The Irish Times view on bail reform: a careful balance required
The statement in the Dáil chamber on Tuesday was a vindication of the O'Farrells' long campaign in the face of official deflection and obfuscation. They have expressed the hope that it will come to be seen as a 'watershed moment' for the administration of justice. But they continue to press for more transparency on why the hit-and-run driver who struck Shane was not in prison at the time, as a court had ordered.
The Minister has appointed a senior counsel to review the bail laws The question of whether these laws are too lax has been a subject of debate, particularly in the context of high-profile crimes committed by individuals released on bail. Critics argue the system sometimes prioritises the presumption of innocence over public safety, allowing repeat offenders or those accused of serious crimes to remain free while awaiting trial.
Under Irish law, bail is generally granted unless the court has a substantial reason to believe the accused will flee, interfere with witnesses,or commit further offences. The Bail Act 1997 allows for bail to be refused in cases where the accused is likely to commit a serious offence if released. However, some legal experts believe this standard is too difficult to meet.
READ MORE
Data from the Garda and the Courts Service occasionally highlights cases where individuals released on bail are later re-arrested for similar or more serious crimes. This has led to calls for stricter bail conditions, particularly for repeat offenders or those charged with violent crimes.
But others argue that tightening bail laws would undermine fundamental rights. And increasing the number of people held in pre-trial detention would place further strain on an already overcrowded prison system. Any reform must therefore strike a careful balance between protecting the public and upholding civil liberties.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
6 hours ago
- Sunday World
Human trafficking has greatly increased in Ireland this year, figures reveal
A total of 528 human trafficking cases have been reported to the Gardai in the past 10 years. There has been a big increase in the instances of Human trafficking reported in Ireland, new figures have revealed. There were 63 incidents dealt with by the Gardai so far this year as of July 18. This is almost as many in seven months as the total 68 cases reported for the whole of last year. A total of 528 human trafficking cases have been reported to the Gardai in the past 10 years. The lowest number was 35 in 2015 while the highest is the 68 cases in 2024. Gardaí are investigating News in 90 Seconds - August 16th The figures weRe released by the Justice Minister Jim O' Callaghan in reply to a parliamentary question from the Aontu leader Peadar Toibin. Reacting to the data the Minister said: 'The prevention, detection. and prosecution of the crime of human trafficking is a priority for the Government. 'Significant measures have been taken to create a more victim centres approach to identifying and supporting victims, to raise public awareness and provide training to relevant people including professionals to detect, understand and combat human trafficking.' He said the State has established a new National Referral Mechanism (NRM) under anew and revised current National plan. He added: 'Under the revised NRA , responsibility for the formal identification of victims of trafficking will be expanded beyond An Garda Siochana to include a range of designated departments and State agencies each of which will be authorised as a competent authority.'
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘We await with interest': Family of Sophie Toscan du Plantier supportive of fresh DNA tests in murder inquiry
The family of murdered Sophie Toscan du Plantier say they will accept whatever findings Irish forensic scientists make on foot of a series of new DNA tests on exhibits from the near 30-year-old investigation . Ms Toscan du Plantier's uncle, Jean Pierre Gazeau, said the family fully supports the decision by the Garda Serious Crime Review Team and Forensic Science Ireland (FSI) to engage US DNA collection experts irrespective of what the move yields. Mr Gazeau said he was interested to see that the Garda and FSI had decided to avail of technology provided by M-Vac Systems to examine exhibits including the stone and concrete block used to murder his niece in west Cork in 1996. 'I think it is the last chance for the Garda – unless, of course, some witness comes forward with new evidence. But even then, they may retract their story, which has happened before, but DNA evidence is objective and scientific and definitive, so it is a welcome development,' he said. READ MORE Mr Gazeau, president of the Association for the Truth about the Murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier, said he did not want to speculate, but that the latest approach could produce a number of different scenarios. 'They may find nothing but obviously if they find DNA and it does not match that of Ian Bailey , then it has the ability to clear Bailey of any culpability,' he said. 'But even if it means the outcome is not what we expect ... it is a scientific outcome, and we must respect that finding and accept it because DNA testing is very definitive. We await with interest to hear from the Garda on what the scientists find.' Ian Bailey, the chief suspect for the murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier, died last year aged 66. Photograph: Courts Collins Mr Bailey, an English journalist, was twice arrested in connection with the French film producer's murder, but was never charged, and repeatedly protested his innocence before his death last year at the age of 66 . He was convicted in his absence at a trial in Paris in 2019 of the voluntary homicide of Ms Toscan du Plantier and sentenced to 25 years in jail. However, attempts by French authorities to have him extradited to serve the sentence were shot down by the Irish courts . M-Vac Systems chief executive Jared Bradley and a scientist from the firm travelled to Dublin last month with their equipment and spent a week examining various exhibits gathered during the original Garda investigation into Ms Toscan du Plantier's murder. The 39-year-old's badly beaten body was found on the laneway leading to her isolated holiday home in Toormore near Schull on the morning of December 23rd, 1996. A postmortem revealed she had been bludgeoned to death with a rock and a concrete block. As well as the cavity block and rock, gardaí from the cold case review team based in Bantry brought several exhibits to the FSI laboratory for examination by the M-Vac team including Ms Toscan du Plantier's dressing gown, leggings, vest and boots. Investigators are hoping that any DNA evidence obtained will enable FSI scientists to make comparisons with DNA samples taken during the original Garda investigation from about 10 people, including Mr Bailey, identified as suspects at the time.
