NHS Fife rebuked by watchdog over handling of transgender row tribunal cost requests
NHS Fife failed to comply with its freedom of information duties over the costs of an employment tribunal, Scotland's Information Commissioner has ruled.
The health board received three separate requests in March 2025 for the cost to date of the legal action, which was brought by nurse Sandie Peggie after her complaint about sharing a changing room with transgender medic Dr Beth Upton led to her suspension.
She was suspended from Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife, in January 2024 after she objected to Dr Upton using the changing facilities in its A&E department on Christmas Eve 2023.
Ms Peggie took the health board and Dr Upton to a tribunal, lodging a complaint of sexual harassment or harassment related to a protected belief under section 26 of the Equality Act 2010.
The tribunal has been part heard, with proceedings set to continue in July.
NHS Fife rejected all three freedom of information (FOI) requests, stating that the information requested was exempt under the FOI Act's exemption - which protects personal information.
However, a probe by the Scottish Information Commissioner has revealed that when responding to the requests, NHS Fife did not actually have the information on which it based its reply.
Information Commissioner David Hamilton said the details about costs was not obtained until later from the NHS Central Legal Office, and that the health board should have replied on the basis of information it did hold at the time of the requests.
Mr Hamilton ordered the health board to carry out fresh searches for information it did "actually hold" at the time, and to issue revised responses in line with what it finds.
The commissioner also disputed NHS Fife's claim the cost data would be exempt from disclosure on the basis set out, and called on it to "exercise caution" when considering related exemptions around any additional information found.
Mr Hamilton described the matter as "frustrating" both for himself and for those who were seeking the information from the health board.
"In the circumstances, I am only able to require that NHS Fife carry out further searches to identify all information held at the time the request was made and then issue a revised response to the requesters," he said.
"The delays that have arisen as a result were wholly avoidable, and I would urge that all public authorities ensure their responses to FOI requests are based on information they actually hold."
A spokesperson for the health board said: "NHS Fife notes the report from the Scottish Information Commissioner and intends to comply fully with its decision notice."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
37 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Campaign 'hate' storm as Swinney says he believes Nigel Farage is a 'racist'
The final weekend of by-election campaigning in Hamilton has descended into a bitter war of words as John Swinney branded Nigel Farage a racist. In a speech to SNP activists today ahead of the critical vote on Thursday, the First Minister accused the Reform UK leader of bringing 'racism and hatred right into the heart' of the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse community, adding: 'It is repugnant and we are going to stand up to it every way we can.' Asked by reporters after the rally if he believed Mr Farage was 'a racist', Mr Swinney emphatically responded: 'Yes'. Pushed on whether he had any concern that branding Mr Farage a racist could prompt a defamation action, the First Minister responded: 'No.' He added: 'He's the leader of his party, he is responsible, I'm responsible for everything the SNP does.' However, a spokesman for Reform hit out that Mr Swinney was 'losing the argument' by going 'for the man and not the ball'. He added that the SNP were in a 'tailspin' ahead of Nigel Farage 's visit to Scotland next week. The row broke out on the tense final weekend of campaigning ahead of the by-election vote on Thursday, prompted by the death of Nationalist MSP Christina McKelvie. Although no official polling has been carried out on the ground for the vote, national surveys ahead of the Holyrood elections for 2026 show that Reform is making inroads with the Scottish electorate. A poll last month found that Reform could become the main opposition party next year, with 21 per cent of the popular vote. Although Nicola Sturgeon had previously asserted on the campaign trail that the race would be between the SNP and Labour, Mr Swinney notably shifted that message in the final days of campaigning. In a letter to voters via a daily newspaper, he appeared to place Reform as the Nationalists' main rival and said: 'If you want to beat Reform, the only way to stop them is to vote SNP.' Speaking today, Mr Swinney said Scottish Labour were 'out' of the race. He told supporters: 'We are the party of hope in Scotland. And what the people of Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse face on Thursday is a very simple choice. 'The Labour Party campaign is collapsing. They are out of is a real threat. Do not underestimate the scale of the threat that Farage poses in this election.' Mr Farage, who will be in Scotland on Monday has been accused of 'introducing poison into our politics' after his party became embroiled in a race row with Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar at the beginning of last week. An election advert by Reform used an old clip of Mr Sarwar at a Pakistani Independence Day dinner in 2022 and suggested he had said that he would prioritise Pakistani people. Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer accused Reform of 'manipulation' of the clip of Mr Sarwar, and said Mr Farage was trying to create a 'toxic divide '. Labour, whose candidate is former roads apprentice Davy Russell, has been warning voters that Reform cannot defeat the SNP and will instead help them win. In another open letter to voters in the Daily Record today, Mr Sarwar claimed that the race is a 'straight contest' between his party and Reform, accusing Mr Farage of being a 'clear and present danger to our country'. He also accused Mr Swinney of using Reform as a 'mask for his failure' and criticised the campaign run by Mr Farage's party. He wrote: 'Throughout this by-election campaign, Reform have tried every dirty trick in the book to drive a wedge to divide this community – but I know you will see right through it.' He added: 'Nigel Farage is a poisonous, pathetic and toxic little man that doesn't understand this community or our country. 'He and his cronies in Reform have spent thousands of pounds spreading bile, misinformation and racial slurs. 'Scotland is my home. I was born here.'
