Pope Francis encouraged Christian-Muslim dialogue and helped break down stereotypes
Francis framed his efforts around the 'culture of encounter,' which he explained in a 2016 morning meditation. Drawing inspiration from the Gospel of Luke, Chapter 7, he noted that this approach was about 'active engagement' rather than passive observation. He urged individuals to embody Jesus by 'not just seeing, but looking; not just hearing, but listening; not just passing people by, but stopping with them.'
In my 2025 book 'Beyond Dialogue – Building Bonds Between Christians and Muslims,' I stress the importance of moving beyond mere tolerance to collaboration as a way to engage with religious diversity − something that Francis demonstrated in his interfaith dialogue efforts with Muslim countries.
In 2021, Francis visited regions in Iraq once held by the Islamic State, or IS. This was the first papal visit to the country. He held masses in Irbil, the capital of the Kurdistan region of Iraq, and he addressed a gathering in the courtyard of the Al-Tahera church, the hub of the Syriac Catholic population in Mosul. The historic 18th-century church was partially destroyed by IS during its occupation of the city from 2014 to 2017. An estimated 5,000 Christians were killed and some 125,000 displaced in Iraq during that time.
At Church Square in Mosul, where there are four churches, Francis prayed for the victims of the conflict and called for harmonious coexistence between Christians and Muslims. He also invited displaced Christians to return to their homes and praised the young Iraqi volunteers – both Christians and Muslims – working side by side to rebuild the churches and mosques destroyed by IS.
In addition, he convened an interreligious gathering in Ur, the birthplace of Abraham, a prophet revered by Jews, Christians and Muslims.
His actions not only brought together Christians and Muslims but also helped break down stereotypes.
In 2019 he visited the United Arab Emirates, marking the first papal visit to the Arabian Peninsula, the birthplace of Islam. The visit coincided with the Emirati government proclaiming 2019 the Year of Tolerance, promoting coexistence, diversity and respect.
During his visit in Abu Dhabi in 2019, Francis celebrated a historic Catholic Mass in Zayed Sports City, drawing 180,000 attendees from over 100 countries, for which the UAE government declared a special holiday.
This unprecedented event challenged negative Western stereotypes about the Arabian Peninsula's religious intolerance. The UAE Constitution, for example, guarantees religious freedom to all people, albeit with restrictions on proselytization among non-Islamic communities. It also offered a counternarrative of unity between Christians and Muslims in a region often viewed through a lens of religious strife and war.
Francis' visit to the UAE also culminated in some crucial interfaith initiatives. In Abu Dhabi, Francis and the Grand Imam of Al-Azhar University, Ahmed El-Tayeb, cosigned the document on Human Fraternity for World Peace and Living Together. The document stresses the need to work together to promote a 'culture of reciprocal respect.' While the Emirati president, Sheikh Mohammed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, did not directly sign the document, he supported the interfaith initiatives that followed Francis' trip.
This document led to the setting up of the Higher Committee of Human Fraternity, a collaborative project of a diverse groups of academic, cultural and religious leaders and entities from around the world. The committee created the Human Fraternity Education and Leadership for Peace program, a global youth movement. It also worked with the United Nations General Assembly to designate Feb. 4 as the International Day of Human Fraternity.
The Higher Committee of Human Fraternity also guided the construction of the Abrahamic Family House in Abu Dhabi, a shared space for a church, mosque and synagogue that opened in 2023.
I had the opportunity to attend the opening ceremony of the Abrahamic Family House in 2023. It was a memorable experience. A Christian girl, a Muslim boy and Jewish boy each brought a cube representing each house of worship to the center platform of the forum and placed them side by side on the ground. The simple act mirrored the architectural design of the Abrahamic Family House by bringing the abstract concept of interfaith harmony to life in a concrete and relatable way. The Emirati youth provided a glimpse into what a tolerant future could look like.
The closest historical comparison to the Document on Human Fraternity is the Nostra Aetate, a declaration from the Second Vatican Council of 1965, when major reforms were initiated in the Catholic Church.
Nostra Aetate marked a turning point in the Catholic Church's relations with Islam and all non-Christian traditions. After a history of conflict, limited positive engagement and mutual suspicion, it emphasized harmony, dialogue and respect with Islam.
However, the Document on Human Fraternity went further. For starters, it was a joint declaration with prominent Muslim leaders, signifying a deeper commitment to Christian-Muslim partnership, whereas Nostra Aetate was an internal Catholic document. The document called for grassroot activities, pointing to a more action-oriented approach to Christian and Muslim relations. Given that it was signed by the pope, it held influence within the Vatican leadership and among liberal cardinals. Its core principles are being integrated into pastoral initiatives and interreligious dialogue at the national and international levels.
Francis' approach to Christian-Muslim dialogue differed notably from his predecessors. While Pope John Paul II focused on intellectual exchange and theological dialogue, Francis emphasized that they were insufficient on their own. In turn, he prioritized direct action and personal engagement with others as a means to a deeper understanding of the other.
