The shocking military gaffe that let Bin Laden escape just months after 9/11 as CIA boss admits ‘we could have ended it'
But it took the American intelligence services almost 10 years to hunt down
Advertisement
16
For years Osama bin Laden managed to evade US authorities
Credit: AFP
16
He was the mastermind behind 9/11, the worst terrorist attack in US history
Credit: Getty Images - Getty
16
President Barack Obama, Joe Biden, Hillary Clinton and other top US officials nervously watch on as Bin Laden is hunted
Credit: AP
Now, a new Netflix documentary, American Manhunt: Osama bin Laden, charts the nerve-wracking, decade-long global missions to capture the world's most notorious criminal.
It also examines the costly errors that meant the Al Qaeda leader could have been brought to justice far sooner, with a senior CIA boss candidly admitting they "could have ended it" just months after the atrocity.
From the moment the
Advertisement
READ MORE FEATURES
Gina Bennett, a CIA counter-terrorism analyst, says: 'There was a name on a manifest that was suspected of being a pretty major Al Qaeda operative.
"For years that was the terrorist group that we knew was determined to attack the United States. That name, that moment, there was just no way that was a coincidence. We knew immediately this was Osama bin Laden.'
Gina was part of a crack CIA team, mainly women, who had been focusing on Bin Laden since the Nineties.
Her colleague Cindy Storer says: 'We knew that Bin Laden was operating training camps and safe houses against the
Advertisement
Most read in The Sun
Exclusive
Exclusive
"When the war was over, we discovered he turned those camps into training camps for Islamic militants to go out and attack other countries. We knew they had terrorist capabilities.
"So we didn't know to what extent they were going to come directly after the US.'
Shameless Taliban claims there is 'no proof' Osama bin Laden was behind 9/11
16
The events of 9/11 left 2,977 people dead
Credit: AFP
16
The moment President Bush was told about the attacks while visiting a school
Credit: AFP
Advertisement
Attacks started across the world, heralding a new wave of terrorism, and in the months before 9/11, there was intelligence that Al Qaeda posed a threat to American targets.
Gina says: 'All the indicators were that something big was happening.'
Cindy adds: 'We got reporting that people in Bin Laden's network were calling their mothers and telling them goodbye and stuff like that. Something very serious was about to happen.'
Unimaginable atrocity
The US government was warned by the CIA that the likely targets would be famous landmarks or symbols of US capitalism - but they did not know when or how.
Advertisement
And none of them could have imagined the extent or horror of 9/11 when it did happen.
Cindy says: 'You can't not feel some responsibility for not stopping an attack that occurred on your watch. So you can't help but question yourself.'
It soon became clear that the Taliban government in Afghanistan were providing a safe haven for Bin Laden, who became the world's most wanted man after the events of 9/11 left 2,977 people dead.
We got reporting that people in Bin Laden's network were calling their mothers and telling them goodbye and stuff like that. Something very serious was about to happen
Cindy Storer
So America gave them an opportunity to turn him over, which they refused.
Advertisement
Just four days after 9/11, President Bush decided to go to war and put the CIA and its counterterrorism boss, Cofer Black, in charge of hunting him down.
'Operation Jawbreaker' sent small teams of CIA agents behind enemy lines to work with their Afghan allies, the Northern Alliance, who were already fighting the Taliban.
And Cofer Black's instructions were clear - he wanted Bin Laden's head on a stick to present to President Bush.
16
Operation Jawbreaker tracked Bin Laden down to the mountainous stronghold of Tora Bora in the months after the atrocity
Advertisement
16
Just four days after 9/11, President Bush decided to go to war
16
Bin Laden released propaganda videos praising the attacks
Credit: Getty
By December, the Americans and the Northern Alliance had taken control of all the major Afghan cities - but Bin Laden had got away.
American intelligence located his whereabouts in the mountainous stronghold of
Advertisement
They needed military reinforcements, but they were denied. The decision was made to bomb anyway, despite CIA protestations that they needed support.
