Girl, 8, died after falling 60ft from 'cluttered' sixth-floor balcony visiting her mother who had smoked cannabis that day, inquest hears
A 'happy' eight-year-old girl fell 60ft to her death from a cluttered sixth-floor balcony after visiting her mother who had smoked cannabis that day, an inquest heard today.
Minnie-Rae Dunn tragically died from catastrophic injuries after she fell from the balcony which had 'little space' and was cluttered with eight bin bags full of clothes and furniture.
Her heartbroken mother Rebecca Dunn told her inquest she initially told Minnie-Rae that she could not play on her balcony, but ended up 'giving in' because 'I'm a sucker for her eyes'.
At the time of the incident, Ms Dunn had smoked cannabis, which she uses for medicinal purposes to help her with her anxiety and mental health.
Ms Dunn said allowing 'sassy' Minnie-Rae onto the outdoor terrace has been the 'biggest mistake of my life'.
A coroner today ruled that Minnie-Rae's death was 'an accident', caused when the youngster fell after she stood on an object.
In a heartfelt written tribute after the inquest, Minnie-Rae's family said she had a 'smile as bright as the sun'.
The inquest at Portsmouth Coroner's Court, Hants, was told that Minnie-Rae had lived with her grandmother Dorothy Kenney since October 2018.
The youngster would often visit her mum, who lived in a flat in Pickwick House tower block in Buckland, Portsmouth.
Ms Dunn was asked about how often Minnie-Rae would play on the balcony and she said 'not all the time, but sometimes'.
It was heard that Minnie-Rae would colour and paint on the outdoor terrace, which had a wall that was one and a half metres high.
The inquest heard the balcony had an item of furniture on it, which was referred to as a pouffe and padded seat by the coroner.
There were also eight bin bags containing clothes belonging to Ms Dunn's other daughter.
Ms Dunn said that the pouffe was usually positioned closer to the door but had been moved.
'Someone went out for a fag and moved it and didn't move it back,' she told the inquest.
On August 24 2023, Minnie-Rae was visiting her mum with another young girl, who has not been named for legal reasons.
On that day, Ms Dunn had smoked a 'joint of cannabis in the morning and another at around five o'clock in the afternoon'.
'I do it for my mental health,' Ms Dunn told the inquest.
Jason Pegg, area coroner for Hampshire, Portsmouth and Southampton, asked the mother whether she thought this had impacted upon her 'ability to look after Minnie-Rae'.
In response, she said: 'No, it never has before.'
The inquest heard that in the late afternoon and early evening, the girls went out onto the balcony.
Describing how this came about, Ms Dunn said: 'She did ask me to go out but I said no at first.
'They got slime all over the bed, and I'm a sucker for her eyes, I ended up giving in and that is the biggest mistake of my life.'
While outside, Minnie-Rae was 'playing and chatting' with the other young girl before she tragically fell to her death.
The circumstances are unclear but it is understood that the youngster stood on an object on the balcony, meaning she was 'elevated'.
The girl told the police that she had tried to grab Minnie-Rae's leg as she slipped backwards but was unable to hold on.
One neighbour described hearing a 'loud dull thud' as the youngster hit the concrete while another said they saw a 'flash of burgundy' from their window before hearing a 'bang'.
Despite efforts of medical staff, Minnie-Rae died at the scene.
Ms Dunn described her daughter as 'sassy', adding: 'She was a good kid.'
Ms Kenney, Minnie-Rae's grandmother, told the inquest: 'She was happy.
'She loved her family, she loved school and friends and she liked to go out playing, going to different places on holidays.
'She was quite a happy girl.
'She used to like charge around quite a bit, like round the house and stuff.
'When it came to like danger and stuff like that, she was quite savvy, quite a savvy girl.
'But, she could be a bit clumsy at times.'
A post-mortem examination concluded that Minnie-Rae died of multiple injuries sustained in a fall from height.
Delivering his conclusion, Mr Pegg said: '[Minnie-Rae] was a happy girl, someone who was loved by all of her family, someone who liked playing and someone who would spend some of her time with her mother at Pickwick House.
'Ms Dunn... you have told me that Minnie-Rae was sassy and a good kid and you told me about the occasions when she would come and visit you at your flat.
'You have told me that when Minnie-Rae would come and visit you, she would go out onto the balcony on occasions and play with her friend who was of a similar age.'
Mr Pegg said he heard evidence that the balcony is usually 'free of any debris and clutter'.
