Scoop: Philly man wrongfully convicted as a teen sues city and police
The big picture: David Sparks, whose case was featured in an Inquirer investigation in 2018, is among at least 41 exonerees in Philly who have been cleared of wrongdoing in the last eight years.
Many of the convictions were overturned because of allegations of police misconduct, per the lawsuit.
The latest: In his federal lawsuit against the city and more than a dozen members of the Philadelphia Police Department, Sparks, 35, alleges that his wrongful conviction resulted from "extraordinary misconduct."
Sparks is accusing police of making critical mistakes that tainted their investigation into a fatal shooting at a Labor Day block party in Nicetown in 2006.
He alleges detectives coerced witnesses into implicating him in the murder of 19-year-old Gary Hall, and withheld evidence that suggested another teenager was the shooter.
What they're saying: Police homicide detectives had "free reign to engage in unconstitutional actions with the knowledge and acquiescence of city policymakers and PPD Homicide Division supervisors and command staff, all of whom were deliberately indifferent to this misconduct," Sparks' lawyers wrote in the complaint.
Sparks is seeking unspecified damages and attorney fees to compensate him for the more than 15 years he spent behind bars.
He "looks forward to finally obtaining some measure of accountability," Sparks' attorney, Grace Harris, told Axios in a statement.
The other side: The Philadelphia Police Department referred Axios to the city Law Department, which declined to comment on the lawsuit.
Context: Sparks, one of many teens at the scene during the 2006 shooting, was 16 years old when he was charged in Hall's murder.
Sparks had called 911 shortly after gunshots rang out to report that Hall had been shot and needed medical attention, per the lawsuit.
Sparks was convicted at a bench trial in 2008, sentenced to life in prison, and spent years fighting to prove his innocence.
The Innocence Project took on his case in 2014 and worked to obtain evidence that showed police detectives were told someone else was responsible for the homicide.
A judge vacated Sparks' conviction in 2023, and prosecutors dismissed the case.
Zoom in: After the shooting, one of the police supervisors at the scene ordered officers to conduct curfew checks on the teenagers present at the block party, instead of instructing them to interview the dozens of potential witnesses, per the lawsuit.
Many teens left the area without speaking to police in order to avoid being issued curfew citations, the suit states.
Still, several people told police that another teenager at the party, Ivan Simmons, had shot Hall after he argued with Simmons' brother, the suit alleges.
Simmons was killed three months later as part of what the lawsuit describes as a string of retaliatory shootings stemming from Hall's murder.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Axios
11 hours ago
- Axios
D.C.-area Dems rage as Trump takes control of city's policing
Democratic lawmakers from the Washington, D.C. area are blasting President Trump for deploying the National Guard to the city and seizing control of its police force in an effort to crack down on crime. Why it matters: "Shocking stuff, even for Trump," Rep. Glenn Ivey (D-Md.) told Axios, adding, "Suspicious minds might wonder if this is just kind of a first step towards a move on other parts of the government in D.C." "At the end of the day, it's pretty telling. January 6th ... he doesn't want to call the National Guard. Here you get essentially a minor felony, and he's going to call the National Guard and federalize the D.C. police?" Ivey added. "It's ridiculous," he said. "It really is." State of play: Trump said Monday he will federalize the D.C. Metropolitan Police Department and send the National Guard into the city in a major escalation of his campaign to tackle local crime. Trump has spent days threatening such a takeover after a DOGE staffer was allegedly beaten during an early-morning carjacking. Trump, at a White House press conference, called the move a "historic action to rescue our nation's capital from crime, bloodshed, bedlam and squalor, and worse." What they're saying: Ivey and Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-Md.), who both represent the D.C. suburbs, pointed to data that suggests violent crime in the city has dropped in recent years. Raskin, in an interview with Axios, said Trump "continues to search for distractions and provocations to divert attention from his outrageous refusal to release the Epstein files." "Of course, the president has a major political bone to pick with the people of Washington, D.C., who have voted 10-to-1 against him at every opportunity. So this is one more chance to exact revenge," Raskin added. Between the lines: Trump said he will call up 800 D.C. National Guard troops and said he may send in the military as well "if needed." He said he is taking control of the D.C. Police under the Home Rule Act, which allows such a move in response to "special conditions of an emergency nature" for up to 30 days. Congress can, in theory, vote to terminate the emergency, but it is unlikely to do so with Republicans in charge of both chambers. The bottom line: "It's a very extreme exercise of these powers, raising all kinds of legal questions," said Raskin, who is the ranking member of the House Judiciary Committee.