The mountain cave was hit for 56 hours with some of the heaviest bombing since World War Two - but there was no proof Bin Laden was dead and fears grew that escape routes had not been sealed off.
Then, six months later, the Americans' worst fears were realised - film footage emerged proving Bin Laden was alive.
Cofer Black says: 'We could have ended it and moved on. It would have given some closure to the
Advertisement
"This was the best chance we ever had and I am sorry we didn't take it.'
Hunt for the henchmen
16
Osama bin Laden with Ayman al-Zawahiri, an Egyptian who was known as his right-hand man
Credit: Getty
16
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, who was being tracked by American intelligence for years, was the 'architect' of 9/11
Credit: AP
As Bin Laden released another propaganda video, the hunt for him and his henchmen intensified.
Advertisement
The Al Qaeda founder was at the top; after him was his deputy Al Zawahiri. Next in command were a handful of lieutenants who were also very close to Bin Laden.
These were Abu Zubaydah, who was suspected to be Bin Laden's chief operations operative, and a mysterious figure known only as Mukhtar.
In December 2001, three months after 9/11, a flight attendant on an American airliner thwarted another terror attack when he discovered a passenger with a bomb in his shoes.
The investigators felt they were at a dead end, but then they managed to capture Abu Zubaydah in a raid in Pakistan.
Advertisement
Unbelievably, he cooperated with the FBI and named the mysterious Mukhtar as a man they had been tracking for years - Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, known as KSM.
But that was nothing compared to what happened next.
Mastermind unmasked
Zubaydah revealed KSM was not just one of Bin Laden's closest accomplices, but the chief planner behind the September 11 attacks.
FBI Special Agent Ali Sofan says: 'He was the architect, the visionary, the mastermind of 9/11.'
Advertisement
He had been the man behind the first attack on the World Trade Centre back in 1993, but considered it a failure when he failed to topple the towers.
So he found his way to Afghanistan and Al Qaeda and pitched an idea to Osama Bin Laden to target not only the World Trade Centre, but also the Capitol Building and the Pentagon.
After 9/11, KSM went into hiding, but intelligence revealed he was in Pakistan.
In March 2003, they raided his villa in Rawalpindi, and he was captured. But what became clear was that Bin Laden was still very much in charge - and there were real concerns about additional attacks.
Advertisement
In the months that followed came the 2004 Madrid train bombings, which killed 193 people, then the 7/7 bombings in London that left 52 dead.
Cindy Storer says: 'There was attack after attack, we knew there could be another attack at any time, anywhere."
KSM provided information about Al Qaeda as an organisation. But there was one thing he wouldn't talk about - Bin Laden.
The hunt for Bin Laden stalled. But the terror plots continued - another was uncovered to blow up the New York subway, another to blow up 15 airliners over the US.
Advertisement
Bin Laden was looking for his next 9/11.
Monster hunt
16
Osama Bin Laden occasionally released videos so his followers knew he was alive
Credit: AP
16
US intelligence managed to trace his whereabouts to a large house in Abbotabad, Pakistan
Credit: EPA
16
Obama gave orders for the operation, despite the uncertainty that Bin Laden was in the home
Credit: Netflix
Advertisement
In September 2007, six years after 9/11, Bin Laden released a new videotape proving he was alive and still plotting against the US. But the trail on him had gone cold.
Barack Obama was sworn in as US President, and he told the CIA their number one task was to find Bin Laden.
The CIA analysed every video Bin Laden put out, and the focus was on how he was getting them to the news - there must be a trusted courier.
An Al Qaeda operative arrested in Africa named the courier as Abu Ahmed.
Advertisement
But he proved elusive until the summer of 2010, when they were able to track his phone to Pakistan.
They managed to follow him to a large house in Abbottabad. It was a bigger compound than any other in the area, boasting 18ft tall walls topped with barbed wire. It was clear that someone of high value was located there.
The CIA started immediate surveillance of the compound, but it had no phones or internet, and all their rubbish was burned.
