Israel Faces Backlash at Home and Abroad over Gaza War Escalation Plan
Germany, a key European ally, announced it would halt exports of military equipment to Israel that could be used in Gaza, a decision Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called disappointing. Britain and other European allies urged Israel to reconsider its decision to escalate the Gaza military campaign.
However, U.S. President Donald Trump's ambassador to Israel, Mike Huckabee, told Reuters that some countries appeared to be putting pressure on Israel rather than on the militant group Hamas, whose deadly attack on Israel in 2023 ignited the war.
In Israel, families of hostages held by militants in Gaza, and opposition leaders blasted Netanyahu for a decision that they said would put hostages' lives at risk.
Far-right allies in the prime minister's coalition have been pushing for a total takeover of Gaza as part of his vow to eradicate Hamas militants, though the military has warned this could endanger the lives of remaining hostages held by militants.
Opposition leader Yair Lapid called the decision to send Israeli forces into Gaza City a disaster, saying it defied the advice of military and security officials.
He accused far-right ministers Itamar Ben Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich of dragging Netanyahu into a prolonged campaign that would result in the deaths of hostages and soldiers.
Netanyahu told Fox News Channel's Bill Hemmer in an interview that aired on Thursday that the military intended to take control of all of Gaza. He said Israel did not want to keep the Gaza Strip, but to establish a 'security perimeter' and to hand over the territory to Arab forces.
The announcement from the prime minister's office early on Friday, following Thursday's security cabinet meeting, said the military would take Gaza City, but did not say if Israeli forces would take all of the enclave.
Israel's cabinet is expected to endorse the Gaza City plan.
Netanyahu spoke with German Chancellor Friedrich Merz on Friday to express disappointment over Berlin's suspension of weapons exports to Israel, the prime minister's office said.
Netanyahu told the chancellor that Israel's goal was to 'free Gaza from Hamas' so a peaceful government could be established there, and that Israel does not intend to take it over, it said.
'HEART OF GAZA'
The military has said that it controls around 75% of Gaza. Amir Avivi, a retired Israeli brigadier general, estimated that if the military did take Gaza City, it would give Israel control of about 85% of the strip.
'Gaza City is the heart of Gaza. It's really the centre of government. It has always been the strongest and even in the eyes of Hamas, the fall of Gaza City is pretty much the fall of Hamas,' said Avivi. 'Taking over Gaza City is a game changer.'
Israeli media have said 900,000 people now live in Gaza City, including many who have been displaced by the military.
'Where should we go? Do we throw ourselves in the sea?,' said Maghzouza Saada, a displaced Palestinian from Gaza's north.
Before the war, Hamas' most powerful fighting units were believed to operate in northern Gaza, including Gaza City.
There are 50 hostages still held in Gaza, of whom Israeli officials believe 20 are alive. Most of those freed so far emerged as a result of diplomatic negotiations. Talks toward a ceasefire that could have seen more hostages released collapsed in July.
CONDEMNATION FROM ABROAD
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen was among foreign leaders urging Israel to reconsider its decision to advance into Gaza City.
Regional power Saudi Arabia, which has said it could not normalise ties with Israel without the establishment of a Palestinian state, condemned any move to occupy Gaza.
Asked in an interview with Reuters about criticism of Israel's decision to escalate the war, U.S. Ambassador Huckabee questioned why some nations were 'once again' placing 'all the pressure on Israel' instead of on Hamas.
Huckabee said Trump was frustrated that Hamas is unwilling to reach 'any kind of reasonable settlement', adding the president insists that the militant group cannot remain in power and must disarm.
Israel had already come under mounting pressure at home and abroad over the war in Gaza, including over the humanitarian disaster in the enclave. In recent weeks, Britain, Canada and France said they could recognise a Palestinian state at the U.N. General Assembly next month.
DOMESTIC PRESSURE
Netanyahu has said there will be no end to the war until Hamas is disarmed. Opinion polls have shown that a majority of Israelis believe he should end the war immediately in a diplomatic agreement that would see the release of remaining hostages.
The Hostages Families Forum, which represents many families of captives in Gaza, said the pursuit of occupying Gaza means abandoning the hostages all while ignoring public support to immediately end the war in a deal that releases the hostages.
