logo
Netflix Doc Reveals Risks To Kid Stars, As States Gut Child Labor Laws

Netflix Doc Reveals Risks To Kid Stars, As States Gut Child Labor Laws

Forbes15-04-2025

Netflix pulls back the curtain on social media child stardom in its latest buzzworthy documentary, Bad Influence: The Dark Side of Kidfluencing, which premiered on April 9, 2025. The three-part investigative series follows Piper Rockelle's rise to fame as a YouTube child influencer starting at age nine. The series not only shines light on the hidden reality of child content creation. It also illuminates the inadequacy of child labor laws in the U.S.
Rockelle's social media career was engineered by her mother, Tiffany Smith, who built a group of aspiring child stars into an online phenomenon known as the 'Squad.' At its height, Rockelle's YouTube channel was getting billions of views of the Squad's skits, dances, pranks, challenges, and 'crushes,' as its members grew from tweens to teens.
Kidfluencing is a lucrative business. Rockelle's channel was raking in upwards of $620,000 a month from revenue streams and brand partnerships, for an estimated $4.2 to $7.5 million a year.
Over time, the parents of some of the Squad's participants began to suspect a toxic behind-the-scenes experience. Multiple children from the Squad came forward with serious allegations of emotional, physical, and sexual abuse. The children also alleged exploitative work conditions, often logging extremely long hours without meals or rest breaks, without on-set schooling, and without sharing fairly in the profits, according to a 2022 Los Angeles Times investigation.
Bad Influence, directed by Jenna Rosher and Kief Davidson, follows the children's experience from the Squad's creation to the resulting lawsuit filed against Smith in 2022. The suit was brought by 11 former Squad members and their parents, seeking at least $22 million in damages. Smith paid $1.85 million to settle the lawsuit in 2024, without admitting wrongdoing, which she has publicly denied.
The working conditions portrayed in the docuseries have renewed calls for increased child labor protections. But instead of updating child labor laws, many states are moving in the opposite direction. In the last five years, a record number of states have fielded bills to roll back existing child labor laws, in response to both industry and political pressure.
These opposing trends—increasing child labor violations alongside decreasing child labor protections—are analyzed in a 2023 report by the Economic Policy Institute, authored by Jennifer Sherer, Deputy Director of EPI's Economic Analysis and Research Network, and Nina Mast, EPI Policy and Economic Analyst. Sherer and Mast explore what this conflict means for the future of child labor in the U.S.
Employers must comply with both federal and state child labor laws. Federal law sets the floor, and states can impose higher (but not lower) child labor protections.
Child labor law violations are on the rise in the U.S. The number of minors employed in violation of federal child labor laws identified by the U.S. Department of Labor in fiscal year 2024 increased by 43% over fiscal year 2021, and by nearly 300% over fiscal year 2015. The DOL imposed over $15 million in civil penalties against employers for child labor violations in fiscal year 2024 alone.
This data likely captures only the tip of the child labor iceberg. 'These numbers represent just a tiny fraction of violations, most of which go unreported and uninvestigated,' according to Sherer and Mast.
The challenge of uncovering child exploitation is compounded for child influencers, whose work is often controlled by parents and takes place largely behind private doors. It's unclear whether the work of kidfluencers even counts as 'labor' under existing laws.
The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 is the federal law governing child labor for employers nationwide that meet certain size thresholds. The FLSA sets minimum ages and maximum hours for child workers, with greater restrictions for minors working in hazardous industries. However, the FLSA excludes child actors from its coverage, leaving their protection up to the states. Historically, most states enacted their own child labor laws imposing a higher level of protection.
Some state laws specifically protect child actors. This includes several states with so-called 'Coogan laws,' which require a certain percentage of a child actor's earnings to be placed in a trust until adulthood. California and Illinois have extended their Coogan laws to apply to children making money on social media. Otherwise, state laws protecting child actors typically have not been applied to kidfluencers.
This gap in existing child labor laws—along with the rise in child labor violations in conventional workplaces—has renewed long-time calls for strengthening legal protections for child workers.
Despite growing concerns about the welfare of child workers, many states have been pushing for less, rather than more, child labor protections.
Since 2021, over 60 bills to weaken existing child labor laws have been introduced across 29 states, according to a 2024 report by the State Innovation Exchange and the Economic Analysis and Research Network of the EPI. At least 17 of those bills have been successfully enacted across 13 states. This includes eight states that adopted child labor rollbacks during just the first half of 2024, according to EPI data.
These state bills are targeting the full range of child labor protections.
Some states bills would eliminate youth work permits and parent or guardian permission requirements, remove or lower age restrictions, expand permissible work hours, or extend work hours allowed before breaks. Some state bills would permit a lower minimum wage for children. And some state bills would reduce restrictions on minors working in hazardous industries, or in jobs that require driving or serving alcohol.
The recent push to deregulate child labor is being fueled by both industry and political forces.
Across the country, the primary proponents of laws to roll back child labor protections are business groups and their state affiliates, including the National Federation of Independent Business, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, and the National Restaurant Association. Lobbyists from the hotel, lodging, hospitality, tourism, grocery, construction, home builders, and agricultural industries are among the supporters.
Conservative organizations have also been involved in efforts to weaken child labor restrictions, including Americans for Prosperity, The Acton Institute, and the Florida-based Foundation for Government Accountability.
Florida's Republican Governor Ron DeSantis supports loosening child labor laws as a way to replace immigrant workers with American youth. Last month, Florida's legislature advanced a bill to weaken child labor restrictions, including allowing children as young as 14 years old to work overnight shifts.
Many of the proposed state bills are actually seeking to reduce child labor protections below the federal floor set by the FLSA. These laws sow confusion among employers, who may not realize that they are still required to follow federal law.
The U.S. Department of Labor recently alerted employers that they remain legally obligated to comply with federal child labor protections rather than any newly enacted, weaker state laws. 'Where a state child labor law is less restrictive than the federal law, the federal law applies,' the DOL instructs on its webpage on child labor standards.
Why would states enact laws that contradict federal law, knowing that employers must still comply with the higher federal mandates?
'The ultimate intent of the corporate lobby is clear: to pave a path to national deregulation of child labor, one state at a time,' said Sherer and Mast in their 2023 EPI Report. 'Industry lobbyists backing state child labor law changes appear to view state-by-state erosion of protections as a way to build pressure for eventual relaxation or elimination of federal wage and hour standards for the whole country.'
As the effort to roll back child labor laws has gained momentum, some states have bucked the trend by passing laws in 2024 to enhance child labor protection or enforcement efforts. These states include Alabama, Colorado, Illinois, Minnesota, Nebraska, Oregon, Utah, and Virginia.
Organizational leaders should educate themselves on these legal developments, as companies may increasingly be pushed to take a stand on the battle over the future of U.S. child labor laws. Calls for companies to incorporate child labor protection into their corporate social responsibility plans will likely expand from an international to a domestic focus as child labor risks increase.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

