logo
Neurosurgeon loses High Court claim against McLaren branch over snowmobile crash

Neurosurgeon loses High Court claim against McLaren branch over snowmobile crash

Andrew Cannestra suffered a brain injury when his snowmobile crashed near Ivalo, northern Finland, on February 2 2020 during a four-night 'Pure McLaren Arctic Experience' arranged by McLaren Automotive Events.
Barristers for the 54-year-old Floridian told a trial in London earlier this month that the company was negligent and in breach of contract, including allegations that a safety briefing given by guides for a 'snowmobile safari' was inadequate.
They also claimed that a guide sped off, causing Mr Cannestra to lose sight of him and speed up in an attempt to keep up, which led to him losing control of the snowmobile on a turn, veering off the track into deep snow, and hitting a tree.
The company defended the legal action, with its lawyers saying there was 'no evidence' the briefing did not meet safety standards and that the 'irreducible risk' of the activity was 'reasonably controlled'.
In a ruling on Friday, Mr Justice Ritchie said the safety briefing complied with relevant standards and that the crash was caused by Mr Cannestra's 'accidental throttle use' when entering the turn.
He said: 'It was not caused by 'out of sight' guiding. It was not caused by the claimant going too fast because he was trying to keep up with a disappeared guide.
'It was caused by accidental throttle use by the claimant due to failing to follow the instructions which he had been given about safe operation during a left turn, with the guide well in sight before both turns one and two.'
Neil Block KC, representing Mr Cannestra, told a seven-day trial in London in written submissions that Mr Cannestra and his former partner, Kaitlin Mealor, spent almost £24,000 before flights on the 'couples package', with activities including driving a McLaren car on ice, and optional events such as snowmobiling.
While Mr Cannestra had experience driving supercars, he and Ms Mealor were 'absolute novices' on snowmobiles, Mr Block said.
The barrister said the pair were given a safety briefing by two guides, Arto Pitkanen and Jouni Satta, which lasted 'approximately five minutes', but alleged it was not 'proper and adequate' as it did not include information on track layout or the positions of potential hazards.
Mr Block said the Lynx Xtrim 900 snowmobiles had three modes – eco, standard and sport – with the tour beginning in eco mode, which had a top speed of 40kph.
Shortly after the activity began, Mr Block said the group stopped, and Mr Pitkanen approached Mr Cannestra and changed the mode, which increased its top speed and was 'not appropriate'.
Mr Pitkanen was alleged to have then set off at speeds of up to 60kph, causing Mr Cannestra to lose sight of him and speed up as he 'did not want to be on his own'.
He suffered a 'very significant' brain injury and 'orthopaedic injuries' as a result of the crash, the court was told.
Giving evidence, Mr Cannestra acknowledged he initially told others following the crash that it was his 'error', but said he was 'not thinking clearly' at that time due to his 'traumatic brain injury'.
He said: 'The guides simply did not guide me through the turns.
'That put my life in danger, and this never would have happened to me if that had occurred.'
Matthew Chapman KC, for the company, said in his written submissions that the turn where Mr Cannestra crashed was 'quite safe if negotiated at an appropriate speed', and that Mr Pitkanen changed the snowmobile's mode as Mr Cannestra was 'eager' for this to happen.
He added that Mr Cannestra's speed was 'wholly within his control', and the claim that Mr Pitkanen had driven too far in front 'cannot sensibly succeed'.
In his judgment, Mr Justice Ritchie ruled that Mr Pitkanen 'did not ride at excessive speed' and that the change of the snowmobile's mode did not have 'any proven causative effect on the accident', adding that Mr Cannestra was 'a mature, supercar and jet-ski aficionado, who had ridden confidently and wanted more speed'.
He continued that Mr Cannestra's evidence was 'illogical and contrived' and that a 'fundamental problem' with it was that it was 'contradictory to what he said after the accident'.
He said: 'For a man with substantial experience of driving super cars, with very high intelligence and a clear understanding of the dangers of driving at speed on corners, he based his case on ignoring those dangers and desperately wanting to keep up with a guide.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Christian Horner's sacking no surprise given Red Bull ‘drama'
Christian Horner's sacking no surprise given Red Bull ‘drama'

Glasgow Times

timea day ago

  • Glasgow Times

Christian Horner's sacking no surprise given Red Bull ‘drama'

Horner's tenure as boss of Red Bull was dramatically brought to an end on July 9, ending a 20-year chapter in charge of a team he led to 14 world championships. His departure came 17 months after he was accused by a female staff member of 'inappropriate behaviour'. Horner, 51, always denied the claims and was twice exonerated. Red Bull have struggled on the track this season, with four-time world champion Max Verstappen, who is 69 points off the title pace ahead of this weekend's Belgian Grand Prix, consistently linked with a move away from the team. Brown was not surprised by Horner's departure (David Davies/PA) Against that backdrop, Brown, whose McLaren team lead the way in both constructors' and drivers' championships, says he was not shocked to see Horner dismissed. 'I'm maybe (surprised by) the timing, but not the result,' Brown told Canadian TV channel TSN. 'I think there's been a lot of drama there the last couple of years and it doesn't seem like that drama has been calming down – maybe been getting worse.' Verstappen has a contract, which includes a performance-related release clause, until 2028, but Mercedes are interested in signing him and the Dutchman has been hesitant to say he will see out his Red Bull deal. Verstappen's future has dominated the agenda this season (David Davies/PA) Horner was the youngest F1 team principal when he took charge of the team in 2005 and has overseen two spells of dominance, with Sebastian Vettel and Verstappen both winning four consecutive drivers' titles. Brown believes Horner could return to motorsport in the future, adding: 'Given his age and his history in motor racing, I'd be surprised if he didn't show up somewhere in motor racing. 'But I don't know his other interests, whether he wants to go run a football team or what have you. So, we'll see.'

