logo
SA/US relations: How South Africa now finds itself in humiliating position

SA/US relations: How South Africa now finds itself in humiliating position

IOL News20-05-2025

President Cyril Ramaphosa arrives at the Joint Base Andrews Airport in Washington. He is received by Trade and Industry and Competition Minister Parks Tau, South African Embassy Chargè d 'Affairs, Stanley Makgohlo, Col Pumla Dlali, Assistant Defence Attache at the South African Embassy and Abby Jones, Acting Chief of Protocol, State Department.
AS A chartered plane carrying 49 Afrikaner 'refugees' touched down in Washington, D.C., under the invitation of former President Donald Trump, South Africa's President Cyril Ramaphosa made a far more consequential landing of his own.
He arrived in the United States this week to lobby for the renewal of the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), a preferential trade agreement that grants South African exporters duty-free access to American markets.
That this diplomatic visit follows so closely on the heels of a flight cloaked in white grievance and manufactured genocide narratives is no coincidence, it is a symptom of the same unresolved contradictions at the heart of South Africa's post-apartheid identity: a nation that cannot decide whose suffering it takes seriously.
Trump's invitation to self-styled Afrikaner victims, most of whom claim 'discrimination' and 'white genocide,' is a damning reflection of how global far-right movements have opportunistically latched onto South Africa's unresolved racial wounds.
While these individuals find safe haven in the United States, the Women on Farms Project reminds us that the actual marginalised black and brown farm workers, largely women continue to suffer silently, unheard by the same government now pleading with the U.S. to keep its markets open.
'They are opportunists,' said the Project's Denile Samuel, speaking plainly about the white Afrikaners who fled under Trump's programme. 'The real people who are marginalised, the real people who are not heard and not seen are farm workers.'
Her words land with quiet force. They highlight a bitter irony: that even as white South Africans reinvent themselves as persecuted minorities abroad, the working class remains ignored by ministers who can't be bothered to acknowledge invitations, let alone engage with communities facing daily violations of their labour rights.
It is against this backdrop of performative victimhood and governmental neglect that Ramaphosa's U.S. visit must be understood. The official reason is trade or more accurately, the attempt to save it.
AGOA is set to expire later this year, but its renewal is far from guaranteed. American patience with South Africa has worn thin. Pretoria's geopolitical non-alignment particularly its warm ties with Russia and China has unsettled Washington.
The Lady R scandal, in which a sanctioned Russian cargo ship docked in Simon's Town under suspicious conditions, continues to cast a long shadow. Although President Ramaphosa's Phala Phala cover-up has largely consumed domestic attention, it is the shadow diplomacy of the failure to assure the U.S. of South Africa's reliability that now threatens billions in export revenue and thousands of local jobs.
To be clear, this is not just about citrus fruit and car parts. AGOA is a litmus test for South Africa's global legitimacy. If it fails to secure renewal, it will be a signal that Washington no longer views Pretoria as a trusted partner, but rather as a country adrift neither reliable ally nor coherent adversary. The optics matter. The President is not going to Washington in triumph. He is going cap in hand, attempting to make nice with a partner that no longer trusts us.
And he is doing so while right-wing white South Africans land in the same city, not as emissaries, but as 'refugees' claiming victimhood under the very state he represents. The symbolic whiplash is staggering.
The backdrop to Ramaphosa's trip also includes a more surreal diplomatic episode: the tense Oval Office confrontation between Donald Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky just weeks ago.
That meeting was marked by Trump's theatrical accusation that Zelensky was 'gambling with World War Three' and the Ukrainian president's desperate attempt to placate an increasingly hostile American administration. The parallel is unnerving. The White House has become a theatre where global leaders must perform for American approval whether they are trying to save their sovereignty, their trade deals, or their economic lifelines.
Ramaphosa's delegation knows that time is running out. If they cannot secure AGOA's renewal, they will at least try to delay its death. Their objective is simple: get their ducks in a row before the doors shut completely. The urgency of the visit reveals what government will not say out loud that South Africa no longer commands automatic goodwill, and that trade access is now something we must actively fight to keep.
It is a humiliating position for a country that once sold itself as the moral compass of the Global South. But perhaps it is also a necessary reckoning. South Africa cannot continue to straddle every fence siding with Russia in UN votes while calling itself a neutral broker, cosying up to China while relying on U.S. trade. That diplomatic ambivalence has now reached its limit. The AGOA negotiations will test whether we can still walk that tightrope or whether the world, much like our own neglected workers, has simply stopped listening.
Roos is a policy writer, researcher and political analyst

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Is ‘Trump always chickens out' worth repeating?
Is ‘Trump always chickens out' worth repeating?

