Neurosurgeon loses High Court claim against McLaren branch over snowmobile crash
Barristers for the 54-year-old Floridian told a trial in London earlier this month that the company was negligent and in breach of contract, including allegations that a safety briefing given by guides for a 'snowmobile safari' was inadequate.
They also claimed that a guide sped off, causing Mr Cannestra to lose sight of him and speed up in an attempt to keep up, which led to him losing control of the snowmobile on a turn, veering off the track into deep snow, and hitting a tree.
The company defended the legal action, with its lawyers saying there was 'no evidence' the briefing did not meet safety standards and that the 'irreducible risk' of the activity was 'reasonably controlled'.
In a ruling on Friday, Mr Justice Ritchie said the safety briefing complied with relevant standards and that the crash was caused by Mr Cannestra's 'accidental throttle use' when entering the turn.
He said: 'It was not caused by 'out of sight' guiding. It was not caused by the claimant going too fast because he was trying to keep up with a disappeared guide.
'It was caused by accidental throttle use by the claimant due to failing to follow the instructions which he had been given about safe operation during a left turn, with the guide well in sight before both turns one and two.'
Neil Block KC, representing Mr Cannestra, told a seven-day trial in London in written submissions that Mr Cannestra and his former partner, Kaitlin Mealor, spent almost £24,000 before flights on the 'couples package', with activities including driving a McLaren car on ice, and optional events such as snowmobiling.
While Mr Cannestra had experience driving supercars, he and Ms Mealor were 'absolute novices' on snowmobiles, Mr Block said.
The barrister said the pair were given a safety briefing by two guides, Arto Pitkanen and Jouni Satta, which lasted 'approximately five minutes', but alleged it was not 'proper and adequate' as it did not include information on track layout or the positions of potential hazards.
Mr Block said the Lynx Xtrim 900 snowmobiles had three modes – eco, standard and sport – with the tour beginning in eco mode, which had a top speed of 40kph.
Shortly after the activity began, Mr Block said the group stopped, and Mr Pitkanen approached Mr Cannestra and changed the mode, which increased its top speed and was 'not appropriate'.
Mr Pitkanen was alleged to have then set off at speeds of up to 60kph, causing Mr Cannestra to lose sight of him and speed up as he 'did not want to be on his own'.
He suffered a 'very significant' brain injury and 'orthopaedic injuries' as a result of the crash, the court was told.
Giving evidence, Mr Cannestra acknowledged he initially told others following the crash that it was his 'error', but said he was 'not thinking clearly' at that time due to his 'traumatic brain injury'.
He said: 'The guides simply did not guide me through the turns.
'That put my life in danger, and this never would have happened to me if that had occurred.'
Matthew Chapman KC, for the company, said in his written submissions that the turn where Mr Cannestra crashed was 'quite safe if negotiated at an appropriate speed', and that Mr Pitkanen changed the snowmobile's mode as Mr Cannestra was 'eager' for this to happen.
He added that Mr Cannestra's speed was 'wholly within his control', and the claim that Mr Pitkanen had driven too far in front 'cannot sensibly succeed'.
In his judgment, Mr Justice Ritchie ruled that Mr Pitkanen 'did not ride at excessive speed' and that the change of the snowmobile's mode did not have 'any proven causative effect on the accident', adding that Mr Cannestra was 'a mature, supercar and jet-ski aficionado, who had ridden confidently and wanted more speed'.
He continued that Mr Cannestra's evidence was 'illogical and contrived' and that a 'fundamental problem' with it was that it was 'contradictory to what he said after the accident'.
He said: 'For a man with substantial experience of driving super cars, with very high intelligence and a clear understanding of the dangers of driving at speed on corners, he based his case on ignoring those dangers and desperately wanting to keep up with a guide.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Auto Car
3 hours ago
- Auto Car
Boxster, Focus, MR2, Twingo... These are the amazing 1990s cars you need to buy NOW (from just £1000!)
