‘Actually romantic and actually funny': why When Harry Met Sally is my feelgood movie
There's not a dull moment in When Harry Met Sally, Nora Ephron and Rob Reiner's 1989 classic, which has become the apotheosis of the romcom. Every detail in the film is to be savoured: the golden leaves of Central Park. Billy Crystal's apartment. Meg Ryan's glasses. The sweaters! Oh, the sweaters!
It's not exactly a groundbreaking choice, so much so that I'm almost embarrassed to call it my 'feelgood movie'. Calling When Harry Met Sally a perfect comfort film is like calling pizza the perfect comfort food. It's hardly discerning or original.
But as with all comforts, it's never simply about the thing itself. There's always a story, some personal reason why that particular work of art compels you to return to it time and time again.
My relationship to When Harry Met Sally started when I was 11. I dreaded Monday mornings – that stomach-dropping feeling when you realise that it is indeed morning and yes, you do have to go to school. Just the anticipation of that feeling would fill Sunday evenings with dread.
In my bedroom, I had an old box TV with an in-built VHS player. By the time I started high school in 2008, VHS tapes were already out of fashion; DVDs and Blu-rays were how most people watched films at home. But our house was full of VHS tapes. (I loved that Sally alphabetised her videotapes on index cards. And yes, reader, I soon started alphabetising our family tapes.)
I made my way through the VHS tapes we had in our house, the way more precocious children ransack the local library. One evening, I picked up When Harry Met Sally. I remember the colours on the box were dull and faded. But as soon as the stylish opening credits started, with the jazzy piano rendition of It Had to Be You playing over them, I was hooked.
Soon after, I was watching When Harry Met Sally almost every Sunday evening over the course of a year. Sometimes I gave the film my full attention; other times, I had it on in the background as I did other things. It was just a comfort knowing it was there. Rewinding the tape back to the beginning was a cherished part of the weekly ritual. I've since watched the film countless times on a variety of formats, but I always think back to those Sunday evenings, watching the VHS cross-legged on my bedroom floor.
At its heart, When Harry Met Sally is a fantasy movie. Not just in its insistence that heterosexual men and women can never be friends without sex rearing its randy head in the way, but in the lifestyle it depicts: healthy, good-looking Manhattanites who live in beautiful apartments, wear gorgeous outfits, and whose major worries (Harry's hypochondria notwithstanding) are matters of the heart and not, say, how the next rent will be paid.
To me at 11, When Harry Met Sally represented a life worth fantasising about: I wanted to go on roadtrips; I couldn't drive. (Still can't.) I wanted to live in Manhattan, not Lancashire. (Still don't.) I wanted to fall in love. (Eventually did, though after some years of trial and error.) I knew Harry's cynicism and arrogance weren't to be admired, but otherwise I wanted his life: when you realise you want to spend the rest of your life as a New York-based political consultant who reads Stephen King novels in fancy chairs in even fancier apartments, you want the rest of your life to start as soon as possible.
Part of the film's brilliance comes from the supporting cast: Carrie Fisher as Marie and Bruno Kirby as Jess, Harry and Sally's best friends who develop their own romance. Marie and Jess provide the film's best lines (yes, better than 'I'll have what she's having'). Jess, during a frustrating game of Pictionary, pleads with Sally: 'Draw something resembling anything!' And Fisher delivers a line for the ages in New York's Shakespeare & Co bookstore: 'Someone is staring at you in Personal Growth.'
I sometimes ask myself whether I should love When Harry Met Sally as much as I do. I mean, isn't the film a bit reductive when it comes to gender? Maybe. Yet at the same time, it's a romantic comedy that's actually romantic and actually funny, something few romcoms can boast today. But the reason it's my feelgood film is because I discovered it at a time when I needed it most. To borrow Sally's words: When Harry Met Sally, you may have provided an unrealistic template for life, but it's impossible for me to hate you.
