Incels, misogyny, role models: what England's new relationships and sex education lessons will cover – and how young people will benefit
The new guidance also looks different in many ways to the last statutory guidance, released in 2019. It includes many new and valuable topics such as the law around strangulation, sextortion, upskirting, deepfakes, suicide prevention and bereavement. Schools are also required to challenge misogynistic ideas, cover misogynistic influencers and online content, and explore prejudice and pornography.
As a researcher working on sex education and masculinity, I see many positives in how these issues are approached in the government's new guidance. The new topics are a move in the right direction, meeting the needs of the pupils being taught.
Get your news from actual experts, straight to your inbox. Sign up to our daily newsletter to receive all The Conversation UK's latest coverage of news and research, from politics and business to the arts and sciences.
Another key change is the removal of the proposal to put age restrictions on the teaching of certain topics. This is welcome news: it aligns with evidence and allows teachers to design sex education that takes context into account. It means they can teach their pupils what they need to know in a proactive and responsive way.
The guidance also explicitly mentions giving pupils the opportunity to discuss incels. Incel, an abbreviation of 'involuntary celibate', refers to those who identify as wanting romantic and sexual partners but find it difficult to achieve this.
Online incel communities are underpinned by hostility towards women, resentment, misogyny and the support of extreme violence against women. They may espouse an ideological position that claims societal structures are set up to unfairly disadvantage them.
Keeping boys in the conversation
One aspect included in the guidance is that it is important for pupils to understand that 'most boys and young men are respectful to girls and young women and each other'. It also states that 'teachers should avoid language which stigmatises boys, or suggests that boys or men are always perpetrators or that girls or women are always victims'.
These are really important points that need to underpin the teaching of misogyny and online incel culture. A risk is that such teaching may otherwise portray boys, as a group, as perpetrators. This can create a culture of blame that may alienate boys and young men. Instead, seeing boys as valuable contributors to these conversations around misogyny can foster educational progress.
Another important reference in the guidance is that children and young people should have opportunities to develop 'positive conceptions of masculinity and femininity', and how to 'identify and learn from positive male role models'.
This focus on positive examples of masculinity is a welcome way to support boys and young men in developing healthy identities – not only considering gender but other intersecting aspects of their identity, such as class, ethnicity, culture and values.
Good relationships and sex education needs dialogue and understanding between pupils, teachers and parents. For adults, this means knowing the landscape first. Familiarisation with why young people may be attracted to problematic online spaces will be useful.
These online spaces often offer a skewed sense of belonging, and offer simplistic answers to complex emotions and questions. Young people's thoughts and opinions of misogynist online influencers may be contradictory, rather than simple approval or disapproval. This requires thoughtful unpicking of concepts and ideals, and open conversation rather than blame. It is also important to recognise that teaching these topics is not easy, and that teachers may need support too.
New content
While much of the new guidance is welcome, it's important that teacher training and professional development keeps pace with these changes. Teachers may not feel confident addressing such a broad range of often-sensitive topics without support.
The guidance also falls short of making relationships and sex education statutory for those aged 16-18 in sixth-form colleges, 16-19 academies or further education colleges, despite evidence that it is very much needed for this age group.
The rights of transgender people and the issues affecting them are dealt with in a limited way, which could affect teachers' ability to have supportive conversations with trans and non-binary pupils. There is also limited detail for those working in special education for pupils with complex needs.
One of the most important aspects of teaching on sex and relationships is to create a safe space for open discussion.
Young people should be encouraged to provide their own input into how relationships and sex education is taught, and to give their ideas on what they feel they need to learn about – and what they already know. While this approach is often overlooked, meaningful engagement with pupils is highlighted as a key guiding principle in the new guidance.
Young people are the experts on the world they inhabit. It is essential they are listened to to ensure that lessons are relevant and effective.
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.
