CBRM councillors call for thorough review of fire departments, equipment and staffing
This week, Coun. Gordon MacDonald called for a thorough review following talks over a lengthy list of issues raised at last week's meeting.
"We know through our discussions at the committee of the whole last week that there are many deficiencies and inefficiencies happening in fire services," he said Tuesday.
"We've really got to start identifying where these issues are, what [are] the issues that they're causing to fire services, where the resources are needed the most [and] how best we are able to get those resources to protect the citizens of the CBRM."
Last week, the Glace Bay volunteer fire department threw up its hands and ceded budgeting of its operations entirely to CBRM's fire service.
At the same time, the municipality's fire chief and deputy chief warned council that more than 20 fire trucks in various stations across the municipality are nearly 25 years old and are about to reach the end of their useful life and could cost at least $20 million to replace.
Council also heard from the regional fire chiefs association that volunteer ranks are getting desperately slim.
Councillors unanimously agreed to have the chief administrative officer conduct a review, but they did not set a timeline on the review or determine how it should be done.
In 2016, CBRM commissioned a consultant to review the fire service, resulting in what's known as the Manitou report.
It recommended centralizing control and funding of the entire fire service and eliminating some stations, but that has not happened.
Deputy Mayor Eldon MacDonald said that report would be a good starting point.
"We need to provide our services [as] fast and efficient to our residents as possible and currently that's not happening and that review is much needed," he said.
Two stations in Sydney are staffed around the clock by unionized career firefighters.
CBRM also has 32 volunteer departments throughout the county. Three of them — in the former towns of Glace Bay, New Waterford and North Sydney — are considered composite stations that are owned and run by volunteers but also have a full-time career firefighter on hand around the clock.
Fire service officials say the rising cost of firefighting equipment and vehicles has made it unaffordable for many volunteer departments to operate as they used to, citing that as the main reason Glace Bay handed its budgeting over to the municipality.
CBRM does provide grants for equipment and vehicles, but Deputy Chief Craig MacNeil said a basic truck now costs around $900,000 without the modifications required for local equipment and needs.
He would not say that CBRM has too many departments and vehicles, but he has been asking volunteer departments about the possibility of downsizing the fleet.
List of pressures going to province
"We have 130 pieces of equipment right now in CBRM," he said. "That's the exact same amount of equipment [Halifax Regional Municipality] has. We have a lot of fire trucks and a lot of fire stations."
MacNeil said even if a 25-year-old truck still runs, the insurance industry considers it as being at the end of its life, and keeping it in service could cost the municipality and property owners more in insurance premiums.
Council has not decided how it will handle the 22 aging vehicles but has agreed to review and consider the list, and Mayor Cecil Clarke said it will be added to a list of financial pressures that CBRM intends to take to the provincial government.
The overall review is also expected to consider volunteer numbers, which are a concern as well, Westmount fire Chief Rod Beresford told council last week.
Beresford, who chairs CBRM's association of regional chiefs, said even in departments where numbers are higher, the volunteers are not all fully trained.
In Westmount, a suburb on the opposite side of the harbour from Sydney, only one volunteer works in the area during the day, Beresford said.
And a neighbouring department with more volunteers does not always have a fully trained complement, he said, so backup firefighters might be able to arrive on scene with a truck, but might not be trained to fight a large structure fire.
That's why he asked for and got approval for an automatic response from career firefighters in Sydney for any call involving a possible or working structure fire in Westmount's territory.
Meanwhile, a provincewide review of fire governance that's also underway is expected to be completed by the end of this year.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Post
30 minutes ago
- National Post
Canada's laws ‘outdated and inadequate' to fight cross-border crime, head of police chiefs group says
VICTORIA — The head of the Canada's police chiefs association says they are guided by 'outdated and inadequate' laws that were never designed to take on the current criminal landscape that no longer respects international borders. Article content Thomas Carrique, president of the Association of Chiefs of Police, said police would have been in a better place to 'disrupt' transnational crime, if the federal government had listened to his group in 2001, when it last proposed legislative changes. Article content 'Across Canada, police are confronting the domestic fallout of international disorder, but we are being asked to do so using tools, and authorities built for a different era, guided by outdated and inadequate legislation that was never designed to address today's criminal landscape,' he said on Tuesday. Article content Article content Carrique said 'geopolitical instability and social unrest' around the world are driving what he called 'a new wave of public safety threats' as Canadian police confront transnational organized crime, extremism, drug trafficking and exploitation through the internet. Article content 'Whether it's human smuggling as well as illicit exportation and importation of drugs, precursors, and firearms, organized crime groups are taking advantage of systematic blind spots, outdated statues, and digital platforms to victimize Canadians,' he said. Article content While geopolitics and social unrest might be beyond the control of Canadians and their government, their level of preparation and response is not, he said. Article content Article content The current Strong Borders Act legislation proposed by the federal governments gives police many — but not all necessary _ tools to confront globalized crime, he said. Article content Article content The government said the bill would help authorities combat transnational organized crime, stop the flow of fentanyl, crack down on money laundering and bolster police response to criminal networks. Article content He said the federal government's legislation aligns closely with several resolutions the group has passed during the conference this week. Article content Carrique said there are a 'number of loopholes' that must be closed to reflect the realities of 21st century crime, such as the inability of police to get a search warrant for any Canada Post package under 500 grams. Article content 'So, a judge cannot even issue a search warrant for a package of that size that may contain enough fentanyl to kill a number of people.'
