Fraudster who conned luxury brands into buying fake Scottish tea jailed
Operating under the business name The Wee Tea Plantation, Robinson fraudulently sold the tea to high-profile clients in the hospitality sector between January 2014 and February 2019.
Representatives of the Balmoral Hotel, the Dorchester Hotel and a company acting on behalf of Fortnum & Mason were among those tricked by the fraudster, who had claimed to have sold tea to customers including Kensington Palace.
A Food Standards Scotland (FSS) investigation found Robinson also misled genuine Scottish tea growers by selling them plants under the false pretence they were a unique, locally-grown variety.
On May 25, he was found guilty of two counts of fraud to a value of almost £553,000 after a trial at Falkirk Sheriff Court, which followed an investigation by FSS.
Robinson, also known as Tam O'Braan and Thomas O'Brien, tried to bolster his credibility by fabricating academic qualifications and industry awards.
On Wednesday, Robinson was sentenced at Stirling Sheriff Court. Hours earlier, his lawyer withdrew from the case.
Representing himself, Robinson begged for 'compassion' as he appeared by videolink from HMP Low Moss, wearing a green sweatshirt.
Sheriff Keith O'Mahony refused a bid to defer sentence and said it was in the public interest that it went ahead, as Robinson was 'articulate' enough to represent himself.
Robinson, who told the court he has four children and attends church, claimed he awoke every morning in his cell plagued with guilt about the 'reputational damage' caused to genuine Scottish tea growers.
'I've had time to wrestle with this over sleepless nights, coming to realise how wrong and stupid I've been,' he told the court.
'The damage this has on all concerned, the stigma of misleading others… I should have been much more transparent and owned up to the situation. Hubris and arrogance made me believe I did my best.
'The method by which you could grow tea in Scotland, something I was told you couldn't do… I didn't know the best, I didn't act as I should have. I go to church, I'm perfectly aware that a sin is not only to do something, but also not to do the right thing.
'The shame of that hangs over me every morning every time I wake up in my cell. Central to that guilt I'm responsible for reputational damage of those involved and reputational damage of growing tea in Scotland.
'It was a scheme I received support from the Scottish Government. I solemnly hope my actions have not detracted from the success which can be achieved for people who want to grow tea in Scotland. I can only offer my sincere apologies if my actions have besmirched that capability.'
He told the court he had experienced 'suicidal emotions' due to guilt and had been 'too ashamed to explain' to his four children.
Robinson claimed he would not reoffend and had learnt from his actions, 'not only from shock of my conviction but truthful acceptance of what I have done'.
He added: 'I solemnly would ask that the above is taken into consideration not as an excuse but an acceptance of the serious nature of my actions and inactions, and I throw myself on the mercy of the court for your compassion.'
Sheriff O'Mahony said the jury had 'generally rejected' Robinson's evidence, and the charges spanned five years and totalled £552,988.
He added: 'By any measure these convictions must be regarded as significant. Mr O'Brien demonstrated significant planning, he was persistent, he repeatedly made false statements.
'These charges are not victimless, witness after witness gave evidence and said they would not have had the transaction if they had known. They were convinced on false pretences to hand over significant sums of money.'
Robinson put his head in his hands as the three-and-a-half year sentence was handed down.
Helen Nisbet, procurator fiscal for Tayside, Central and Fife, said: 'Individuals, businesses, and genuine Scottish tea growers suffered financial and reputational harm as a consequence of Robinson's deceit.
'But thanks to partnership working between Food Standards Scotland, Police Scotland and the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service, he has been brought to account for his crimes.
'We are committed to tackling financial crime of this kind.'
Ron McNaughton, of FSS, said: 'We welcome today's sentencing as a clear signal that food fraud is a serious crime with serious consequences.
'A three-and-a-half year custodial sentence reflects the scale and impact of Mr Robinson's deception. His actions caused real financial and reputational harm to individuals, businesses and a developing sector of genuine Scottish tea producers.
'This outcome is the result of a complex and painstaking investigation involving a dedicated team at FSS and the co-operation of partner agencies and key witnesses.
'It demonstrates that those who set out to mislead consumers and defraud businesses will be held accountable.
