‘Absolutely perfect' newborn baby died from missed ‘hole in the heart' after mum spotted her eyelid twitching
The newborn 's condition led to a bleed on her brain, an inquest has heard.
1
Esme's mum Ellen Roberts recalled the moment she found she was going to lose her baby daughter.
During an inquest hearing at South Manchester Coroner's Court, she said: "The doctors came out to us and said they've been working on her for half an hour."
She added: "They said: 'Your baby's going to die', which is the worst thing you can say to anyone."
A post-mortem examination found Esme had a ventricular septal defect (VSD), reports Manchester Evening News.
VSD is a congenital heart defect where there's a hole in the wall (septum) that separates the two lower chambers (ventricles) of the heart.
The condition makes it more difficult for blood to be pumped efficiently around the body.
Senior coroner Alison Mutch OBE heard while neither of her parents had any congenital conditions, Ellen's identical twin sister had been diagnosed with a heart condition.
Esme was born on February 7 2024 and just six hours after her birth was taken to the neonatal unit.
While doctors were worried about her oxygen levels, Ellen described her daughter as "absolutely perfect".
When she was two days old, Esme was sent for an X-ray.
Emma Willis, 48, reveals she underwent secret surgery on her HEART after shock diagnosis
But consultant paediatric radiologist Dr Rob Hawkes told the court Esme's VSD couldn't be seen on an X-ray, as the type of image it produced would only show an "enlarged" heart rather than the detail required to identify the condition.
Shortly after Esme was discharged and returned home with her parents, Ellen and Esme's dad Louis Atkinson.
Initially, she appeared a normal newborn, but then Ellen and Louis noticed she started to feed less.
On March 6, Esme "projectile vomited across the room" after being fed.
A midwife visited the following day as part of a routine visit and advised them to take her to the GP as Esme looked unusually pale and to be "better safe than sorry".
The doctor looked into Esme's blood but found they hadn't been done.
But Ellen revealed she was none the wiser to what was going on.
On March 17, Ellen had been struggling to get her daughter to take from the bottle, and noticed something seemed off.
She said: "When she was feeding I looked down and her right eyelid was twitching. I thought maybe there was something in her eye so I wiped it with some cotton wool.
"About an hour or so later she had done it again. She had never done that before."
After confiding in a group chat for new parents, Ellen decided to take Esme to hospital, arriving at Stepping Hill around 6:30pm.
She was seen after 15 minutes, which Ellen had thought was good, until a nurse said Esme "should have been seen as soon as you came in".
Esme was placed on oxygen and CPR was carried out.
But despite doctors' efforts, Esme passed away on March 17 2024.
The inquest continues.
Ventricular septal defect (VSD) symptoms
A VSD usually causes no signs or symptoms.
The blood flowing through the hole can create a swishing noise. This is called a heart murmur.
Doctors can hear a heart murmur when they listen to your heart with a stethoscope.
In rare cases, a VSD may cause signs and symptoms in children, such as:
shortness of breath, especially when exercising
being very tired
being underweight and growing slowly
irregular or extra heart beats, called arrhythmias.
Adults with a VSD may also have signs and symptoms, such as:
shortness of breath, especially when exercising
you may not be able to exercise for long
feeling very tired
irregular or extra heart beats, called arrhythmias
fainting.
If you have any of these symptoms, speak to your doctor.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
22 minutes ago
- The Independent
NHS launches personalised ‘blood matching' test
A new personalised 'blood-matching' test has been launched in the UK for patients with rare conditions requiring regular blood transfusions. The test utilises genetics to generate detailed blood group information, allowing for closer matching of donor blood and reducing the risk of severe reactions. Approximately 300 individuals with rare inherited anaemias are initially eligible for the test, along with all patients suffering from sickle cell disorder and thalassaemia. This genotyping testing programme is a collaborative effort between NHS Blood and Transplant and NHS England. The initiative is supported by the family of Woody Mayers, a 22-month-old boy with a rare anaemia who relies on monthly blood transfusions, highlighting the importance of well-matched blood.
