CBRM councillors call for thorough review of fire departments, equipment and staffing
Councillors in the Cape Breton Regional Municipality have called for a full review of volunteer and career fire services over concerns about the number of departments and the cost of staffing and equipping them.
This week, Coun. Gordon MacDonald called for a thorough review following talks over a lengthy list of issues raised at last week's meeting.
"We know through our discussions at the committee of the whole last week that there are many deficiencies and inefficiencies happening in fire services," he said Tuesday.
"We've really got to start identifying where these issues are, what [are] the issues that they're causing to fire services, where the resources are needed the most [and] how best we are able to get those resources to protect the citizens of the CBRM."
Last week, the Glace Bay volunteer fire department threw up its hands and ceded budgeting of its operations entirely to CBRM's fire service.
At the same time, the municipality's fire chief and deputy chief warned council that more than 20 fire trucks in various stations across the municipality are nearly 25 years old and are about to reach the end of their useful life and could cost at least $20 million to replace.
Council also heard from the regional fire chiefs association that volunteer ranks are getting desperately slim.
Councillors unanimously agreed to have the chief administrative officer conduct a review, but they did not set a timeline on the review or determine how it should be done.
In 2016, CBRM commissioned a consultant to review the fire service, resulting in what's known as the Manitou report.
It recommended centralizing control and funding of the entire fire service and eliminating some stations, but that has not happened.
Deputy Mayor Eldon MacDonald said that report would be a good starting point.
"We need to provide our services [as] fast and efficient to our residents as possible and currently that's not happening and that review is much needed," he said.
Two stations in Sydney are staffed around the clock by unionized career firefighters.
CBRM also has 32 volunteer departments throughout the county. Three of them — in the former towns of Glace Bay, New Waterford and North Sydney — are considered composite stations that are owned and run by volunteers but also have a full-time career firefighter on hand around the clock.
Fire service officials say the rising cost of firefighting equipment and vehicles has made it unaffordable for many volunteer departments to operate as they used to, citing that as the main reason Glace Bay handed its budgeting over to the municipality.
CBRM does provide grants for equipment and vehicles, but Deputy Chief Craig MacNeil said a basic truck now costs around $900,000 without the modifications required for local equipment and needs.
He would not say that CBRM has too many departments and vehicles, but he has been asking volunteer departments about the possibility of downsizing the fleet.
List of pressures going to province
"We have 130 pieces of equipment right now in CBRM," he said. "That's the exact same amount of equipment [Halifax Regional Municipality] has. We have a lot of fire trucks and a lot of fire stations."
MacNeil said even if a 25-year-old truck still runs, the insurance industry considers it as being at the end of its life, and keeping it in service could cost the municipality and property owners more in insurance premiums.
Council has not decided how it will handle the 22 aging vehicles but has agreed to review and consider the list, and Mayor Cecil Clarke said it will be added to a list of financial pressures that CBRM intends to take to the provincial government.
The overall review is also expected to consider volunteer numbers, which are a concern as well, Westmount fire Chief Rod Beresford told council last week.
Beresford, who chairs CBRM's association of regional chiefs, said even in departments where numbers are higher, the volunteers are not all fully trained.
In Westmount, a suburb on the opposite side of the harbour from Sydney, only one volunteer works in the area during the day, Beresford said.
And a neighbouring department with more volunteers does not always have a fully trained complement, he said, so backup firefighters might be able to arrive on scene with a truck, but might not be trained to fight a large structure fire.
That's why he asked for and got approval for an automatic response from career firefighters in Sydney for any call involving a possible or working structure fire in Westmount's territory.
