
Brits who challenge train ticket inspectors or make silly mistakes when booking are at risk of getting a criminal RECORD, new report reveals
Train passengers who are caught travelling without a valid ticket could find themselves with an unexpected criminal record, it has emerged.
A review published by the Office of Rail and Road revealed that even passengers who have mistakenly bought the wrong tickets for their journey could be prosecuted if their appeals against a penalty fare are rejected.
Penalty fares are handed by inspectors to passengers without a valid ticket while travelling and on National Rail services typically cost around £100 plus the full cost of a single fare for the journey. They can be appealed within 21 days of receipt.
But in some extreme cases, fines of up to £1000 can be brought forward if a person is convicted of travelling with the intent to avoid payment.
The rule change comes in a bid to clamp down on fare-dodging and was ruled by a judgement from the Chief Magistrate Paul Goldspring earlier this year.
An extract from the independent review reads: 'In February 2025, the Chief Magistrate ruled on whether an unsuccessful penalty fare appeal provided protection from prosecution for certain fare evasion offences.
'He ruled that criminal prosecutions can be brought following a penalty fare appeal being rejected.'
Christian Waters, 47, from Leeds, was targeted for prosecution in 2022 after he had an appeal for a penalty fare rejected and told The Telegraph that the ruling, which was until now private, should have been made public.
He said: 'Why was this ruling not published, given it affects the protection of that hundreds of thousands of passengers would assume they had from the regulations?'
Mr Waters eventually had his case dropped after realising Northern Rail, a train company owned by the government, had broken their rules by trying to prosecute him at the time.
He says his avoidance of prosecution now feels like he 'got off on a technicality' and still disputes that their ticket machine was not working at the time.
The ruling at Westminster Magistrates' Court, which was allegedly seen by the newspaper, came after the also government-owned Southeastern asked the court if previous convictions it had brought were lawful.
The newspaper last night reported that Judge Goldspring said: 'It is clearly irrational that a person who brought an unmeritorious appeal could not be prosecuted, whereas someone who did not could be.'
Rules for commuters hit with penalty fares originally brought to the House of Commons had always sought to avoid seeing passengers criminalised.
Conservative peer Lord Marshall told Parliament in 1988: 'If, however, a passenger on a train is not in possession of a ticket, he is not to be treated as a criminal under this bill.
'He is simply asked to pay a penalty fare which is a civil penalty and not a criminal one.'
Regulation 11 (3) of the Railways (Penalty Fares) Regulations Act 2018 states that prosecution is only allowed where the penalty has been cancelled by the operator before the appeal panel has decided the outcome.
Judge Goldspring allegedly said in February that prosecutors 'should not bring a prosecution if it is excluded' and that there is 'no obligation on the court to investigate whether the defendant has a defence'.
Private company Appeal Services handle all penalty fare appeals, and are paid by train operating companies to do so.
Its website reportedly says that four in five first-stage appeals were rejected in the last 28 days.
A Department for Transport spokesperson told MailOnline: 'Deliberate fare-dodging costs the taxpayer up to £400 million annually – money which could be better spent on improving passenger experience.
'This must be dealt with in a balanced manner, which is why Great British Railways will bring operators together to establish oversight and better standardise practices, putting an end to inconsistent prosecutions and making sure passengers are treated fairly.
'We're working at pace to simplify ticketing as part of our rail reforms, to alleviate confusion and make it easier for people to buy the right fare.'