Close The 1990s were a time of great speed. As marathon-ready trainers became everyday footwear and hard-and-fast house music pulsed through city streets, it seemed a given that even the most snooze-worthy family hauler would be reheated into a have-a-go hero. Sierra Sapphire Cosworths and Lotus Carltons hit the headlines as the joyriders' favourites - eminently nickable and so fast the fuzz couldn't keep up. Japanese manufacturers finally stamped their mark on the performance car scene, undoubtedly helped along by the immense popularity of Sony's game-changing Playstation and the Gran Turismo series. And, as if we didn't already have it good enough, we witnessed a speed war between Jaguar, McLaren and many more besides. So revered were those cars that a great many of the '90s' motoring highlights are now well out of reach. What was once a £20,000 Honda NSX is now an £80,000 garage queen. Lancia Delta Integrales can push six figures, and even the common man's Ford Escort RS Turbo is £20,000. That isn't to say there aren't bargain superstars out there, however. Here are some of the best… Porsche Boxster (986) A howling flat six, super-sharp steering and stunning wide-hipped looks – they can all be yours from just £3000. Of course, the cheapest Boxsters are best avoided, but the truth is that these are surprisingly hardy little roadsters – provided you buy carefully. Its best-known Achilles is the intermediate-shaft (IMS) bearing, which in some cases fractures or even shatters after a long and hard life. This then throws off the engine's timing and shunts pistons into valves, requiring a really rather expensive rebuild. Thankfully, many examples' bearings have already been replaced, and typically with a sturdier aftermarket item that isn't prone to exploding. If it hasn't been done, add another £800 or so to the car's price, if you get it done alongside a new clutch – which you probably should. It's also worth checking the immobiliser, locks and alarms work as intended: blocked door seals or a leaky roof can mean the ECU (located under the driver's seat) gets wet and dies. Replacements are £500-plus. Still, it's easy to snag a good 'un – and you absolutely should, before prices soar. Volkswagen Corrado VR6 Volkswagen's junior coupé was always a tidy steer, but its full potential wasn't unleashed until 1992. The fitment of a potent 2.9-litre narrow-angle V6 made it the fastest front-driver of the day, and it somehow improved the handling compared with the smaller (but turbocharged) four-pot. Every Corrado was made from galvanised steel, so they hold up better against rust than many rivals – and it's a good indicator of a dodgy repair, which should be easy to spot. High-milers go for around £6000, but you shouldn't be scared off by that: these are generally reliable bona fide modern classics. Vauxhall Calibra 4x4 Turbo Early Calibras were tarnished with a reputation for being a bit too much like the Cavalier on which they were based. The 4x4 Turbo flipped that notion on its head, turning what was a slightly humdrum coupé into Britain's cheapest 150mph car. Today, though, they're an expensive window onto the past, with prices venturing well into five figures. Honda Integra Type R This was the car that really put the Type R name on the map when it landed here in 1998, thanks to an all-time-great engine and tremendous handling. Clean cars go for about £15k, but it's also worth considering importing one from Japan while the yen's value is low. Rover 220 Turbo 'Nasty steering, a vague gearchange, dubious handling and dead-feeling brakes,' we said back then, pulling no punches. The 220 may not be a good car to drive, but it has an intangible appeal as the plucky underdog. These are now incredibly rare and prices vary wildly, but around £5000 should be enough to secure one in mint condition. BMW 328i (E36) 'The hardest-hitting, least compromised all-rounder on sale for less than £30,000,' is what we reckoned of the 328i back in 1995. Much of the same remains true today, except you can snag one for one-tenth of the as-new asking price. Many have led hard lives, though – these were sub-£1000 cars for a long time – so buy carefully. Fiat Coupé A Chris Bangle masterpiece, and not half bad to drive either. The five-cylinder 20-valve engine, offered in both naturally aspirated and turbocharged forms, has the most exotic feel, but the four-cylinder option, a descendant of the Delta Integrale powerplant, still has the means to entertain. Rust is by far the biggest issue: inspect the sills, subframes, wheel arches, footwells, boot floor, exhaust… Basically, just give the whole thing a thorough going-over. Interior plastics are prone to developing a horrid sticky finish, too. Running project cars can be found for £500, but the best examples are north of £10,000. Toyota MR2 (SW20) Forget the second-generation MR2's reputation for