Meanwhile, a provincewide review of fire governance that's also underway is expected to be completed by the end of this year.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Post
an hour ago
- National Post
G7 leaders will get a 'truly Albertan experience' says Kananaskis lodge GM
A host of world leaders will land in Calgary this weekend before making themselves at home in one of Canada's prized natural gems for three days of discussion on economic instability, war, political relations and other matters of global importance at the G7 summit. Article content Guests have already begun arriving at the Pomeroy Kananaskis Mountain lodge, according to Elizabeth Hovey-Smith, the lodge's general manager. For staff who have worked there for years, the next week will look quite different from the average work day. Article content Article content Article content For one, a controlled access zone has been created around the property by the Integrated Safety and Security Group, a multi-agency team lead by the RCMP that includes the Calgary Police Service, Alberta Sheriffs, provincial conservation officers and members of the Canadian Armed Forces. Article content Anyone entering Kananaskis Country requires accreditation, with different levels of permission afforded to people depending on their roles and requirement to enter certain areas of the lodge, Hovey-Smith said. Article content 'Normally, to get into K-Country, all you need is to register your licence plate and pay for your conservation pass,' she said. 'But now there are roadblocks.' Article content Staff are shuttled from the Stoney Nakoda resort and pass through several security checkpoints. Employees who want to hike in the region have to drive outside the zone. Article content Within the lodge, certain spots only allow certain employees, Hovey-Smith said. Article content 'I'm general manager, but that doesn't mean I get to go everywhere, because I might not need to,' she said. Article content 'Certainly, that's very different,' she said. 'That's not normal practice for us but very understandable, given the high-level conversations and people that are going to be attending.' Article content This year's summit, attended by leaders from Canada, U.S., Japan, France, Germany, Italy, France and the European Union — as well as invited guests from Australia, Brazil, Indonesia, India, Mexico, South Korea, South Africa and Ukraine — will focus on topics around economic instability and the Russia-Ukraine crisis. Article content The lodge is no stranger to hosting events of this political significance; it hosted the G8 summit in 2002, one of three events since the lodge was taken over by the Pomeroy group that it has hosted an event that it was completely taken over by a client, according to Hovey-Smith.
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Awaiting sex crimes trials, billionaire Frank Stronach in Austria for a TV appearance
Social Sharing On June 5, Canadian billionaire Frank Stronach was doing what has preoccupied him for years: hawking his economic ideas in front of the camera. But this was not one of his regular speeches at his Aurora, Ont., restaurant or at some Canadian business gala. The 92-year-old, who is to stand trial in Toronto and Newmarket, Ont., next year for more than a dozen alleged sex crimes, gave his economic stump speech an ocean away, in Austria, on a current affairs news program. Stronach, who had to surrender his passport to the courts when he was arrested in June 2024, has been in the country of his birth for three weeks, CBC News has learned. Court documents obtained by CBC News show that Stronach's bail conditions were quietly altered on May 21, granting him the return of his passport and ability to travel from May 24 to June 14. The section of the document set aside to provide reasons why a bail condition should be changed contains only a single sentence with no further explanation: "To allow Mr. Stronach to travel to Austria." The change to Stronach's bail conditions, which were requested by his Toronto lawyer, Leora Shemesh, was approved by assistant Crown attorney Jelena Vlacic. The alteration did not require a hearing before a judge, because the Crown did not object. Vlacic confirmed in an interview that she consented to the change. "I'm not in a position to sort of make any comments," she said when asked why she agreed. Not unusual to grant passport request: lawyer Although Stronach was required to surrender his passport last year, his bail conditions do not mention any other restrictions on travel, a common feature, said Ottawa criminal lawyer Michael Spratt. "Bail is not intended to be punitive," he told CBC News in a Friday interview. "An accused person is presumed innocent." Spratt said the primary reason a court orders the surrender of a passport is to prevent an accused person from fleeing the country. While someone of Stronach's wealth has the means to leave, Spratt said that is not the only consideration at hand. "If someone, say, suddenly moved a lot of assets into that country, or bought a home there, or bought a one-way ticket to a country that doesn't have an extradition treaty, the Crown might take a much harder look at that," said Spratt, who is not part of the Stronach case. If those sorts of conditions don't exist, the Crown is likely to grant the return of a passport, he said. Spratt said in a case like Stronach's, where a high-profile person is facing multiple criminal charges, the release of a passport will raise some eyebrows. But it is not unusual for such a request to be granted. Shemesh, in an emailed statement to CBC News, said the paperwork was a "formality." "He is presumed innocent. He has no criminal record. He maintains his innocence and enjoys the same freedoms we all do." 'A disappointing double standard for wealthy' Stronach is a well-known political and business figure in Austria. Aside from the fame and wealth he garnered from leading the Ontario-based auto-parts giant Magna for decades, he once ran his own political party in Austria. Called Team Stronach, the party had limited electoral success in 2013 but was a thing of the past by 2014. He surrendered his passport at the courthouse in Brampton, Ont., on June 7, 2024. Stronach, 91 at the time, was arrested and charged with sexual assault, rape and forcible confinement in cases involving 10 women dating back decades. By October 2024, his charge sheet ballooned to 18 criminal counts. Stronach has denied all of the charges against him, calling the allegations made by the women "lies." He now faces two trials. Twelve of the charges against him will be heard in a Toronto courtroom starting on Nov. 16, 2026. The remaining charges will be tried in York Region, with a jury trial scheduled to begin on June 1, 2026. CBC News reached out to several of the women who allege Stronach assaulted them. They declined to comment or could not be reached on Friday. "I'm baffled by Frank Stronach's presence in Austria. It was reported that he had surrendered his passport," said Jane Boon, a former Magna intern who says she had a sexual encounter with Stronach in 1986, when she was 19 and he was 54. Last year, Boon spoke to Fifth Estate reporter Mark Kelley about her uncomfortable sexual experience with Stronach, which is not part of any of the criminal cases the former auto-parts magnate is facing. "It was a horrible abuse of power," she told Kelley. "This extravagant trip suggests a disappointing double standard for wealthy defendants of serious crimes," she said Friday of Stronach's recent trip to Austria. However, Spratt said it is not uncommon for passports to be returned to people facing a criminal trial. Sometimes it is for a medical or family emergency, he said, and other times for something as simple as a vacation. Requests to change bail are also common in high-profile cases, including sex crime trials. In January 2014, then-CBC Radio host Jian Ghomeshi faced seven sexual assault charges, for which he was later acquitted. He, too, had to surrender his passport, and his bail conditions required him to live with his mother. The Crown later agreed to modify his bail, which included the return of his passport. But former fashion mogul Peter Nygard, currently serving 11 years in prison after being found guilty of four counts of sexual assault, was denied changes to his bail in 2024 because a judge said he presented a flight risk.