They started to track the women and children who were seen coming and going, and they discovered that there were two families living in the compound - those of Abu Ahmed and his brother.
Advertisement
But then satellite footage revealed that there was a third family living in the house that never left the compound.
There was a man who would come outside every day and walk in the garden, but the walls and security meant it was impossible to get a clear image of his face.
Without exact proof that Bin Laden was there, it was difficult for the President to make a decision to take action against the compound.
If this was a botched operation, his reputation would be in tatters. But he asked the CIA to prepare to go into the compound.
Advertisement
Bin Laden's reign of terror
By Kevin Adjei-Darko
EVIL mastermind Osama Bin Laden orchestrated some of the deadliest terror attacks the world has ever seen.
As the leader of al-Qaeda, he was the brain behind the September 11, 2001 atrocities that killed nearly 3,000 people in New York, Washington D.C., and Pennsylvania.
Nineteen hijackers took over four planes, slamming two into the Twin Towers, one into the Pentagon, and another crashing in a field after passengers fought back.
Before 9/11, Bin Laden's fingerprints were all over other deadly plots. In 1998, he ordered truck bombings at US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania, killing 224 and injuring thousands.
In 2000, al-Qaeda struck again with the bombing of the USS Cole in Yemen, killing 17 American sailors.
Bin Laden used his fortune and twisted ideology to fund global jihad, radicalise followers, and build terror networks.
The Saudi-born terror chief became the world's most wanted man, hiding in plain sight in Pakistan for years before U.S. Navy SEALs took him out in a daring 2011 raid.
Admiral William McRaven, head of the Navy Seals, was tasked with planning the raid.
Seal Team Six was sent to Jalalabad, where they built a mock-up of the compound and practised for weeks.
On May 1, 2011, the most classified operation of the last 20 years was launched. Bin Laden's codename was Geronimo.
As the helicopters carrying the team hovered over the compound, one of them crashed - but miraculously, the Navy Seals walked away.
Advertisement
The crash had awoken the neighbourhood, but the decision was taken to carry on with the mission.
Within minutes, the Seals were within the compound and shot and killed Abu Ahmed.
As they made their way up the stairs, their next target was Bin Laden's son, Khalid. As the Seals peeled off to search, there were only two of them left to go to the top floor, where Bin Laden could be hiding.
Officer Robert J O'Neill says: 'Standing in front of me, two feet away, was Osama Bin Laden. It was one of those moments in life where it did slow down.
Advertisement
"He's taller than I thought, he's skinnier than I thought. His beard was grey/white. But I recognised his nose. This is definitely him. He's not surrendering, he's a threat, not just to me but to my team. He has to die.'
Back in America, President Obama and his team were about to hear the words America had wanted for 10 long years: 'Geronimo, Geronimo, we got him.'
American Manhunt: Osama bin Laden is out now on Netflix.
16
Robert O'Neil was the Navy SEAL who fired the bullet that killed Osama bin Laden
Credit: Universal News and Sport (Scotland)
Advertisement
16
In May 2011, Barack Obama announced to the world that Bin Laden had been killed
Credit: Reuters
16
Pictures released later by the US showed the conditions of the compound, which housed Bin Laden
Credit: BBC
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Sarah Harte: When positivity meets reality, sometimes you have to choose
Last week, I had to stay positive when several challenges presented themselves. As my own humdrum existence was unfolding, I followed Gareth Sheridan's candidacy for the presidential election, watching him being buffeted by searching questions and probes. He is, by any metric, a positive person, a quality I generally admire. The origin story for his wealth and success is a familiar one of hard work, gumption, self-sacrifice, and a supportive partner willing to set off on the hero's journey with him. It's the primary narrative arc we are fed in American movies and self-help books. Sheridan seems like somebody who would live his life by positive nostrums extracted from those self-help business books. He is also only 35. He is now seeing the dark side of the bright side. Headlines like Sheridan plays down, Sheridan denies, Sheridan minimises links to… While the political arena is widely acknowledged to be gladiatorial, I don't enjoy watching people being torn asunder. I imagine we have lost out on highly qualified presidential candidates because they smoked some dope in college or nicked some money from the collections box in the church when they were small, or took an ill-advised photo on a wild night out where they departed from their otherwise sane existence. We have swapped places with America. Now, they can have presidents with limited personal morals and rap sheets as long as their arms, but here you have to be a paid-up shining beacon of puritanical morality with a flawless family, which used to be the case in America. We all have relatives we hope stay in the background. Some of us are