Calgary Herald
31 minutes ago
- Calgary Herald
U.S. auto exports to Canada plummet on tariff tussle with Trump
Canada imported more vehicles from Mexico than the US in June for the first time in three decades, underscoring the historic shifts underway as the global auto industry grapples with President Donald Trump's tariffs. Article content Canadian importers brought in C$1.08 billion of passenger vehicles from Mexico during the month, exceeding the C$950 million from the US, according to Statistics Canada figures. That's the first time the Mexican auto sector has outsold the US in monthly data going back to the early 1990s. Article content Article content Trump's imposition of 25% tariffs on foreign vehicles has disrupted the long-standing system that mostly allowed the free flow of vehicles and parts across the three North American countries. For cars and trucks shipped under US-Mexico-Canada Agreement, the duty is applied only to the value of non-US content. But that small reprieve has done little to repair the strained relationship between the US and Canada. Article content Article content In retaliation, Canada announced a tariff on US-assembled vehicles in a structure that largely mirrors the White House's move. But the government also provides tariff relief for automakers that keep their manufacturing and investment in the country. Article content The shift in Canada's imports is a potential barometer of how Trump's tariffs will reshape the American industry, given that Canada is by far the biggest customer of US-made cars and light trucks. Article content Article content The US ran an auto trade surplus with Canada in 2024 including the parts sector, according to data from the US Commerce Department. American exports of finished vehicles to Canada exceeded exports to Germany, Mexico and China combined. Article content Companies such as General Motors Co. and Ford Motor Co. generally serve the Canadian market with vehicles made in the US. Ford isn't currently making anything at its lone Canadian assembly plant in Ontario, though it has promised it will start making F-Series Super Duty pickups there next year. Article content It's possible that Mexico's rise to No. 1 exporter of vehicles to Canada will be short-lived. Canadian imports of US autos were unusually high in February and March, averaging C$2.5 billion over those two months, as automakers raced to ship their products before any tariffs came in. That compares with monthly average last year of a little more than C$1.8 billion.
CTV News
34 minutes ago
- CTV News
‘Devastating blow': Alberta responds to 75.8% Chinese tariffs on Canadian canola
Pumpjacks draw out oil and gas from well heads surrounded by Canola fields near Cremona, Alta., Monday, July 15, 2024. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh Alberta is responding to the announcement by the Chinese government that a 75.8 per cent anti-dumping duty will be imposed on Canadian canola starting on Thursday. The province produces about one-third of Canada's canola, about 6.4 million tons a year. 'China's decision to impose a 75.8 per cent tariff on additional Canadian canola products is another devastating blow to Alberta's agriculture industry. 'This comes on top of the existing 100 per cent tariffs on canola oil, canola oil cake and peas and threatens to cut Alberta producers out of one of their most valuable markets almost entirely,' R.J. Sigurdson, minister of agriculture and irrigation, wrote in a statement on Tuesday. 'These tariffs by China are in response to the federal government's decision to impose 100 per cent tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles and 25 per cent tariffs on steel and aluminum, effective October 2024. Alberta's farmers, ranchers and processors did not create this situation, yet they are paying the price. 'Alberta is once again calling on Ottawa to act swiftly, engage in constructive dialogue with China, and restore access to one of our most critical markets before more livelihoods are lost.' The province's calls for federal intervention are echoed by the Alberta Canola Producers Commission. 'We've seen it in softwood lumber, we've seen it in other industries where there's the threat of tariffs,' board chair Andre Harpe told CTV News Edmonton. 'The federal government is doing a lot of work with them. We need them to be as serious with canola as they are with other industries that are under the threat or tariffs are happening.' Harpe, a canola farmer himself, says the tariffs could devastate farmers. 'I woke up this morning, as most canola farmers did, seeing that we had lost about $1 a bushel in the value of our product that we want to sell this year. So quite roughly, that's seven per cent of our income that we potentially could lose just just overnight by just having the Chinese make that announcement,' he said. 'Obviously we're going to be waiting to see what the long lasting effects are, and to see if they actually go through with this tariff.' China is Canada's second-largest canola market. The largest export market for Canadian canola is the United States, where Canadian exports not compliant with the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement are subject to 35 per cent tariffs. With files from CTV News Edmonton's Evan Kenny