They added that only a small number of prosecutions could see a person land a criminal record.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Sky News
14 minutes ago
- Sky News
Three teenagers arrested after boy, 14, stabbed to death in north Manchester
Two teenage boys have been arrested on suspicion of murder after a 14-year-old boy was found fatally stabbed in north Manchester, police have said. Officers from Greater Manchester Police responded to reports of a serious assault on Nevin Road, New Moston, at around 5pm on Sunday. They found a 14-year-old boy with stab wounds and despite the efforts of the emergency services, including air ambulance staff, he later died in hospital. Potential suspects were quickly identified by the force, who arrested a 37-year-old woman on suspicion of assisting an offender at a nearby address. Two boys aged 14 and 16 were arrested on suspicion of murder a short time later. A 14-year-old girl has been arrested overnight on suspicion of assisting an offender. All four remain in custody for questioning. Detective Chief Inspector John Charlton said the incident "will have shocked and saddened the local community, and distressed anyone who witnessed it". The force was able to "quickly identify potential suspects" after "significant resources" were allocated to the investigation, DCI Charlton said. "We are still trying to establish the full circumstances around the incident - there will be a large police presence and several scenes in place while we continue to investigate this horrific incident. "The boy's family are being supported by our officers and we are determined to give them the answers they deserve. He appealed to the public for any "information, doorbell or dashcam footage, or eye-witness accounts" from anyone in the area at the time. Please refresh the page for the latest version.


The Independent
16 minutes ago
- The Independent
Murder inquiry after boy, 14, stabbed in Manchester
Detectives have launched a murder inquiry after a 14-year-old boy was stabbed to death in a 'horrific incident' in north Manchester. Police say two boys, aged 14 and 16, are under arrest on suspicion of murder and a girl, 14, and woman, 37, are being held on suspicion of assisting an offender. Officers were first called to the Nevin Road area of New Moston in the city at about 5pm on Sunday, Greater Manchester Police (GMP) said. The 14-year-old boy was found with stab wounds and despite the efforts of the emergency services and staff from an air ambulance, he later died in hospital. Police said early investigations established the identities of possible suspects and after attending a nearby address, the woman was arrested on suspicion of assisting an offender. A short time later, the boys aged 14 and 16, were arrested on suspicion of murder and the teenage girl was arrested overnight for assisting an offender, GMP said. All four remain in custody for questioning. Detective Chief Inspector John Charlton of GMP said: 'This incident will have shocked and saddened the local community, and distressed anyone who witnessed it. 'We are deploying significant resources to this murder investigation, and this led to quickly identifying potential suspects. 'We are still trying to establish the full circumstances around the incident – there will be a large police presence and several scenes in place while we continue to investigate this horrific incident. 'The boy's family are being supported by our officers and we are determined to give them the answers they deserve. 'Despite making several arrests, this is still a live investigation, and we are looking for information, doorbell or dashcam footage, or eye-witness accounts from anyone who was in the area at the time quoting log 2250 of 8/6/25. 'Information can be reported to us by calling 101 or anonymously via the independent charity Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111. 'You can also use the reporting tools on our website – always call 999 in an emergency. 'We will provide updates to the family and the community as the investigation continues.'


BBC News
16 minutes ago
- BBC News
DVLA Scams
What is a DVLA Scam?Scam emails, texts and websites which include DVLA logos and branding in an attempt to appear aim of the messages is to encourage you to click on a link leading to a copycat DVLA website that asks for personal and financial Tax Status - Unpaid! ScamOne of the most common DVLA Scams is receiving a fake email that claims your car tax is overdue. Here's an example of what it might sound like..."Your latest vehicle tax payment failed. It appears that some of your billing details have expired. If you don't pay your vehicle tax on time you can be fined up to £1,000 or your details passed to a debt collection agency. Click here to verify your billing details..."Red Flags to Look Out ForCheck the Sender: What email address does the sender use? Any official correspondence from the DVLA will end in . language: Does the email use phrases like: "Do not delay" or "Imminent Enforcement Action"? Inactive links on website: Often, the surrounding links on a fake website don't lead web address - Check the web address at the top, and always use the official website, found here. , externalRequest for financial details: Never enter financial details through following an email link. DVLA will never ask you for your bank account details or ask you to confirm payment details. They will only ask you to confirm your personal details by email or text if you have a live enquiry with To Deal With a DVLA ScamIf you do follow through with the scam and input your financial details, contact your bank immediately. They can help protect your account from further use and potentially recover lost you come across any of these scams or any other suspicious activity, you can play your part in helping the DVLA to help combat fraud by:- reporting phishing emails to the National Cyber Security Centre, external- reporting online scams to Action Fraud, externalTo legitimately check the tax status of your vehicle, click here., external