Brown 'not surprised' by Horner's Red Bull sacking
Brown 'not surprised' by Horner's Red Bull sacking

BBC News

time2 days ago

  • BBC News

Brown 'not surprised' by Horner's Red Bull sacking

McLaren Racing chief executive officer Zak Brown says he was "not surprised" Christian Horner was sacked as team boss of Red was dismissed as team principal and CEO of Red Bull on 9 July, three days after their driver Max Verstappen finished fifth in the British Grand told Canadian television channel TSN: "I'm maybe [surprised by] the timing, but not the result."There's been a lot of drama there the last couple of years and it doesn't seem like that drama has been calming down - maybe been getting worse. So I'm not surprised."Red Bull has given no reason for the removal of Horner, who has been replaced by Frenchman Laurent Mekies, formerly the principal of second team Racing had led the team since their debut in 2005. His departure came 17 months after it emerged that a female employee had accused him of sexual harassment and coercive, controlling behaviour. Two separate Red Bull internal investigations dismissed the allegations, which Horner has always then, Red Bull have gone through a tempestuous period, including a decline in their competitiveness. Their chief technical officer Adrian Newey resigned in April last year, at least partly as a result of the allegations against Horner. Newey - regarded as the greatest F1 designer in history - now works for Aston July last year, long-time sporting director Jonathan Wheatley also resigned. He is now team principal of Sauber, which next year is morphing into Audi's factory in September Red Bull head of strategy Will Courtenay signed for McLaren. He is currently being held to his contract and is expected to join his new team at some point next year. While Verstappen won his fourth consecutive world title last season, the Dutchman won only twice in the final 13 races of the year and Red Bull finished third in the constructors' year, Verstappen is third in the drivers' championship with just two wins in the first 12 races and the team fourth in the constructors' championship, and Red Bull have been engulfed by speculation about whether the Dutchman might leave for Mercedes at the end of the has had a strained relationship with Horner over the past few said Red Bull's breaching of the budget cap in 2021 "constitutes cheating", and in an interview with BBC Sport last summer Brown said he and Horner "used to get on".Brown has taken a less provocative approach to Horner this year, but has not hidden his disdain for Red Bull's sniping about the legality of the McLaren car behind the the Miami Grand Prix, he drank from a bottle labelled "tyre water", a reference to Horner complaining to the FIA about their belief that McLaren were using water to cool their tyres. Brown considered the allegation spurious, and said it had no foundation in described the bottle as "poking fun at a serious issue".Brown said: "Teams have historically made allegations of other teams - most recently one team focuses on that strategy more than others. And I think that there is a proper way to protest a team at the end of a race, and you have to make it formal, disclose where it comes from, put some money down."

McLaren boss Zak Brown ‘not surprised' after F1 arch rival Christian Horner's shock Red Bull exit
McLaren boss Zak Brown ‘not surprised' after F1 arch rival Christian Horner's shock Red Bull exit

The Independent

time2 days ago

  • The Independent

McLaren boss Zak Brown ‘not surprised' after F1 arch rival Christian Horner's shock Red Bull exit

McLaren F1 CEO Zak Brown insists he was 'not surprised' by the sudden departure of arch rival Christian Horner at Red Bull. Horner, 51, was relieved of his duties as team principal and F1 CEO at Red Bull Racing after 20 years in the role. Laurent Mekies, formerly of sister team Racing Bulls, has taken over ahead of this week's Belgian Grand Prix. Yet Brown, who enjoyed several vocal squabbles with Horner in the last few years, believes the 'drama' at Red Bull in recent times inevitably led to Horner's downfall. 'Maybe the timing, but not the result,' Brown told Canadian sports channel TSN, when asked if he was surprised by Horner's exit. 'I think there's been a lot of drama there the last couple of years and it doesn't seem like that drama has been calming down, maybe been getting worse. "So, I'm not surprised, anytime in the middle of the season. But we're head down on our championship. They've got Max [Verstappen] still knocking on the door, so we've got to pay attention to that. But, yeah, tremendous amount of success they've had.' Horner led Red Bull to six constructors' titles and eight drivers' championships during his time in charge, but saw the team plunge into issues in recent years. Red Bull were the only team in breach of the cost-cap in its initial year in 2021, while the investigation surrounding an allegation of 'inappropriate behaviour' against Horner – he was cleared twice – made headlines away from the racetrack at the start of last season. Despite this, Brown expects Horner – who has been linked with Ferrari and Alpine – to return to the paddock in some capacity. 'Given his age and his history in motor racing, I'd be surprised if he didn't show up somewhere in motor racing," Brown added. "But I don't know his other interests, whether he wants to go run a football team or what have you. So, we'll see.' Meanwhile, there are just eight points between championship leader Oscar Piastri and McLaren teammate Lando Norris heading into this week's race at Spa-Francorchamps.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store