Telegraph
23 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Midwife who praised Oct 7 attacks sues hospital for referring her to Prevent
An NHS midwife who praised the Oct 7 Hamas attacks on Israel is suing the hospital where she worked for referring her to Prevent. Fatimah Mohamied retweeted a post on X which said Palestinians have a 'right to resist' occupation, writing above the post ', hell yeah'. She also said: 'Would you take abuse lying down, for years and years and years? If you never retaliated, never resisted, would you respect yourself?' Chelsea and Westminster Hospital NHS Foundation Trust referred her to the Prevent anti-radicalisation programme and the Nursing and Midwifery Council regulator, a year after she had resigned from her employment and following a complaint about her online activity from UK Lawyers for Israel. The mother of two, who lives in London, alleges that the referrals breached her rights under the Equality Act 2010 and constituted post-employment harassment and/or discrimination, according to the law firm Leigh Day. 'A campaign of harassment' She said: 'I have been subjected to a concerted and targeted effort to intimidate, harass and punish me into silence for my Palestinian advocacy and criticism of Zionism. 'I am taking legal action against my former employer to finally seek accountability for a campaign of harassment against me in the midst of a live genocide perpetrated by the Israeli state – I will not accept the attempts to silence me and those like me. 'Healthcare workers in the NHS have the right to critique a colonial political ideology that has upheld an illegal occupation for decades and is responsible for violating universal values of health.' On Oct 8 2023, a complaint was lodged about Ms Mohamied's social media posts in which she voiced her support for Palestinian people and her opposition to Zionism in the wake of the Hamas attacks in Israel, Leigh Day said. Refusal to delete posts Her line manager asked her to consider deleting the posts or her account, but she refused to do so. Three further complaints were made about the midwife's social media posts and on Dec 20 2023, the trust received a letter from UK Lawyers for Israel accusing Ms Mohamied of expressing support for Hamas. In early January the following year, the trust's director of maternity told Ms Mohamied that if they received 'more emails or letters of concern', her actions could be considered misconduct. Ms Mohamied, who was a cultural safety lead midwife and had worked at the trust since June 2019, resigned in March last year. In March this year, the trust received a second letter from UK Lawyers for Israel, which launched further complaints about further social media posts and accused Ms Mohamied of anti-Semitism, bullying and harassment and of stirring up racial hatred against Jews and Israelis. Towards the end of the month, the trust referred Ms Mohamied to the Nursing and Midwifery Council and then to the Metropolitan Police under Prevent over her online activity. 'Entirely disproportionate response' Both referrals were dismissed, and Leigh Day said in a letter to the trust that the regulator and police each assessed Ms Mohamied's posts 'amounted to lawful expression of her beliefs and did not present cause for concern'. Liana Wood, partner at the law firm, said: 'We say the trust's referrals against Fatimah, made a year after she had stopped working for them, were an entirely disproportionate response to her lawful expressions of belief on her personal blog and social media accounts. 'Fatimah's case, which has parallels with other cases we have seen recently in the NHS, highlights the need for employers to resist pressure from lobby groups in such cases, and to carefully consider any potential infringement on an individual's rights before taking action against them.'
The Sun
23 minutes ago
- The Sun
Major retailer stops selling Mounjaro due to ‘nationwide shortages' after customers panic buy stock
A MAJOR high street pharmacy has stopped selling Mounjaro amid a nationwide shortage of the popular fat jab. It comes just days after The Sun revealed the price of the 'King Kong' injection would soon soar, sparking a rush of customers panic-buying. 1 Superdrug has said it is experiencing a "short term stock issue" which means it has been forced to "switch off" its "Mounjaro offering across all strengths". "We hope to have new stock arriving in the coming weeks and will switch this back on as soon as we do," they added, in a post on its website. People paying privately for Mounjaro in the UK face a rise in the cost of treatment after manufacturer Eli Lilly announced on Thursday it was increasing the list price by as much as 170 per cent. The change means the suggested price for a month's supply of the highest dose of the medicine will increase from £122 to £330 (for the provider). While retailers who sell Mounjaro may be able to negotiate discounts, it's likely the price will increase at least somewhat for the estimated 1.5 million people on weight loss drugs in the UK. Superdrug has been approached for comment.
