Bill requiring app stores to verify age for minors in Alabama stalls in House committee
Rep. Chris Sells, R-Greenville, speaks to a colleague on the floor of the Alabama House of Representatives on Feb. 12, 2025 at the Alabama Statehouse in Montgomery, Alabama. (Brian Lyman/Alabama Reflector)
A bill that would require app stores to verify the age of individuals creating accounts in Alabama will likely not become law this year.
The House State Government Committee was set Tuesday to consider SB 187, sponsored by Sen. Clyde Chambliss, R-Prattville. But the committee did not have a quorum for its scheduled meeting, preventing a vote on the bill.
With just two days left in the 2025 legislative session, the committee would have to meet Wednesday to give the bill a chance of passage on May 14, the last scheduled day of the session, but Rep. Chris Sells, R-Greenville, the chair of the committee, indicated that legislation will be worked on over the summer to be introduced in the next legislative session.
The bill would require app stores to obtain parental consent for users identified as minors before they can download or purchase apps or make in-app purchases. The bill would have also prohibited developers from enforcing disclosures or terms of service on minors without parental consent.
'Apps would have to be approved by the parent and be age-appropriate for the child, so that would take care of the problem of the phones that are already out there, and that's what this is about, protecting children,' said Sells, who sponsored a similar bill in the House.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
A companion bill, SB 186, also sponsored by Chambliss, was passed by both chambers and sent to Gov. Kay Ivey Thursday. It will require smartphones and tablets manufactured on or after June 1 and activated in Alabama include a pre-installed filter capable of blocking obscene material. Sells said that 'will address the issue going forward.'
Justin Hill, a spokesperson for NetChoice advocating for limited internet government control, free speech and enterprise across the country aid 'we all agree on the why' for the bill, but disagreed on the basis of free speech. He suggested that the bill could face legal challenges.
'There are 17 states where this bill was filed, they run afoul of the First Amendment in our belief. And we do a lot of work in this space. We have a litigation team that litigates a lot of similar bills. This one has not made it to the point of litigation yet,' Hill said.
NetChoice has sued or is in litigation with at least 12 states. Georgia was sued in March after passing a law that would require children to acquire parental consent to use social media.
Melea Stephens, a Birmingham marriage and family therapist and a board member of the National Center on Sexual Exploitation, claimed to have seen cases in her private practice of children 'being exploited on commonly used apps.' She said that minors are entering contracts with 'multibillion dollar companies when they sign up for an app without parental permission.'
'We do not allow minors to go into a bank and sign a contract because they cannot comprehend the risk involved,' Stephens said, adding that the legislation is 'based on contract law, not content moderation or free speech issues.'
Rachel Holland, a spokesperson for Meta, a vocal proponent of the legislation, said in an email after the bill's passage that they look forward to working with lawmakers on this legislation.
'Parents want a one-stop shop to verify their teen's age and grant permission for them to download apps in a privacy-preserving way. The app store is the best place for it, and one-third of US states and the US Congress have introduced bills recognizing the central role app stores play,' she said in a statement.
Holland also cited a poll from the Alabama Policy Institute, a conservative think tank, suggesting 83% of voters support parental approval in app stores.
Rep. Russell Bedsole, R-Alabaster, said that 'whether or not this legislation is the right piece,' he feels that parents need help monitoring children's behavior online. He said that he uses a service that requires his children to ask for permission before downloading an app on their phone. Despite approving apps that seemed harmless to his children, Bedsole said there was still some unwanted content in the form of advertising or surveys.
Bedsole said that despite these concerns, lawmakers should work with groups like NetChoice to address them because of their complexity.
'We've got to have someone who represents the development of these apps to be at the table, because the technology behind it is so complex that, as a parent alone, I need some help,' Bedsole said.