'Food fraud undermines consumer trust and damages the integrity of Scotland's globally respected food and drink sector. We remain committed to detecting and disrupting criminal activity of this nature.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
2 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Young Scots risking their lives with 'rhino ket' drug craze glorified by Kneecap
Scottish health bosses have warned of the rapid emergence of the drug. Young Scots are risking their lives with a 'rhino ket' drug craze that has surged after rappers Kneecap glorified it in their music. Scottish health bosses have warned of the rapid emergence of the drug, which turbo-charges the horse tranquilliser drug ketamine by adding amphetamine. The mix has been appearing more and more in Scotland, leading to fears of addiction and death among those who take it. One mother contacted the Daily Record after her 16-year-old son sought out the drug after getting into the controversial Kneecap rap act –whose song Rhino Ket is one of their top anthems. The mum said: 'My boy never touched drugs before watching the Kneecap movie last year and they were banging on about stuff like 'going down the K-hole'. 'He got in a state one night and could hardly talk when he got home. His face was bashed and he said someone had given him rhino ket, which was new to me. We found out that it's ketamine mixed with amphetamine and it's hugely dangerous.' She added: 'I'm a liberal person but when I looked at the lyrics in the Kneecap song it was basically telling young people to take this drug. It's not on because this drug is designed to make people behave in a way that exposes them to danger.' Rhino ket has been in the Scottish supply chain for several years but its increased prevalence in drug reports prompted Public Health Scotland to issue a specific alert. In PHS's latest Rapid Action Drug Alerts and Response (RADAR) identifies the drug as a fast emerging trend, according to data shared by Police Scotland. The report states: ''Rhino ket' is terminology the police have been encountering more frequently. This term is sometimes used to describe a mixture of ketamine and amphetamine, which are taken together to increase the effects.' The RADAR report also identifies 'speedballing' – the combined use of crack cocaine and heroin – as another potentially deadly emerging trend. The song 'Rhino Ket', from the album 'Fine Art', is part of the Kneecap movie's soundtrack and celebrates being 'K-holed off my head'. The lyrics include: 'Recently I heard a secret, there's this thing called Rhinoceros Ket. When you take a line it makes you forget (Sounds great). Bally up and lets rob a vet (Sweet)'. It goes on: 'Can't sit, can't think, can barely even walk, dunno how the f*** we'll make it back to Falls. I'm K-Holed off my head, this s*** puts Rhinos to bed.' Ketamine is often found as an off-white crystalline powder. Effects include euphoria, hallucinations and dissociative sensations. But it also causes panic attacks and sometimes an inability to move, known as a 'k-hole'. Earlier this year, it was revealed that young Scots are risking heart attacks by taking cocaine and ketamine in a mix dubbed Calvin Klein. Almost 20 alerts about rising use of the lethal narcotics cocktail were flagged to Public Health Scotland. Almost 300,000 people in the UK between the ages of 16 and 59 reported using the drug in the year up to March 2023 – the biggest number on record, according to the Home Office. In 2019, 17-year-old violin prodigy Katya Tsukanova died of a suspected overdose after apparently taking the fatal 'Calvin Klein' mix in London. In NHS Lothian, there was an increase in under-25s taking a highly potent batch of the drug named rhino ket – leaving them suffering from heart palpitations and mouth ulcers. In Fife, a series of drug deaths were suspected to be from ketamine, as well as 'multiple overdoses in people aged under 25 in several locations, needing ambulance service after collapse'. Another instance resulted in 'serious, unexpected adverse effects including amnesia and seizures.' Elsewhere, officials noted young people turned to the deadly CK mix after hearing a number of high-profile cases of youngsters dying from taking MDMA pills. Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. A spokeswoman for Fife Alcohol and Drug Partnership (ADP) said it was is aware of the risks associated with the unprescribed use of ketamine and remains committed to a proactive and preventative approach in tackling substance-related harm. The spokeswoman said: 'We work closely with a range of partners across Fife, including third sector organisations and statutory services, to ensure a broad network of support is available to those who need it. Our team meets weekly to monitor emerging issues and respond quickly to any potential harms. 'In addition, we hold monthly meetings focused on reviewing local substance trends and identifying practical actions to reduce risk and protect the health and wellbeing of our communities.' Superintendent Joanne McEwan, of Police Scotland, said: 'Police Scotland works in partnership with a wide range of national and international partners and law enforcement agencies to monitor trends and emerging threats, and share intelligence to help address the number of recorded drug deaths in Scotland. We support ongoing initiatives which aim to reduce the harm associated with problematic drug use. 'Officers from local policing and specialist divisions work tirelessly to remove illegal drugs from communities every day and remain committed to disrupting the activities of those organised criminals who supply drugs and continue their work to ensure Scotland is a hostile environment for them to operate. 'We can't tackle this issue alone and would urge the public to continue supporting us in building intelligence about the possession and supply of drugs by contacting Police Scotland on 101 or anonymously via Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111.'