He continued: 'But, on the 24th of August 2023, when Minnie-Rae visited your flat there were a number of black bin bags containing clothes, distributed and cluttering the balcony.
'There was very little space for Minnie-Rae and [the other girl] to go and play out onto the balcony.'
Mr Pegg spoke of how the girls would have wanted to play on the balcony because it was likely a 'fine' summer's day.
He referred to evidence from Ms Dunn, who said that she 'didn't think about the fact there was not much space' for the girls on the balcony.
Mr Pegg said: 'Minnie-Rae stood on something, elevating herself so that her waist was above the wall of the balcony.
'Minnie-Rae then fell from that balcony.'
Mr Pegg returned a conclusion of an accidental death for the youngster.
He said: 'Minnie-Rae fell from the sixth floor balcony... onto the ground below, causing Minnie Rae to suffer multiple injuries.
'Minnie-Rae had been playing on the balcony and during that time, had elevated herself on an object which had been left on the balcony, causing Minnie-Rae to fall over the balcony wall.'
In a handwritten tribute, Ms Dunn and Minnie-Rae's sister Porscha said: 'Minnie Rae was a happy, loveable, sassy, little girl.
'She was loved by all that met her. She made friends wherever she went. Her family adored her.
'Her passing had and continues to have a massive impact in our lives.
'Losing our sweet Minnie-Moo was devastating but we will always have such fun memories of her, such as when we went to the sunflower field, her smile was just as bright as the sun.
'We will have to love you from afar, but that love will never, never stop.
'Love and miss you forever in our hearts.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
11 minutes ago
- BBC News
MSPs vote in favour of scaled-back social care reforms
MSPs have unanimously passed legislation which will allow people in care homes to receive visits from a named loved one even in restricted Care Reform (Scotland) Bill will also introduce changes to social care procurement and a new right to breaks for unpaid legislation was backed by 116 votes to to introduce a national care service, which were initially part of the bill, were dropped in January after unions withdrew support and a number of health boards and care organisations expressed concerns. What changes to social care are planned? One of the big changes planned under the new law is a legal right to breaks for unpaid mean councils will have a duty to decide whether a carer is able to take sufficient breaks from their caring they are not, then the local authority will provide support to enable this, such as providing funding for short respite policy, given Scotland has around 700,000 unpaid carers, will cost between £196m and £315m by 2035/36, according to the Bill's financial it remains a fraction of the £13.9bn that unpaid care is currently saving Scotland every to the way information is shared in health and social care - to make it less likely that people will have to repeat their information - as well changes to procurement rules in the sector are also up the powers that watchdogs can take against failing care providers is also part of the most high-profile part of the Care Reform (Scotland) Bill is Anne's Law, which allows people in care homes to receive visits from a named loved one even in restricted is named after Anne Duke, who died aged 63 in November 2021 after being cut off from her family while battling early-onset dementia during the Covid pandemic. Why was the National Care Service ditched? The original proposal for a National Care Service, inspired by the NHS, was to take social care provision and staff away from local authorities into a new national was then dropped in favour of creating a national care board to supervise service delivery and improve consistency - but this failed to win over a growing number of body Cosla and trade unions then withdrew their support for the project, while a number of health boards and care organisations also expressed plan, which was also subject to a series of delays, was eventually scrapped in January after £30m was spent on the Care Minister Maree Todd said at the time she was "still committed to the ambitions of the National Care Service" but added the SNP no longer had the support it needed in parliament to pass its original plans into law.