It said in a statement the security cabinet had chosen to 'embark on another march of recklessness, on the backs of the hostages, the soldiers, and Israeli society as a whole'.
'I think it's a death sentence to all the hostages that are still being held there. And it's the wrong decision to do it at this time,' Danny Bukovsky, a hotelier in Tel Aviv, said of the announcement that Israeli forces would move into Gaza City.
A full occupation of Gaza would reverse a 2005 decision in which Israel withdrew thousands of Jewish settlers and its forces, while retaining control over its borders, airspace and utilities.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Japan Times
an hour ago
- Japan Times
Australia plans to recognize Palestinian state within days: Sydney Morning Herald
Australia plans to recognize a Palestinian state as early as Monday following similar moves by France, Britain and Canada, the Sydney Morning Herald reported. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese could sign off on the move after a regular cabinet meeting on Monday, the SMH reported, citing unidentified sources. Albanese's office did not immediately respond to a request seeking comment. France and Canada last month said it planned to recognize a Palestinian state, while Britain has said it would follow suit unless Israel addresses the humanitarian crisis in Palestine and reaches a ceasefire. Israel has condemned decisions by countries to support a Palestinian state, saying it will reward Hamas, the militant group that governs Gaza. Netanyahu told reporters on Sunday that most Israeli citizens were against establishing a Palestinian state as they thought that would bring war and not peace, even as thousands of protesters flooded the streets of Tel Aviv, opposing his plan to escalate the nearly two-year war and seize Gaza City. "To have European countries and Australia march into that rabbit hole just like that, fall right into it ... this is disappointing and I think it's actually shameful but it's not going to change our position," Netanyahu said. Albanese has been calling for a two-state solution, with his center-left government supporting Israel's right to exist within secure borders and Palestinians' right to their own state. Treasurer Jim Chalmers last month said it was "a matter of when, not if, Australia recognizes a Palestinian state."
The Mainichi
2 hours ago
- The Mainichi
Netanyahu defends new military offensive in Gaza and says it will be wider than announced
JERUSALEM (AP) -- Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Sunday defended a new military offensive in Gaza that's more sweeping than previously announced, declaring in the face of growing condemnation at home and abroad that Israel "has no choice but to finish the job and complete the defeat of Hamas." Even as more Israelis express concern over the 22-month war, Netanyahu said the security Cabinet last week instructed the dismantling of Hamas strongholds not only in Gaza City but also in the "central camps" and Muwasi. A source familiar with the operation, who spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to talk to the media, confirmed that Israel plans it in both areas. The camps -- sheltering well over a half-million displaced people, according to the U.N. -- had not been part of Israel's announcement Friday. It was not clear why, though Netanyahu faced criticism this weekend within his ruling coalition that targeting Gaza City was not enough. Netanyahu said there would be "safe zones," but such designated areas have been bombed in the past. Late Sunday, heavy bombardment was reported in Gaza City. Shortly before midnight local time, broadcaster Al Jazeera said correspondent Anas al-Sharif was killed in a strike. Rami Mohanna, administrative director at the nearby Shifa Hospital, said the strike hit a tent for Al Jazeera journalists outside the hospital's walls. Along with al-Sharif, three other journalists and a driver were killed. Israel's military confirmed it, asserting al-Sharif had "posed as a journalist" and alleging he was with Hamas. Al-Sharif had denied having any political affiliations. The Committee to Protect Journalists last month said it was gravely concerned for his safety and said he was a "targeted by an Israeli military smear campaign." Netanyahu spoke with Trump about plan Netanyahu's office late Sunday said he had spoken with U.S. President Donald Trump about the plan and thanked him for his "steadfast support." Rejecting starvation in Gaza as well as a "global campaign of lies," Netanyahu spoke to foreign media just before an