When Harry Met Sally is available to rent digitally in the US and UK
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
20-05-2025
- The Independent
Rob Reiner shouted at Doug Emhoff during debate party that Biden would ‘lose our f***ing democracy,' book claims
Tensions were high at a Hollywood debate watch party on June 27, 2024, when director Rob Reiner lashed out at then-second gentleman Doug Emhoff over President Joe Biden 's disastrous debate performance. A report on the confrontation appears in the new book Original Sin: President Biden's Decline, Its Cover-Up, and His Disastrous Choice to Run Again by CNN anchor Jake Tapper and Alex Thompson of Axios. Reiner is said to have exclaimed that the U.S. could 'lose our f***ing democracy,' as a result of Biden's performance at the June 27 debate against now-President Donald Trump, according to reporting by The Hill. The incident occurred at the home of James Costos, the former HBO executive and President Barack Obama 's ambassador to Spain. 'The gathering had originally been planned as a fundraiser for the Biden Victory Fund, but then the debate was scheduled for the same night, so the hosts turned it into a fancy and hopefully fun debate watch party, with people sitting in three or four different rooms,' the book states. In addition to Reiner and Emhoff, actor and activist Jane Fonda was also present, in addition to Democratic governors Andy Beshear of Kentucky, JB Pritzker of Illinois, and Gretchen Whitmer of Michigan. As President Biden spoke in a weak voice, repeatedly stumbled over answers, misspoke, and lost his train of thought, the evening quickly turned into a 'debate watch horror show.' 'A few minutes into it, Reiner, in the main living room, stated plainly: 'We are f***ed!'' Tapper and Thompson wrote, adding that he 'became angry. Soon he was venting, standing, full of fury.' 'He seemed to be looking at Emhoff. Daggers.' 'We're going to lose our f***ing democracy because of you!' the When Harry Met Sally director is said to have shouted at Emhoff. ''Because of me?' Emhoff thought,' the book states. CNN reported on the incident a few days after it occurred, but in less detail, noting: ' Rob Reiner was screaming about losing and Jane Fonda had tears in her eyes, according to people in the room.' The first presidential debate of the 2024 election, in which Biden struggled from the get-go and Trump repeated a barrage of lies and misinformation, was watched by 51.27 million viewers. It sparked 'deep panic' among Democrats, to the delight of supporters of Trump, and ultimately led to Biden stepping aside as the party's nominee in favor of Vice President Kamala Harris. On July 10, George Clooney, who just weeks before headlined a star-studded fundraiser that raked in $28 million for Biden's re-election campaign, penned an emotional op-ed telling his 'friend' in no uncertain terms to take himself out of the 2024 race. After another 11 days of mounting calls for him to step aside, Biden pulled out on July 21, putting Harris, with Emhoff by her side, at the top of the ticket.
Daily Record
19-05-2025
- Daily Record
Meghan Markle's wedding speech left guests shocked with this one remark
It has been seven years since Prince Harry and Meghan Markle got married. Today marks seven years since Meghan Markle and Prince Harry tied the knot at St George's Chapel. The couple's big day was a beautiful occasion and the world watched on as they became the Duke and Duchess of Sussex. After the stunning ceremony the newlyweds and hundreds of their guests headed to their reception followed by an evening party which was hosted by Harry's now estranged father, King Charles, at Frogmore House. Insiders say it really was quite the celebration with guests tucking into 'dirty burgers' and candyfloss and drinking themed cocktails. One cocktail was even named 'When Harry Met Meghan' - a nod to the iconic romcom movie When Harry Met Sally, writes The Mirror. Meghan also made a speech at her big day, which apparently left many guests speechless. In her moving speech, she said she had "found her prince", praised the late Queen and thanked Charles for stepping in at the last minute to walk her down the aisle. However, royal biographers Omid Scobie and Carolyn Durand claim in their book that Meghan hinted at how she had not been able to use her voice during her time as part of the Royal Family in the speech. In the book Finding Freedom, they write: "A first for a royal bride, the move reinforced the idea that this American was no typical duchess. "'You could literally hear a pin drop', said a close confidant, who described the speech as a momentous occasion even for the Americans. 'For her to have been quiet for as long as she had, and then have this really safe space where she could give these heartfelt remarks, it was a really special moment', the source said. "'She spent so many years, whether on campus, on TV, or advocating for women to be empowered, speaking out. And she's respected that. She does have a lot of respect for the family and the institution that she has joined. But it's just a different way of living. We'd missed hearing her speak'. And apparently Meghan felt the same way, because she laughed, 'I know it's been a while'." Years later, during her interview with Oprah Winfrey, Meghan spoke directly on the issue of not having a voice, saying she had been silenced and comparing herself to The Little Mermaid. She said she was shocked by the parallels between herself and the cartoon princess who also 'lost her voice' after marrying royalty. She recalled a day when she sat down at the couple's former home, Nottingham Cottage at Kensington Palace, to watch the movie on TV. "Now, who as an adult really watches The Little Mermaid?" she joked to Oprah. "But it came on and I was like, well, I'm just here all the time, so I may as well watch this. "And I went 'Oh my God, she falls in love with a prince and because of that she has to lose her voice'. "But by the end, she gets her voice back," she added. In her and Harry's explosive Netflix series released in 2022, Meghan revealed what exactly she said in her wedding day speech. In the last episode of the six-part series, Meghan reads the speech from her phone while sat beside Harry and says her first line "got a big laugh" from guests. She then read out: "Onto the crux of why I wanted to speak tonight. First of all, it's been a while. Continuing to recall her speech, Meghan goes on: "But mostly I wanted to share a story. A story about the man that I love and the way that we met. 'Let's call this a modern fairytale. Once upon a time, there was a girl from LA. Some people called her 'an actress'. And there was a guy from London. Some people called him 'a prince'. All of those people didn't fully get it. Because this is the love story of a boy and a girl who were meant to be together. "They meet on July 3rd, 2016 in London and they giggle endlessly. "They have their second date and he brings her cupcakes because it's 4 July.''A bittersweet celebration', he says. Ironic really. Her country's independence from his country. Yet in this moment they know they don't want to be independent from each other. "And after a month of long-distance courtship, they settle into the quiet of Botswana. And amidst whatever momentary worries that creep in, they look at each other and think, whatever world we're in. They would love and garden and travel and laugh, and rack up more air miles than any couple could have. "And when the tides were rough, they squeezed each other tighter. 'Nothing can break us,' they'd say. 'For this love, she was a fighter.' "I appreciate, respect and honour you, my treasure, for the family we will create. And our love story that will last forever. "So I ask you to raise a glass to the astounding assurance that now life begins. And the everlasting knowing that, above all, love wins.' Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community!