The Herald Scotland
22 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Glen Rosa a reminder of challenges facing UK shipbuilding
The themes of these relevant and supporting strategies crossed my mind earlier this month as close to home, MV Glen Rosa passed a further significant step on its journey into service as it left dry dock for interior fit out back at the quayside of Ferguson Marine. I think most of us now are aware of the complexity of the design and the build difficulties that have resulted in late delivery. However, for me, the images of the now near finished ship in dry dock really illustrate the impressive scale of what has been achieved by the Ferguson team, and it's a fitting image that summarises the impressive complex engineering that the whole system of the ship contains. Recognising, and having pride in the engineering achievement is not intended to dismiss the cost to both public purse and loss of service to island communities that the long delays to delivery have brought. It's important to address the major errors by all stakeholders through this part of the yard's history, but equally 'we are where we are', and now it's time to look forward more than back. The £160m award earlier this year for seven small electric ferries to a Poland yard rightly raised questions about why no consideration for social value was included in the bidding process, despite the UK's current National Shipbuilding Strategy calling for public tenders to include for this. The call for this inclusion rightly seeks only that there is a level playing field to compensate for significantly higher levels of state investment, favourable tax incentives, or lower labour rates out with the UK. In this case the awarding body deemed the risk of legal challenge sufficient enough to not include it. Read more: It's a theme that's painfully present here in Scotland given that Alexander Dennis is currently fighting to keep their Scottish manufacturing operation open, after a deeply disappointing outcome from the Scottish Zero Emission Bus Challenge (ScotZEB2) award last year. In that case over 80% of the £42m Scottish Government grant ended up funding the manufacture of those buses principally in China and also Egypt. Getting the balance right between risk and reward for public procurement funded by taxpayers is critical, and it's hard not to perceive that elsewhere the appetite to 'lean in' is higher. For Ferguson Marine, its recent contract award by BAE Systems for build of three sections for HMS Birmingham is more than welcome, but we should be clear that this alone will not sustain the business in the long term. If we lose the business, we also lose the social, economic and community benefits to the wider Inverclyde area, and indeed Scotland, that its high-quality employment and training continues to deliver. At this risk of stating the obvious, to sustain a shipyard, it needs to build whole ships from design to delivery. Module build will keep a key section of the engineering fabrication, welding and technical support occupied, but full ships and their complex design and development employ and grow a much wider skillset, and there needs to be a pipeline of demand that keeps those wider skills current and trains new additions for the future. This isn't a challenge just for Ferguson Marine either, it's a pattern that's replicated across the UK, where outside of naval shipbuilding, the number of commercial ships designed, built and commissioned from scratch is far too low for an island nation that has and will continue to depend on maritime connectivity to sustain ourselves. If we return to the Strategic Defence Review, its candid tone of being ready for a 'move to warfighting readiness' still makes me sit up straight, with the planning - and capacity - for that readiness a sharp reality check. A wider, stronger, UK shipbuilding enterprise that includes a step change in the number of commercial vessels is the answer, and build contracts procured with public funds should be our starting point. To go a step further, there is a valid argument that given the current precarious geopolitical climate, we should consider the potential dual use of publicly procured ships in terms of what role they could play in the event of the UK being pulled into conflict and so review their build in terms of sovereign capability. In the first instance however, the procurement process for the replacement for the MV Lord of the Isles, built by Fergusons thirty-five years ago, is the front and centre opportunity to make sure that the public investment to sustain and grow Ferguson Marine over the last decade has not been in vain. The yard's own call for a direct award under the relevant provisions of the Procurement Act 2023 has gathered wider support politically and regionally, and my understanding is that consideration is underway as part of the wider procurement planning. Let's hope the evaluation on that balance of risk is in favour of sustaining a business of significant importance to Scotland, and when we consider shipbuilding capacity, the UK too. Paul Sheerin is chief executive of Scottish Engineering
The Herald Scotland
22 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
The accountant who changed career to join the family bakery