emergency meeting of the United Nations Security Council, a platform for outrage but little action on the war. "Our goal is not to occupy Gaza, our goal is to free Gaza," Netanyahu asserted. The goals, he said, include demilitarizing the territory, the Israeli military having "overriding security control" and a non-Israeli civilian administration in charge. Israel wants to increase the number of aid distribution sites in Gaza, he said, but in a later briefing to local media, he asserted: "There is no hunger. There was no hunger. There was a shortage, and there was certainly no policy of starvation." Netanyahu also said he has directed Israel's military to "bring in more foreign journalists" -- which would be a striking development, as they haven't been allowed into Gaza beyond military embeds during the war. He again blamed many of Gaza's problems on the Hamas militant group, including civilian deaths, destruction and aid shortages. "Hamas still has thousands of armed terrorists," he asserted, adding that Palestinians are "begging" to be freed from them. Hamas responded with a lengthy statement that summed up Netanyahu's remarks as "blatant lies." U.S. defends Israel at Security Council meeting The United States defended Israel, saying it has the right to decide what's best for its security. It called allegations of genocide in Gaza false. The U.S. has veto power at the council and can block proposed actions there. Other council members, and U.N. officials, expressed alarm. China called the "collective punishment" of people in Gaza unacceptable. Russia warned against a "reckless intensification of hostilities." "This is no longer a looming hunger crisis; this is starvation," said Ramesh Rajasingham with the U.N. humanitarian office. "Humanitarian conditions are beyond horrific. We have frankly run out of words to describe it." Israel faces growing action even by its closest allies. Netanyahu said Chancellor Friedrich Merz of Germany had "buckled under" the growing international criticism by stopping exports of military equipment to Israel that could be used in Gaza. Merz, for his part, told public broadcaster ARD that Germany and Israel were talking "very critically" but Berlin's overall policies of friendship haven't changed. More Palestinians killed as they seek aid At least 31 Palestinians were killed while seeking aid in Gaza, hospitals and witnesses said. The Associated Press spoke to witnesses of gunfire in the Israeli-controlled Morag and Netzarim corridors and the Teina area in the south. All accused Israeli forces of firing at crowds trying to reach food distributions or waiting for convoys. Fifteen people were killed while waiting for trucks near the Morag corridor that separates the southern cities of Rafah and Khan Younis, according to Nasser hospital. The situation is a "death trap," said Jamal al-Laweh, who said Israeli forces opened fire there. "But I have no other choice to feed the kids." Six were killed while waiting for aid in northern Gaza near the Zikim crossing, according to Gaza's Health Ministry and Shifa hospital. In central Gaza, witnesses said they heard warning shots before fire was aimed toward crowds trying to reach a distribution site operated by the Israeli-backed and U.S.-funded Gaza Humanitarian Foundation. The AP could not independently confirm who fired. Awda hospital said four people were killed by Israeli gunfire. Six other aid-seekers were killed while trying to reach GHF sites in Khan Younis and Rafah, Nasser hospital said. The GHF sites opened in May as an alternative to the U.N.-run aid system, but operations have been marred by deaths and chaos. Responding to AP inquiries, the GHF media office said: "There were no incidents at or near our sites today." Israel's military said there were no incidents involving troops near central Gaza aid sites. Hunger death toll among children hits 100 Israel's air and ground offensive has displaced most Palestinians and pushed the territory toward famine. Two Palestinian children died of malnutrition-related causes on Saturday, bringing the toll among children to 100 since the war began. At least 117 adults have died of malnutrition-related causes since June, when the ministry started to count them. The hunger toll is in addition to the ministry's war toll of 61,400 Palestinians. The ministry, part of the Hamas-run government and staffed by medical professionals, doesn't distinguish between fighters or civilians, but says around half of the dead have been women and children. The U.N. and independent experts consider it the most reliable source on war casualties.
