Two charges against soldier accused of filming sex without consent dropped
Corporal Manu Smith was facing a Court Martial on three counts of making intimate visual recordings under the Armed Forces Discipline Act.
In a Court Martial, a military panel made a decision on the accused's guilt or innocence.
This morning, Justice Tom Gilbert, who was presiding over the court, advised the military panel that he had granted the defence's request to drop two of the charges.
The judge said the two charges were dismissed for legal reasons because, in light of the evidence, he ruled that a properly directed panel could not reasonably convict on those charges.
ADVERTISEMENT
That afternoon, the accused Corporal Manu Smith gave evidence for the defence.
Defence lawyer Timothy Leighton asked Corporal Smith why he had taken out his phone and started recording during sex with the complainant, and if the woman had known he was filming.
Corporal Smith said he saw it as a way of expressing their intimacy and that she had seen that he was filming on his phone, and did nothing to indicate she wanted him to stop filming.
He said the pair's relationship had been sexual from the start, and they both shared intimate sexual images with each other.
Corporal Smith said the pair had talked about boundaries.
"Yes, I expected the same respect from her that she did with me, in terms of sharing content with a third party or anybody outside.
"...It was a circle of trust, it should have been. I don't want images of me shared with her girlfriends, nor would she want me to share intimate images of her."
ADVERTISEMENT
Where to get help for sexual violence. (Source: 1News)
He said the pair had discussed filming sexual encounters, while discussing their sexual likes and dislikes, and he believed she was open to it.
Corporal Smith said he believed he did have consent to record the sexual encounter which was the subject of the complaint, and he said if she had asked him to stop he would have.
The prosecution's captain John Whitcombe asked Corporal Smith about the nature of his relationship with the complainant and whether she had reason to assume it was a exclusive relationship.
Corporal Smith said the nature of their relationship was not discussed, but he saw it as non-exclusive and he believed she did too.
Captain John Whitcombe challenged Corporal Smith's assertion that the woman had consented to the sex being filmed, asking if there was ever an express discussion about him filming on the day in question.
Corporal Smith said they had talked about it in a light-hearted, jovial way.
ADVERTISEMENT
"There was no black and white, no written agreement," he told the court.
The defence and prosecution will give their closing addresses this afternoon.
rnz.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
1News
9 hours ago
- 1News
'Really difficult': NZ woman, son, detained by US immigration
A New Zealand woman and her six-year-old son have been detained by US immigration officials after she tried to return to America from a trip to Canada. Sarah Shaw had taken her two older children to Vancouver so they could catch a direct flight back to New Zealand on July 24 to visit family, and she then planned to travel back to her home in Washington state with her younger son. Shaw's lawyer Minda Thorward told local media that she had a temporary immigration document that allowed her travel and re-enter the US but there was an 'administrative error' with it. Her friend Victoria Bescancon told 1News that she was stopped at the border by immigration agents and told there was a problem with her documents, so she and her son would be detained immediately. 'Sarah slept on the floor with her son in a room. They had an emergency blanket,' said Besancon. ADVERTISEMENT Shaw and her son were then transferred to a facility in South Texas – one of only two that can house families together. 'Sarah is trying really hard to stay positive and trying really hard to adjust to the situation, but watching your child be detained in an immigration facility being the only two people who speak English in that facility and being treated every single day like a criminal has been devastating to her,' said Bescancon. Shaw and her son are now sharing their room with four other families, she said. 'She's not even able to have a conversation with anybody or just relate. And it's been really difficult for her.' Besancon has setup a fundraising page for Shaw to help with legal costs, with nearly US$40,000 already raised. 'She's not able to independently make phone calls to anybody she would like, but it has meant the world to her to know that she's not alone in this situation, that there are people who care and there are people who are taking this situation very seriously for her and her son.' Shaw's legal team have told them the allegations from immigration officials are incorrect and they are now fighting for a court date. ADVERTISEMENT Along with legal costs, Shaw is also covering rent and car payments. Her two older children were due back in the US next month, Bescancon said. Seattle media site KING5 said Shaw immigrated to the United States three and a half years ago with her then-husband as her sponsor. They subsequently divorced and while this can jeopardise a green card application, Shaw was able to reapply independently under guidelines for survivors of domestic abuse, KING5 said. Shaw has been working at a juvenile care facility run by Washington state. NZ's Ministry of Foreign Affairs said consular officials were aware of reports that a New Zealander and her son have been detained and are seeking further information. 1News has approached United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement for comment.
