Scottish 85-year-old pens scathing letter to Keir Starmer
A SCOTTISH woman has written a scathing letter to Keir Starmer over the impact of the new immigration rules.
Vicky Currie, 85, fears it will impact her 92-year-old husband Jim – who has Alzheimer's and requires the help of carers.
The Prime Minister – during a speech in which he invoked far-right Enoch Powell-style language – announced significant changes to immigration rules to significantly reduce net migration in May.
This included a new system to end automatic settlement and citizenship for anyone living here for five years, with migrants instead required to spend a decade in the UK before applying to stay.
READ MORE: SNP demand UK Government act amid new Israeli plan to 'bury' Palestinian state
The UK Government immigration changes will impact many sectors, but Scotland's care industry is one that is under particular threat given its high dependence on international workers.
The National previously reported on how Perth and Kinross – as the region with the highest proportion of elderly people and also where Vicky and Jim live – will be disproportionately impacted.
'I feel compelled to write this letter as I am absolutely incensed, disgusted and outraged at the decision which you made on May 12 to significantly change the existing immigration rules,' she wrote in the letter to Starmer (below).
(Image: Vicky Currie)
'Please explain to me why you think changing the five year to a 10 year citizenship rule will do anything to stop the illegal immigrants when, in actual fact, all it will be doing is making it too difficult, expensive and unfair for these lovely people to stay who initially came to this country legally under the five year rule. It's Brexit all over again except it's not European 'carers' this time!'
Vicky went on to explain that it will directly impact her and her husband given the caring staff who take care of him may have to leave Scotland soon as a result and put further strain on Perth and Kinross's already struggling care sector.
She added: 'These people came to this country legally, pay their taxes and work extremely hard for what I consider to be an underpaid, overworked and under-appreciated job. They ALWAYS treat my husband and me with respect and kindness and are a pleasure to have in your home.'
Local SNP MP Pete Wishart said that Vicky and Jim's situation is a 'stark example of just how much damage the UK Government's immigration proposals are already causing across my constituency'.
He added: 'Hard-working carers, much loved by their clients, are already planning to leave as a direct result of these proposals, right at a time when their presence here has never been more important.
'It would have been unimaginable not so long ago for a Labour Government to be demonising the very people who are helping to prop up our cherished public services.
Wishart went on: 'Their direction of travel on this issue is alarming and flies in the face of our demographic reality. Unless they wake up to this, and abandon their futile 'Reform-lite' agenda, what we will see is more sick and elderly people in Perthshire and beyond being left without vital care support.'
The UK Government has been approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Channel 4
8 minutes ago
- Channel 4
Aid groups accuse Israel of ‘weaponising starvation' in Gaza
More than a hundred humanitarian groups and aid agencies have signed a letter to protest Israeli against restrictions on aid coming into Gaza. Signed by Oxfam, Medicines Sans Frontiers and others, the letter accuses the current aid distribution system run by the secretive new Gaza Humanitarian Foundation of 'weaponising starvation'. Israel claimed it needed to stop Hamas stealing food and denied its restricting supplies.