Daily Mail
44 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
John Lennon's Scots holiday home won't have a plaque to say so after plans dropped
His worldwide fame as one of The Beatles means every town and city craves a connection to his legacy. However, plans to mark the Edinburgh home where John Lennon spent his childhood holidays have collapsed following a bitter fall out among officials. As a schoolboy Lennon regularly spent part of the summer holidays with his aunt and uncle at the two-storey property in the capital's upmarket Murrayfield area. He penned the Fab Four's song Rain while staying at the house and also returned to visit at the height of Beatlemania. To mark the connection, a commemorative sign was proposed by Pete Gregson of the Murrayfield Community Council (MCC), which initially backed the project in 2023. Just weeks later Mr Gregson was asked to resign by fellow councillors after they took exception to comments they claimed he wrote online about the 'situation in Gaza'. Minutes from subsequent meetings show the issue was resolved, with Mr Gregson continuing to be on the community council until choosing to leave this year. However, in the wake of his departure, the plaque proposal has now been officially dropped. MCC secretary Hamish Ross said: 'A new Community Council was formed following the 2025 election cycle. 'Local plaques are not on the agenda at the moment and the leading light behind this particular one stood down at the elections.' Lennon's aunt Elizabeth – known to her family as 'Mater' – was the sister of his mother Julia, and lived at 15 Ormidale Terrace with her son Stan Parkes and her second husband Robert Sutherland. The proposed wording on the plaque read: 'John Lennon visited Ormidale Terrace regularly until the age of 17 in 1957 to visit his aunt and cousin; he often performed for the family on his aunt's piano. 'The cupboard under the stairs was where he penned The Beatles ' song Rain, the 1966 B-side to Paperback Writer. His long summers here ranked among his happiest childhood memories, describing Edinburgh as one of his favourite cities, enjoying the Festival, the Tattoo and the rugby at Murrayfield. 'He even brought Yoko Ono here in 1969.' Marlene Wood, 62, the current owner of the £1 million townhouse, said some people liked the idea of the plaque 'but others definitely opposed it'. She said: 'We already get people ringing the doorbell to ask for a look around. 'I think some neighbours were worried the street would become a tourist attraction. The taxi drivers know the house, so I see them slowing down and people staring out.' In a letter written in 1978 to his cousin Stan, two years before Lennon was murdered outside his New York apartment, he expressed his regret at the house being sold by the family. He wrote: 'I would have bought 15 Ormidale. Wish, wish, wish.'
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE Criminals allowed to watch X-rated and violent films from the comfort of their jail cells
Scotland's most hardened criminals are being allowed to watch X-rated films and TV shows featuring extreme criminal activity, sex and drug use from the comfort of their cells Amid an 'epidemic' of violence behind bars, inmates at one of the country's toughest jails, HMP Barlinnie, are free to rent from a range of thousands of 18+ DVDs, which include films about serial killers and sexual deviants. That is despite such X-rated films and videos being outlawed in English jails since 2013. A list of movies available to prisoners, obtained via freedom of information laws, include titles such as Saw, Silence of the Lambs and American TV show Dexter, about a police forensic officer who kills criminals in his free time. Inmates can also watch TV shows about real-life child killers Fred and Rose West, Myra Hindley and Beverley Allitt, as well as highly sexualised content including Fifty Shades of Grey, Brokeback Mountain and American Pie. Shockingly, US TV series Prison Break – about two brothers hatching a complex plan to break free from jail – is also available to watch. Prison officers have now demanded that the Scottish Prison Service (SPS) review access to the material amid fears it could heighten tensions behind bars. It comes after it was revealed that there have been more than 250 assaults on prison staff on average each year over the past decade. Earlier this month, the High Court in Edinburgh heard that convicted murderer Robert Paterson plotted to have a guard at HMP Saughton 'seriously assaulted' with a handgun. A spokesman for the Prison Officer's Association said: 'Given all the factors such as overcrowding, drug use, bullying and organised crime gang activities inside our prisons, the last thing we need is anything else adding to the tension or temperatures. 'It is something that the SPS should be reviewing as a priority with a view to limiting the availability of these films.' However, the Scottish Conservatives went further and demanded that SNP ministers intervene to force the SPS to remove the films. Justice spokesman Liam Kerr said: 'Ordinary Scots will be appalled that inmates are being provided with X-rated movies. 'England and Wales banned 18-rated movies and TV shows from their prisons 12 years ago and it is about time the Scottish Prison Service followed suit. 'Many of the prisoners at Barlinnie will be behind bars for violent crimes, so it is common sense that they should not be able to access graphically violent material about serial killers and torturers.' He added: 'Prisoners trying to get clean will also not be helped by having access to content that promotes drug use. 'SNP ministers must intervene and immediately direct the SPS to remove violent or sexual films.' The SPS was asked by the Tories to provide a full list of the films, TV shows and games that prisoners had access to in Glasgow's HMP Barlinnie. Thousands of titles were revealed, of all different certifications, including many that appear to be highly inappropriate for a rehabilitative environment. Those featuring graphic violence and torture include Silence of the Lambs, about a serial killer who preys on women, as well as the Saw horror franchise, another film about a serial killer, who tortures his victims. Dexter, Blade, Deadpool, Kill Bill and the Exorcist are also available as well as shows with graphic and disturbing sexual content. These include Taxi Driver, about a 12-year-old child who is forced into sex work. Other films and TV series that may be seen to promote criminal activity and drug use include Scarface, The Wire, Narcos, Sons of Anarchy, Breaking Bad, Prison Break and Peaky Blinders. In 2013, former Conservative Justice Minister Chris Grayling cracked down on the availability of such films and TV shows in prisons in England and Wales. A spokeswoman for the SPS said: 'Access to watching DVDs is a privilege not a right, and is available at the discretion of the Governor.'