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
31 minutes ago
- The Hill
Labor chief charged after arrest at ICE raid
California union leader David Huerta has been charged in federal court with conspiracy to impede an officer after he was arrested on Friday while protesting federal immigration enforcement efforts. Huerta, the president of the California branch of Service Employees International Union (SEIU) is detained and is slated to appear for a bond hearing Monday afternoon. A Homeland Security agent alleged in a court affidavit, dated Sunday, that officers were trying to execute a search warrant at a Los Angeles establishment suspected of hiring people who had entered the U.S. without authorization when Huerta took several steps to 'disrupt the operation.' Huerta sat and paced in front of a gate, the federal agent wrote in the affidavit, and refused to move aside. At one point, Huerta 'refused to move away from the path,' when a law enforcement van approached with its sirens blazing and tried to enter through the gate, according to the Homeland Security agent. Huerta, according to the federal agent, 'instead stood in front of the vehicle with his hands on his hips.' The agent said he then saw a law enforcement officer approach an 'uncooperative' Huerta and 'put his hands' on Huerta 'in an attempt to move him out of the path of the vehicle.' Huerta pushed the officer back, according to the agent, and 'in response,' the officer pushed Huerta to the ground, handcuffed him and arrested him. The incident has provoked outrage from Democrats. California Sens. Adam Schiff and Alex Padilla (D) joined Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) on Monday in a letter to several Trump administration officials 'demanding answers' about Huerta, who they say 'was injured, arrested and detained by federal officials while exercising his lawful right to observe the conduct of immigration enforcement personnel.' 'It is deeply troubling that a U.S. citizen, union leader, and upstanding member of the Los Angeles community continues to be detained by the federal government for exercising his rights to observe immigration enforcement,' the lawmakers wrote in a letter. 'As U.S. Senators, we are privileged and proud to represent Americans like Mr. Huerta, who are pillars of their community and stand up for the fundamental rights of all residents of our great state,' they wrote, noting they have a 'constitutional duty to conduct oversight' of federal agencies and are requiring a response to a list of questions about the incident. Rep. Maxine Waters (D-Calif.) also on Sunday attempted to speak to Huerta at the federal detention facility where Huerta was being held, but was blocked from entering, CNN reported. SEIU members, meanwhile, rallied in several cities Monday in Huerta's defense. The California branch of the union on Friday said that Huerta was arrested and injured 'while exercising his First Amendment right to observe and document law enforcement activity.' 'We are proud of President Huerta's righteous participation as a community observer, in keeping with his long history of advocating for immigrant workers and with the highest values of our movement: standing up to injustice, regardless of personal risk or the power of those perpetrating it,' the group's executive director Tia Orr said in a statement.
Los Angeles Times
35 minutes ago
- Los Angeles Times
Union leader faces federal charge of conspiracy to impede an officer during L.A. ICE raids
Federal authorities on Monday charged David Huerta, president of the Service Employees International Union California, in a criminal complaint with conspiracy to impede an officer for his alleged actions during an immigration enforcement raid last week. Huerta, 58, has been held at the Metropolitan Detention Center in downtown L.A. since Friday and is expected to make his initial appearance in federal court on Monday afternoon. He is facing a felony charge that carries up to six years in federal prison, according to the U.S. attorney's office in L.A. His attorney did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Huerta was detained and injured while documenting a workplace immigration raid in downtown L.A. on Friday. He was treated at a hospital and transferred to the Metropolitan Detention Center. Nine people tied to the protests have been charged federally, according to the U.S. attorney's office in L.A. Among them is Russell Gomez-Dzul, a Mexican national, who the White House said was arrested for assaulting a federal officer. Rallies are scheduled in more than a dozen cities across the U.S., including in L.A., by union members and other supporters demanding Huerta's release and an end to the workplace immigration raids. California Sens. Adam Schiff and Alex Padilla sent a letter Monday to the Department of Homeland Security and the Department of Justice demanding a review of Huerta's arrest. The U.S. Atty. for Los Angeles, Bill Essayli, a staunch Trump ally and hard-line conservative who was appointed in April, last week posted a photo on X of Huerta, hands behind his back, following the arrest. Essayli accused Huerta of obstructing the access of federal authorities to a facility where they were conducting a search warrant. 'Let me be clear: I don't care who you are—if you impede federal agents, you will be arrested and prosecuted,' Essayli wrote on X. 'No one has the right to assault, obstruct, or interfere with federal authorities carrying out their duties.' The labor union said in a statement Friday that Huerta was detained 'while exercising his First Amendment right to observe and document law enforcement activity.' Schiff, who referred to Huerta as 'a very prominent union leader in Los Angeles, a very respected voice,' was waiting to attend the labor leader's hearing Monday. Schiff spoke with reporters in front of a building graffitied in expletives aimed at Immigration and Customs Enforcement. He said that Huerta was 'exercising his lawful right to be present and observe these immigration raids.' 'It's obviously a very traumatic thing, and now that it looks like the Justice Department wants to try and make an example out of him, it's all the more traumatic,' Schiff said, when asked how Huerta was doing. 'But this is part of the Trump playbook. They selectively use the Justice Department to go after their adversaries. It's what they do.' According to the criminal complaint, U.S. Magistrate Judge Margo A. Rocconi authorized search warrants Thursday for four business locations 'suspected of unlawfully employing illegal aliens and falsifying employment records related to the status of its employees'. In an affidavit filed with the federal complaint, a supervisory special agent with Homeland Security Investigations, whose name was redacted, said news quickly spread about 'ICE raids' taking place throughout L.A. According to the complaint, Huerta arrived at Ambiance Apparel in the downtown Los Angeles Fashion District before noon Friday, joining several other protesters. The company was one of the sites of a workplace raid. 