Vance name fails to boost Bowman in Cincinnati mayor's race

Yahoo

07-05-2025

Cincinnati hasn't had a Republican mayor in more than 50 years, and that streak isn't in danger based on Tuesday's primary election results.
Incumbent Mayor Aftab Pureval is poised to cruise into a second term with little resistance. He dominated the low-turnout primary with 82.5% of the vote, according to unofficial results from the Hamilton County Board of Elections. Republican Cory Bowman, Vice President J.D. Vance's half-brother, came in a distant second with 13% of the vote.
More: What the primary tells us about Hyde Park, JD Vance, and the November election
The two men will now go head-to-head in November for the mayor's seat. Barring some scandal or self-inflicted political wounds by Pureval, I don't expect the outcome to change. Bowman, who has struggled to rally support, might get beaten even worse in a general election when more voters usually turn out.
Cincinnati mayor Aftab Pureval during The Cincinnati Enquirer mayoral debate at the Covedale Center for the Arts Tuesday, March 25, 2025.
Pureval expressed gratitude to the people of Cincinnati.
"Election Day is always a special day in our democracy. It is our opportunity as citizens to make our voices heard and choose the direction we want our city to go in the next four years. I don't take lightly the responsibility the voters have given me over the past three years," Pureval told me in a phone interview.
Of Tuesday's election results, he said, "I'm not sure I can read anything into it other than the people think the city is on the right path."
Bowman, a West End pastor and coffee shop owner, kept the faith despite the Grand Canyon-sized vote gap between him and Pureval. Advancing to November in his first political campaign was the goal, he said. I reached out to Bowman, but he didn't immediately return my call or text.
"What I will say is that looks like he had a good head start, but we're kind of catching up a little bit," Bowman told the Enquirer. "So once I see the numbers there, I'll know what our mission, our focus needs to be going into November.'
More: Forget the mayor's race. 27 want to run for Cincinnati City Council
A good head start? I guess that's one way of looking at it, if you're wearing rose-colored glasses. Here's a more clear-eyed view. Bowman has a 16,000-vote Mount Everest he must climb the next six months in a Democratic-leaning city. He got less than 3,000 votes and won only two of 190 precincts. I'll be generous and say the chances of overcoming those numbers are highly improbable.
Bowman's family ties might have helped him outlast Republican Brian Frank, whose performance was more dismal with less than 5% of the vote, but riding Vance's coattails won't be enough to unseat Pureval. The vice president endorsed Bowman just hours before the polls closed, seemingly without much effect.
If Bowman wants any shot at a more respectable finish in November, he needs to give Cincinnatians a reason to vote for him. That starts with doing a better job of articulating his vision and plans for the city. Saying what you don't like and that new leadership is needed simply isn't enough.
I'm glad that Bowman and Frank decided to run against Pureval. I think the public loses anytime candidates run unopposed for elected office. Citizens benefit whenever candidates have to debate their ideas, explain their vision, and defend their records. Seeing the contrast and having a choice matters.
That's why I'm hoping Bowman can step up his game in the months ahead.
Is he serious about being Cincinnati's mayor, or is he more interested in trading on his half-brother's celebrity for his own 15 minutes of fame? He managed to get featured in POLITICO Magazine before the primary.
Winning might not be the point. Bowman could simply be using this race to raise his national profile or position himself for other political opportunities down the road. (Hey, it worked for Vivek Ramaswamy.) If so, that's even more of a reason for him to make a decent showing. The political future isn't typically bright for candidates who get trounced in elections.
Cincinnati mayoral candidate Cory Bowman makes a statement as polling numbers show him trailing behind incumbent mayor Aftab Pureval, and advancing to the general election, at his election night party in the West End neighborhood of Cincinnati on Tuesday, May 6, 2025.
Meanwhile, Pureval has his sights set on another four years as mayor in what could be his last election. Nothing is certain, but Pureval said the thought of stepping away from politics after a second term has crossed his mind.
"A lot of politics is timing, and there may not be an opportunity for me in elected office given the political realities in the state," Pureval said. "My goal was never to be a career politician. It was to do the most good with the time that I have. I'm genuinely passionate about public service, but that may not take the role of electoral politics."
But that's a conversation for the future. Pureval said he's focused on the two most important jobs he has right now: being mayor and being a father to two sons under five.
"You have a very brief amount of time in these roles, and I feel a sense of urgency to get the difficult things done and set Cincinnati up for success after I'm gone," Pureval said.
Bowman doesn't have much time either. He'd better start knocking on some more doors. After Tuesday, the one to the mayor's office might already be closed.
Opinion and Engagement Editor Kevin S. Aldridge can be reached at [e-mail]. On X: @kevaldrid.
This article originally appeared on Cincinnati Enquirer: JD Vance's endorsement didn't help Bowman in mayoral primary | Opinion