Japan Times
3 hours ago
- Japan Times
Netanyahu defends Gaza plan condemned at home and abroad
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu defended his plan for a military sweep against the final Hamas strongholds in the Gaza Strip, calling it the best available option for recovering hostages while safeguarding his country's long-term security — an argument that's met vocal opposition at home and abroad. After talks on a third ceasefire stalled in July, the Netanyahu government on Friday authorized an advance on Gaza City. Israeli forces had previously skirted the area for fear that hostages believed to be held there could be hurt or lost in the chaos of combat. Though the army has yet to mobilize the reinforcements required to roll into action, the plan has drawn condemnation from foreign powers already upset at a hunger crisis besetting Palestinians in Gaza, after Israel cut off aid between March and May in a bid to sideline Hamas. The U.S., by contrast, has indicated readiness to back its Middle Eastern ally. Four Al Jazeera journalists were among five people killed Sunday when an Israeli airstrike hit a tent in Gaza City. The Israeli military said the target of the strike was Anas Al-Sharif, a contract reporter whom the Qatari media network hired to cover the Israel-Hamas war. But witnesses and health officials in Gaza said the attack also killed another reporter, as well as two cameramen. The Israeli military said that Al-Sharif "posed' as a journalist and was a member of the military wing of Hamas. It didn't comment on the other casualties. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu gives a press conference in Jerusalem on Sunday. | AFP-JIJI U.S. President Donald Trump and Netanyahu spoke by phone on Sunday, Netanyahu's office said in a social media post that didn't characterize the call further. The White House didn't immediately respond to a request for comment. There's been recrimination over Netanyahu's plans in Israel, where polls for months have shown a majority prefer a negotiated deal to recover all hostages, even if it means winding down the war with Hamas still standing. Relatives of the hostages are calling for a general strike to protest the latest plans. At the other end of the political spectrum, far-right coalition parties are grumbling that the proposal, which Netanyahu says will defeat Hamas once and for all, doesn't go far enough. "Our goal is not to occupy Gaza. Our goal is to free Gaza — free it from Hamas terrorists,' Netanyahu told foreign reporters at a briefing on Sunday. "Contrary to false claims, this is the best way to end the war.' In previous statements during the 22-month-old conflict, Netanyahu suggested victory was imminent. He struck a more cautious note on Sunday, declining to give a detailed timeline for advances on Gaza City and, later, on central townships that have also largely been spared incursions. The operations would be "fairly quick' and prevent Israel from getting into a war of attrition with Hamas holdouts, he said. Twenty of the hostages, mostly taken during the Hamas incursions into Israel in October 2023, are believed to be still alive. Hamas has threatened to execute them rather than see them rescued. Their relatives also worry about the risk they could be killed in crossfire once new assaults ramp up. "The move that I'm talking about, I think, has a possibility of getting them out,' Netanyahu said. Doubling down on his rejection of allegations that Israel has been deliberately starving Gazans, Netanyahu said the "exact opposite' was true. While acknowledging "deprivation' in parts of the coastal enclave, he said aid is now reaching its 2 million civilian residents. Palestinians carry the shrouded body of a loved one killed the previous day while seeking aid near Zikim, west of Beit Lahia, in the northern Gaza Strip, at Al-Shifa hospital in Gaza City on Sunday. | AFP-JIJI In contrast, the U.N.'s World Food Program says a quarter of Gazans are on the brink of famine. Hamas authorities say the daily number of trucks entering in the past two weeks, since restrictions on aid deliveries were relaxed by Israel, has averaged 100, far below the 600 the group demands. Still, black market food prices, a measure of scarcity, are dropping. Sugar, at $8.76 a kilo is about 10 times cheaper than a few days ago. A kilogram of flour costs $3.50 to $4.38, a recent steep decline although still far above the pre-war price of $0.88. Several Western countries, lamenting the protracted conflict, have pledged to recognize a Palestinian state. Germany, historically Israel's most important European ally, intends to stop supplying the Netanyahu government with arms for use in Gaza. Netanyahu said his German counterpart, Chancellor Friedrich Merz, had "buckled under the pressure' of what he called false media reports and pro-Palestinian groups. "We will win the war with or without the support of others,' he said. Most Israelis don't want any remnant of Hamas in Gaza nor a Palestinian state to arise there or in the West Bank, Netanyahu said. Hamas, which is committed to the Jewish state's destruction and blacklisted as a terrorist group in much of the West, has sounded undeterred by Netanyahu's plan. "The weapons of resistance are a legitimate right as long as the occupation remains,' Hamas official Osama Hamdan told Al-Araby TV, reiterating the group's refusal to disarm as demanded by Israel for an open-ended truce. "The resistance will continue until the establishment of an independent, sovereign Palestinian state.'
