ESB board had ‘significant concern' that €318,000 salary was not sufficient for chief executive post
The board of the
ESB
had 'significant concern' that the salary for company's chief executive was insufficient for retaining an appropriately-skilled person for the role, the
Department of the Environment, Climate and Communications
told a Government pay review group.
In an appendix to a submission sent by the then Minister
Eamon Ryan
last summer, officials said at that point the post of ESB chief executive had a salary of €318,000.
The department said it was 'considered imperative that the company is led by a suitably qualified, experienced and dynamic leader and the post should be competitively remunerated accordingly to attract same'.
The department in its appendix to Mr Ryan's letter to the Senior Posts Remuneration Committee said 'due to the size and scope of ESB's remit, the level of remuneration has been previously cited as an area of significant concern for the board of the ESB in retaining an appropriately-skilled CEO'.
READ MORE
'The chair of ESB has also noted the current salary as insufficient to attract the calibre of candidate sought for the role in comparison to alternative employment options available to them.'
The department said the ESB was 'one of the country's most valuable assets' as the largest semi-State company.
'Therefore it is critically important for the business to attract, retain and motivate the right calibre of people across all levels of the organisation to deliver on their strategic goals and to meet shareholders' expectations in terms of decarbonisation, energy security, critical infrastructure provision and economic growth.'
It said the ESB chief executive at that point had a salary of €318,000. It said the code of practice for governance of remuneration in State bodies urged that pay at the top level should be set in a manner that allowed 'sufficient headroom between the CEO and senior management'.
The department told the review group that 'this must be considered in the context of the ESB'.
[
Gas Networks Ireland, Uisce Éireann, LDA told Minister chief executive pay limits posed 'serious risks' to organisations
Opens in new window
]
It said as of December 2023, the ESB had a regulated asset base of about €13.2 billion, comprising ESB Networks €10.6 billion, NIE Networks €2.6 billion, a 27 per cent share of generation in the all-island market and more than two million customer accounts throughout the island of Ireland and in Great Britain.
It said the ESB had provided more than €1.5 billion in dividends to the State over the previous decade.
Last month following the report of the remuneration committee, the Government signalled it would update rules to allow a 'market rate' to be paid to chief executives in commercial State companies.
Minister for Public Expenditure
Jack Chambers
said the Government would implement most recommendations made by the committee.
He said the Government accepted the need to update a system for top-level pay determination in commercial State organisations that had been in place for more than a decade and would move to generally implement the recommendations.
He said the upper limit on any proposed package would be the market rate rather than 120 per cent of it. However, there would be no backdating of any increases to May 1st of last year, another committee recommendation, and no reintroduction of performance-related bonuses worth up to 25 per cent of salaries, which was also proposed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
19 minutes ago
- Extra.ie
Modular homes laws ‘will slash red tape for home extensions'
Housing Minister James Browne has told the Cabinet that regulations to permit modular homes in back gardens will also slash red tape for home extensions. The proposed exemptions include converting attics with roof lights, dividing existing homes, and loosening the requirements around extensions in a bid to bolster the housing supply. Energy-efficient measures such as external wall insulation and storage structures at the front of the building for bikes and bins will also be covered in the proposed exemptions that are to be sent for public consultation next month. Housing Minister James Browne has told the Cabinet that regulations to permit modular homes in back gardens will also slash red tape for home extensions. Pic: Gareth Chaney/Collins Photos The plans stem from a proposal by Minister of State at the Department of Housing John Cummins, who initially sought to have detached modular buildings exempt from planning laws. However, no mechanism for objecting to a modular development in a neighbouring property outside of the court's process has been set ahead of a public consultation on the measures next month. Tom Philips, a Dublin-based town planner, told RTÉ's Morning Ireland that the focus needed to be on supply and not putting older people in 'attics or sheds'. The plans stem from a proposal by Minister of State at the Department of Housing John Cummins, who initially sought to have detached modular buildings exempt from planning laws. Pic: Getty Images 'The real issue is supplying the correct number of houses for people to live in the first place, not to be putting elderly people in attics or garden sheds,' he said. Mr Philips said that there was a need for purpose-built accommodation for older people to meet their needs. He added that the 'bottom line' was that more houses are needed and they will not get built if people continue to object to housing developments. 'People need to stop objecting to everything,' he added. 