Glasgow Times
8 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Large drop in number of pupils studying Welsh at A-level since 2005, data shows
More than 500 fewer students studied Welsh to a high level this year than in 2005, the latest data shows. The drop has come despite the Welsh Government having set a target of one million Welsh speakers by 2050. Around 538,000 people can speak the language in Wales. Data examined by the PA news agency shows some 372 students took Welsh as a first or second language at A-level this year, down from 927 in 2005. The lowest year on record was 2023, when just 353 pupils took the subject. This year has been the lowest year for people taking Welsh as a first language, with 185 entries, compared with 260 in 2020. Some 187 pupils took the subject as a second language, with 209 having taken it in 2020. Efa Gruffudd Jones, the Welsh Language Commissioner – an officer appointed by the Welsh Government to oversee an independent body aiming to promote the use of the Welsh language – described the drop as a 'matter of concern'. Speaking to PA, Ms Gruffudd Jones said she supported calls from the Coleg Cymraeg Cenedlaethol (Welsh National College) for Welsh to become a protected subject. She said: '(This would) make sure that every educational institution post-16 offers the course. 'What I hear from people who get in touch with my office, if only you know three or four people want to study it, then schools don't offer the subject at all. 'I believe they need 12 before they decide to run the course. I don't think that's right. 'I think it should be offered at every educational institution post-16.' Ms Gruffudd Jones also said the qualification itself is under review, and the content needs to be made more attractive and relevant to students. She added: 'The other thing is that you can study many more courses through the medium of Welsh now than you used to be able to. 'You can study psychology, criminology, etc, through the medium of Welsh. 'Maybe people in the past who would have wanted to study through the medium of Welsh chose Welsh, but now they have a wider range of choice.' The commissioner stressed that Welsh is not the only language to have seen a decline, with many European languages having seen a drop across the UK. Total entries for French, German, and Spanish were down by 20% from 443 to 352 in Wales this year, with Ruth Cocks, director of British Council Wales, describing the drop in interest in international languages as a 'concerning story'. Ms Gruffudd Jones said the reason for the move away from studying languages was unclear, but may be due to pupils being encouraged to study more Stem subjects. 'I understand that we need people with technical ability, but I would argue that you also need linguistic ability in order to communicate with people in workplaces, to articulate yourself well in future,' she said. 'I would argue that literature gives you some insight into the world. 'I don't think really that it should be either or. 'What's important is that it doesn't go any lower, and we continue to make efforts to attract people to learn Welsh to a high standard.' The Welsh Government's aim to have one million Welsh speakers by 2050 was first set out in 2017. Earlier this year, a new five-year plan was unveiled by the commissioner to help achieve the goal. And the Welsh Language and Education (Wales) Bill, which aims to close the gap in Welsh speaking ability among pupils from different schools, passed in the Senedd. Figures from the 2021 census showed a decline in the number of people who can speak Welsh compared with a decade earlier. Around 538,000 people in Wales – roughly 17% of the population – said they could speak Welsh, compared with 562,000 in 2011, around 19% of the population. Recent years have seen Welsh place names take prominence over English as the default, with Eryri replacing Snowdonia on official communications from the national park authority. In response to the decline in A-level entries, a Welsh Government spokesperson said: 'We would like more learners to take Welsh as a subject. 'A consultation is taking place to look at creating new Welsh AS and A-levels, making them engaging and attractive to learners. 'We see the Welsh Language and Education (Wales) Act 2025 as a means to provide more children and young people with access to the language within the education sector than ever before. 'We want all young people to leave school with better Welsh skills, regardless of whether they do A-level Welsh or not.'
Daily Mail
9 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Cancel culture? I'm not to blame, says Sturgeon in wake of Fringe venue Forbes ban
Nicola Sturgeon is under fire after denying blame for the ' cancel culture ' which led to deputy First Minister Kate Forbes being banned from an Edinburgh Festival Fringe venue. She also refused to apologise to the women vilified for opposing her botched gender reforms. The Scottish Tories accused Ms Sturgeon of being 'delusional' for not accepting she had fuelled a cancel culture by branding her critics intolerant and bigoted. Her 'obsession with gender ideology and intolerance towards women's groups poured fuel on the fire', the party said. During the official launch of her memoir, Frankly, at the Edinburgh book festival, she said: The world is 'literally' her oyster and she may move abroad It could be another 10 years before SNP policies have an effect She received cruel messages about rape and her miscarriage online Summerhall Arts venue this week caused outrage after indicating Kate Forbes won't be allowed back because of her views on trans issues. The