One Bad A** American Woman
One Bad A** American Woman

Fox News

time22 minutes ago

  • Fox News

One Bad A** American Woman

Gerri Willis, anchor and personal finance reporter for FOX Business, has dedicated recent years to researching remarkable American women whom her younger colleagues can admire. In her exploration, she discovered Elizabeth Van Lew, a young spymaster for the Union Army during the Civil War. Gerri and Kennedy discuss her new book, Lincoln's Lady Spymaster, sharing the inspiration behind her decision to share this story and what's next! Follow Kennedy on Twitter: ⁠⁠@KennedyNation⁠⁠ Kennedy Now Available on YouTube: ⁠ ⁠ Follow on TikTok: ⁠ Join Kennedy for Happy Hour on Fridays! ⁠ Learn more about your ad choices. Visit

The New OceanGate Documentary Dives Into the Depths of the Titan Submersible Tragedy
The New OceanGate Documentary Dives Into the Depths of the Titan Submersible Tragedy

Yahoo

time34 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

The New OceanGate Documentary Dives Into the Depths of the Titan Submersible Tragedy

Two years ago, OceanGate's Titan submersible imploded in the Atlantic Ocean off the coast of Newfoundland. Now, amid ongoing investigations by the U.S. Coast Guard, Netflix has a new documentary that proposes—citing sound evidence and on-camera interviews with sources that were formerly close to OceanGate—just what went wrong on the ill-fated journey to the site of another prolific sea disaster, RMS Titanic. Much of it has to do with OceanGate's eccentric late CEO, Stockton Rush, one of the five victims of the 2023 incident. On June 11, Netflix released the documentary Titan: The OceanGate Submersible Disaster, which documents the circumstances behind the June 2023 incident that spawned countless memes and endless speculation. While the movie dives deep (ahem) into the specifics of the Titan's implosion, including pointing out the submersible's carbon fiber construction that was vulnerable to deep-sea water pressure, the movie points a finger at Rush, who is described by subjects in the movie as "arrogant" with a major "temper." "I worked for somebody that is probably borderline clinical psychopath. Definitely a narcissist," said Tony Nissen, a former engineering director at OceanGate in the movie. "How do you manage a person like that who owns the company?" In the movie, Stockton Rush is described as having a "privileged background" originating from generational wealth; his family tree includes two signers of the Declaration of Independence. Subjects in the film recall Rush hoping to fashion himself as a billionaire explorer like Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk, with his eyes set on Earth's oceans instead of Mars. "Big swinging dicks" was a term Rush liked to say out loud and often, and being a "big swinging dick" himself was an explicit goal. (Rush was not a billionaire, but he had money to burn nonetheless.) Joseph Assi, a videographer hired by Rush to capture OceanGate's expeditions, says that one of Rush's personal philosophies was that "accessibility is ownership." As Assi says in the documentary: "If there's a small island in the middle of the ocean, and you're the only one you can access it, it doesn't matter who owns it, you have ownership over it because you have the accessibility to get to it. And he truly believed in that." Titan: The OceanGate Submersible Disaster makes a belabored point that OceanGate's failings leading to the implosion stemmed from Rush's leadership. His short temper and arrogance permeated in all his efforts to build a business around deep-sea commercial tourism. This included trying to skip critical testing conducted by third parties—which is standard practice in the industry—and cutting costs where possible, such as in the aforementioned use of carbon fiber materials which cannot sustain oceanic pressure. Rush also verbally stated he could and would "buy a congressman," which alarmed many OceanGate employees. Rob McCallum, a consultant, recalls