my tummy and went down to my vagina.' She said she didn't consent to it. The woman said she immediately told her brother, who then confronted Mr George. 'I went up to him straight away and grabbed him,' the brother told the court. He said they were 'mouthing off' at each other and Mr George started laughing, which made him 'more angry'. CCTV footage captured the resulting confrontation on the nightclub floor that quickly escalated as others became involved and security moved in to break up the fight. The footage showed pushing and growing tensions between two groups. Mr George's cousin, Junior Marsters, testified that he had also heard rumours that Mr George had 'touched' a woman and confronted him, but Mr George denied it. After being told to leave by security, the groups gathered outside the nightclub before police arrived and separated the parties. Detective Sergeant Michael Bradley, who was rostered in the safe night precinct that night, said his team dispersed the crowd and walked Mr George, Ms Marsters and Odain Marsters away from the club. 'We tried to keep all parties separate,' Sergeant Bradley told the court. Body-worn camera footage showed the trio walking casually to a set of traffic lights, laughing and appearing to be in good spirits. They then encountered another group, which included Mr Tuiasau, but everyone told police they were fine, and officers let them go. 'There was no aggression whatsoever,' Sergeant Bradley said. Junior Marsters, along with other members of the group, testified that Mr George and Mr Tuiasau had shaken hands and made peace. 'He apologised … (Tuiasau) accepted the apology,' Mr Marsters told the court. After letting the group go on their way, Sergeant Bradley said moments later a member of the public alerted police to an incident in the direction the group had walked. When officers arrived, they found Mr George unconscious on a bench, surrounded by the group. An officer initially found a pulse, but Mr George's heart soon stopped, prompting police to begin CPR before paramedics arrived. Earlier in the trial, the jury viewed CCTV footage showing the moment Mr George was allegedly struck. The court was told that after parting ways with the officers, tensions flared again as the group walked through Surfers Paradise just before 4am. As the group continued walking, Mr George became increasingly agitated, insisting on returning to find his brothers. Witnesses said he was speaking loudly in a mix of Cook Island Maori and English, while CCTV footage showed shoving between him and other members of the group. Mr Tuiasau, who appeared uninvolved in the physical exchanges, was walking on the far side of the group. The footage showed Mr George leaning toward him before Mr Tuiasau suddenly struck him once in the face. Mr George fell backwards and hit his head on the pavement. He immediately lost consciousness. In court, Mr George's widow Arden George became visibly distressed when the footage was played, turning away and crying. Family members audibly gasped when the blow was shown for the first time. Ms Marsters described being in disbelief, seeing her uncle fall to the ground. 'I was in shock … I tried to help him up to get him on to the chair,' she said. Odain Marsters told the court that Mr Tuiasau said 'that is what you get' after the punch. Ms Marsters said she did not hear that remark. Under cross-examination, both admitted they initially told police that Mr George had simply fallen and hit his head. They did not explain why they had not told the truth at the time. Another witness, Dylan Thoroughgood, a friend of the Marsters family who was with the group that night, also admitted to lying in his initial statement to police. 'I didn't want to be involved in something like this,' he said. 'I didn't know he was going to pass away.' Under cross-examination, he answered 'yes' when asked if he lied because he knew some of the group had taken cocaine and to also protect Mr George, who had become angry leading up to the punch. However, when questioned at other times about why he lied, he would also say, 'I don't know'. Mr Tuiasau was arrested at 4.30am and interviewed later that morning at the Southport watch house. In the recorded interview played to the jury, he admitted to throwing the punch. 'I looked at him and then I, I hit him … I punched him,' he told police. 'It was a good night … up until the very end.' He said he had been drinking throughout the night and felt 'triggered' after hearing what Mr George had allegedly done to someone he knew. Crown prosecutor Toby Corsbie told the court that Mr Tuiasau had lashed out after learning of the alleged assault, but the punch was a 'single moment in time, a single choice' that caused Mr George's heart to stop. Mr Tuiasau's barrister, Craig Eberhardt KC, argued that his client acted in self-defence against 'a drunk and aggressive man who had already sexually assaulted a woman that night'. 'It is tragic that he died,' Mr Eberhardt told the court. He said some of the witnesses were not being truthful in their accounts of what happened that night.
News.com.au
18 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Froling Eyes Remarkable NBL Comeback After Dodging Death
Reigning NBL champion the Illawarra Hawks are eyeing an inspirational Harry Froling comeback after the big man suffered a horrific one-punch attack