luckier than others in this regard. A balance in what we ask of Irish presidential hopefuls would be positive. Anyway, at the weekend I came across a quote in American writer and Pulitzer Prize finalist Adam Haslett's new book Mothers and Sons. A character says, 'There's this myth that we're endlessly elastic. It's propaganda. Capitalist, patriarchal propaganda. Stay positive! Work hard! Find that extra little efficiency that lets you do more and more in less time... Because if you try hard enough, anything is possible, and we're never going to die, so there's always time. But there isn't.' Blunt but true. Gareth Sheridan may be learning his hero's journey is more complicated than he first conceived. When he graduates to a later stage, he may realise there is no hero's journey. There is hard work for sure. A modicum of intelligence helps. Even more helpful is a degree of self-knowledge; this one is harder to come by, especially for those with entrepreneurial drives. The very thing that drives them on can be the thing that prevents them from accepting defeat or even identifying or acknowledging their own personal weaknesses. Putting a positive spin on everything does not get you through every situation and can be toxic. Those who do not learn this often go on to cause great destruction around them because this over-positivity derails a person's ability to be in touch with reality, facts, and feelings appropriate to the given moment. These characters' tragedy is that they are often talented in their way. But no amount of knockbacks can stop them from chugging on, and it often ends badly for anyone hapless enough to be in their path. As I write this, an image of the Black Knight in Monty Python's The Holy Grail flashes through my head. All his limbs hacked off by King Arthur, he threatens: "I'll bite your legs off." Rational people are required sometimes to accept defeat, acknowledge regret, fold the tent and go home to lick their wounds. When you're at home reflecting on what you could have done differently, one comfort should be the fact there is no heroic journey. There is a limited degree of control over your destiny. Hard work, intelligence, strategy, and ambition play a part here. And then there is good and bad luck. We don't think about this too much because we'd go mad if we focused on the random nature of chance. We go around the place pretending things can't change, like clicking our fingers. Safety is an illusion. Three occasions last week required me to reflect on random bad news (hopefully this will come out the right way), random good luck in making it through an unexpected bad luck situation, and on the harsh reality of a persistent failing of mine. Parking the first one, the random bad and good luck one was that I was eating a steak on Saturday night, when I, quite literally, nearly choked to death — such a simple thing. Eating too quickly (blame a brain that was stressed and speeding), eating a too-big bite of steak (blame greed), and the steak obstructed the larynx. I couldn't breathe and staggered to my feet, wondering, Is this how it ends. My random good luck came into play in that I was eating with a restaurateur who calmly got up and swiftly and effectively administered what used to be called the Heimlich manoeuvre. It is now called an abdominal thrust. The steak (and other stuff, I'll spare you) rocketed out of my mouth. I felt fortunate she was there, and she didn't break my ribs (she's very strong). Although what's a few broken ribs compared to the alternative? Google Maps has its merits, particularly in the city, where it can be a Godsend, but it does mad things in rural Ireland, sending you down crazy routes. What I also appreciated was that the people I was eating with didn't put a ceaselessly positive spin on what happened when it wasn't called for. It was a close shave, and like stunned mullets, we acknowledged the reality. The reality of a personal lacking and where it leads me, never mind time wasting, came into play on the way back from Ennis to Cork, where I had been working. Basically, I have no sense of direction. I own it. There's no sugar-coating this or saying, well, all things considered, you did pretty well. It's like a chip is missing in my brain. This has led me down many long, winding roads, as it did last week. I will say the multiple road closures across the country, with no alternative routes signalled (thanks), played their part. Google Maps has its merits, particularly in the city, where it can be a Godsend, but it does mad things in rural Ireland, sending you down crazy routes. The app needs to get a handle on this. We don't want to drive down famine roads that are overgrown for centuries or cling to the side of cliffs. When it happens, I try to stay positive. I begin thinking, 'Ah, the Irish countryside is beautiful on this sunny day.' 'You never drove through Broadford before.' 'It was a chance to see Kanturk (three times).' This always wears off and leaves me feeling defeated. I face the fact that the odyssey will culminate in a late arrival home and barely suppressed mirth from family members and sly questions about what took me so long. It's called reality, and it's always better to be acquainted with it, whatever the context, big or small, personal or even presidential. Positivity will only get you so far.