Sophie King-Hill receives funding from the ESRC.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
32 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Britain to lower voting age to 16, sparking debate among lawmakers
On Thursday, the British government, led by the Labour Party, announced major changes to its electoral system, most notably plans to lower the voting age from 18 to 16 before the next general election in 2029. Prime Minister Keir Starmer defended the reform, arguing that people who 'pay in' to the political system deserve to cast their vote and have a voice in how their money is spent. The electoral overhaul goes beyond lowering age requirements. The proposed changes include allowing bank cards to be used as voter ID and increased rules on political donations. However, these changes still need to be approved by Parliament before becoming law, according to The Associated Press. This reform fulfills a key campaign promise made by Labour before their July 2024 election victory, when they pledged to expand voting rights to younger citizens, per the AP. Global context The U.K. isn't alone in wanting to shift to a lower voter age. Last year, European Union members Germany, Belgium, Austria and Malta moved to lower their citizens' voting age to 16, as reported by Reuters. However, the global standard remains 18 years of age in most democracies. MPs in Parliament clash over electoral changes The announcement has sparked debate across party lines, with Labour Party members championing the change while Conservative and Reform members of the United Kingdom's Parliament have expressed opposition. Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner framed the reform as essential for rebuilding political trust, as reported by the AP. 'For too long, public trust in our democracy has been damaged and faith in our institutions has been allowed to decline,' Rayner said. 'We are taking action to break down barriers to participation that will ensure more people have the opportunity to engage in U.K. democracy.' Conservative MPs have responded with more skepticism. Tory MP Paul Holmes criticized both the substance of the proposal and the way it was introduced, expressing frustration that significant electoral changes weren't announced through a formal government statement. Holmes highlighted what he sees as inconsistencies in the government's approach to age-related rights. 'Why does this government think a 16-year-old can vote but not be allowed to buy a lottery ticket or an alcoholic drink, marry or go to war, or even stand in the elections they're voting?' Holmes asked during Thursday's House of Commons session, as reported by The Guardian. Holmes continued, 'Isn't the government's position on the age of maturity just hopelessly confused?' Reform party leader Nigel Farage and Reform MP Richard Tice both posted their opposition to the electoral reform in posts on X. 'Giving 16 and 17-year-olds the right to vote is an attempt to rig the political system,' Farage said. Tice called the move 'wrong.' Labour MP Lisa Nandy also took to X but to voice her support of the government's changes. 'Young people deserve a say in the decisions shaping their future and we're making sure they have one,' she said. The proposal faces a challenging path through Parliament, with the government's substantial majority likely to overcome opposition, but not without debate that so far has revealed fundamental differences in how British lawmakers view youth participation in their democracy. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Tariffs at 30 Percent Would Be a Tipping Point for European Furniture- and Lighting-makers
MILAN — Will a tariff-for-tariff battle play out on both sides of the Atlantic or will the EU be able to broker a deal and avert crisis? That is top of mind for Italian furniture and home industry leaders, as a 30 percent duty on exports as early as Aug. 1 would be a dramatic blow to business. Until now, firms have held strong and pledged, for the most part, merely to raise prices for the U.S. consumer. The consequences will be severe and impact jobs and growth if duties rise even further, design pillars said after U.S. President Donald Trump posted letters to Truth Social detailing the new duty rates for Mexico and the 27-member European trade bloc on July 12. More from WWD Trump Trade Deal Revealed: Indonesia Shoe Imports to US Will Face 19 Percent Tariff Rate Shoe Prices Dip in June but Tariff Pressures Could Lead to Increases Later This Year, FDRA and AAFA Say President Trump's Tariffs Spark Reactions in Italy According to Claudio Feltrin, president of FederlegnoArredo, the Italian federation of woodworking and furniture industries which represents the majority of Europe's luxury furniture-makers, being subject to Trump's whims is dismaying. 'Faced with the news of Trump's decision to introduce 30 percent tariffs on EU exports to the U.S., we can only be concerned and alarmed. Europe must avoid a tariff-against-tariff battle that would benefit no one,' Feltrin said, adding that the entire European production system would be severely impacted. The Italian wood-furniture sector's second largest market by export value is the U.S. 'Failing to defend our businesses now could result in the industrial desertification of the Old Continent,' he added. The Lighting Sector Bears Additional Tariffs Carlo Urbinati, who is also president and chief executive officer of Italian lighting house Foscarini and president of the Italian lighting association Assoluce, also said the lighting sector would certainly be severely impacted if the currently declared tariff levels were to remain in place beyond Aug. 1. The lighting sector also bears the added burden of the 50 percent tariff on aluminum and steel, already in place. 'This situation makes it decidedly difficult for companies to maintain market share in the U.S., especially for technical and outdoor/public lighting, where the share of aluminum and steel is significantly higher,' he warned. Foscarini had already updated its U.S. price lists with an initial 7.5 percent increase after the initial announcement and is ready to update that percentage upwards to 10 and 12 percent, taking into account the weak dollar, which has dropped approximately 10 percent over the last six months. Confartigianato – the lobbying group that supports artisans and 1.5 million businesses, 12 trade federations and 41 craft associations, including those representing furniture, decor and fashion –estimates the nominal value of the impact at risk at 17.8 billion euros in exports from Italian micro and small businesses that trade with the U.S. Small and micro businesses represent a large part of the industrial backbone of the Italian economy. What Sets Italy Apart? Italy's top markets outside of the EU are China and the U.S. Its exports to China have suffered, due to a consumer spending slowdown amid a housing and economic slowdown. The U.S. market faces additional pressures, like the declining dollar, which hit its lowest point against the euro in four years at the end of June. Andrea Sasso, CEO of Dexelance, which is home to upscale brands like Meridiani, Turri and lighting-maker Davide Groppi, was concerned about the combined effect of the further devaluation of the dollar and the increased tariffs. 