'That to me, will be the greatest thing we could have in the planning system, is to stop this constant objection to things. 'People mightn't want their children to live in a shed in their back garden, but object to a housing scheme being built next door to them where their children could live in proper housing,' he said. Senior planner with the Irish Planning Institute, Seán O'Leary, said that there was a 'missed opportunity' to tease out how the exemptions would work prior to it going to public consultation next month. Taoiseach Micheál Martin said that the measures were 'one step in terms of a broad range of steps' that are being taken in relation to housing. Pic: Leah Farrell/ 'There probably is a bit of a missed opportunity here in terms of how these proposals are being developed,' he told RTÉ's News at One. 'I think these could and should have been worked up with planners working in local authorities, private practice, who've been dealing with the current exempted development regulations for 25 years nearly. I think we could have stress tested it before it went out to full consultation,' he said. Taoiseach Micheál Martin said that the measures were 'one step in terms of a broad range of steps' that are being taken in relation to housing. 'There's a lot of positive practical outcomes from this, which would deliver quicker delivery, in terms of a range of structures, but also in terms of granny flats or modular buildings, or attics. 'And that would, in its own way, unburden the planning system,' he said. A review of Exempted Developments, which have not been revised since being signed into law in 2001, lists several areas that require updating outside of residential. The areas for further consideration include: school infrastructure, extensions for health facilities to increase bed capacity, in the agriculture sector, slurry storage, fishery harbour centres and agricultural schemes. In the area of transport, railways, ports, airports and roads are mentioned, while infrastructure relating to energy, communications, water, and gas installations are also mentioned.
Irish Times
29 minutes ago
- Irish Times
What does the latest ECB cut mean for borrowers, savers and the broader economy?
Another rate cut from the ECB? How many is that now? It is the eighth rate cut since the current downward cycle began a year ago – or the ninth if you count what the ECB called a 'technical adjustment' last September. And why has the bank cut its rates again? Eurozone inflation inching just below the magic 2 per cent mark (at least magic in the eyes of Frankfurt bankers) in recent days might be one reason. Fairly anaemic growth across some of the powerhouses of Europe is another reason while a slowdown in global trade caused by the Trump administration's dizzying turns on tariffs will also have been a consideration for economic policymakers. READ MORE Will this be the last rate cut this year? It is hard to say for sure. Some hawkish members of the ECB's governing council were against this cut and there is a widely held view that while there may be one more 0.25 per cent cut this year, we are coming to the bottom of the rate cycle. The ECB will – as it always does – insist that its moves will be determined by economic conditions as the year progresses but the smart money would suggest rates will hover at around 2 per cent in the medium term. [ ECB cuts interest rates by quarter percentage point Opens in new window ] Okay, enough about them. What will this latest cut mean for me? It depends on who you are. If you are one of the 126,000 people who still hold a tracker mortgage you will see an almost immediate benefit as a result of the latest rate cut. If you are coming off a fixed rate in the month ahead you might – but it is only a might – be able to benefit from lower rates while variable rate mortgage holders and those who have mortgages with so-called vulture funds may also see rates drop slightly in the months ahead. As a tracker holder, when will my rate fall? The exact date will depend on the bank you are with, when your monthly repayment falls due and the nature of the mortgage contract you signed but banks have a window of around 30 days to pass on the rate cut which means you could see the benefit as early as your next repayment date. And how big will that benefit be? Again it depends on your individual circumstances but the latest ECB's quarter-point cut equates to a €13 a month saving for every €100,000 owed on a tracker mortgage. That means that if you have an outstanding home loan of €250,000 you are likely to be better off by around €33 a month from the end of this month. Some will see even larger savings while some will see more modest savings. And how much have tracker holders saved over the course of the current cycle? This is the eighth rate decrease since last June when the ECB cut rates by 0.25 per cent. It is actually the ninth if the technical adjustment that amounted to a 0.35 per cent cut that kicked in last September is included. That means the ECB's lending rate is now 2.15 per cent compared with 4.5 per cent this time last year. A tracker customer with around €150,000 left on their mortgage over 10 or 15 years, on a margin of 1 per cent, will now paying around €170 less each month compared to a year ago. That is just over €2,000 less than at the height of the interest rate cycle early last year. That is pretty massive? It is but context is key. While the rate cuts rolled out over the last 12 months have saved a certain cohort a significant amount of