Father denies shaking baby with injuries ‘equivalent to car crash'
A 31-year-old man has denied ever shaking his five-month-old daughter, causing her to suffer a brain bleed and other serious injuries, as he claimed that earlier statements admitting that he had shaken her and dropped her accidentally were both lies.
The accused, who can't be named to protect the identity of his child, took the stand at Cork Circuit Criminal Court on Tuesday and said that he had lied both to medics at Cork University Hospital (CUH), social workers and gardaí when he made statements about how his daughter came to be injured.
The couple had brought the baby to CUH on January 4th, 2021, where doctors diagnosed that a bleed on the brain, bleeding at the back of her eyes and soft tissue injuries near her spine were consistent with abusive head trauma or shaken baby syndrome, but the couple could not explain the injuries.
The man later told social workers at CUH on January 7th that he had accidentally dropped the baby at their home on December 7th, 2020, while later on January 7th he told consultant paediatrician Dr Rosina McGovern that he had also accidentally dropped the baby at home on January 4th.
READ MORE
The man had said the first fall occurred when he was winding the child on his shoulder, and she toppled and fell on to a sofa before landing on the wooden floor, while the second fall happened when he tripped near the top of the stairs and the baby fell from his arms on to the landing.
But on Tuesday, when cross-examined by prosecution counsel Jane Hyland SC, the man said both statements were false but said he made them after his partner's mother suggested that he do it, as CUH staff were not allowing them to take the child home until they found out what happened to her.
'Dr McGovern told me the injuries were the equivalent to a car crash and if we tried to leave the hospital, security would be called . . . somebody I trusted (his partner's mother) then suggested it would be a good idea to tell them I dropped her,' he said.
He initially told the social worker he had dropped the child on the sofa, and she fell on the floor on December 6th but when Dr McGovern said the child's injuries could not have resulted from such a fall, he made up a story that she fell a second time on January 4th at the top of the stairs.
Asked by Ms Hyland why then he sought a meeting with a Tusla social worker and told her on March 23rd that he had actually shaken the baby on two separate occasions, the man said that he feared that if one of them didn't admit shaking the baby, they would lose custody of the child.
He said they had been given supervised access to their child by Tusla at her grandmother's home, but his partner was pregnant and not eating, and he was worried about her so he decided to say that he had shaken the infant and would take the blame so his partner could be reunited with the child.
He had told the Tusla social worker that he was at home alone with the infant in her highchair on December 7th and was cooking when the smoke alarm went off and the child started to cry, and he took the child and shook her back and forth for a few seconds until she stopped crying.
And he had said that on the second occasion, on the morning of January 4th, that he was again at home alone with the child and made her breakfast and they had gone back to bed, and he had fallen asleep, but the child woke up crying in her cot and he had again shaken her.
Asked by Ms Hyland if the story about the accidental falls amounted to the third set of lies that he had told about what happened to his daughter, the man said that he would say 'it was the same lie that I just kept going . . . yeah, I told lies [but] to get my daughter back.'
The case continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
39 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Trucker arrested after €1m cannabis find told gardaí: ‘I'll smoke it tomorrow', court hears
'I'll smoke it tomorrow,' a lorry driver allegedly found transporting more than €1 million worth of cannabis told investigating gardaí, a court has heard. Andrew Cooley (32) from Ballyoran, Dundalk, Co Louth, was arrested at Dublin Port at 1.45am on Saturday driving a truck that had arrived on a boat from Holyhead. The father of two was charged with unlawful possession of 55.4kg of cannabis, with an estimated value of €1,108,000, for the purpose of sale or supply. On Monday, he appeared at Dublin District Court where Garda Dylan Mallon objected to bail due to flight risk concerns. READ MORE The garda alleged a customs officer engaged with Mr Cooley and smelled cannabis coming from the truck. A search of the cab allegedly led to finding black bags covered by clothes. The contested bail hearing was told there were 31 black packages allegedly containing cannabis. Gardaí took Mr Cooley to Store Street station and interviewed him several times. It was alleged he admitted ownership and told gardaí: 'I'll smoke it tomorrow.' The garda feared the accused would evade justice because he had travelled to Europe multiple times as a driver, and his work was transferable. Defence solicitor Luke Staines said information from his client's employer showed Mr Cooley had never gone to continental Europe and had only travelled in Ireland and England. The defence stressed that Mr Cooley has ties to Ireland and has children here, while there was nothing to suggest he would leave the jurisdiction. Mr Staines said his client could face two years on remand until his trial. The solicitor told the court the driver would obey conditions and furnish a satisfactory address. Judge Michele Finan reserved her decision on the bail application until Friday. She granted legal aid.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Alison Healy on how a 19-year old woman tricked the world with a literary hoax
The news desk of the New York Times had a bountiful harvest of stories to choose from on June 4th, 1926. Its front page features a story about the Crown Prince Gustav and Crown Princess Louise of Sweden stopping by the laboratory of Thomas Edison in New Jersey. He told the prince he had come up with a record that could play for 40 minutes and to prove it, he played I'll Take You Home Again Kathleen to the impressed royals. He also whipped a strip of film from his pocket and handed it to the prince, telling him it was a motion picture. Also on the front page is a story about a theatrical producer sentenced to prison over a case involving a bathtub on a stage that contained alcohol – this was the era of Prohibition of course. And in something that could have come straight out of an Agatha Christie novel, there's a report about a suspected gem thief who was arrested outside the Ritz and found to have had $30,000 worth of jewels in a secret compartment of her handbag. But most interesting of all for Irish readers is the headline 'Girl Tricks World with Literary Hoax intended as Joke'. A sub-heading