The Journal
2 hours ago
- The Journal
Syrian and Israeli diplomats reportedly hold rare meeting in Paris to discuss 'de-escalation'
SYRIA'S FOREIGN MINISTER has held a rare meeting with an Israeli delegation in Paris, the Syrian state-run news agency said. The talks were brokered by the United States, which has been pushing for Syria and Israel to normalise relations, the report said. Foreign minister Asaad al-Shibani met Israeli officials today to discuss de-escalating tensions and restoring a 1974 ceasefire agreement, the SANA news agency said. Syrian officials have acknowledged holding indirect talks with Israel to defuse tensions. There was no immediate confirmation of such a meeting from Israel. Tensions have soared between the two neighbouring countries following the overthrow of Syrian president Bashar Assad in December. Israeli forces seized control of a UN-patrolled buffer zone in Syria shortly after Assad's overthrow and carried out airstrikes on military sites in what officials said was aimed at creating a demilitarised zone south of Damascus. Advertisement Israel has said it will not allow hostile forces to establish themselves along the frontier, as Iranian-backed groups did during Assad's rule. It distrusts Syria's new government, which is led by former Islamist insurgents. Syrian President Ahmad al-Sharaa, a former al-Qaida commander who severed ties with the militant group years ago, has pledged to build a new country that respects the rights of minorities, but sectarian violence has erupted on a number of occasions, raising concerns about the country's fragile transition. Israel stepped up its intervention when violence erupted in Syria's Sweida province last month between Bedouin clans and government forces on one side and armed groups from the Druze religious minority on the other. Israel said it was acting to protect the Druze, who are seen as a loyal minority in Israel and often serve in the military. Israel launched dozens of airstrikes on convoys of Syrian forces around Sweida and struck the headquarters of the Syrian ministry of defence in the heart of Damascus, Syria's capital. Israel seized the Golan Heights from Syria in the 1967 Middle East war and later annexed the strategic plateau in a move that has only been recognised by the US. The rest of the international community views the Golan as occupied Syrian territory.
The Journal
3 hours ago
- The Journal
Israel demands release of all hostages at once, casting doubt on new Hamas-backed truce proposal
ISRAEL WILL NOT accept a Gaza ceasefire deal unless it sees all of the remaining hostages still being held by Hamas released at once, according to a senior official. It comes a day after Hamas accepted a new truce proposal and signalled its readiness for a fresh round of talks aimed at ending Israel's offensive in Gaza. Mediators are awaiting an official response from Israel to the new proposal, with Qatar noting that it was 'almost identical' to an earlier version agreed to by the Israeli government. According to a report in Egyptian state-linked outlet Al-Qahera News, the latest deal proposes an initial 60-day truce, a partial hostage release, the freeing of some Palestinian prisoners and provisions allowing for the entry of aid. But speaking on the condition of anonymity, a senior Israeli official told AFP the government's stance had not changed and demanded the release of all hostages in any deal. Egypt said Monday that it and Qatar had sent the new proposal to Israel, adding 'the ball is now in its court'. Speaking today, Qatari foreign ministry spokesman Majed al-Ansari said Hamas had given a 'very positive response, and it truly was almost identical to what the Israeli side had previously agreed to'. 'We cannot make any claims that a breakthrough has been made. But we do believe it is a positive point,' he added. Mounting pressure Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has yet to publicly comment on the plan, but said last week that his country would accept 'an agreement in which all the hostages are released at once and according to our conditions for ending the war'. Police disperse ultra-Orthodox Jews blocking a highway during a protest against army recruitment, in Bnei Brak, Israel. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo Senior Hamas official Mahmoud Mardawi said on social media that his group had 'opened the door wide to the possibility of reaching an agreement, but the question remains whether Netanyahu will once again close it, as he has done in the past'. Advertisement Hamas's acceptance of the proposal came as Netanyahu faced increasing pressure at home and abroad to end the war. On Sunday, tens of thousands took to the streets in the Israeli city of Tel Aviv to call for an end to the war and a deal to free the remaining hostages still held captive. Of the 251 hostages taken during Hamas's 7 October 2023 attack, 49 are still in Gaza, including 27 the Israeli military says are dead. The new proposal also comes after Israel's security cabinet approved plans to seize control of Gaza City, fanning fears the new offensive will worsen the already catastrophic humanitarian crisis in the devastated territory. Amnesty International has accused Israel of carrying out a deliberate campaign of starvation in Gaza, while the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification has said that famine thresholds have already been reached in most of the territory. Israel's far-right National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir slammed the plan, warning of a 'tragedy' if Netanyahu 'gives in to Hamas'. In June, the UK sanctioned Ben Gvir and Israel's finance minister Bezalel Smotrich for 'inciting violence' and abuses of Palestinian human rights. 'Unbearable' Meanwhile, Gaza's civil defence agency reported that 45 people were killed today by Israeli strikes and fire across the territory. Palestinians pray over the bodies of people who were killed in an Israeli airstrike during their funeral outside Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis, in the southern Gaza Strip. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo Agency spokesman Mahmud Bassal told AFP the situation was 'very dangerous and unbearable' in the Zeitoun and Sabra neighbourhoods of Gaza City, where he said 'artillery shelling continues intermittently'. The Israeli military declined to comment on specific troop movements, saying only that it was 'operating to dismantle Hamas military capabilities' and took 'feasible precautions to mitigate civilian harm'. The military later said a strike in Khan Younis overnight targeted a Hamas militant, adding that 'steps were taken to mitigate harm to civilians, including the use of precise munition, aerial surveillance, and additional intelligence'. Media restrictions in Gaza and difficulties accessing swaths of the Palestinian territory mean AFP is unable to independently verify the tolls and details provided by the civil defence agency or the Israeli military. Related Reads 'We don't know the taste of sleep': Gaza City in peril as Israel plans to seize control Baby girl killed with her parents in Israeli airstrike on Gaza UN says at least 1,760 people have been killed while seeking aid in Gaza since late May Sabra resident Hussein al-Dairi, 44, said 'tanks are firing shells and mortars, and drones are firing bullets and missiles' in the neighbourhood. 'We heard on the news that Hamas had agreed to a truce, but the occupation is escalating the war against us, the civilians,' he added. Today, the United Nations took aim at Israel's months-long block on bringing tents into the Gaza Strip, despite continual displacement orders being issued to civilians in the devastated territory. Jens Laerke, spokesman for the UN humanitarian agency OCHA, said shelter items had been banned from entering Gaza for about five months – a period in which more than 700,000 people had been displaced or re-displaced. 'They may have been provided with a tent, and then they are displaced again and they have no possibility of taking the tent with them,' he told a press briefing in Geneva. He said Israel had classified tents as 'dual use' because they considered tent poles could potentially be used for a military purpose. He decried 'layers of bureaucracy which seem designed not to facilitate fast entry of anything but rather the opposite'. The Palestinian health ministry said Israel's offensive has killed at least 62,064 Palestinians, most of them civilians, figures which the United Nations considers reliable. With reporting from AFP Need more information on what is happening in Israel and Gaza? Check out our new FactCheck Knowledge Bank for essential reads and guides to navigating the news online. Visit Knowledge Bank Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
