‘Gross over-reach': Labor group urges Albanese to reject key parts of antisemitism envoy plan
Labor Friends of Palestine, an internal campaign group of members and politicians, said it was concerned about anti-Jewish hatred, but would be troubled about wider adoption of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's contested definition of antisemitism, as recommended by Jillian Segal in a wide-ranging plan last week.
Three co-convenors of the group have written to the prime minister, Anthony Albanese, saying they were 'deeply concerned' about parts of Segal's recommendations, describing her ideas about amending immigration law, changing school curriculums or potentially terminating funding to academics and artists as 'gross over-reach'. The group is also planning a campaign to gather further support from more Labor party branches.
'There is a groundswell of outrage among rank-and-file Labor members,' Peter Moss, a co-convener of Labor Friends of Palestine, told Guardian Australia.
'There is deep concern about the use of the IHRA definition which has been deployed to stifle criticism of the State of Israel.'
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
Albanese is currently mulling a response to envoy Segal's 49 recommendations to stamp out anti-Jewish hate. It is widely expected the government could focus its response on the education and prevention measures in Segal's plan. More complex recommendations, such as defunding universities or academic grants, would face more significant debate.
Guardian Australia reported on Friday that Segal's push for the federal government to 'require' the IHRA definition 'to be used across all levels of government and public institutions' will face pushback from some concerned Labor MPs and party members. That definition is contested in some quarters, with concerns it was increasingly being used to conflate antisemitism with criticism of Israel.
Other Labor voices believed some criticism of Segal's report had been an overreaction, noting attacks on synagogues as an issue that required action.
Albanese in 2021 committed federal Labor to the IHRA definition, as did then-prime minister Scott Morrison, and then-Labor premier Daniel Andrews in 2022. However it's understood that any federal push to codify or more widely embed the definition into various sectors would face internal pushback from some federal MPs.
Albanese and Segal have both said legitimate criticism of the Israeli government, including its military actions in Gaza, would not be forbidden.
Moss and his co-conveners told Albanese in their letter that many Labor members would reject the wider adoption of the IHRA definition, claiming it had been 'been deployed to stifle criticism of the policies and practices of the State of Israel and undermine the capacity of the Palestinian people to assert their rights under international law'.
The group noted a 2023 open letter from more than 100 Israeli and international civil society organisations – including Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International and the American Civil Liberties Union – which asked the United Nations to reject the IHRA definition because it is being 'misused' to protect Israel from legitimate criticism.
Moss and the group's other co-conveners also wrote to the prime minister of their concerns about some of Segal's recommendations.
'Proposals for amendments to immigration law, changes to school curriculum or reform of funding arrangements for universities and cultural institutions are beyond the scope or expertise of the Envoy and should be rejected,' they wrote.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
Segal said on Friday that stripping funding would be a 'last resort', downplaying the potential for such a power to be used.
Labor friends of Palestine said they 'share the Government's concerns about increased reports of antisemitic behaviour – just as we share concerns about increased rates of Islamophobia'.
'However the Plan makes some very broad claims that seem to be designed to create a sense of crisis rather than to foster social cohesion,' they wrote.
Instead they said the government should focus on cultural and educational programs 'that promote and celebrate the full diversity of our multicultural society.'
Moss and his co-conveners also urged Albanese to review the antisemitism envoy position itself, suggesting instead a broader-based program to combat all forms of racism. The Labor government also instituted an envoy to combat Islamophobia, Aftab Malik, who said last week his report would be sent to government in August.
'More than 100 members from around Australia have reached out to Labor Friends of Palestine in the past 24 hours asking us to speak out urgently on this issue,' Moss said.