Daily Mirror
19-05-2025
- Daily Mirror
Meghan's cutting remark about royal life at wedding left royals 'speechless'
Meghan Markle and Prince Harry both gave speeches at the private celebrations on their wedding day in 2018, and the new Duchess of Sussex made a comment on her royal life so far It has been seven years since Meghan Markle walked down the aisle of St George's Chapel to marry Prince Harry in an unforgettable wedding. The day has been a beautiful celebration of the couple's love, and people around the world came together to toast the new Duke and Duchess of Sussex. Once the televised church service was over, the newlyweds and their guests headed to a lunchtime reception followed by an evening party hosted by harry's now estranged father King Charles at Frogmore House. Insiders say it was quite the party, with guests tucking into 'dirty burgers' and candyfloss and drinking themed cocktails including one named 'When Harry Met Meghan' - a play on the hit romantic comedy When Harry Met Sally. When it came to the speeches, Meghan proved she was the modern bride by joining her new husband to say a few words - and it appears to left many speechless. In her moving speech, she said she had "found her prince", praised the late Queen and thanked Charles for stepping in at the last minute to walk her down the aisle. But royal biographers Omid Scobie and Carolyn Durand claim that Meghan hinted at how she had not been able to use her voice during her time as part of the Royal Family in the speech. In the book Finding Freedom, they write: "A first for a royal bride, the move reinforced the idea that this American was no typical duchess. "'You could literally hear a pin drop', said a close confidant, who described the speech as a momentous occasion even for the Americans. 'For her to have been quiet for as long as she had, and then have this really safe space where she could give these heartfelt remarks, it was a really special moment', the source said. "'She spent so many years, whether on campus, on TV, or advocating for women to be empowered, speaking out. And she's respected that. She does have a lot of respect for the family and the institution that she has joined. But it's just a different way of living. We'd missed hearing her speak'. And apparently Meghan felt the same way, because she laughed, 'I know it's been a while'." Years later, Meghan spoke directly on the issue of not having a voice during her bombshell interview with Oprah Winfrey, saying she had been silenced and comparing herself to The Little Mermaid. She said she was shocked by the parallels between herself and the cartoon princess who also 'lost her voice' after marrying royalty. She recalled a day when she sat down at the couple's former home, Nottingham Cottage at Kensington Palace, to watch the movie on TV. "Now, who as an adult really watches The Little Mermaid?" she joked to Oprah. "But it came on and I was like, well, I'm just here all the time, so I may as well watch this. "And I went 'Oh my God, she falls in love with a prince and because of that she has to lose her voice'. "But by the end, she gets her voice back," she added. In her and Harry's explosive Netflix series released in 2022, Meghan revealed what exactly she said in her wedding day speech. In the last episode of the six-part series, Meghan reads the speech from her phone while sat beside Harry and says her first line "got a big laugh" from guests. She then read out: "Onto the crux of why I wanted to speak tonight. First of all, it's been a while. Continuing to recall her speech, Meghan goes on: "But mostly I wanted to share a story. A story about the man that I love and the way that we met. 'Let's call this a modern fairytale. Once upon a time, there was a girl from LA. Some people called her 'an actress'. And there was a guy from London. Some people called him 'a prince'. All of those people didn't fully get it. Because this is the love story of a boy and a girl who were meant to be together. "They meet on July 3rd, 2016 in London and they giggle endlessly. "They have their second date and he brings her cupcakes because it's 4 July.''A bittersweet celebration', he says. Ironic really. Her country's independence from his country. Yet in this moment they know they don't want to be independent from each other. "And after a month of long-distance courtship, they settle into the quiet of Botswana. And amidst whatever momentary worries that creep in, they look at each other and think, whatever world we're in. They would love and garden and travel and laugh, and rack up more air miles than any couple could have. "And when the tides were rough, they squeezed each other tighter. 'Nothing can break us,' they'd say. 'For this love, she was a fighter.' "I appreciate, respect and honour you, my treasure, for the family we will create. And our love story that will last forever. "So I ask you to raise a glass to the astounding assurance that now life begins. And the everlasting knowing that, above all, love wins.'