'Not so much because of the size of the increase itself, but because of the general uncertainty that this combination might generate in the market,' he said. Sasso added that instead of raising its prices, it has introduced a 'custom tariffs' declaration on its invoices, which detail the monetary impact of duties, guaranteeing transparency. 'We intend to maintain this same approach even if the tariffs were to rise to 30 percent,' he said. In 2024, turnover of Italy's wood furnishing sector, which represents the makers and brands that fuel the wider luxury furnishings sector, reached 51.7 billion euros. In a trade note in March, national statistics bureau Istat examined Italy's exposure to the U.S. vis-à-vis exports amid the global escalation on trade. The report said that furniture accounts for 2.5 percent of all of Italy's goods exported to the U.S. The U.S. is Italy's largest trade partner outside of the EU; Italian exports to the U.S. accounted for 10 percent of all goods, in-line with those exported to Germany but higher than those traded with France and Spain. The EU and the U.S. are each other's largest trading partners by far, according to the European Commission. A Fatal Blow for U.S. Manufacturers Trump supporters are hoping trade policy will reinvigorate Made in America and its domestic supply chains, which saw its manufacturing prowess decline significantly in the 1970s and 1980s and beyond. At that time, companies began shifting production outside the U.S., facilitated by trade agreements with China and the entry of China into the World Trade Organization. For now, Trump's administration has secured investments in the U.S., like a $14 billion investment from Japan's Nippon Steel that he said will create at least 70,000 jobs and will ensure steel is made in America for decades to come. Today, companies that survived the Made in America crisis of the 1980s and '90s are feeling the burn and raising concerns about Trump's economic agenda. Tariffs dealt a fatal blow to the furniture pulse of Eastern Michigan, shuttering the doors of two historic names: the Howard Miller Company and Hekman. Press reports in July indicated that Michigan-born Howard Miller, which took over Hekman, also born in Michigan, in 1983, will halt operations, with plans to shutter its doors by next year. Since the dawn of the housing market downturn, Howard Miller's sales suffered due to higher tariffs, resulting in unsustainable costs for materials and components, according to various local news outlets. The Retail Effect Luca Fuso, CEO of Haworth Lifestyle's Design Division, which includes upscale design firm Cassina, confirmed that a 30 percent tariff would diminish sales to the U.S. across the board. 'The effect of Trump's letter is to freeze any purchases from the U.S. during the current month and to increase prices for the final customers once the tariff is finalized and applicable, thus reducing the sales potential of EU brands for the future,' he said. Fellow furniture-maker Boffi|DePadova's top market is the U.S. and it recently opened a sprawling flagship on New York City's Madison Avenue to cater to its growing American clientele. Its CEO and president Roberto Gavazzi has said that Italian high-end companies are better positioned than others to battle the crisis as they are not in direct competition with American producers, but expressed concern over recent developments. 'This [tariffs] is still under negotiation and we need to be careful in making comments about how things will go. If the 30 percent tariffs [happen, it ] will certainly affect every business. Every evaluation will be made after this becomes a certainty,' he warned. Despite the obstacles, the U.S. market remains strategic for fellow luxury furniture firm Giorgetti. Their CEO Giovanni del Vecchio confirmed the company will press forward with planned investments, including the opening of a new flagship store in Miami, and will strengthen its presence in key cities such as New York, Houston, Boston and Washington, D.C., alongside selective distribution through around 10 leading multibrand retailers. A Glimmer of Hope Furniture-makers are still holding out hope as the EU continues to weigh its options with the goal of reaching some sort of middle ground. Economists have said that the EU has a few negotiating chips to play, like offering to boost its imports of U.S. military equipment, reduce tariffs and restrictions on U.S. imports like cars and negotiate down the U.S. goods trade deficit with the EU, which swelled to $235.6 billion in 2024, according to U.S. government data. The EU, on the other hand, has a trade surplus with the U.S., which stood at 17.9 billion euros in December 2024. Trump's letter to the EU included a demand that Europe drop its own tariffs. 'The European Union will allow complete, open market access to the United States, with no tariff being charged to us, in an attempt to reduce the large trade deficit,' he wrote. European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen said the 30 percent tariffs 'would disrupt essential transatlantic supply chains, to the detriment of businesses, consumers and patients on both sides of the Atlantic.' Growth Prospects Market drivers for the Italian economy remain. According to economists at Istat, the Italian economy is expected to grow 0.6 percent in 2025 and 0.8 percent in 2026, supported by domestic demand though a 'negative impact of tariffs on global trade and international growth prospects is still assumed.' Feltrin and business owners here are also banking on growth in the Middle East in new frontiers in Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates. Though new markets, such as Southeast Asia and the Middle East, are expanding their adoption of design, Fuso cautioned that this won't be enough to weather the storm. 'We cannot consider the upside of one area as offsetting the loss of another. The tariffs are surely a mighty blow to Italian design in a relevant and mature market as the United States and this will affect the overall growth of brands worldwide,' he said. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Wall Street Journal
an hour ago
- Wall Street Journal
Europe Gets Tougher on Putin
European leaders on Friday at long last cranked up sanctions on Russia, sending Vladimir Putin a message that there will be more economic costs if he continues his drone and missile barrages on Ukraine. Now it's Washington's turn. Brussels' latest sanctions package ratchets up economic pressure on Moscow by closing loopholes and punishing foreign companies that circumvent them. Europe has already ended most of its Russian natural gas imports by pipeline. Oil tankers that are insured by European companies are also prohibited from transporting Russian crude sold at more than $60 a barrel.