money, the rate hikes over the 18 months that came before that cost them dearly. A typical tracker mortgage holder with a loan costing them around €1,100 a month in 2021, might have seen their repayments soar above €1,500 at the top of the ECB rate cycle and while their current repayments of around €1,300 are a good bit less than what they were paying, they are also a good bit more than that were paying too. But enough about tracker mortgage holders what about those on fixed and variable rates? There is not likely to be any massive reduction in either fixed or variable rates from the mainstream lenders, in the short term although the Flex Mortgage announced by Bank Inter, formerly Avant Money should fall as its variable rates are linked to the 12-month Euribor rate. According to industry experts in Ireland, the correlation between home loan rates and ECB rate cuts. is not as solid as you might think because lenders here tend to price predicted cuts – and indeed hikes – into their offerings. When the ECB increased interest rates by 4.5 percentage points course of 2022 and 2023, banks only increased their home loan rates by just over 2 per cent on average. There is likely to be at least some pressure on fixed rates and more offerings slightly below 3 per cent might be on the cards in the weeks and months ahead. And will people with vulture fund mortgages be better off? There might be some relief on the horizon for many of those paying the very highest rates on the market but that remains up in the air. All these cuts aren't good news for savers or the property market though? That is right although it is worth pointing out that most savers are very much victims of their own misfortune. What do you mean by that? Irish people have more that €160 billion on deposit right now and around €140 billion of that is resting in accounts that offer very low or no interest at all. The ECB moves are likely to make no difference to this cohort as they are getting absolutely nothing for their money anyway. There will be downward pressure on the savings accounts that do offer rates of up to 3 per cent or so which will be very unwelcome news for many. And what about the broader market? Well cheaper money might fuel property price inflation here and with prices already climbing alarmingly fast that will not be good for anyone not least those looking to buy a home.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Sean McGovern concerned over ‘legality, propriety, process' of Dubai arrest and extradition, court told
The legal team hired by alleged Kinahan cartel senior figure Sean McGovern has told the Special Criminal Court in Dublin it was very concerned about the legality of his arrest in Dubai, his extradition to Ireland and his arrival in Dublin last week. Olan Callanan BL, for Mr McGovern, on Thursday told the court those reservations would be formally raised and set out to the Director of Public Prosecutions by the office of Michael Staines solicitors. 'What is to the fore, and of fundamental concern, is the legality, propriety and process which surrounded his arrival in Dublin last week,' Mr Callanan told the three-judge court. After a brief hearing of the court in central Dublin, during which Mr McGovern appeared by video link from Portlaoise Prison, he was further remanded in custody pending his next court appearance on June 18th. READ MORE Thursday's hearing was taking place a week after Ms Govern (39), a father of two, was extradited from the United Arab Emirates (UAE). He is charged in relation to the Kinahan-Hutch feud murder of Noel Kirwan (62), conspiracy to murder another man, directing a crime organisation and enhancing the capacity of a crime organisation. The murder charge he faces carries a mandatory sentence of life imprisonment, while the offence of directing a criminal organisation carries a sentence of up to a life term. At the accused's first court hearing last Thursday, Mr Callahan said his client was reserving his position in relation to the 'lawfulness of his arrest' and the jurisdiction of the Special Criminal Court. Mr McGovern is the first Irish person to be extradited from the UAE and the first alleged Kinahan cartel member arrested there. He had been in detention in the UAE since his arrest at his Dubai home last October on foot of an extradition request from the Irish authorities. The accused man arrived into Casement Aerodrome, Baldonnel, on an Air Corps Casa C295 plane last Thursday, May 29th, before being taken to the Courts of Criminal Justice for an evening sitting of the Special Criminal Court. He appeared before Ms Justice Karen O'Connor, Judge Elma Sheahan and Judge Gráinne Malone and was remanded in custody to Portlaoise Prison to today's date – Thursday, June 5th – when he appeared before the court again via video link from jail. Mr McGovern is charged with five alleged offences including the December 22nd, 2016, murder of Christopher 'Noel' Kirwan on St Ronan's Drive, Clondalkin. He is also charged with directing a criminal organisation between October 20th and December 22nd, 2016, and with enhancing the capacity of a criminal organisation between the same dates, all in relation to the Kirwan murder. Separately, he is charged with directing a criminal organisation between October 17th, 2015, and April 6th, 2017, in relation to the surveillance of Dubliner James Gately in preparation for the commission of indictable offence. He was further charged with facilitating a criminal organisation engaged in a conspiracy to murder Mr Gately between the same dates.