'Labor members want the prime minister to reject the envoy's plan and review the envoy's position.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
STI tests for 800 more children amid abuse allegations; Hannah Thomas pleads not guilty; and pint-sized pubs
Good afternoon. An additional 800 Victorian children are being recommended for testing for sexually transmitted infections after four more childcare centres were added to the list of known workplaces of alleged paedophile Joshua Dale Brown. More dates have also been added for 10 other childcare centres, with police now saying they believe Brown worked at 23 childcare centres between January 2017 and May 2025. In their statement, police said establishing Brown's complete work history had been 'extremely complex' as childcare providers do not have centralised records. It meant detectives had to 'execute search warrants to obtain handwritten records, shift rosters and other critical information'. Federal court dismisses Torres Strait climate case but warns of 'bleak future' without urgent action NSW police yet to withdraw protest charge against Hannah Thomas as promised as she pleads not guilty Domestic violence case management not 'core business' of police, Queensland's top cop says Australian journalists confronted by Chinese security guards during PM's Beijing trip Mark Latham denies abuse claims made in court documents by former partner Card payment surcharges should be banned for debit and credit payments, RBA says Antisemitism happens – it's bad! But there are already a gazillion anti-protest laws. Do we need more? It's not unreasonable or racist to protest against genocide, says First Dog on the Moon. 'This is an attempt by the eSafety commission to turn this hearing into a royal commission into certain aspects of X.' Lawyers acting for social media giant X fired back at the eSafety commissioner in a case over how the platform handles terror content. The administrative review tribunal is considering whether Julie Inman Grant was correct to issue a notice to X in March last year to report on how it deals with terror content on its platform. When eSafety lawyers asked an X employee during cross-examination whether she was aware that X's owner, Elon Musk, had referred to Grant as the 'commissar', X argued Musk's view was irrelevant. Mitchell Starc has produced one of the all-time great bowling spells as Australia kept the West Indies to the second-lowest Test innings score in history. The match in Jamaica was full of notable numbers: Starc notched his 400th wicket in his 100th Test with a whopping 6 wickets for just 9 runs, Scott Boland claimed a hat-trick, while the West Indies' second innings lasted just 14.3 overs, the third-shortest innings on record. Sign up to Afternoon Update Our Australian afternoon update breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion David Hourigan's intricate miniature models of beloved music venues around Melbourne are so realistic that it can be hard to tell whether you are looking at a photo of the Espy or the Tote – until Hourigan's big hands loom into view. The artist likes to recreate venues that have closed or are in danger of closing: 'I want to preserve these before they disappear.' Today's starter word is: UNCI. You have five goes to get the longest word including the starter word. Play Wordiply. Enjoying the Afternoon Update? Then you'll love our Morning Mail newsletter. Sign up here to start the day with a curated breakdown of the key stories you need to know, and complete your daily news roundup. And follow the latest in US politics by signing up for This Week in Trumpland. If you have a story tip or technical issue viewing this newsletter, please reply to this email. If you are a Guardian supporter and need assistance with regards to contributions and/or digital subscriptions, please email
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Are arms firms or constituents the priority for our MPs?
The UK Government had announced it would be making the Conservative Party's ban on puberty blockers for trans youth a permanent fixture of Labour's 'changed' Britain and I had hoped to discuss it with my elected representative. I suspected the entire thing would be an exercise in frustration but I was at least curious to know just how much of a waste of time it would be. And in that sense, Glasgow South MP Gordon McKee did not disappoint. McKee represents an area of Scotland with one of the largest queer and trans demographics in the nation. As the MP for that area, I hoped McKee would be willing to engage with the worries my community had with his party. READ MORE: UK Government draining aid budget with 'broken' asylum hotels policy, watchdog warns Beyond an automated response confirming that my email had been received, my first message went unanswered. I followed up a month later. Then again another month after that. And once more in March. But then, a sign from on high! Lo, a leaflet came through my letterbox from the man himself. McKee, it seemed, held regular surgeries. And although there was no actual information on when or where they were going to be held, here was an option to speak to him. So I asked to meet my MP to discuss the matter in person, and a few days later I had my first response. I was offered a chance to speak for 15 minutes with two caseworkers over Teams. OK. It was around this point that I finally received a response to my earlier emails – three months after they were sent. After a little brag about Labour's investment in the NHS, McKee got down to business: the Labour Government, I was informed, has to follow the evidence, including the findings of the infamous Cass Review commissioned by the previous Conservative government. It didn't seem to matter that the Cass Review had not, in fact, recommended banning puberty blockers for trans young people, nor that the report has been ripped to shreds