Pope Benedict XVI, despite his commitment to dialogue, faced challenges due to remarks that outraged Muslims worldwide. During his Regensburg address in 2006, he mentioned a medieval dialogue attributed to Manuel II Palaiologus, the Byzantine emperor who reigned from 1391 to 1425, a period of growing power of the Ottoman Empire. Manuel II had criticized the concept of jihad in Islam and referred to Muhammad, the prophet of Islam, as 'evil' and 'inhuman.' While Benedict repeatedly emphasized that he was quoting Manuel II's views on the relationship between faith and reason and not personally endorsing the emperor's assessment of Islam, the pope's comments were perceived as disrespectful toward the Islamic faith and its prophet.
Upon Francis' death, the president of the UAE – Sheikh Mohammed bin Zayed Al Nahyan – described him as 'a symbol of human fraternity, cultural coexistence and interfaith dialogue,' adding that he inspired 'future generations in upholding the values of tolerance and mutual understanding.'
Francis' gestures of solidarity, personal relationships and frequent visits to Muslim countries, I believe, laid a tangible foundation to move beyond dialogue and toward human fraternity.
This article is republished from The Conversation, a nonprofit, independent news organization bringing you facts and trustworthy analysis to help you make sense of our complex world. It was written by: Craig Considine, Rice University
Read more:
A pope of the Americas: What Francis meant to 2 continents
Pope Francis danced the tango with the global Catholic Church amid its culture wars
Pope Francis filled the College of Cardinals with a diverse group of men – and they'll be picking his successor
Craig Considine does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Times
3 hours ago
- New York Times
Hundreds of Indian Lawmakers Detained at a Protest Claiming Vote Rigging
Hundreds of Indian opposition figures were briefly detained by the police in New Delhi on Monday as they tried to march on the country's election commission, protesting what they say are repeated and calculated electoral irregularities favoring Prime Minister Narendra Modi's powerful ruling party. Chaotic scenes of some opposition leaders trying to climb over police barricades before they were bused to police stations marked a new escalation in a fight that has been intensifying in recent years. Opposition parties have stepped up accusations of foul play as they have struggled to overcome results favoring Mr. Modi's ruling Bharatiya Janata Party, including in states where they say that uncorrupted tallies should have gone strongly against the B.J.P. The opposition, led by Rahul Gandhi of the Indian National Congress, claims the ruling party and the election commission are jointly manipulating elections through obscure additions and deletions to voter rolls. The issue gained momentum after a sudden revision of voter rolls ahead of elections in Bihar, the eastern state of over 130 million that is expected to elect its local government in November. The election commission has cut over six million people, which Mr. Modi's party said was to clear the rolls of 'infiltrators.' But the opposition sees it as a way of disenfranchising the state's Muslim voters and other blocs hostile to their Hindu nationalist policies. India's Election Commission has dismissed the opposition's accusations as an effort to 'mislead the people by claiming irregularities in the electoral rolls.' Dharmendra Pradhan, a cabinet minister from Mr. Modi's B.J.P., accused the opposition of 'raising a mountain of lies' and creating anarchy. 'They don't have any faith in democracy,' Mr. Pradhan said in a news conference. 'If you win elections then all is well, and if you lose the election then you find all type of irregularities.' Mr. Gandhi, who has led efforts to accuse Mr. Modi's party of election manipulation, said his party had been trying to make sense of a pattern in recent elections where the 'the mood would be one thing, the result would come out something else.' What particularly drew their suspicion, he said in a news conference last week, was the dramatic change of fortune in back to back elections last year in crucial state of Maharashtra, where the financial hub of Mumbai is located. The opposition parties did well in the state in the national election, where Mr. Modi managed to squeeze through for a third term with the help of coalition partners. But only months later, opposition groups were routed in an election for the state government. They pointed to a sudden increase in voter numbers. 'We asked the election commission to give us the voter list, the video recordings,' Mr. Gandhi said. 'The election commission refused to.' Mr. Gandhi said the work of voter verification is made difficult for political parties as the election commission refuses to share digital data. Instead, he said, the commission offers voter-roll information in hundreds of thousands of physical pages. When his team narrowed in on one assembly seat in India's south and spent six months going through the voter data, they found that more than 100,000 votes from the total of 650,000 votes cast appeared questionable, he said. He cited obvious duplicate votes, dozens of voters registered in fake addresses or to small homes that could accommodate only a few people, and voters lacking photos in their records. Analysts and activists said the concerns over abuse of power have been amplified by a growing lack of transparency in the electoral process. 'By keeping critical information under wraps and failing to publicly justify its actions, the Election Commission of India risks eroding voter trust,' said Anjali Bhardwaj, the co-convener of the National Campaign for People's Right to Information. In Bihar, the government's sudden move to revise the voter rolls has faced pushback from political parties and watchdogs, many of whom are suing the government for rushing the exercise before a vote and without proper consultation. The election commission had given the state's nearly 80 million registered voters about one month to confirm their identities by providing a range of documents. Excluded from those documents was the most commonly used identification card in India, the Aadhaar, despite repeated encouragement from the country's supreme court to allow its use. Political parties and observers have questioned why the election commission removed digital files of the draft rolls it initially uploaded and replaced them with scans that aren't easily machine readable. The election commission has told the court that it is not obligated to publish a list of the names deleted, or the reasons, but that anyone missing from the draft rolls can appeal their deletion. Ms. Bhardwaj said change in the voter lists amounted to an average deletion of about 27,000 voters per constituency. 'In a state where most seats are won by a slender margin, this number exceeds the winning margin in two-thirds of seats in the 2020 elections,' she said. 'This scale of deletions could potentially swing the electoral outcome in most assembly constituencies.'