Scottish Daily Mail revealed how bosses apologised to performers after the Deputy First Minister appeared at a Fringe event last week. Some artists set up a 'safe room', claiming to be 'terrified' by the 5ft 2in MSP. The venue said booking Ms Forbes, who has criticised gender reforms and backs single-sex spaces for biological women, was an 'oversight' they would prevent 'happening again'. It led to calls for a recent award of £608,000 of public funding to be withdrawn. After appearing at the Edinburgh Book Festival yesterday, Ms Sturgeon, who now admits she should have 'paused' her gender reforms, was asked about the ban. She said: 'I don't agree with cancel culture and I don't agree with that.' The Book Festival has been criticised for failing to include gender critical writers, including the authors of the best-selling essay collection The Women Who Wouldn't Wheesht. While the National Library of Scotland has been accused of 'cowardice' for pulling the book from a major exhibition after staff complained about it promoting 'hate speech'. Asked if she bore responsibility for the 'censorious atmosphere', Ms Sturgeon said: 'No, I don't.' Pressed on whether she would say sorry to people who felt vilified for their gender-critical views, she said: 'No, I won't apologise. People on both sides of this debate are vilified. I've been vilified and received some awful abuse - nothing like the abuse trans people are getting right now. 'I tried to stand up for rights of one of most stigmatised minorities in the country. I don't believe that is in conflict with the rights of women which I have stood up for and will continue to stand up for.' She added: 'As a frontline politician for three decades, I am not without responsibility for the state of public discourse. I've got to take my share of collective responsibility. 'But I think we've also all got to just stop shouting abuse at each other and take a step back and try to find out a way of find a way of agreeing and disagreeing.' Conservative MSP Roz McCall said: 'It's frankly shameful that Nicola Sturgeon still refuses to apologise to women and girls for putting them in harm's way. 'For years she arrogantly dismissed their valid concerns, vilified them, and sacrificed their rights to appease extremist gender activists. 'Across Scotland, public bodies are still unpicking the chaos caused by her botched gender reforms - yet Nicola Sturgeon and her partner in crime John Swinney refuse to admit they were wrong. 'We saw that this week at the Fringe and it's delusional for her to deny that this cancel culture doesn't stem from the gender policies she pushed. 'Vile abuse on either side of this debate is completely unacceptable, but it's impossible to deny that Nicola Sturgeon's obsession with gender ideology and intolerance towards women's groups poured fuel on the fire.' The ex FM also revealed she received a rape threat and vile comments about her miscarriage after the release of her memoir. She said: 'These are people who call themselves feminists, standing up for women's rights, saying things about me, such as when I described my miscarriage experience the other day, 'I haven't laughed as much in years', accusing me of making it up, people saying they hope I'm raped in a toilet. These are the kind of things that go in both directions.' Earlier, on stage with broadcaster Kirsty Wark to discuss her memoir Frankly, Ms Sturgeon was cheered by fans for taking a swipe at Joanna Cherry, KC. The former SNP MP, who was ostracised by party colleagues for opposing gender reforms, said this week Ms Sturgeon was 'Stalinist' in how she ran the SNP. Ms Sturgeon said: 'There are certain people in this world who spend a lot more time thinking about me than I spend thinking about them.' She also admitted her flagship pledge to close the attainment gap in schools could take twice as long to deliver as she promised. She vowed in 2016 to end the gulf in exam results between rich and poor areas in a decade. But she suggested yesterday it could be another 10 years before SNP policies had an effect - as she hadn't realised tackling poverty was needed to address the poverty-related problem. She said: 'Unless you're changing the conditions kids are growing up in, then you're not going to have the impact, and that's what I learned along the way. 'Some of the things that I am proudest of are the Scottish Child Payment, the doubling of early years education, the baby box. These are things that are lifting children out of poverty, and I believe in time will make a difference.' Ms Wark replied incredulously: 'In time? That was ten years ago. That gap has not been closed. 'In time' is leaving a whole generation of children without that.' Ms Sturgeon: 'It will take longer than I appreciated or allowed myself to appreciate at the time, and that was my mistake. But it will work through the system. 'I absolutely believe that things like Scottish Child Payment, if we're looking back 10 years from now, the benefits of that in school attainment, in the attainment gap, will be seen.' Scottish Tory education spokesman Miles Briggs said: 'Nicola Sturgeon claimed that education was her top priority, but her record was disastrous - and now she says it will be another decade before progress is made on the flagship promise she made 10 years ago. 'It would be laughable if it wasn't so serious for the young people she has let down.' Asked why there was so little in her memoir about Scotland's drugs deaths crisis on her watch and if she owed the public an explanation, Ms Sturgeon said: 'It's for the public to read my book and make up their minds about that and other issues.'