through peer review over unsound methodology and more. After months of waiting, months of watching the situation in the UK deteriorate further and further for trans people, I had been sent a carefully prepared statement delivered en masse to all who had raised concerns about Labour's attacks on the LGBTQ+ community – and it was still wrong. So I asked if McKee would be willing to meet a group of trans constituents to discuss their concerns, giving him a chance to listen to and understand the people in his community who were angry or even afraid at the direction Labour were taking under Keir Starmer's failing right-wing leadership. My request was met with further silence. However, I was finally offered a chance to finally speak to McKee – for 15 minutes, with less than 24 hours' notice for the following weekday. I was also asked for details of the group that wanted to meet with McKee. Before I had a chance to provide anything, the offer was rescinded. READ MORE: Labour council takes no action against councillor who grabbed Gaza protester by neck According to a caseworker, McKee was too busy focusing on issues such as homelessness (even though the primary responsibility for homelessness lies with local councils, not MPs). Instead, he would respond to the issues I had raised in my previous emails. I did not receive a response to my previous emails. Nor the next ones I sent. But after more following up, I was offered a solo surgery date four weeks later. It took five months, but I finally had the chance to speak to my MP. It was a complete waste of time. Face to face, I asked repeatedly if McKee would commit to meeting properly with a group of trans constituents to talk about the current dire situation being inflamed by his party – and the answer was no. I was told that if anyone had an issue, they could reach out to Gordon individually (emails to be sent to and he would be able to help on that basis – though the five months of ignored emails and U-turns to organise a 15-minute discussion would really suggest otherwise. Getting a straight answer to any question I asked proved almost as difficult as getting the meeting in the first place. READ MORE: Why is the BBC not talking about Scottish concerns? I was reminded of this exchange last week when I saw McKee pop up on the Sunday National's list of MPs running a cross-party group looking to 'partner' with defence firms, to give them exclusive access to Westminster MPs and policy makers for as little as £1499. It took nearly six months for my MP to meet me, but now I see my error. If only I had been an arms firm with cash to spare, maybe the process could have been expedited somewhat. In the scheme of things, my experience is not the worst by any measure. But it is a story being told the length of the United Kingdom on a daily basis. We are treated with absolute contempt by the British political class, who will cosy up to arms firms while proscribing people who take action against them as terrorists. Politicians will attack your rights, your welfare and your freedom while thumbing their nose at even the suggestion of accountability. I doubt McKee is any worse than his colleagues, but isn't that just the greatest indictment of the political establishment he represents?
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Transport for NSW threatens to deregister Sydney driver's car over numberplate
A Lebanese-Australian has been forced to hand in a set of number plates after Transport for NSW said they 'may give rise to controversy or public disagreement'. Mahmoud, who lives in Greenacre in Sydney 's south-west, was told by Transport for NSW last month that it would deregister his 'FU2IDF' number plates if he didn't turn them in. Mahmoud registered the plates in 2024 as 'my silent protest' in response to the Gaza War between Hamas and its allies and Israel. The war is the deadliest for Palestinians in the unresolved Israeli–Palestinian and Gaza–Israel conflicts dating back to the 20th century. 'My wife is Palestinian. Her family has had people killed since the start of the occupation in 1948. They've been displaced, they can't go home. So this is raw for us,' he told the publication Deepcut. Mahmoud received a letter from Transport for NSW on June 30 telling him to return his plates within 18 days or risk losing his registration. 'Transport for NSW has policies that prevent particular number plate content being displayed,' the letter read. 'This is related, but not limited to, content that has a religious theme, is discriminatory, is political, promotes violence, has a sexual reference, promotes drug taking/drinking or may be deemed to give rise to controversy or public disagreement. Mahmoud shows off the letter he was sent by Transport for NSW on June 30 'Transport for NSW has determined that these number plates may give rise to controversy or public disagreement and must be returned.' Mahmoud claimed his free speech rights were being taken away as he protests the war in the Middle East and Israel's treatment of Palestinians. 'I thought this was a free country where people can express themselves and their opinions,' he said. 'Some people find my number plate offensive, but the murder of tens of thousands of women and children isn't offensive to them.' Mahmoud even told a story of how a NSW police officer pulled him over before asking about the number plates. 'He was adamant that he wanted me to disclose what the plates meant. Once I disclosed what it meant, he actually shook my hand,' Mahmoud said. Mahmoud will turn the plates in, but has no plans to stop speaking out about the situation in Gaza. His other vehicle - a Toyota LandCruiser - has information about the Israel-Palestine war printed on the back. 'People see my car and give me the thumbs-up all the time. I want to spread that awareness so people understand the reality of what's been going on in Palestine for decades.'