having a wayward tail – we never thought that held very much water. Still, Toyota revised the model no fewer than five times, with updates two (in 1991) and three (1993) gradually softening the handling to tune out the risk of snap oversteer. Any MR2 is a great drive and a fairly reliable proposition, barring rust or any extensive modifications. It's worth seeking out a Japanese-import Turbo model or one with the atmospheric 'Beams' engine that came with Yamaha-developed cylinder heads; either example brings with it the soundtrack and performance the car's chassis and looks deserve. Such cars will set you back around £10,000. Renault Twingo The Twingo has aged like Mr Blobby: once a tad unsightly, but now remembered for flouting convention and embracing the absurd. In the Twingo's favour, it didn't single-handedly traumatise a generation of children, so it's looked back on a bit more fondly. You can occasionally find them from £5k, but it's perhaps easier to source and import a clean car yourself. If it's a pure driver's car you want, look elsewhere. But the Z3 has otherwise aged tremendously, with long-nosed, low-slung proportions and – as long as you go for the 2.0-litre engine or bigger – some of BMW's greatest straight-six lumps. Prices – from £1000 – are on the up, so now is the time to buy. Peugeot 306 GTi 'The GTi is back,' declared our road testers after sampling the performance-enhanced 306. For years, hot hatchbacks had been iced over, hamstrung by horrendous insurance premiums and the looming threat of theft. But the French machine's combination of a 167bhp four-pot (then one of the most powerful engines to have featured in a hatch), a six-speed gearbox (when most rivals made do with five ratios) and a simply stunning chassis raised the bar. Suddenly, the race was back on. Avoid track-converted cars; clean examples should start at £5000 or so. Mercedes-Benz SL (R129) Technically speaking, the R129's life started in the late 1980s, but the fourth-generation SL didn't really hit the limelight until a few years later. Its sheer desirability – thanks in no small part to those futuristic lines and stonking £50k-plus price tag – made it the darling of the burgeoning hip-hop subculture. And if you can picture yourself rollin' in a 500 Benz, just like Tupac, the good news is that SLs are today shockingly affordable. Just £3000 gets you behind the wheel of a ropey car, but we'd budget £10,000 or so for something more dependable. Engines ranged from a 2.8-litre V6 all the way up to a 7.3-litre V12 fettled by AMG (good luck finding one of those), but our pick was the grunty 5.0-litre V8, badged 500 SL. Look out for an original car with a good service history, and you shouldn't encounter too many issues. A hard-top roof is a desirable extra for the colder months, but the standard soft-top should prove adequate, providing it's been properly looked after (or replaced in the relatively recent past with an official Mercedes-Benz part). Ford Escort RS2000 Hot hatches are nothing new, but it's rare that the treatment proves to be the redemption story for what was otherwise a generational stinker. So it proved, however, for the maligned Mk5 Escort, transformed by a fizzy 148bhp twin-cam four, quicker steering and a chassis overhaul. The addition of four-wheel drive in 1994 only raised its limits, making it a genuine Cossie-lite. As remixes go, it's tantamount to The Prodigy turning a kids' safety ad about not talking to strangers into a rave classic. Not cheap today, though: expect to pay about £8000 for a good runner. Peugeot 106 GTi All the joy of the 306 GTi, but in a smaller, lighter and slipperier package. The 106 GTi was as close as Peugeot ever came to properly replacing the 205 GTi, and today a good example can fetch a five-figure sum. At that price, though, you should also consider the 106 Rallye, which went without power steering and much of the cabin kit in pursuit of pure driving thrills. Ford Focus The Focus was the car that righted all the later wrongs of its Escort predecessor and democratised the attributes of all the best driver's cars. Ignore the ST and the eye-wateringly expensive RS, and instead look for a tidy Zetec petrol that has managed to elude the tin worm. Just a few thousand pounds should snag one you can enjoy for years to come. BMW 8 Series Munich's Icarus was too heavy and too blunt in its responses to be a proper grand tourer, and it cost around the same money as Mercedes' SL. But in 1993 the tide began to turn with the introduction of the 850CSi. It was an M car in all but name, with its V12 engine upsized and boosted to a hearty 375bhp so the 8 could finally provide a driving experience that lived up to its gorgeous looks. It's also worth considering the later 4.4-litre 840Ci, which finally felt like the 8 Series had become a proper GT car. Prices for the 8 Series start at around £10,000, but CSis are now hitting £50,000-plus. Join our WhatsApp community and be the first to read about the latest news and reviews wowing the car world. Our community is the best, easiest and most direct place to tap into the minds of Autocar, and if you join you'll also be treated to unique WhatsApp content. You can leave at any time after joining - check our full privacy policy here. Next Prev In partnership with