1News
10 hours ago
- 1News
Judge ruled to split Patterson trial to avoid prejudice
Triple murderer Erin Patterson would have been unfairly prejudiced if a jury heard allegations she tried to kill her ex-husband in the years before a deadly mushroom lunch. Victorian Supreme Court Justice Christopher Beale made the decision on March 14, ruling Patterson would have to face a separate trial for the three attempted murder offences. Prosecutors ultimately dropped the charges in relation to Simon Patterson just before the triple-murder trial started in Morwell. Patterson was found guilty on July 7 of killing Simon's parents, Don and Gail, 70, and his aunt Heather Wilkinson, 66, along with the attempted murder of her husband Ian Wilkinson. Justice Beale's redacted pre-trial rulings were released to media on Monday evening after Patterson lost her bid to keep the evidence a secret to preserve her appeal rights. ADVERTISEMENT The details around the alleged attempted murders of Simon Patterson were revealed for the first time on Friday. The morning's headlines in 90 seconds, including poll numbers paint grim picture for leaders, Trump sending the National Guard into Washington, and where have all the coaches gone? (Source: 1News) Prosecutors had alleged Patterson tried to poison Simon several times between 2021 and 2022. The first was a penne pasta Patterson cooked for him before leaving for a camping trip in November 2021, which led to a five-day hospital stay for Simon. He also ended up in a coma after a camping trip in late May 2022 where he allegedly ate a chicken korma curry Patterson had made him. Simon had to undergo surgery to remove a large portion of his bowel after eating the curry, he told the Supreme Court during pre-trial hearings. It was also alleged he fell ill in September 2022 after eating a wrap Patterson prepared for him while camping together at Wilson's Promontory. ADVERTISEMENT The prosecution claimed the allegations could be used as coincidence evidence to show the similarities between what allegedly happened to Simon and the mushroom lunch guests. But Justice Beale ruled the charges should be heard in a separate trial to prevent jurors from "misusing or overvaluing" the evidence in relation to Simon. He determined if a jury found Patterson had deliberately poisoned her four lunch guests in July 2023, there was a risk they would wrongly assess the charges relating to Simon. "I am not persuaded that its probative value substantially outweighs the significant danger or risk of unfair prejudice to the accused," Justice Beale said in his written reasons. The judge also made pre-trial rulings in relation to documents about poisoning found on devices police seized from Patterson's home. Justice Beale ruled the documents failed the relevance test because the evidence could only go as high as Patterson possibly accessed the file. The judge also stopped the jury from seeing a Facebook post Patterson made to a poisons page, where she claimed her cat had chewed on a mushroom and was vomiting. ADVERTISEMENT Justice Beale noted the post was made 18 months before the first allegation in relation to Simon. "In my view, even if the evidence of this post shows an interest in poisons, it is temporally remote," the judge said in his reasons. Patterson will face a two-day pre-sentence hearing later in August, during which she will listen to statements from the Pattersons and Wilkinsons. She will have 28 days to appeal after she is sentenced.
1News
2 days ago
- 1News
Kiwis player Brandon Smith questioned by QLD police at airport
South Sydney have spoken with the NRL Integrity Unit after star signing Brandon Smith was interviewed by police on arrival at Gold Coast airport on Saturday. The 29-year-old was released without charge to take his place in the Rabbitohs side against the Gold Coast on Sunday afternoon at Robina in what will be his 150th NRL game. AAP spoke to club chief executive Blake Solly at the ground before kick-off. While no details have emerged on why exactly Smith was spoken to by police, it is understood there was no issue with the 2020 premiership winner, who was permitted to join the team at their hotel and prepare to play in the match. The Rabbitohs have also informed the NRL, which had no problem with him playing. ADVERTISEMENT The Titans worked with stadium staff to ensure Smith was not bounced by camera crews on his arrival with the side on the team bus hours before kick-off. Queensland Police issued a statement confirming they had spoken with Smith: "Queensland Police had cause to speak to a 29-year-old male at Coolangatta Airport. The male was later released without charge. Police have no further information to provide." It is also understood Smith was not involved in any behaviour on the plane that was untoward. Smith joined the Rabbitohs mid-season after securing a release from the Sydney Roosters. His return to play was curtailed until he had fully recovered from an ACL injury suffered last year. In his first game for the Rabbitohs in round 18 he sustained another knee injury, an MCL sprain. Sunday's clash is just his second for the club after previously lining up in 107 games for Melbourne and 41 for the Roosters.