'The protesters, including HUERTA appeared to be communicating with each other in a concerted effort to disrupt the law enforcement operations,' the agent wrote. The agent wrote that Huerta was yelling at and taunting officers and later sat cross-legged in front of a vehicle gate to the location where law enforcement authorities were serving a search warrant. 'In addition to sitting in front of the gate, HUERTA at various times stood up and paced in front of the gate, effectively preventing law enforcement vehicles from entering or exiting the premises through the gate to execute the search warrant,' the agent wrote in the affidavit. 'As far as I was aware, this gate was the only location through which vehicles could enter or exit the premises.' The agent wrote that they told Huerta that, if he kept blocking the Ambiance gate, he would be arrested. Huerta responded that he couldn't hear the agent through his mask, according to the affidavit. Huerta used a curse word, the agent wrote. According to the complaint, as a white law enforcement van tried to get through the gate, Huerta stood in its path. Because Huerta 'was being uncooperative, the officer put his hands on HUERTA in an attempt to move him out of the path of the vehicle.' 'I saw HUERTA push back, and in response, the officer pushed HUERTA to the ground,' the agent wrote. 'The officer and I then handcuffed HUERTA and arrested him.' Huerta on Friday released a statement through his union, saying: 'What happened to me is not about me; This is about something much bigger. 'This is about how we as a community stand together and resist the injustice that's happening. Hard-working people, and members of our family and our community, are being treated like criminals. We all collectively have to object to this madness because this is not justice. This is injustice. And we all have to stand on the right side of justice.' Ahead of the Monday afternoon hearing, Huerta's cousin, Marta Gonzales, said she was there to represent the family. 'We're all heartbroken. We have family all over the world,' she said. 'Everyone's been watching.' Gonzales called Huerta 'a giant in our family.' 'This is so unjust,' she said. Asked about the protests over the weekend, she said she wondered if Huerta 'was the spark for a lot of it. It just angered so many people.'
43 minutes ago
LA immigration protests live updates: 700 Marines deployed to Los Angeles
They're expected to arrive over the next 24 hours, a U.S. official confirmed. Tensions are escalating in Los Angeles as protests against Immigration and Customs Enforcement grip the city, with demonstrators clashing with law enforcement and setting vehicles on fire downtown. President Donald Trump deployed 2,000 National Guardsmen to "address the lawlessness," White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said. But California Gov. Gavin Newsom asked the administration to rescind the deployment, saying Trump is trying "to manufacture a crisis" and that the president is "hoping for chaos so he can justify more crackdowns, more fear, more control." Key Headlines 9 minutes ago 700 Marines deployed to Los Angeles 24 minutes ago Trump says if protesters spit at National Guardsmen 'they will be hit' 31 minutes ago Homan: More resources are needed in LA 1 hour and 38 minutes ago California AG outlines decision to sue Trump administration Here's how the news is developing. 6 Updates 12:10 PM EDT Congresswoman blames Trump for civil unrest in her district Rep. Linda Sanchez, the House Democrat representing the Los Angeles area experiencing the unrest, is condemning the ICE raids and blaming President Donald Trump for enforcing a "cruel and broken immigration system." ICE's presence "does not make our neighborhoods safer. Instead, they are tearing families apart, traumatizing children and undermining trust with our local officials and law enforcement," Sanchez said in a statement. "The Trump administration's raids serve no purpose other than to stoke fear and enforce a cruel and broken immigration system." Sanchez added that she's working to learn whether any of the ICE detentions were unlawful. -ABC News' John Parkinson Trump administration border czar Tom Homan refuted claims that he was going to arrest Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass and California Gov. Gavin Newsom, telling Fox News that an interview from this weekend was taken out of context. "The reporter asked about, 'Could Governor, Governor Newsom, or Mayor Bass, be arrested?' I said, 'Well, no one's above the law, if they cross the line and commit a crime. Absolutely they can,'" Homan explained. "So there was no discussion about arresting Newsom." Homan asserted that he was speaking broadly that if anyone "crosses the line," they will be prosecuted. "You can protest. You got your First Amendment rights. But when you cross that line, you put hands on an ICE officer, or you destroy property, or ICE says that you're impeding law enforcement … that's a crime, and that the Trump administration is not going to tolerate," he said. President Donald Trump offered similar comments on Sunday, saying if California officials "stand in the way of law and order, yeah, they will face charges." California Gov. Gavin Newsom said the state is suing the Trump administration, claiming President Donald Trump illegally federalized the National Guard. The clashes between protesters and law enforcement "is exactly what Donald Trump wanted," Newsom wrote on social media Monday morning. "He flamed the fires and illegally acted to federalize the National Guard," Newsom said. "The order he signed doesn't just apply to CA. It will allow him to go into ANY STATE and do the same thing. We're suing him." President Donald Trump in a series of social media posts said the National Guard should be brought in "right now" to help deal with protesters in Los Angeles. "Jim McDonnell, the highly respected LAPD Chief, just stated that the protesters are getting very much more aggressive, and that he would "have to reassess the situation," as it pertains to bringing in the troops, Trump said in one post. He added, "He should, RIGHT NOW!!! Don't let these thugs get away with this. MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN!!!" Trump was referring to McDonnell's Sunday night press conference, where he said, "this thing has gotten out of control" and would now have to make a "reassessment" about requesting the National Guard. -ABC News' Justin Gomez