Now commercial director, Aisling McGhee, tells how she came to move her focus to the bakery that has just seen its brand surge in popularity amid an expansion of the business, which is based in Glasgow. Aisling McGhee said: 'We are incredibly proud of our Scottish roots and the role we have played in helping to feed Scotland for four generations.' (Image: Story Shop) The baker was a new entrant to the "most chosen" category in the Worldpanel by Numerator's 2025 Scotland Brand Footprint rankings, second behind Irn Bru. The report reveals the ranking of shoppers' most chosen food and drink brands over the past year, with Graham's, Tunnock's, and Bells making up the top five Scottish brands. She said: "I stepped into a proper role – not something invented for me." Among her ambitions would be: "To leave a legacy for my children like the one I have the privilege to be a part of." Name: Aisling McGhee What is your business called? McGhee's Family Bakers Where is it based? Headquartered in Glasgow, with five sites across Scotland. What does it produce/do? We're a fourth-generation, family-owned bakery best-known for our morning rolls and potato scones. We also produce a wide range of confectionary products including empire biscuits, caramel shortcake, assorted tarts and other Scottish classics that have stood the test of time! To whom does it sell? We supply major supermarket chains and convenience stores across Scotland as well as wholesale and food-service customers. While our roots are firmly in Glasgow and the west, our reach is now truly national. What is its turnover? Our last filed accounts were £53.7 million – up £5.5m year-on-year. How many employees? 440 Why did you take the plunge? There were two parts to it. I was at KPMG and my time there was incredibly rewarding. It was a tremendous learning experience and I am grateful for the skills and perspective I gained in financial services, including having the opportunity to work overseas in the Toronto office for two years. However, over time I reached a natural decision point in my career where I wanted to broaden my experience and explore opportunities in other industries beyond the financial sector. Around that time, the Directors (my dad and two uncles) had decided to bring in external advisors to undertake a family governance project. They interviewed the next gen (me, my sister, my cousins) – none of us were formally in the business – and the senior generation. The conclusion was clear: if we wanted McGhee's to stay family-owned and family-run, someone from our generation had to step in. Legacy is important for Aisling McGhee. (Image: Story Shop) The timing was right. The management accountant was due to retire, so I stepped into a proper role – not something invented for me. Everything just lined up. I realised I'd never be as passionate working anywhere else. It was also a personal decision – being a twin, I've always had a competitive streak. I wanted to make the family business as good as it can be. The sense of ownership of having your name above the door makes you strive to be the best. READ MORE: What were you doing before? I was (and am) a chartered accountant. I spent seven years at KPMG, where I was an audit manager. What do you least enjoy? Working with my dad – but it's also one of the best parts. The father/daughter dynamic can be tricky: sometimes I'd do things differently, but there's still that instinct that your dad knows best. We don't always agree, but it works because we both care deeply about the business. What are your ambitions for the firm? To leave a legacy for my children like the one I have the privilege to be a part of. My two cousins and I have big shoes to fill, and we need to keep building on the growth achieved by previous generations. We're thinking about what's next beyond Scotland, and also about how to adapt to changing tastes – like the success of our sourdough rolls for health-conscious customers. What single thing would most help? More support for significant Scottish employers. There are constant demands and added costs, but little clarity or assistance – especially for businesses like ours that are on the cusp of being classed as "large" but don't typically qualify for funding. Traditional industries often get overlooked in favour of newer sectors. The government's changes to BPR tax relief has also made IHT planning for businesses like ours significantly more difficult. What is the most valuable lesson you have learned? Patience is a virtue. Working in a family business is a long-term thing. I want everything now – that's my nature – but this business is more like steering an oil tanker. I've learned that progress takes time. Looking at what's been achieved in 90 years is a good reminder of that. What was your best moment? Rolling out our new packaging over the past year has been very exciting and to be recognised in the Worldpanel by Numerator report as the second most chosen Scottish brand was hugely rewarding. It showed all the investment, planning and hard work paying off. And of course any time I see someone enjoy one of our products! What was your worst moment? I'm an optimistic person, so I tend to always take any 'bad' moment as a lesson. I haven't faced the kind of challenges my dad and my uncles have faced in their long tenures in the business. There were periods when the business wasn't as successful as it is today, so in comparison, my worst moments have been minor setbacks. But I've only been here for seven years… How do you relax? Spending time with my family – although with a three-year-old and a four-year-old it's not always relaxing! Running is my real switch-off; I try to get out three times a week, block everything out, and think.