CBC
2 hours ago
- CBC
N.W.T. Supreme Court grants eviction orders for occupants of 2 cabins
The N.W.T. Supreme Court has issued three rulings in cases related to the territorial government's push to remove unauthorized cabins from public land, two of which resulted in eviction orders. The rulings, released Wednesday, relate to cabins near Narcisse Lake and Banting Lake. The cases are part of the territorial government's Unauthorized Occupancy Project, a program launched in 2021 to address the growing number of cabins built or bought without legal permission to use the land. The Unauthorized Occupancy Project separates cabins built before and after April 1, 2014, the date the territory assumed responsibility for administering territorial lands from the federal government. More than 700 cabins were identified for review under the program. Structures built before that date are evaluated for potential tenure eligibility. If a site fails to meet the criteria or cannot be linked to an Indigenous treaty right, legal action for removal can be taken. In two of the three recent cases, the court granted the government's application to evict the occupant. In the third, the judge declined to grant the eviction because of concerns about the information used to justify it. Matt Pond was born in Yellowknife and is a member of the Qalipu Mi'kmaq First Nation. In the late 1990s, he built a cabin with his parents north of Narcisse Lake. He had no lease, but he argued that his Indigenous status and his intention to transfer to the Yellowknives Dene First Nation entitled him to occupy the land. In the affidavit, Pond said he received verbal assurances in the 1990s and early 2000s that a lease was not required for small traditional-use cabins. He also said he completed a voluntary declaration form to assert those rights, though it was not signed by any N.W.T. Indigenous government, which is a requirement. The judge found Pond was not yet a member of a local Indigenous government with established or asserted rights in the area. She ruled that the possibility of transferring band membership in the future wasn't enough to give him legal permission to stay on the land. The court granted the government's application for eviction. In a second case, Frank Walsh took over a cabin on Narcisse Lake in 2007. The cabin was originally built around 2000. In 2013 or 2014, he asked the Department of Lands about getting a lease and was told that he would need a bill of sale and to remove a lakeside wharf. Walsh did not remove the wharf or apply for a lease. The department later determined that the cabin's location did not meet leasing criteria because it was within the ordinary high-water mark. Walsh also admitted he was aware he had no lease. Walsh argued he had occupied the site for over 20 years and should be allowed to stay under the legal principle of adverse possession. The judge rejected the argument, writing that Walsh had acknowledged the government's authority by inquiring about a lease and by later asking the court to order one. She also cited case law suggesting that public land cannot be claimed through adverse possession. The court granted the territory's application for eviction. In the final case, Thomas Van Dam purchased a cabin on Banting Lake in 2015. The structure was originally built in 2005 or 2006. A previous owner applied for a lease in 2013, but the application was denied in 2014 due to a temporary hold on recreational leasing in the area. Van Dam declared his ownership of the cabin to the Department of Lands after he began working there in 2021. He says a supervisor told him verbally that he would "get a lease." However, in 2022, he was informed that his site did not conform to cabin evaluation criteria. The government's application to court stated that the site failed to meet the criteria. However, the judge found the documentation did not specify how the cabin failed the criteria. She also said that Van Dam had moved the cabin to comply with the Yellowknife Watershed Development Area Regulations. The judge denied the government's request for eviction in this case but granted the government the ability to reapply once the minister reviews the process set out under the Unauthorized Occupancy Project.