Axios
16 hours ago
- Axios
Salt Lake City homicides drop while violent crime climbs in 2025
Homicides in Salt Lake City dipped slightly in the first half of the year, while violent crimes including rape, aggravated assault and robbery rose, according to new data from an organization of law enforcement executives. Why it matters: The modest drop in homicides is clouded by rising rates of other violent crimes, signaling persistent public safety challenges in Utah's capital. By the numbers: Homicides in Salt Lake City fell to five in the first half of 2025 from seven during the same period in 2024, according to stats compiled by the Major Cities Chiefs Association (MCCA). Rape saw a 24% uptick, from 121 to 150. Aggravated assault jumped 9% from 436 to 475. Robberies crept up marginally, from 173 to 179. The Salt Lake City Police Department did not immediately provide comment. Catch up quick: The data comes after Salt Lake City Mayor Erin Mendenhall in January released a public safety plan under pressure from state Republican leaders. In June, the Salt Lake City Council approved the police department's 12.5% year-over-year budget increase request for the 2026 fiscal year to support wage bumps and investments in crime-solving technology. Last month, Salt Lake City police chief Brian Redd acknowledged ongoing concerns about violent crime, saying it was associated with the disruption of local drug networks. The big picture: Reports from 68 law enforcement agencies around the country showed a 19% drop in homicides in the first six months of 2025 compared with the same time last year, per MCCA data. Homicides declined in major U.S. cities — by more than 50% in some communities, including Denver, Honolulu, Orlando, Florida, Portland and Tampa, per an Axios analysis of the figures. Nationally, other violent crimes appear to be falling in every category. Rape was down 9%, robbery decreased 18% and aggravated assaults fell 10%. Yes, but: Some communities saw a jump in homicides during this period. Boston experienced a 143% surge in homicides during the first six months of 2025. Cincinnati, El Paso, Fort Worth, Milwaukee and Kansas City, Missouri, also saw increases, the Axios analysis found.
Chicago Tribune
2 days ago
- Chicago Tribune
Elgin police rank 6th for DUI arrests, per AAIM, falling from last year
The Elgin Police Department ranked in the top 10 law enforcement agencies making the most drunk driving arrests in 2024, though the ranking dropped from last year's second-place berth. The Alliance Against Intoxicated Motorists (AAIM) released the results of its Illinois DUI Arrest Survey for 2024 that showed Elgin ranked number six. Elgin had 245 DUI arrests, the survey showed. 'Each arrest reflects the hard work and dedication of the officers who put themselves on the line every day. Their efforts help protect lives and prevent families from experiencing the pain of a crash,' said Rita Kreslin, AAIM executive director, in a press release. Last year, Elgin Police Department made 282 arrests to achieve the second-place spot. The change could be a result of different factors, like people using rideshare services to avoid drinking and driving or people staying at home more, said Elgin Sgt. Hector Gutierrez, the department's public information officer. EPD does 'no refusal' campaigns during holidays, including Memorial Day weekend. They allow police to work with prosecutors to obtain a seach warrant against drivers who refuse to take a breathalyzer, blood or urine test during a drunk driving stop or investigation, according to the Kane County State's attorney's office. A campaign is coming up for Labor Day weekend, Gutierrez said. 'We are going to be looking for intoxicated drivers on the roadway to keep everyone safe,' he said. 'Hopefully those (campaigns) resonate with people, and they are taking safety precautions,' Gutierrez said. AAIM's survey showed Det. Paul Dublinski had 22 DUI arrests in Elgin last year. Dublinski is a veteran officer who routinely has the highest number of DUI arrests in the department. 'We have officers who really care about getting DUI drivers off the roadway and making the streets safer for the community,' Gutierrez said. AAIM is an Illinois-only citizen activist group founded in 1982 by victims of drunk driving. Its survey, which started 35 years ago, had an 81% response rate from nearly 700 police agencies around the state in 2024. The survey showed the top 10 police departments were: Aurora remained the first in the state for the second year in a row. Naperville had one of the largest increases in arrests from 2023 to 2024, 51.8%, along with West Chicago, which had a 31.2% increase. The sheriff's department reporting the most DUI arrests was Winnebago County with 387. The top five list included McHenry County with 189 arrests, Cook County with 155, Lake County with 136, and Will County with 133. 'Enforcing DUI laws is demanding but essential work. The entire AAIM organization sincerely appreciates the officers' daily sacrifice, dedication to public safety, and efforts to save lives. We deeply value their constant commitment,' Kreslin said, in the release.