4 hours ago
2 men in Indonesia sentenced to public caning over sexual acts: kissing and hugging
BANDA ACEH, Indonesia -- An Islamic court in Indonesia 's conservative Aceh province on Monday sentenced two men to public caning, 80 times each, after Islamic religious police caught them engaged in what the court deemed were sexual acts: hugging and kissing. The trial at the Islamic Shariah District Court in Banda Aceh, the provincial capital, was held behind closed doors. Judges have the authority to limit public access in such a case and open it only for the verdict. The two men, aged 20 and 21, were arrested in April after residents saw them entering the same bathroom at Taman Sari city park and reported it to police patrolling the area. The police broke into the toilet and caught the men kissing and hugging, which the court considered to be a sexual act. The lead judge, Rokhmadi M. Hum, said the two college students were 'legally and convincingly' proven to have violated Islamic law by committing acts that lead to gay sexual relations. The court didn't publicly identify the men. Prosecutors previously sought 85 strokes of the cane for each, but the three-judge panel decided on what they described as lenient punishment because the men were outstanding students who were polite in court, cooperated with authorities and had no previous convictions. The judges also ordered the time they have served to be deducted from their sentence. It means the number of lashes will be reduced by four as they have been detained for four months. The prosecutor, Alfian, who like many Indonesians uses only a single name, said he was not satisfied with the lighter sentence. But he said he will not appeal. Aceh is the only province in Muslim-majority Indonesia allowed to observe a version of Islamic law. It allows up to 100 lashes for morality offenses including gay sex. Caning is also punishment for adultery, gambling, drinking and for women who wear tight clothes and men who skip Friday prayers. Indonesia's secular central government granted Aceh the right to implement the law in 2006 as part of a peace deal to end a separatist war. Aceh implemented an expansion in 2015 that extended the law to non-Muslims, who account for about 1% of the province's population. Human rights groups have criticized the law, saying it violates international treaties signed by Indonesia protecting the rights of minorities. Indonesia's national criminal code doesn't regulate homosexuality. Monday's verdict was the fifth time that Aceh has sentenced people to public caning for homosexuality since the Islamic law was implemented. In February, the same court sentenced two men to public caning up to 85 times for gay sex after neighborhood vigilantes in Banda Aceh suspected them of being gay and broke into their rented room to catch them naked and hugging each other. ___
5 hours ago
US congressman discusses with Syrian president return of body of American killed in Syria
DAMASCUS, Syria -- U.S. Congressman Abraham Hamadeh made a brief visit to Syria where he discussed with the country's interim president the return of the body of an American aid worker who was taken hostage and later confirmed dead in the war-torn country, his office said Monday. Hamadeh's visit to Syria comes as a search has been underway in remote parts of the country for the remains of people who were killed by the Islamic State group that once controlled large parts of Syria and Iraq before its territorial defeat six years ago. Kayla Mueller, 26, was captured in northern Syria in August 2013 and her family and U.S. officials confirmed her death more than a year later. Hamadeh, an Arizona Republican, has vowed to return Mueller's body — which has not yet been found — to her family. Hamadeh's office said he was in Syria for six hours to meet President Ahmad al-Sharaa to discuss the return of Mueller's body to her family in Arizona. The statement added that Hamadeh also discussed the need to establish a secure humanitarian corridor for the safe delivery of medical and humanitarian aid to the southern province of Sweida that recently witnessed deadly clashes between pro-government fighters and gunmen from the country's Druze minority. A Syrian government official did not immediately respond to requests for comment on Hamadeh's statement. Dozens of foreigners, including aid workers and journalists, were killed by IS militants who declared a so-called caliphate in 2014. The militant group lost most of its territory in Iraq in late 2017 and was declared defeated in 2019 when it lost the last sliver of land it controlled in east Syria. Since then, dozens of gravesites and mass graves have been discovered in northern Syria containing remains and bodies of people IS had abducted over the years. American journalists James Foley and Steven Sotloff, as well as humanitarian workers Mueller and Peter Kassig are among those killed by IS. None of the remains is believed to have been found. Mueller, from Prescott, Arizona, was taken hostage with her boyfriend, Omar Alkhani, after leaving a Doctors Without Borders hospital in Aleppo, Syria, where he had been hired to fix the internet service for the hospital. Mueller had begged him to let her tag along because she wanted to do relief work in the war-ravaged country. Alkhani was released after two months, having been beaten. In 2015, the Pentagon said Mueller died at the hands of IS and not in a Jordanian airstrike targeting the militant group as the extremists claimed earlier. ____