IOL News

timean hour ago

  • IOL News

Is ‘Trump always chickens out' worth repeating?

President Donald Trump holds a chart on reciprocal tariffs during an event titled 'Make America Wealthy Again', at the White House in Washington, DC. Trump backed down days later. Pat Dennis Every day is 'TACO Tuesday' for Democrats this week. Ever since President Donald Trump angrily dismissed a reporter's question about the 'Trump always chickens out' trade theory - the market's bet that Trump will back off his trade bluster - it has become a nonstop meme, complete with a taco truck to taunt Republicans. I'm head of a progressive opposition research shop, so you might assume I'm celebrating this outbreak of trolling. You'd be wrong. Democrats need to drop it immediately. I understand that the claim that 'Trump always chickens out' on trade policy feels vindicating. To see his political allies on Wall Street call him weak and goad him into a Truth Social tantrum scratches a particular itch. But this attack enrages Trump only when it's coming from his own base - and when Democrats repeat it, they're helping him squirm his way out of a political disaster he has created for himself. Trump hasn't 'chickened out' on his tariffs. He is - at this very second - inflicting great harm on American workers, families and the entire U.S. economy. With Trump in charge, prices are up, small businesses are struggling, loan delinquencies are rising, and economic growth has slowed. Polling from Navigator last month showed that only 30 percent of Americans have a favorable view of Trump's tariffs, including an abysmal 20 percent of independent voters. But when the Democratic Party yells 'TACO,' Americans feel hope that these harmful tariffs are only a negotiation tactic, rather than the economic suicide mission they are. The entire conversation feeds into the decades-old, TV-fueled perception of Trump as a master businessman, just as Democrats are finally gaining traction with a more negative impression. The Working Class Project by American Bridge is listening to voters in 21 states across the country to understand why working-class Americans moved away from the Democratic Party. Here's what a male voter in North Carolina had to say about Trump's shifting tariffs: 'I know Canada kind of backed down, and I think that's what he's banking on. I don't think China will back down, but they will eventually reach an agreement. And it will create a bunch of jobs and industries if he's successful.' This response was typical among people we've talked to: Voters see the give-and-take of tariff news - especially Trump 'backing down' off tariffs to talk to other countries - as a sign of progress. Many mistakenly believe his policies have not gone into effect, even as the temporarily scaled-back tariffs are still at levels unseen since World War II. Yet Democrats are on TV, in newspapers and on social media boosting a message that's helpful for Trump. We must remind voters that Trump's tariffs aren't just empty social media posts or a game of global chess - they are real and harmful. Small businesses are laying off workers or shuttering doors. Experts are telling newlyweds to add up to 15 percent more to their wedding budgets. New parents are paying more for car seats and strollers. We desperately need new housing, but costs of construction materials are skyrocketing. The message should be relentless: Trump's trade policies are a failure, and Americans are suffering the consequences. He promised a manufacturing boom; Mack Truck cut hundreds of jobs in Pennsylvania. He promised to lower inflation, then told families that they should buy fewer Christmas presents for their kids if toys are too expensive now. He promised to strengthen small businesses; one small-business owner in Ohio said she's bracing for 'mass extinction of small businesses' as a result of these tariffs. In a world of political branding, it's tempting to hit Trump where he appears weakest - his inconsistency, his ego, his impulsiveness. But on trade, that strategy plays right into his strengths. The smarter path is to argue that Trump's trade policies are a disaster because he followed through. The party can't get complacent and hope the real-life tariffs will do all their messaging work for them, either. Despite four months of chaos, Republicans still retain a 10-point lead on the economy. Democrats need to stop talking about TACO and start hammering home the truth: Trump is making life more expensive for everyone, and he's not going to stop.