Telegraph
13 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Academics lose discrimination case over trans-critical film
Two academics have failed in their attempt to sue their union for stopping their trans-critical film from being shown to students at the University of Edinburgh. Dr Deirdre O'Neill, a lecturer at the University of Hertfordshire, and Michael Wayne, a professor at Brunel University, argued that they suffered unlawful discrimination when the University and College Union (UCU) opposed their film, Adult Human Female, which challenges claims made by trans rights activists. On Monday, Employment Judge Laidler, sitting with two side members, concluded the claimants were not treated detrimentally contrary to the Equality Act 2010, and were not subjected to harassment. Mary Senior, a UCU Scotland official, welcomed what she described as 'a sensible and common-sense decision'. She added: 'I am proud that UCU successfully defended this case in tribunal. It cannot be right that a trade union is not able to protest peacefully within the law and to employers when material is presented on campus which it believes attacks the human rights of others.' The tribunal, which was held remotely, heard that in November 2022, Dr O'Neill and Prof Wayne released their film examining claims made by trans rights activists that 'trans women are women and should be treated as women in all legal and social contexts'. The UCU's branch at the University of Edinburgh wrote to its principal, Prof Sir Peter Mathieson, asking the university not to host or facilitate the film screening, which it regarded as an 'attack on trans people's identities and not in line with the [university's] dignity and respect policy'. The tribunal was told that the union also published a series of social media posts denouncing the showing of the film, describing it as transphobic hate, and encouraging protests which twice blocked screenings in Edinburgh. The academics said the UCU's opposition amounted to unlawful discrimination on the basis of their gender-critical belief that there are only two sexes. Film 'contained misinformation' At the time, they wrote to Jo Grady, the union's general secretary, asking her to confirm they were entitled to their gender-critical beliefs and that UCU did not support preventing the showing of their film. Ms Grady confirmed that gender-critical beliefs were recognised to be legitimate philosophical beliefs protected under the Equality Act 2010. She also noted that UCU members held many opposing views and that it was not for the union to stand in the way of members and branches protesting certain expressions of protected beliefs. The tribunal noted that UCU Edinburgh was not objecting to the beliefs of the claimants but was protesting against a film which it believed presented misinformation about trans and non-binary people and that was damaging to trans and non-binary staff and students. Ms Senior added: 'It is welcome to have this positive decision at the start of Pride month, and at a time when trans and non-binary people feel under attack. 'This decision demonstrates that trade unions and others can stand up for trans rights and trans inclusivity, and our union is committed to continuing to promote a more equal and safe world for all people regardless of their gender identity'.
The Sun
13 minutes ago
- The Sun
I made my own privacy fence using our old Ikea doors & £30 ‘forest scene' Temu wallpaper that's been slashed to just £8
A DIY fan has given her garden the ultimate makeover thanks to her new privacy fence. Liz Smith took to social media to share the new addition to her backyard and how she did it on a budget. 2 2 Sharing an image of the garden, Liz had put up a black privacy 'fence' and decorated it with a woodland-themed mural. But instead of forking out for pricey wood, she decided to upcycle old items she had lying about in her house. The DIY whizz revealed she had some old Ikea folding doors knocking about, so she decided to use them instead. Liz said: "Used old IKEA doors and sticky back plastic murals from Temu for the frieze to make a focal point" The black doors were sealed shut and Liz then added the stick-on murals to each door. The cheap and effective decoration is currently on sale at Temu for £8 instead of £30. She revealed she used screws to fix the doors to the top and bottom of the brick wall to keep them upright. The gardening pro also pointed out that her plants were still growing despite the doors blocking the light out. "Plants still growing so the lighting will soften on the house," she said. To finish the garden makeover, she added plenty of twinkling fairy lights around the border of the doors and along the wall of the house. I made a DIY fence for £68 with pallets from Facebook Marketplace - it gives more privacy & people say it's 'fantastic' The post was shared on the Facebook group, Garden Makeover Ideas On A Budget, and people were in awe of her DIY skills. One person wrote: "Stunning, love it. What a great original idea to do that with the doors!" Another commented: 'It's lovely I love the lights." "Beautiful," penned a third. Rules on fences and trees Fences: Height Restrictions: In most areas, fences in front gardens should not exceed one metre in height without planning permission. For rear gardens, the limit is generally two metres. Shared Fences: If a fence is shared with a neighbour, both parties are typically responsible for its maintenance and any costs associated with repairs or replacement. Building Regulations: Ensure that any new fence complies with local building regulations and does not obstruct visibility for drivers or pedestrians. Trees: Ownership: Trees located on your property are your responsibility, including any damage they may cause. Conversely, trees on a neighbour's property are their responsibility. Overhanging Branches: You are entitled to trim branches that overhang into your property, but only up to the boundary line. The cut branches should be offered back to the tree owner. Protected Trees: Some trees are protected by Tree Preservation Orders (TPOs). Check with your local council before undertaking any work on a tree, as unauthorised work can result in fines. Roots: If tree roots from a neighbour's tree cause damage to your property, you have the right to remove the roots. However, it is advisable to discuss this with your neighbour first to avoid disputes. Always consult your local council or a legal adviser for specific regulations and advice. "Looks fantastic,' claimed a fifth. Someone else added: 'This is gorgeous."