in the documentary: "Stockton said that he decided that he saw no need for classification, for third-party oversight. I stood up and said, 'I'm sorry I can't be part of this conversation, nor can I be associated with OceanGate or this vehicle in any way.' And I left. He had every contact in the submersible industry telling him not to do this. But once you start down the path of doing it entirely yourself, and you realize you've taken the wrong turn right back at the beginning... You have to admit you were wrong. That's a big pill to swallow." Rush is also described as having a callous attitude towards employees, refusing to take accountability for his failures. For example: In 2016, Rush and OceanGate hosted an expedition to the SS Andrea Doria. The trip nearly ended in disaster after Rush brought their sub into a dangerous spot; David Lochridge, OceanGate's Director of Marine Ops and a more experienced pilot, took over controls and got everyone aboard safely to the surface. Though Rush thanked Lochridge, the CEO turned cold towards him, later excluding him from important communications. Rush eventually fired Lochridge, in a tense meeting heard in the movie via audio recording. Later, Rush suggested promoting another OceanGate employee, Bonnie Carl, to take over Lochridge as the next lead pilot. But Carl was an accountant who headed the HR department, and had no experience as a submersible pilot. Titan: The OceanGate Submersible Disaster is a cut above typical straight-from-the-headlines Netflix documentaries, as a level-headed if straightforward deep dive (again, ahem) about a disaster that dominated the news cycle two summers ago. But while the ins and outs of a deadly trip into the sea have morbid appeal, it's the movie's interrogation of one man's toxic hubris that makes Titan a worthy watch. You Might Also Like Kid Cudi Is All Right 16 Best Shoe Organizers For Storing and Displaying Your Kicks

Harris Yulin, Emmy-Nominated Actor of ‘Scarface' and ‘Ozark,' Dies at 88
Harris Yulin, Emmy-Nominated Actor of ‘Scarface' and ‘Ozark,' Dies at 88

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

Harris Yulin, Emmy-Nominated Actor of ‘Scarface' and ‘Ozark,' Dies at 88

Harris Yulin, a prolific Emmy-nominated actor whose career spanned more than five decades across film, television, and stage, died Tuesday of cardiac arrest in New York City. He was 88. The character actor's many films include 'Scarface,' 'Clear and Present Danger, and 'Training Day.' He also played Buddy Dieker on the Netflix series 'Ozark' from 2017 to 2018. He guested on 'Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt' and 'Buffy the Vampire Slayer' and was Emmy nominated in 1996 for a guest role on 'Frasier.' He made his film debut in 1970 in the black comedy 'End of the Road,' but landed his first featured role in Brian De Palma's 1983 'Scarface' as Mel Bernstein, a dirty narcotics cop. The actor was always memorable even in small parts, such as the New York judge in 'Ghostbusters II' who agrees to reverse murder charges for a pair of rampaging ghosts. Yulin was a well-respected theater actor, making New York debut in 1963 in 'Next Time I'll Sing to You' and first appeared on Broadway in the 1980s production of 'Watch on the Rhine.' He also starred in Broadway productions of 'The Diary of Anne Frank,' 'The Price,' and 'Hedda Gabler.' The actor was set to begin production on the MGM+ series 'American Classic,' opposite Kevin Kline and Laura Linney. Series co-creator Michael Hoffman told The Hollywood Reporter, 'Harris Yulin was very simply one of the greatest artists I have ever encountered.' Yulin was married to actress Gwen Welles Nashville from 1975 until her death in 1993 at age 42. He is survived by his second wife, actress Kristen Lowman, and his son-in-law Ted, nephew Martin and godchildren Marco and Lara. The post Harris Yulin, Emmy-Nominated Actor of 'Scarface' and 'Ozark,' Dies at 88 appeared first on TheWrap.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store