Cyril Ramaphosa and Donald Trump to discuss trade relations at G7 Summit
Cyril Ramaphosa and Donald Trump to discuss trade relations at G7 Summit

IOL News

timean hour ago

  • IOL News

Cyril Ramaphosa and Donald Trump to discuss trade relations at G7 Summit

President Cyril Ramaphosa and his US counterpart Donald Trump are set to meet, for the second time, at the G7 Summit expected to be held in Canada this weekend. Image: Supplied / GCIS President Cyril Ramaphosa is set to meet with US President Donald Trump on the sidelines of the Group of Seven (G7) Summit in Canada this weekend. The meeting will focus on key issues, including the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) and US-SA tariffs. Ramaphosa's meeting with Trump comes after South Africa submitted a revised framework proposal to the US, aiming to expand trade and investment relations between the two countries. The US imposed tariffs on South African imports in April, with a 90-day pause on reciprocal tariffs of 30% against South African exports. The tariffs were part of a broader set of 'liberation day' tariffs imposed by Trump on all US trading partners. However, they were later reduced to a base rate of 10%, with the expectation that countries would use the 90 days to propose solutions addressing the US's trade deficit concerns. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading Ramaphosa's meeting with Trump will be his second in about three weeks, following their encounter at the White House last month. During their previous meeting, Ramaphosa emphasised the importance of the US's role in the G20 Summit and invited Trump to attend the G20 Leaders' Summit in Johannesburg later this year. Trump agreed to attend, and Ramaphosa sees this as a positive development for bilateral relations. According to sources close to Ramaphosa, the meeting agenda will include discussions on AGOA, providing duty-free access to the US market for some African products. The agreement is set to expire in September, and South Africa is eager to see it renewed. Ramaphosa will also raise concerns about US-SA tariffs, urging the US not to increase them beyond the current 10% if negotiations on a new trade framework are not concluded by July 9. The sources further said the meeting between Ramaphosa and Trump was significant, given the current state of US-SA trade relations. 'The business sector has expressed concerns about the rise of tariffs, and Ramaphosa is under pressure to come up with answers. A successful meeting could help to ease tensions and pave the way for improved trade relations between the two countries,' the source added. Presidency spokesperson Vincent Magwenya had not responded to questions as to what to expect at the upcoming meeting. However, Ramaphosa, while speaking to journalists on Tuesday after he announced the date for the National Dialogue on various issues affecting the country, confirmed that he would be meeting Trump, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney, and German Chancellor Friedrich Merz. Ramaphosa said he was invited by Carney, who holds the presidency of the G7, and would also use the opportunity to talk about the G20 Summit to be hosted by South Africa in November, where Trump will take over the presidency. 'We're going to use it as a platform to begin to consolidate what we want to achieve in November when the leaders' summit takes place here (in Johannesburg),' he said. Last month, Ramaphosa and his delegation included Minister of Trade and Industry Parks Tau, Minister in the Presidency Khumbudzo Ntshavheni, Agriculture Minister John Steenhuisen, and International Relations Minister Ronald Lamola. His goals for that meeting included resetting US-SA relations and beginning serious engagement with the US on trade and investment. He emphasised that South Africa did not 'go kowtowing' to the White House but rather took the initiative to engage with the US. 'For us, it's important for us as a nation to reposition ourselves in the very turbulent geopolitical architecture or situation that we have,' Ramaphosa said at the time. Business Unity South Africa could not respond to inquiries regarding expectations of Ramaphosa's upcoming meeting, citing the absence of its CEO, Khulekani Mathe, who is in Switzerland on a work visit.

Elon Musk: I went 'too far' with Donald Trump posts
Elon Musk: I went 'too far' with Donald Trump posts

The South African

timean hour ago

  • The South African

Elon Musk: I went 'too far' with Donald Trump posts

Once viewed as close friends and confidantes, the 'bromance' between Elon Musk and Donald Trump recently disintegrated in the midst of a public fallout and war of words on social media. Musk, who was granted special US government employee status to lead the Department of Government Efficiency, recently saw his role at the White House come to an abrupt end. As part of his 'special' role at the helm of DOGE, he oversaw major cuts to the federal workforce as Trump administration's sought to reduce federal spending. However, the relationship between the South Africa-born tech billionaire and US leader fell apart after Musk raised concerns about his sweeping tax and spending cuts package. As Musk went on the offensive, he urged Americans to call their representatives in Washington to 'kill the bill', alleging it would 'cause a recession in the second half of the year'. In another particularly evocative claim, he also alleged – without evidence – that Trump appears in unreleased government files linked to the late sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. In response Trump said Musk had 'lost his mind' and threatened to cancel his government contracts which have an estimated value of $38bn (R674,965bn), while the US leader told NBC in an interview: 'I think it's a very bad thing, because he's very disrespectful. You could not disrespect the office of the president.' Musk appeared to have deleted many of his posts over the weekend, and on Wednesday he then commented: 'I regret some of my posts about President Donald Trump last week. They went too far.' Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 0211. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store