Agriland
7 hours ago
- Agriland
Former agri journalist Mairead McGuinness to run for presidency
Former MEP and European Commissioner Mairead McGuinnes, who started her career as an agricultural journalist, has secured the Fine Gael nomination to run as a candidate to become President of Ireland. Current President, Michael D Higgins will finish his second seven-year term at Áras an Uachtaráin in November. The President of Ireland (Uachtarán na hÉireann) is Ireland's Head of State. Every seven years the public elect a new president who can serve two terms in total. According to the electoral commission, some of the president's constitutional roles include: Representing the people of Ireland; Appointment of the Taoiseach, members of the government, judges and other officials; Summoning and dissolving the Dáil, and convening the Oireachtas; Signing legislation into law and/or referring Bills to the Supreme Court; Supreme Commander of the Defence Forces. To be nominated as a Fine Gael candidate, a candidate required the nomination of at least 20 members of the Fine Gael Parliamentary Party, 25 councillors and five members of the Fine Gael Executive Council. McGuinness's name will go forward for ratification at a party event in September. This will be the start of the Fine Gael presidential election campaign. Tánaiste and Fine Gael president Simon Harris said: 'The Fine Gael party is pleased to confirm Mairead McGuinness has been nominated as our candidate for the Presidential election and will be ratified by the party in September. 'Mairead has secured the support of the parliamentary party and the wider Fine Gael organisation. I look forward to working with her over the coming months. 'Presidential elections are always an important point for the country. I believe Mairead possesses all the attributes to bring our nation together at this important time.' Commenting on being nominated as the Fine Gael candidate for the role, Mairead McGuinness said: "I am conscious of the opportunity and challenge ahead, given the very important constitutional role of the President, and the esteem in which the office is held by the people. "Subject to my candidacy being ratified by the party in early September, I very much look forward to setting out my vision for the Presidency. And I look forward to working with you all over the coming weeks and months. "The campaign when it starts will be full-on," she added. A native of Ardee, Co. Louth, from a strong Fine Gael family, Mairead McGuinness is married to Tom Duff and they have four children. They now live near Drumconrath, Co. Meath. McGuinness was educated locally at the Convent of Mercy National School and Ardee Community School. She studied agricultural economics at University College Dublin (UCD), the first woman to qualify in the discipline and served as recording secretary of the Agricultural Society (Ag Soc) at the college. She began her career in journalism in RTÉ immediately after college. She worked initially as radio producer and later in research on 'The Late Late Show'. In more recent times McGuinness became well known as a presenter and driving force behind the 'Ear to the Ground' TV series. She also held the role of editor of the Farming Independent. Mairead McGuinness served two terms as chairperson of the Guild of Agricultural Journalists and helped develop the guild as an important network for those in food and farming communications. She also chaired the Consumer Liaison panel set up by the Minister for Agriculture and Food. This panel spearheaded changes in food labelling and traceability initiatives. Related Stories McGuinness was first elected to the European Parliament in 2004 representing the Midlands North-West region of Ireland. She was elected by European counterparts as vice-president and was also previously a full member of the Agriculture & Rural Development/AGRI Committee and a substitute on Environment, Public Health & Food Safety/ENVI Committee as an MEP. She was voted by her colleagues as MEP of the Year for Agriculture in 2011. In 2014 she was awarded the UCD Foundation Day Alumni Award in Agriculture and Food Science. In 2020, she was appointed European Commissioner for Financial services, Financial Stability and Capital Markets Union until 2024.