Daily Mail
4 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Oscar Piastri secures sprint race pole at Belgium Grand Prix
Australia's Formula One leader Oscar Piastri took pole position for the Saturday sprint by nearly half a second at the Belgian Grand Prix while McLaren teammate and title rival Lando Norris qualified third. Red Bull's reigning champion Max Verstappen will join Piastri on the front row for the first race since Christian Horner was dismissed as team boss and replaced with Laurent Mekies. Piastri lapped the Spa-Francorchamps circuit with a best time of one minute 40.510 seconds, 0.477 seconds quicker than Verstappen and 0.618 clear of Norris. He was at risk of being eliminated after straying off track in the second part of the session but bounced back to pip Verstappen, who split the two dominant McLarens by relegating Norris to third, .618 off the pace. 'The car's been mega all day,' said Piastri, who claimed his first sprint pole of the campaign. 'This is a track I love, it's my favourite one of the year and maybe that gave me a couple of extra tenths (of a second).' The Melburnian, who also set the pace in earlier practice, is eight points clear at the top after 12 of 24 rounds. 'It was a good lap. A little scare in SQ2 with the lap deletion. But thanks to the team, the car has been great and this is a track I love. Maybe that gave me a couple of extra tenths. 'The car has been in a good window since lap one and it is a track I always enjoy coming to. 'It is nice to get a result today. 'The Red Bulls were very quick in a straight line in practice. That makes life difficult in terms of it being the worst track to have pole position.' Ferrari's Charles Leclerc starts fourth but teammate Lewis Hamilton will line up 18th after a difficult afternoon for the seven-times world champion, whose most recent win came at the same circuit last year with Mercedes. The Briton spun on his last flying lap while on course to go through, with the suspicion falling on a failure of the car's rear axle. George Russell, who finished first last year for Mercedes but was then disqualified for an underweight car, also struggled and qualified 13th. McLaren team chief Andrea Stella told Sky Sports: 'That was a pretty amazing lap by Oscar, he capitalised on everything available in the car. 'An almost perfect session from Oscar, except for the lap deletion in SQ2 which gave us a bit of a moment on the pit wall!'
Leader Live
13 hours ago
- Leader Live
McLaren's Oscar Piastri quickest in practice for Belgian Grand Prix
Piastri, who holds an eight-point lead over Norris at the midway stage of the season, saw off Red Bull's Max Verstappen by four tenths with Norris 0.504 seconds behind his McLaren team-mate. George Russell finished fourth for Mercedes, one place ahead of Ferrari driver Charles Leclerc. Lewis Hamilton was sixth, one second off the pace. Our top three in FP1 (the only practice session this weekend) 🥇 Oscar🥈 Max🥉 Lando#F1 #BelgianGP — Formula 1 (@F1) July 25, 2025 Former Red Bull team principal Christian Horner is this weekend absent from a Formula One event for the first time in 20 years following his dramatic dismissal earlier this month. Horner was released from his position 18 months after he was accused of 'inappropriate behaviour' by a female staff member – although he was twice exonerated – and Red Bull's dramatic slump in form. Four-time world champion Verstappen has won just four of the last 26 races he has competed in. Occupying Horner's seat on the Red Bull pit wall is Frenchman Laurent Mekies, and he oversaw Verstappen splitting the McLaren drivers. However, Yuki Tsunoda was only 18th in the other Red Bull. Norris arrived in Spa-Francorchamps with back-to-back victories after triumphs in Austria and his home race at Silverstone. But the British driver appears to have his work cut out to stop Piastri at Spa-Francorchamps after the Australian set a blistering pace in the sole practice session on Friday. Hamilton might have hoped an upgraded rear suspension on his Ferrari will reverse his fortunes. Yet the seven-time world champion was a distant sixth in his Ferrari. Earlier in the session, Hamilton also courted the wrath of Gabriel Bortoleto after the rookie accused him of driving slowly through the high-speed Radillon. 'Mate what the f*** is Hamilton doing?' he yelled. 'He is always in the middle of the track.' Qualifying for Saturday's sprint race takes place at 1630 local time (1530 BST).