explains that 'Magdalen King-Hall of Erin's Wild North Coast Wrote of Paris and Venice of Long Ago'. READ MORE The newspaper scoop explains how 'a little Irish girl, the 19-year-old daughter of a British naval officer, has accomplished the greatest literary hoax of the century'. Magdalen King-Hall, who was living in Portaferry, Co Down at the time, was the secret hand behind a best-selling sensation. The Diary of a Young Lady of Fashion in the Year 1764-1765 was published in 1925 and was purported to be the discovered diary of Cleone Knox from Castle Kearney, Co Down. It reads like the mid-18th century version of Bridget Jones' Diary, with a mild hint of Sex in the City and a sprinkle of Jane Austen thrown in for good measure. Conveniently, the foreword explains there is no portrait or miniature of Cleone Knox because of a fire at Castle Kearney in 1808. The diary opens with her beau, the handsome rogue David Ancaster, falling from the ivy as he attempts to gain entry to her bedroom late one night. Papa finds him prostrate on the ground and there is hell to pay. She's not too bothered though as she adds that she 'Tried on my new striped silk gown which becomes me excessively well.' To avoid any more amorous indiscretions, Papa takes Cleone and her brother Ned away on a grand European tour. She finds herself in a series of humorous predicaments, administering a sound box on the ears to a drunken suitor, and falling off the chair with tiredness when a hostess insists on reading from Milton's Paradise Lost for three hours. Like an olde world Forrest Gump, she meets everyone who matters. In France, she's presented to the king and queen at Versailles. She finds the queen to be dowdy and the royal daughters plain and clumsy while King Louis XV is handsome but dissolute. In Switzerland, Voltaire receives her family in a chintz dressing-gown and reminds her of a 'chattering old magpie'. Her brother runs off with a nun in Venice which makes her wonder if there are not enough loose women in Venice 'without him ravishing a cloistered nun'. The diary ends abruptly with the surprise appearance of David Ancaster in Venice. We are informed that they eloped, married and lived happily ever after in Co Down with their brood of 12 children. Recalling the hoax diary on the King-Hall family website, Magdalen King-Hall's late son Richard Perceval Maxwell wrote that The Sunday Times had published a long and enthusiastic review of the book and lauded it as a great find, similar to the Pepys diaries. 'One reader, Winston Churchill…excused his late arrival at a dinner party by saying he had had to finish the Diary before coming,' he wrote. Six months after the bestseller was published, Magdalen King-Hall admitted her deception, thus further boosting sales. She was bored and had written it to pass the time. She also pointed to an error that could have blown her cover – her diarist was reading Walpole's Castle of Otrantoe a few months before the book was published. Happily for readers, Magdalen King-Hall put her lively imagination to great effect in later life, becoming a journalist and successful author. The mid-1920s were no barrel of laughs, with Hitler publishing Mein Kampf and Mussolini becoming a dictator, but, for a short and glorious time, Magdalen King-Hall added greatly to the gaiety of the nation.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Garda not planning to invest in full-time cadaver dog, despite Minister's preference
Cadaver dogs, used to find human remains, are very rarely needed by the Garda and the force has no plans to invest in having dogs available full-time, Garda Commissioner Drew Harris has said. This is despite remarks at the weekend by Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan, who said it would be 'preferable' if the Garda had its own dog in light of developments in the Tina Satchwell murder investigation. The commissioner said that in his near seven-year tenure as commissioner, he believed a cadaver dog had been used three times, with those dogs provided from Northern Ireland. While the Garda does 'not want to be entirely reliant on others', having a cadaver dog is a significant resource, especially as it would be rarely used in the Republic. 'A cadaver dog is not out every day working in the same way that a drugs or firearms or money dog would be, it's a very specialist resource,' he said, adding that even within the area of working dogs, these animals are 'specialist'. READ MORE When asked if a cadaver dog should have been deployed to help find the Satchwell remains in the period immediately after she was reported missing in 2017, the commissioner said the murder investigation is being reviewed. 'But from what I know from the reports I've seen ... the suspicion was harm had been caused to Tina Satchwell, but there was no suspicion that her body was actually there [in her home].' Satchwell, née Dingivan (45), was murdered by her husband Richard Satchwell at their home on Grattan Street, Youghal, on March 19th-20th, 2017, and her body was buried under the house in a deep grave. However, her remains were not found until October 2013, some 6½ years later. Though the Satchwell house was searched in 2017, a cadaver dog was not used. However, when a dog was deployed during a search of the house in 2023 it focused on the area under the sittingroom stairs, where the body was later found. Asked on RTÉ's This Week programme whether such a dog should have been brought into the Satchwell home in 2017 during the investigation, the Mr O'Callaghan said 'probably, it should have happened'. He said he spoke to the commissioner about the effectiveness of cadaver dogs. 'They're a very specialised dog in terms of trying to train them. There is one on the island of Ireland; the PSNI has one,' he said. 'That dog is sought by many police forces in Britain as well. We got the use of the dog here and he was of much assistance. 'It obviously would be preferable if we had a cadaver dog. They have a very limited work life, cadaver dogs, they're only operational for a period of about three years, they have to go through a very difficult training process. It would be preferable if the cadaver dog available on the island had been used earlier.' Richard Satchwell (58), a lorry driver from the UK who had settled in Cork with his wife, claimed he killed her accidentally after fending off a claim attack by her. He then buried her remains under the house to conceal her death. Satchwell, who has 14 previous convictions, was sentenced to life in prison last week. He intends to appeal the verdict. The Garda now have two water cannons. Photograph: Alan Betson The commissioner was speaking to reporters as the force launched a report looking back at its six-year roll-out of significant operational changes. The Garda now has the largest fleet of vehicles in its history, with 3,672, including new specialist vehicles such as two water cannons, the organisation said.
